ROBINS v. U.S., 404 U.S. 1049 (1972)
U.S. Supreme Court
ROBINS v. U.S. , 404 U.S. 1049 (1972)404 U.S. 1049
Robert Joe ROBINS
v.
UNITED STATES.
No. 71-5405.
Supreme Court of the United States
January 17, 1972
On petition for writ of certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.
Mr. Justice BRENNAN, with whom Mr. Justice DOUGLAS and Mr. Justice MARSHALL join, dissenting.
On March 4, 1964 petitioner was arraigned in the United States District Court on charges of prison escape and accompanying assaults. Counsel was appointed that day, and after petitioner and the attorney assured the court they had had sufficient time earlier in the day to
confer, the court accepted petitioner's guilty pleas. On June 22, 1964, petitioner returned for sentencing, and the following occurred:
- 'The Court: Mr. Robbins [sic], when [last] before the Court,
was represented by appointed counsel, Mr. Sheldon Crossette, a
member of the bar of Wyandotte County and of this Court.
- 'I excused Mr. Corssette [sic] from further representation of
Mr. Robbins [sic] since he is in Kansas City and this hearing is in
Leavenworth.
* * * * *
- 'Mr. Robbins [sic], do you desire that other counsel be
appointed to represent you at this hearing?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: No.
- 'The Court: You understand that you have the right to have
counsel?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: Yes.
- 'The Court: And you waive that right?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: Yes, sir.'
Petitioner was then sentenced to consecutive five-year terms of imprisonment on two counts and a concurrent five-year term on a third, all to follow any sentence then being served.
Petitioner subsequently filed a motion in the sentencing court
to vacate sentence under 28 U.S.C. 2255, contending, first, that in
summarily relieving his appointed attorney, the trial court had
denied him his constitutional right to the assistance of counsel
and, second, that he had not validly waived his right to counsel.
In particular, petitioner alleges that he did not accept the
court's offer to appoint new counsel from fear of angering the
court, and because he did not think a new attorney, unfamiliar with
the case, could help him. The District Court in an unreported order
denied relief without a [404 U.S. 1049 , 1051]
U.S. Supreme Court
ROBINS v. U.S. , 404 U.S. 1049 (1972) 404 U.S. 1049 Robert Joe ROBINSv.
UNITED STATES.
No. 71-5405. Supreme Court of the United States January 17, 1972 On petition for writ of certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit. The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. Mr. Justice BRENNAN, with whom Mr. Justice DOUGLAS and Mr. Justice MARSHALL join, dissenting. On March 4, 1964 petitioner was arraigned in the United States District Court on charges of prison escape and accompanying assaults. Counsel was appointed that day, and after petitioner and the attorney assured the court they had had sufficient time earlier in the day to Page 404 U.S. 1049 , 1050 confer, the court accepted petitioner's guilty pleas. On June 22, 1964, petitioner returned for sentencing, and the following occurred:
- 'The Court: Mr. Robbins [sic], when [last] before the Court,
was represented by appointed counsel, Mr. Sheldon Crossette, a
member of the bar of Wyandotte County and of this Court.
- 'I excused Mr. Corssette [sic] from further representation of
Mr. Robbins [sic] since he is in Kansas City and this hearing is in
Leavenworth.
- 'Mr. Robbins [sic], do you desire that other counsel be
appointed to represent you at this hearing?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: No.
- 'The Court: You understand that you have the right to have
counsel?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: Yes.
- 'The Court: And you waive that right?
- 'Defendant Robbins [sic]: Yes, sir.'
- 'The fact that an accused may tell [the judge] that he is
informed of his right to counsel and desires to waive this right
does not automatically end the judge's responsibility. To be valid
such waiver must be made with an apprehension of . . . all . . .
facts essential to a broad understanding of the whole matter.' Von
Moltke v. Gillies, 332 U.S.
708, 724, 323 (1948).