SAN ANTONIO CONSERVATION SOC. v. TEXAS HIGHWAY, 400 U.S. 968 (1970)
U.S. Supreme Court
SAN ANTONIO CONSERVATION SOC. v. TEXAS HIGHWAY , 400 U.S. 968 (1970)400 U.S. 968
Named Individual Members of the SAN
ANTONIO CONSERVATION SOCIETY
v.
The TEXAS HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT et al., and the U.S. Department of
Transportation.
No. 1101.
Supreme Court of the United States
December 21, 1970
Rehearing Denied Feb. 22, 1971.
See 401 U.S. 926.
On petition for a writ of certiorari, before judgment, to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. The petition for writ of certiorari is denied.
Mr. Justice BLACK, with whom Mr. Justice DOUGLAS and Mr. Justice BRENNAN join, dissenting. This case disturbs me greatly. On December 7, 1970, this Court stayed the construction of two federally funded highways in order to save two public parks. One park serves the people of Memphis, Tennessee. [Footnote 1] The park in this case is for the rest and recreation of the the people of San Antonio, Texas. Both cases involve important and timely problems of interpretation of 138 of the Federal Aid Highway Act, passed by Congress to stem the destruction of our Nation's parks by highway builders. These cases give this Court an opportunity to insure that lower courts and certain federal agencies administer this vital environment-saving legislation in the way that Congrees intended. The Tennessee case is still scheduled for oral argument at the earliest possible date-January 11, 1971. Yet, the Court now dissolves the stay previously entered in the San Antonio case, 400 U.S. 961, and denies certiorari. I respectfully dissent from these orders. The San Antonio park has two golf courses, a zoo, a sunken garden, an open air theater and many acres of open space, covered with trees, flowers, and running brooks. It is a lovely place for people to retreat from the frantic pace of bustling urban life to enjoy the simple pleasures of open space, quiet solitude, and clean air. It is a refuge for young and old alike-the kind of a park where a family man can take his wife and children or lovers can while away a sunny Sunday afternoon to-
gether. After today's decision, the people of San Antonio and the birds and animals that make their home in the park will share their quiet retreat with an ugly, smelly stream of traffic pouring down a super six- lane 'North Expressway.' Trees, shrubs, and flowers will be mown down. The cars will spew forth air and noise pollution contaminating those acres not buried under concrete. Mothers will grow anxious and desert the park lest their children be crushed beneath the massive wheels of interstate trucks.
The San Antonio Conservation Society and its individual members filed suit to block federal approval and funding of this expressway. The United States District Court held that the Secretary of Transportation and state officials were free to proceed with federal funding and construction of two segments of the road coming into the park from north and south. It retained jurisdiction to review any later decision on the design and routing of the connecting middle section, which had not been formally approved by the Secretary.
In addition to substantial questions under the Federal Aid
Highway Act, 23 U.S.C. 138, this case involves the newly enacted
National Environmental Policy Act, Pub.L. 91-190, 83 Stat. 852. The
latter requires a detailed study of the probable effects before
approval of 'major Federal actions significantly affecting the
quality of the human environment.' 42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C). Even the
respondent appears to concede that the decision to fund this
expressway is a 'major federal action' requiring careful study
because he has promised that a study will be made before the middle
section is approved. However, the approval of the two end segments
took place in August 1970, eight months after the effective date of
the Act. It is undisputed that no environmental study has been made
with respect to these two segments, [400 U.S. 968 , 970]
U.S. Supreme Court
SAN ANTONIO CONSERVATION SOC. v. TEXAS HIGHWAY , 400 U.S. 968 (1970) 400 U.S. 968 Named Individual Members of the SAN ANTONIO CONSERVATION SOCIETYv.
The TEXAS HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT et al., and the U.S. Department of Transportation.
No. 1101. Supreme Court of the United States December 21, 1970 Rehearing Denied Feb. 22, 1971. See 401 U.S. 926. On petition for a writ of certiorari, before judgment, to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. The petition for writ of certiorari is denied. Mr. Justice BLACK, with whom Mr. Justice DOUGLAS and Mr. Justice BRENNAN join, dissenting. This case disturbs me greatly. On December 7, 1970, this Court stayed the construction of two federally funded highways in order to save two public parks. One park serves the people of Memphis, Tennessee. [Footnote 1] The park in this case is for the rest and recreation of the the people of San Antonio, Texas. Both cases involve important and timely problems of interpretation of 138 of the Federal Aid Highway Act, passed by Congress to stem the destruction of our Nation's parks by highway builders. These cases give this Court an opportunity to insure that lower courts and certain federal agencies administer this vital environment-saving legislation in the way that Congrees intended. The Tennessee case is still scheduled for oral argument at the earliest possible date-January 11, 1971. Yet, the Court now dissolves the stay previously entered in the San Antonio case, 400 U.S. 961, and denies certiorari. I respectfully dissent from these orders. The San Antonio park has two golf courses, a zoo, a sunken garden, an open air theater and many acres of open space, covered with trees, flowers, and running brooks. It is a lovely place for people to retreat from the frantic pace of bustling urban life to enjoy the simple pleasures of open space, quiet solitude, and clean air. It is a refuge for young and old alike-the kind of a park where a family man can take his wife and children or lovers can while away a sunny Sunday afternoon to- Page 400 U.S. 968 , 969 gether. After today's decision, the people of San Antonio and the birds and animals that make their home in the park will share their quiet retreat with an ugly, smelly stream of traffic pouring down a super six- lane 'North Expressway.' Trees, shrubs, and flowers will be mown down. The cars will spew forth air and noise pollution contaminating those acres not buried under concrete. Mothers will grow anxious and desert the park lest their children be crushed beneath the massive wheels of interstate trucks. The San Antonio Conservation Society and its individual members filed suit to block federal approval and funding of this expressway. The United States District Court held that the Secretary of Transportation and state officials were free to proceed with federal funding and construction of two segments of the road coming into the park from north and south. It retained jurisdiction to review any later decision on the design and routing of the connecting middle section, which had not been formally approved by the Secretary. In addition to substantial questions under the Federal Aid Highway Act, 23 U.S.C. 138, this case involves the newly enacted National Environmental Policy Act, Pub.L. 91-190, 83 Stat. 852. The latter requires a detailed study of the probable effects before approval of 'major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment.' 42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C). Even the respondent appears to concede that the decision to fund this expressway is a 'major federal action' requiring careful study because he has promised that a study will be made before the middle section is approved. However, the approval of the two end segments took place in August 1970, eight months after the effective date of the Act. It is undisputed that no environmental study has been made with respect to these two segments, Page 400 U.S. 968 , 970 which themselves desecrate parklands and which make the destruction of further parkland inevitable. Section 138 of the Federal Aid Highway Act provides:
- 'It is hereby declared to be the national policy that special
effort should be made to preserve the natural beauty of the
countryside and public park and recreation lands. ... [T]he
Secretary shall not approve any program or project which requires
the use of any publicly owned land from a public park, recreation
area or wildlife and waterfowl refuge of national, State or local
significance as determined by the Federal, State or local officials
having jurisdiction thereof, ... as so determined by such officials
unless ( 1) there is no feasible and prudent alternative to the use
of such land, and (2) such program includes all possible planning
to minimize harm to such park ....' (Emphasis added.)
- 'major federal actions significantly affecting the quality of
the human environment, a detailed statement by the responsible
official on-(i) the environmental impact of the proposed action,
(ii) any adverse environmental effects which cannot be avoided
should the proposal be implemented, (iii) alternatives to the
proposed action, ( iv) the relationship between local short-term
uses of man's environment and the maintenance and enhancement of
long-term productivity, and (v) any irreversible and irretrievable
commitments of resources which would be involved in the proposed
action should it be implemented.' Section 102(2)(C).
Page 400 U.S.
968 , 973
There can be no doubt that federal funding of a state highway
project is covered by the 1970 Act. The most controversial aspect
of the highway design and location is that it proposes to run a
massive elevated eight- and six-lane expressway through a park in
San Antonio. The Brackenridge- Olmos Basin parklands is a unique
park, recreational, and open spaces area. Specific land uses
include the original Brackenridge Park grant, the Sunken Gardens,
and adjacent outdoor amphitheater, the San Jacinto Park, the Alamo
Stadium, the San Antonio Zoo, the Olmos Basin picnic area, the
Franklin Fields, and numerous other parks, public and open space
areas.
- 'Today the land is being covered by four and six lane highways,
supermarket parking lots, suburban
Page 400 U.S.
968 , 974
high rise apartment buildings and lost to itself and to the
people alike.'
- 'The inadequacy of present knowledge, policies, and
institutions is reflected in our Nation's history, in our national
attitudes, and in our contemporary life. We see increasing evidence
of this inadequacy all around us: haphazard urban and suburban
growth; crowding, congestion, and conditions within our central
cities which result in civil unrest and detract from man's social
and psychological well- being; the loss of valuable open spaces;
inconsistent and, often, incoherent rural and urban land-use
policies; critical air and water pollution problems; diminishing
recreational opportunity; continuing soil erosion; the degradation
of unique ecosystems; needless deforestation; the decline and
extinction of fish and wildlife species; faltering and poorly de-
Page 400 U.S.
968 , 975
signed transportation systems; poor architectural design and
ugliness in public and private structures; rising levels of noise;
the continued proliferation of pesticides and chemicals without
adequate consideration of the consequences; radiation hazards;
thermal pollution; and increasingly ugly landscape cluttered with
billboards, powerlines, and junkyards; and many, many other
environmental quality problems.' S.Rep.No. 91-296, 91st Cong., 1st
Sess., p. 4. (Italics added.)
- 'Poor land-use policies and urban decay' can no longer be
deferred, the report stated. Id., at 5.
- 'We no longer have the margins for error that we once enjoyed.
The ultimate issue posed by shortsighted, conflicting, and often
selfish demands and pressures upon the finite resources of the
earth are clear.' Id., at 5.
- 'The Secretary expressly reserved final approval on the middle
section because there is much parkland contained in the middle
section.
- 'As a matter of fact, one of the primary reasons the Secretary
has not approved the middle section is due to the consideration of
the views expressed by plaintiffs in opposition to the proposed
route the middle section will take through the parklands.'
- 'I think that perhaps the reason that the Department of
Transportation was asked to have a representative here before your
committee was because within the purview of the Department of
Transportation has lain in the past and will continue to lie in the
future many of the activities that, at least, are most apparent to
the people of the country in the field of environmental
impact.'
- 'a growing concern, though in most instances it is not a deep
knowledge perhaps of the scientific implications ... as to what
might happen to life itself in some of the areas of which we are
destroying our environment, it is concerned with the things they
see about them in their daily lives. And in this area, I think,
transportation and the activities of transportation organizations
have been one of those which they have observed and which has
created perhaps as much controversy and concern as any other area
of the State and Federal operations.' Hearings before the Committee
on Interior and Insular Affairs, United States Senate, 91st Cong.,
1st Sess., on S. 1075, S. 237, and S. 1752, p. 76.
- 'We have experts in the field of transportation coping with the
problem of moving people from one city to another in the least
possible time with the greatest degree of safety. We have
constructed a vast system of interstate highways to accomplish
this. Yet at the same time, we have created serious problems of
soil erosion, stream pollution, and urban displacement.
- '... The experts have, by and large, done their job well, but
we must remember their job is
Page 400 U.S.
968 , 981
building highways, increasing our food production, preventing
floods and so on. Their primary concern is not with the quality of
our environment considered as a totality.' 115 Cong.Rec., 91st
Cong., 1st Sess., 26573 (1970).
- 'I think there is a little too much of a tendency, probably not
in the committees involved here, but on the part of the public, to
regard environment as involving only air and water pollution ...
the environment does not involve only water and air; ... it
involves noise-and we are all becoming acutely conscious of this
factor. More and more as time goes on-environmental questions will
also involve land distribution, planning for the future, what kind
of future cities we will plan, and what we will do about the
ghettos-for the ghettos are a part of the environmental picture.
...' Id., at 29061.
- 'were directly concerned with environmental issues, covering a
broad area of interest-cleaning up the Nation's rivers and better
approaches to smog control, improving the use of open space and
prevention of disorderly encroachment by super-highways, factories
and other developments ... and the control
Page 400 U.S.
968 , 982
of urban sprawl, unsightly junk yards, billboards, and power
facilities that lower the amenities of the landscape.' Id., at
29069.
- 'When Congress adjourned last fall, I decided to determine the
extent to which highway construction was threatening our streams
and rivers. I sent questionnaires to fish and game management
officials in each of our 50 States. To date, Mr. President, I have
received responses from 46 States.
- 'The questionnaire consisted of 10 questions, one of which was:
'Are trout streams or other important fishing streams or lakes
adversely affected by highway construction in your State?'
Thirty-two of the forty- six States which have responded to the
questionnaire answered affirmatively, although damage varies in
seriousness from State to State.
- 'Perhaps more significant were the responses to the question:
'Do you feel that additional legislation at the Federal or State
levels is necessary to bring about a satisfactory degree of
coordination of highway and wildlife conservation interests and
objectives in your State?' To this question, Mr. President, fish
and game management men in 37 States replied, 'Yes.' Two States
were undecided about the necessity for legislation, and only seven
see no need for action in this area.
- 'Mr. President, my questionnaire revealed general agreement,
among those most qualified to know, that there is a need for
legislation. This is not a partisan, political issue; it is a
conservation problem cutting across party lines, as shown by
responses to my questionnaire. Fish and game officials working for
Republican and Democratic State administrations agreed there is a
need for legislation to protect fish, wildlife, and recreation
resources from damage due to highway construction.
- 'Our bill, Mr. President, provides a method of meeting that
need. I urge my colleagues to study this problem as it relates to
their own States. I hope this matter will receive the attention of
the Congress this year.' 109 Cong.Rec. 828.