EVANS v. BOLLEN, 4 U.S. 342 (1800)
U.S. Supreme Court
EVANS v. BOLLEN, 4 U.S. 342 (1800)4 U.S. 342 (Dall.)
Evans, qui tam, &c.
v.
Bollen.
Circuit Court, Pennsylvania District.
April Term, 1800
THIS was a qui tam action, in which the following declarawas filed:
- 'October Session 1797.
- 'In the Circuit Court of the United States for the Pennsylvania
District of the Middle Circuit.
- 'District of Pennsylvania, ss.
- 'George Bollen, late of the district of Pennsylvania, yeoman,
was summoned to answer to the United States and to John Evans, who
sues in this behalf, as well for the said United States as for
himself, of a plea that he render to the said United States, and to
the said John who sues as aforesaid, the sum of two thousand
dollars, which to them he owes, and from them unjustly detains: and
whereupon the said John, who sues in this behalf, as well for the
said United States, as for himself, by Joseph Thomas his attorney,
saith that the said George, on the first day of April in the year
of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and ninety-seven, at the
port of New-York, to wit, at the district aforesaid, was aiding and
abetting, in preparing and sending away from a port within the said
United States, to wit, from the port of New-York, a certain vessel
called the Betsey, intending that the same should be employed for
the purpose of procuring from a foreign country, to wit, from the
coast of Africa, the inhabitants of such foreign country, to be
transported to a foreign country, to wit, to the island of Saint
Croix, to be disposed of as slaves, against the form of the statute
in such case made and provided; by means whereof,
and by force of the statute in such case made and provided, an
action hath accrued to the said John, who sues in this behalf, as
well for the said United States, as for himself, to have and demand
of and from the said George the said sum of two thousand dollars:
yet the said George (although often requested) hath not paid the
said two thousand dollars, or any part thereof, to the said John,
who in this behalf sues for the United States as well as for
himself, but the same to him to pay hath hitherto wholly refused,
and still doth refuse, to the damage of the said John, who sues as
aforesaid, five hundred dollars. And thereof he brings suit,
&c. 'Pledges, &c. JOHN DOE. RICHARD ROE. Joseph Thomas,
attorney for plaintiff. The action was founded on the act of
congres, 'to prohibit the carrying on the slave trade, from the
United States to any foreign place or country,' (3 vol. 22. Swift's
edit.) of which the following were the material sections, in the
discussion: Sect. 1. 'Be it enacted, &c. That no citizen or
citizens of the United States, or foreigner, or any other person
coming into, or residing within the same, shall, for himself or any
other person whatsoever, either as master, factor, or owner, build,
fit, equip, load, or otherwise prepare any ship or vessel, within
any port or place of the said United States, nor shall cause any
ship or vessel to sail from any port or place within the same, for
the purpose of carrying on any trade or traffic in slaves, to any
foreign country; or for the purpose of procuring, from any foreign
kingdom, place, or country, the inhabitants of such kingdom, place,
or country, to be transported to any foreign country, port, or
place whatever, to be sold or disposed of, as slaves: and if any
ship or vessel shall be so fitted out, as aforesaid, for the said
purposes, or shall be caused to sail, so as aforesaid, every such
ship or vessel, her tackel, furniture, apparel, and other
appurtenances, shall be forfeited to the United States; and shall
be liable to be seized, prosecuted, and condemned, in any of the
Circuit Courts, or District Court for the district, where the said
ship or vessel may be found and seized. Sect. 2. 'And be it further
enacted, That all and every person, so building, fitting out,
equipping, loading, or otherwise preparing, or sending away, any
ship or vessel, knowing, or intending, that the same shall be
employed in such trade or business, contrary to the true intent and
meaning of this act, or any ways aiding or abetting therein, shall
severally forfeit and pay the sum of two thousand dollars, one
moiety thereof to the use of the United States, and the other
moiety thereof to the use of him or her who shall sue for and
prosecute the same.'- [4 U.S. 342, 344]
U.S. Supreme Court
EVANS v. BOLLEN, 4 U.S. 342 (1800) 4 U.S. 342 (Dall.) Evans, qui tam, &c.v.
Bollen. Circuit Court, Pennsylvania District. April Term, 1800 THIS was a qui tam action, in which the following declarawas filed:
- 'October Session 1797.
- 'In the Circuit Court of the United States for the Pennsylvania
District of the Middle Circuit.
- 'District of Pennsylvania, ss.
- 'George Bollen, late of the district of Pennsylvania, yeoman,
was summoned to answer to the United States and to John Evans, who
sues in this behalf, as well for the said United States as for
himself, of a plea that he render to the said United States, and to
the said John who sues as aforesaid, the sum of two thousand
dollars, which to them he owes, and from them unjustly detains: and
whereupon the said John, who sues in this behalf, as well for the
said United States, as for himself, by Joseph Thomas his attorney,
saith that the said George, on the first day of April in the year
of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and ninety-seven, at the
port of New-York, to wit, at the district aforesaid, was aiding and
abetting, in preparing and sending away from a port within the said
United States, to wit, from the port of New-York, a certain vessel
called the Betsey, intending that the same should be employed for
the purpose of procuring from a foreign country, to wit, from the
coast of Africa, the inhabitants of such foreign country, to be
transported to a foreign country, to wit, to the island of Saint
Croix, to be disposed of as slaves, against the form of the statute
in such case made and provided; by means whereof,
Page 4 U.S.
342, 343
and by force of the statute in such case made and provided, an
action hath accrued to the said John, who sues in this behalf, as
well for the said United States, as for himself, to have and demand
of and from the said George the said sum of two thousand dollars:
yet the said George (although often requested) hath not paid the
said two thousand dollars, or any part thereof, to the said John,
who in this behalf sues for the United States as well as for
himself, but the same to him to pay hath hitherto wholly refused,
and still doth refuse, to the damage of the said John, who sues as
aforesaid, five hundred dollars. And thereof he brings suit,
&c. 'Pledges, &c. JOHN DOE. RICHARD ROE. Joseph Thomas,
attorney for plaintiff. The action was founded on the act of
congres, 'to prohibit the carrying on the slave trade, from the
United States to any foreign place or country,' (3 vol. 22. Swift's
edit.) of which the following were the material sections, in the
discussion: Sect. 1. 'Be it enacted, &c. That no citizen or
citizens of the United States, or foreigner, or any other person
coming into, or residing within the same, shall, for himself or any
other person whatsoever, either as master, factor, or owner, build,
fit, equip, load, or otherwise prepare any ship or vessel, within
any port or place of the said United States, nor shall cause any
ship or vessel to sail from any port or place within the same, for
the purpose of carrying on any trade or traffic in slaves, to any
foreign country; or for the purpose of procuring, from any foreign
kingdom, place, or country, the inhabitants of such kingdom, place,
or country, to be transported to any foreign country, port, or
place whatever, to be sold or disposed of, as slaves: and if any
ship or vessel shall be so fitted out, as aforesaid, for the said
purposes, or shall be caused to sail, so as aforesaid, every such
ship or vessel, her tackel, furniture, apparel, and other
appurtenances, shall be forfeited to the United States; and shall
be liable to be seized, prosecuted, and condemned, in any of the
Circuit Courts, or District Court for the district, where the said
ship or vessel may be found and seized. Sect. 2. 'And be it further
enacted, That all and every person, so building, fitting out,
equipping, loading, or otherwise preparing, or sending away, any
ship or vessel, knowing, or intending, that the same shall be
employed in such trade or business, contrary to the true intent and
meaning of this act, or any ways aiding or abetting therein, shall
severally forfeit and pay the sum of two thousand dollars, one
moiety thereof to the use of the United States, and the other
moiety thereof to the use of him or her who shall sue for and
prosecute the same.'-
Page 4 U.S.
342, 344
The facts were proved, as stated in the declaration, but the
defendant's counsel made two objections to the jurisdiction of the
Court: 1st. That this was a suit under the second section, and the
Circuit Court could not take original cognizance of a case of
penalty, or forfeiture, as the judicial act expressly declared,
that the District Court should have 'exclusive original 'cognizance
of all suits for forfeitures and penalties incurred 'under the laws
of the United States.' 1 vol. p. 53, 4. s. 9. 2d. That the offence
was committed, in the state of New-York; and ought to be tried
there, upon the principles of the common law, adopted by the
constitution of the United States, and various acts of congress.
Const. art. 3. s. 2. 1 vol. 29. s. 67. Amendm. Const. art. 8, 9. 4
Black. Com. 350. 3 Bl. Com. 359, 360. 2 Dall. Rep. 335.