Under §§ 5197, 5198, U.S.Rev.Stat., a national bank which
compounds interest in a manner prohibited by the state forfeits all
interest even though the total interest amounts to less than the
maximum rate permitted by the state.
A national bank, met in an action by the plea of usury, may not
avoid the forfeiture of all interest by then declaring an election
to remit the excessive interest.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
Page 195 U.S. 372
MR. JUSTICE HOLMES delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a writ of error to the Supreme Court of Missouri on the
ground that the plaintiff in error is denied the rights with regard
to charging interest conferred upon it by the National Banking Act.
Rev.Stat. §§ 5197, 5198. The suit was brought by the plaintiff in
error upon a promissory note for twenty thousand dollars, with
interest at eight percent, made on April 29, 1892. The facts,
shortly stated, are as follows: on October 29, 1892, the plaintiff
bought the defendant's note for $15,000, with interest at seven
percent. On July 12, 1895, the defendant being behindhand with his
payments of interest and also having overdrawn a bank account which
he kept in the plaintiff's bank, he gave the plaintiff a new note
for $17,500, and interest at seven percent, in satisfaction of both
liabilities. The amount of this note included three semiannual
interest charges of $525 each, with a few days' further interest,
on the former note, with interest on this interest from the time it
was due, and charges of one percent or more a month on the amount
overdrawn each month. It left the defendant with a credit on his
bank account of $230.50. On April 29, 1896, the note in suit and
another note for $2,000 were given in satisfaction of the last note
for $17,500, and of another note for $2,500, of October 1, 1895,
with interest accrued on both, and of an overdraft of $919.90, and
a balance of $2.42. The overdraft item included, as before, charges
of about one percent a month on the amounts actually overdrawn.
The Supreme Court of Missouri held that the plaintiff must
forfeit all interest from the beginning of the above transactions,
and could recover only the original fifteen thousand
Page 195 U.S. 373
dollars, the actual overdraft on July 12, 1895, four hundred and
seventy-four dollars and twenty-four cents, the bank credit of two
hundred and thirty dollars given the same day, the note of October
1, 1895, for twenty-five hundred dollars, the overdraft on April
29, 1896, of eight hundred and seventy-four dollars and eighty-one
cents, and the bank credit of two dollars and forty-two cents -- in
all, nineteen thousand eighty-one dollars and ninety-seven cents,
less fifty-five hundred dollars collected on account since the
action was begun. 172 Mo. 384, 72 S.W. 925.
By the United States Rev.Stat. § 5197, a bank may charge
"interest at the rate allowed by the laws of the state, . . . where
the bank is located, and no more." By § 5198, taking, receiving, or
charging
"a rate of interest greater than is allowed by the preceding
section, when knowingly done, shall be deemed a forfeiture of the
entire interest which the note, bill, or other evidence of debt
carries with it, or which has been agreed to be paid thereon."
The Revised Statutes of Missouri fix six percent as the rate of
interest in the absence of agreement, § 3705, but allow parties to
agree in writing for not over eight percent. § 3706. They also
allow parties to contract in writing for the payment of interest
upon interest, "but the interest shall not be compounded oftener
than once in a year," § 3711. It will be seen that the charge on
the overdrafts went beyond § 3706, and the compounding of the
semiannual interest on the notes encountered § 3711.
The plaintiff in error denies that the prohibition of
compounding oftener than once a year affects the "rate of interest"
within the meaning of those words in U.S.Rev.Stat. § 5198, and
contends that, so long as the total sums received would not amount
to more than eight percent on the debt, it has a right to charge
them under U.S.Rev.Stat. § 5197, coupled with Missouri Rev.Stat. §
3706. It disposes of the twelve percent charge on overdrafts by the
suggestion that the amount is trifling, and
de minimis non
curat lex, and that this charge was a penalty because of a
failure to pay a debt
Page 195 U.S. 374
when due, and therefore not usurious. We are of a different
opinion. The rate of interest which an man receives is greater when
he is allowed to compound than when he is not, the other elements
in the case being the same. Even if the compounded interest is less
than might be charged directly without compounding, a statute may
forbid enlarging the rate in that way, whatever may be the rules of
the common law. The Supreme Court of Missouri holds that that is
what the Missouri statute has done. On that point, and on the
question whether what was done amounted to compounding within the
meaning of the Missouri statute, we follow the state court.
Union National Bank v. Louisville, New Albany & Chicago
Ry., 163 U. S. 325,
163 U. S. 331.
Therefore, since the interest charged and received by the plaintiff
was compounded more than once a year, it was at a rate greater than
was allowed by U.S.Rev.Stat. § 5197, and it was forfeited. The
suggestions as to the twelve percent charge on overdrafts do not
seem to us to need answer.
There is no doubt, of course, that the court could go behind the
face of the present note, and analyze the sum which it represents
into its original elements.
Brown v. Marion National Bank,
169 U. S. 416;
Haseltine v. Central National Bank, 183 U.
S. 132,
183 U. S.
135-136. These cases sufficiently show, also, if more is
wanted than the words of Rev.Stat. § 5198, that the court below did
not err in forfeiting all the interest from the beginning.
We perceive no warrant in the statute or the cases for the
contention that the bank, when it brings the action and is met by
the plea of usury, may avoid the forfeiture imposed by Rev.Stat. §
5198 in absolute terms, by then declaring an election to remit the
excessive interest.
Judgment affirmed.