Upon these articles the collector of the port levied and
collected a duty of 45 percent imposed by paragraph 122 of the
Tariff Act of October 1, 1890, 26 St. 573, c. 1244, upon "stained
or painted window glass and stained or painted glass windows, . . .
wholly or partly manufactured, and not specially provided for in
this act."
Against this classification defendant duly and seasonably
protested, claiming the articles were exempt from duty as
"paintings . . . specially imported in good faith for the use of
any society or institution . . . established for religious . . .
purposes, . . . and not intended for sale,"
under paragraph 677. A hearing was had before the board of
general appraisers, who overruled the protest and affirmed the
action of the collector. Respondents thereupon filed a petition in
the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York, praying
for a review of the decision of the general appraisers, as provided
in section 15 of the Act of June 10, 1890, 26 St. 138, c. 407. The
circuit court reversed the decision of the board of appraisers and
held the paintings to be entitled to free entry.
In re
Perry, 47 F. 110. From this decision the United States
appealed to this Court.
MR. JUSTICE BROWN, after stating the facts in the foregoing
language, delivered the opinion of the Court.
It is difficult to fix the proper classification of the
importations in question under the Act of October 1, 1890, without
referring to the prior acts upon the same subject.
By the Tariff Act of March 3, 1883, 22 St. 497, c. 121, there
was imposed a duty of 45 percent upon "porcelain and Bohemian
glass, chemical glassware, painted glassware, stained glass, and
all other manufactures of glass . . . not specially enumerated,"
while "paintings, in oil or water colors"
Page 146 U.S. 73
(
id., 513) were subject to a duty of 30 percent, and
"paintings, drawings, and etchings specially imported in good
faith" for religious institutions (
id., 520) were admitted
free. Under this and similar prior statutes, which did not differ
materially in their language, it was uniformly held by the Treasury
Department that the term "paintings" covered all works of art
produced by the process of painting, irrespective of the material
upon which the paint was laid, and that paintings on glass which
ranked as works of art were dutiable as paintings, and when
imported for religious institutions were entitled to admission free
of duty. Like rulings were made with respect to paintings on ivory,
silk, leather, and copper, having their chief value as works of
art. The term was also held to include wall panels painted in oil
and designed for household decoration. A like view was taken by
this Court in
Arthur v. Jacoby, 103 U.
S. 677, of pictures painted by hand upon porcelain,
where the porcelain ground
"was only used to obtain a good surface on which to paint, and
was entirely obscured from view when framed or set in any manner,
and formed no material part of the value of said paintings on
porcelain, and did not, in itself, constitute an article of China
ware, being manufactured simply as a ground for the painting, and
not for any use independent of the paintings."
In the meantime, however, the manufacture of stained glass began
to be recognized industry in this country. Strong protests were
sent to Congress against these rulings of the department, and
demands were made for the imposition of a duty upon stained glass
windows as such, to save the nascent industry from being crushed
out by foreign competition. Accordingly, in the Act of October 1,
1890, we find a notable change in phraseology and the introduction
of a new classification. By paragraph 122, a duty of 45 percent is
imposed upon "all stained or painted window glass and stained or
painted glass windows, and hand, pocket, or table mirrors, not
exceeding" a certain size, while, by paragraph 465, "paintings, in
oil or water colors," are subject to a duty of only 15 percent. The
former exemption of "paintings, drawings, and etchings specially
imported" for religious institutions is
Page 146 U.S. 74
continued in paragraph 677, while in paragraph 757 a similar
exemption is extended to
"works of art, the production of American artists residing
temporarily abroad, or other works of art, including
pictorial
paintings on glass, imported expressly for . . . any
incorporated religious society, . . .
except stained or painted
window glass, or stained or painted glass windows."
It is insisted by the defendants that the painted glass windows
in question, having been executed by artists of superior merit,
specially trained for the work, should be regarded as works of art,
and still exempted from duty as "paintings," and that the provision
in paragraph 122, for "stained or painted window glass and stained
or painted glass windows," applies only to such articles as are the
work of an artisan, the product of handicraft, and not to memorial
windows, which attain to the rank of works of art. Those who are
familiar with the painted windows of foreign cathedrals and
churches will indeed find it difficult to deny them the character
of works of art; but they would nevertheless be reluctant to put
them in the same category with the works of Raphael, Rembrandt,
Murillo, and other great masters of the art of painting. While they
are artistic in the sense of being beautiful, and requiring a high
degree of artistic merit for their production, they are ordinarily
classified in foreign exhibits as among the decorative and
industrial, rather than among the fine, arts. And in the catalogues
of manufacturers and dealers in stained glass, including the
manufacturers of these very importations, no distinction is made
between these windows and other stained or painted glass windows,
which, by paragraph 757, are specially excepted from the exemption
of pictorial paintings on glass.
For most practical purposes, works of art may be divided into
four classes:
1. The fine arts, properly so called, intended solely for
ornamental purposes, and including paintings in oil and water, upon
canvas, plaster, or other material, and original statuary of
marble, stone, or bronze. These are subject to a duty of 15
percent.
Page 146 U.S. 75
2. Minor objects of art, intended also for ornamental purposes,
such as statuettes, vases, plaques, drawings, etchings, and the
thousand and one articles which pass under the general name of
bric-a-brac, and are susceptible of an indefinite reproduction from
the original.
3. Objects of art, which serve primarily an ornamental, and
incidentally a useful, purpose, such as painted or stained-glass
windows, tapestry, paper hangings, etc.
4. Objects primarily designed for a useful purpose, but made
ornamental to please the eye and gratify the taste, such as
ornamented clocks, the higher grade of carpets, curtains, gas
fixtures, and household and table furniture.
No special favor is extended by Congress to either of these
classes except the first, which is alone recognized as belonging to
the domain of high art. It seems entirely clear to us that, in
paragraph 757, Congress intended to distinguish between "pictorial
paintings on glass," which subserve a purely ornamental purpose,
and stained or painted glass windows, which also subserve a useful
purpose, and, moved doubtless by a desire to encourage the new
manufacture, determined to impose a duty of 45 percent upon the
latter, while the former were admitted free. As new manufactures
are developed, the tendency of each tariff act is to nicer
discriminations in favor of particular industries. Thus, by acts
previous to that of 1890, paintings upon glass and porcelain were
distinguished and taken out of the general category of manufactures
of glass and porcelain, and even of stained glass, while under that
act, painted and stained glass windows are distinguished and taken
out of the general designation of paintings upon glass. If the
question in this case rested solely upon the language of paragraph
677, doubtless these importations would be exempted as paintings
imported for religious purposes; but as, by paragraph 757,
pictorial paintings on glass, a more specific designation, are
again exempted, and stained glass windows are excepted and taken
out of this exemption, we think the intent of Congress must be
gathered from the language of the latter paragraph, rather than the
former.
Robertson v. Glendenning, 132 U.
S. 158. Particularly is this so in view of the fact
that, by
Page 146 U.S. 76
paragraph 122, a duty is ievied upon "stained or painted window
glass and stained or painted glass windows"
eo nomine. The
use for which the importations are made in each case is much the
same. The fact that these articles are advertised and known to the
trade as painted or stained glass windows is an additional reason
for supposing that Congress intended to subject them to a duty.
The judgment of the circuit court must therefore be
Reversed, and the case remanded for further proceedings in
conformity to this opinion.