Hubbard v. Ratledge, No. 7:2015cv00599 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/9/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
cœv sos l t. olmcoud ycE l s s A i é ïv . . Tx xoK ,A , o FI ED L I THE UM TED S N TATESDI TW CT COURT S FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF W RGI A CT M R O AN OK E DI SI N W O CR EA D ELL H U BBAR D , 1ûy 29 2 1 95 J A . ULI BY: ' . 1 CA SE N O .7: 15CV 00599 Pe i i r, t tone W. M EM O R A ND U M O PI I N N O CHARIESM TLEDGE, ARDEN , W By:Hon.Gl E.Conr en ad Chi fUni e St e D i t i tJudge e t d at s s r c R es ponde . nt Cr a l Hubba d,a i t a t Unied St t Pe t nta y i Le Co t Vigi a e de l r n nma e t he t aes nie ir n e un y, r ni , pr e ng or K, e t speii f am i ofha sc oc edi o fld hi tton or t bea omus purua t 28U. C.j2241 , s nt o S. . . Hubba d a s rst tli s nt nc i unlwf , nd t c ts d or rt theber s ntnc d. r s e t ha ts e e e s a ul a he our houl de ha ee e e Upon r vi w oft r c d,t c t oncl e e he e or he our c udest tt peii mus besl ma iy dim is d a ha he tton t lm rl s s e s wiho me i. t ut rtl Hubba dwasco c e i t Unie S a e DititCo tf rt Ea t m Dititof r nvi t d, n he t d t t s src ur o he se src Norh Ca olna ofbn r r a r lt d c r s f rwhih hewa s nt nc d i Aprl1 t r i , nk obbe y nd ea e ha ge , o c s e e e n i 989. Hea mi ta hep e i u l c le g dt tud me tt u c sf ly i amo int v c t, e d t h t rv o sy haln e ha j g n ,ms c e sul,n s to o a ae s t a ieo c re t esn e c t e 28U. C. 2 5 .l h sj22 peiin, b rd a srs sd r o rd h e tn e md r S. j 2 5 n i 41 tto Hu b se t t thi e nce s ntnc of327 m o hsunde t Ca ee Ofe rpr son oft Urie ha s nha d e e e nt r he r r f nde ovii he lt d St t s nt nc ng gui lnese e d t ma mlm s nt nc al wedby lw f hi ofe e aes e e i de i xce de he xi l e e e lo a or s f ns 300 mont .The e or hes e r s ntncng. hs r f e, e ks e e e i Hubbard v. Ratledge Doc. 3 A dititc t ynote e t naha a c puspeiinpurua t j2241a t i src our ma ntrai be s or tto s nt o temptng t h ld t as ne eo c n ito lne samo inpt s n t j2 5i tn d q aeo o wai ae e tnc r o v cin lls to t ua t o 25 s t a e u t r r i i fk tv t ts t lg l yo glimae s d tn im' 2 U. C. 2 5 e' e , ..S i nelcie o e the e ai f a& n t'q ee to ' 8 S. j 25 () s e eg, wan t , 1 eRue 1b & 4, e Go rigS cin2 5 Cae (uhoiigds sa o ha e speiinwh r Se ls () Ruls venn e to 2 4 ss at rzn imisl f b a tt o ee iplil a p aso fc o peio ta p t in rino e t ldt ha e srl g. t any p e r m a e f tin h t eio e s t nie o b a ei t t t e Dockets.Justia.com v. ese 43 U. 3 2 3 ( 9 7 . A p o e m a i e i n t j2 5 rle, u ha te Pr sly, 0 S. 7 , 81 1 7 ) r c d lmp dme t o 2 5 eif s c s h saueoflmiainsort r eagans s c svepeii ,doe notrnde j2255r viw ttt i tto he ul i t uc esi ttons s e r ee çn d q t'o tnefcie' I r Vil 1 5F.d 1 9 1 9 n. ( t Ci.1 9 ) Th Untd G a e uae' r t fe tv . n e a, 1 3 1 2, 1 4 5 4h r 9 7 . e ie i i ' Stt Cour ofAppeasf t FourhCic thasf mdt tj2255i i de t andi feci aes t l or he t r ui ot ha s na quae nef tve t t tt l gaiy ofacon c i whe o es he e lt viton n: ( )a t t o c n ito stld1w o ti cruto teS p e Co r 1 the i f o v cin ete a f h s ic i r h u rme u t me etb ihe telg lt o t c n ito ()s b e u n t t prs n rsdr c sa ls d h e ai f he o vcin;2 u s q e t o he io e ' ie t y a p a a dfrtj2 5moin,hes bsa tv 1w c a e s c t a t ec n u t p e l n is 25 to t u tnie a h ng d u h h t h o d c ofwliht prs ne wasc nvitdi de me nott bec nala ()t tc he io r o ce s e d o dmi ; nd 3 he p io rc n ts tsyt g tke pngp o iinso j2 5 b c u et n w r l rs ne n no aif he ae e i r v so f 2 5 e a s he e ue i no oneofco tmtona lw. s t nsi i l a I r J n s 2 6F.d3 , 333 ( t Ci. 0 0 . n e o e , 2 3 28 3 - 4 4h r 2 0 ) . Hubba dma notc le hi Care Ofe rs ntnc e nce ntvi j2241 The r y halnge s e r fnde e e e nha me a . s tntve lw ha no c ubsa i a s t hange s t tHubba d i ac t l im oc ntofba r r a hi d o ha r s tz y r e al nk obbe y nd s ohe ofe ess a t rnde j2255i de t andi fe i t t tt lgaiyoft e t r fns o s o e r na quae nefctve o es he e lt hos c c i .N o doe Hubba dofe e de et thei acua l imoce oft pro onvitons r s r f r vi nc ha s t ly r nt he i r c c i us d t e nc hi f r ls nt nc SeeUnied Stt sv. tior 61 F. 270, onvitons e o nha e s ede a e e e. t ae Pe tf d, 2 3d 2 4(t Ci. 1 )( o dn t a t c u lin c nc t e J n sa p isi t c n e to ha t a 8 4h r 20 0 h l ig h tl t a n o e e md r o e p le n he o tx f biu l a ofe rpr sonsonl whe et c le t ei i lt se s9om f cua i oc nc oft f nde ovii y r he hal nge o lgbiiy t m a t l ml e e he m e caeci s a no fom t lga ca st ain o t me c t ci ' .tFo t Cic t di t rme , nd t r he e l lsik to f he diae rmes' t urh rui ) prc d n h s. . o (t e wie e tn e t era h o ( 8U.. j2 5 /) t to ep tto es e e e t a . n t oh r s l x e d d h e c f 2 SC. 2 5 1 o h s eiin r c alngngo l ters ne e' UntdS ae v. oe 5 F.d2 , 7n. (t Ci. 0 ) h le i ny h i e tnc . ie tts Po l, 31 3 63 26 7 4 h r 2 08 ' (iigI r J n s 2 6F.da 3 3 3 :.Fial,h f c t t ne j2 5 mo info ctn n e o e , 2 3 t 3 - 4 n ly te a tha a w 2 5 to r m Hubbadwoul betmebar dorc i r s esi doesnotma j2255r e r d i re onsdeed ucc sve ke eviw 2 G na quq e'o Gnefe tve. l r Vi ,11 F. a 11 n.5. Ac or ngl Hubba dm a not l de t ' r t f c i ' n e al 5 3d t 94 i i ' c di y, r y p o e dvaj2 41 a dhsp tto i ds s e .Ana p o raeo d rwi e trti d y. r c e i 2 , n i ei n s imis d i p r p it r e l n e l s a l l The Clr i die t dt s nd c e oft sm e o a l opi on a ac om pa ng e k s r c e o e opi s hi m r ndlm ni nd c nyi or rt peii ne . de o tto r EN TER : Iu s 9 J dyo xo e e, 0 s a r vmbr2 1. ClifUnie St t sDititJ le t d a e src udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
