Brown v. McPeak et al, No. 7:2014cv00370 - Document 34 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/6/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF

CLERK' oFFl U, Dl cour S c: s. sm ATRoAt: E, A 11- v :k: 7 px lEk -. ( : 2 ) 02T 16 2 1 29 I TH E UN I N TED STATE S D I STR I C O U RT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI CT RGI A NI ROANOKE DI I O N V SI CURTI J.BROW N, S J A . D , ULI :Y; DEPU ,C E CASE NO.7: 4CV00 1 378 Pl ntf , ai if M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON NI GERALD M CPEAK, AL , :I By:GlnE.Conrad e C hi fU nie St t sD i t c Judge e t d a e s ri t De e f ndants. t) Curi J Br ts . own,aVig ni i t pr ee ng pr K , ie t scvi rght ac i r i a nma e oc di o fld hi i l i s ton p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 .Hi c mpan a n n e alg st a wh l h wa i c r eae u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3 s o li t s me d d l e h t ie e s n ac rtd e a t eNe Rie ValyRe in l alt d fn a t al fiil f ie t p o i ehm wih t h w v r le go a J i,he ee d n j io fcas ald o r v d i t m e a he t te t ntf hi di nos d Pos Tr l tc Stes Dior r AsBr nt l alh r a me or s ag e t atma i r s s de . own s e onl e ks y d caao ya dij n tverle a ha n w b e ta fre , i camsaemo t Th r fr , e lrtr n nu ci eif nd s o e n rnser d hs li r o . eeo e t ec u t o cu e ta tea to mus b s mmaiyds se wi o t eu c t e 2 h o r c n ld s h t h ci n t e u rl imis d t u prj die md r 8 h U .S. j1 A( ( )f fit et saeacai l C. 915 b)1 or all o tt l m. r Th j rs ito o f d r lc u t i l tdt l ec s so c nr v ris U. Co s. r. e u id cin f e ea o rs s i e o i a e r o to e se . S. n t at mi v 11 j 1 I de opme soc trdurngt c s ofac s whihr rt c ztuna et grnt 1, . f vel nt cl i he oure a e c ende he otr bl o a a pa t t r le r ques e t c ai s m us be di m i s d as m oot Bl nc a v. A leg ny r y he e i f e t d, he l m t s se . a ik l he Lu lm Co, 7 F.d6 0, 9 - 9 (d Ci.9 6 . Th ta fro rla eo ap io rg n rly du .7 3 9 6 8 9 3 r1 9 ) e rnse r ee s f rs ne e eal Brown v. McPeak et al Doc. 34 rn e smo ta ycamsfrijmcieo d ca ao yr l fr ltn t t ef r rpa eo e d r o n li o nt tv r e lr tr ei eaig o h o me lc f e 1Thecour i r r t dim isany a i orcl m f l by a prs t s equied o s s cton ai ied ioneragai tagove nment ns r al entt orof i ri t cour de e m i t acton orcl m i fi ous malci ,orf l t sa ea cl m iy fce f he t t r nes he i ai s rvol , i ous ais o t t ai onwhih rle ma beg a e 28U. C. l 5 b ( ) c e if y rntd. S. j 9l A( ) 1. Dockets.Justia.com c i me .SeeCot vofLosAngee v. vi, U. 625,631( 979) W iln v. onfne nt mt ls Da s 440 S. 1 ; lims Grfi 952F. 8 8 (t Ci.9 )(i ngprs rsta frrndeedmoothi cli itn, 2d 20, 23 4h r1 91 tndi ione' rnse e r s ams f rijmciea dd caao yrle M a e v. aes 81 F.d451 45 (t Ci.9 7 o nt tv n e lrt r eig; g e W tr, 0 2 , 2 4h r1 8 ) ( odn t tr n fro ap io e r n ee mo th scam f rij n t erle h lig ha ta se f rs n r e d rd o i li o nu ci eig. v Br wnalg st a wh l h wa i ac rtda t j if ro e ay a , en tfe t e o l e h t ie e s nc r eae the al o v r e r h o iid h e de e nt ofhi me a heat pr e sa as d r pe t dl t s et ps hitita f nda s s nt l lh oblm nd ke e a e y o e he yc a rs bout m e c ton. The de e di a i f ndan splce Br on a ls t c ul wih aps hi ti ntr e t a d own it o ons t t yc arc ls pr c ii r butfvemont pas e bef r t sa nt e occ r d i Nove be 201 a ttone , i hs s d o e hi ppoi m nt ure n m r 3. Br wn t d t spr es i ofhi PTSD d a i a o he m e a heat pr e she was o ol hi of sonal s i gnoss nd t r nt l lh oblm e re i a s t d hi he woul s ha a a n m e twih aps hititr r ng xpe i nc ng, nd he ol m d oon ve n ppoi t n t yc a rs ega di pos i em e c ton.Br sbl dia i own wat d e g mor m ont a t n wa pr de a t r ie i ht e hs nd he s ovi d no he c ula i wih t ntr epr ttoneron J y 1 201 She s i s wo d r n t t t de de ons tton t he ls acii ul 7, 4. a d he ul u ess o ci whihmediai weea oprae Fr taed,Br wntldt sj 1 a ton,s e ngbetr c c tons r ppr it. usr t o ie hi 983 ci e ki te me tl e l te t n a tej i a da kn t r c v rh sc ssfrt elws i.l mi- us, n a h at rame t t h al n s ig o e o e i o t o h a u t n d Aug t h Br fl an a nde co pli ,r ii t s m ec am sco e ni deaysi a ce st own ied me d m a nt a sng he a li nc r ng l n c s o me tl e lhc r a ds e n smia d caao ya ijmcier l fa an t al fkil.He n a h at ae n e kig i lr e lrt r nd nt tv ei g i s ji o t as e as a d das p r t cam a u b igd nida c s t t j i' lw lb ay. lo d e e a ae li bo t en e e c e s o he als a irr On Se e r30,201 howe r Br no ii d t c tt theha bee ta f r e pt mbe 4, ve , own tfe he our ha d n r nse r d t Bl nd Cor e tonalCe e . A st de e o a rci nt r he f ndant na ed i t sac i no l rha a s m n hi ton onge ve ny a hort t evauaeand pr dete t ntf Br ut iy o l t ovi r a me or own' men a he lh ne o hi lgalr s a ch s t l at eds r s e e e r n e s h scamsfrd caaoy a dij ci rle a an tte aemo t Be a et ec u t e d , i li o e lrt r n nun tve eif g is h m r o . c us h o r 2 c nn lng rg a therle h s e s t ec mpan wil ed s se wih u p eu ie a o o e rn t eif e e k ,h o lit l b imis d t o t rj dc , purua t j1 A( ( ) Ana o it or rwilis t sda s nt o 915 b)1. ppr prae de l sue hi y. TheCl r i diecedt s c e oft sme o a l opi on a ac om pa ng e k s r t o end opi s hi m r ndlm ni nd c nyi o de t pl ntf. r r o ai if EN TER : Ths6 i N d y o oco r 2 4 a f tbe, 01 . ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.