Farley v. Stoots et al, No. 7:2014cv00270 - Document 206 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/2/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL ' OF I t.. : :Q:X ' ERKS FCE l nI% : AT DAN?ILE, L VA FI LED I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STR I T O F VI G I A C R NI R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI D AR R ELL EU G EN E FA RL EY , Pl ht f , ai i f N2# -2 2 1 25 JULI c uo A BY: , L E C i lA cti N o.7: vvi on 14-c 00270 M EM O R AND UM O PI I N N O SGT.STOOTS,e al, t . D ef endant s. By: H o Jacks L. ie n. on K s r Seni U nied St esD i t ctJudge or t at s ti Dar l Euge Fa l y,aVigi ai aepr e ng nr K ,fl d as co a e d r el ne re r ni nm t oc edi o ie e nd m nde c mp an ( No. 2 p s n t 4 U. C. 1 8 , n n vaiu o fcaso t Vign a o lit ECF 6 ) urua t o 2 S. j 9 3 n mi g ro s fiil f he r ii De rme t fCor cin (ç pat n o re to s ç VDOC' Gre Ro kCo rcina Cè tr(ç e nRo k' a ' e n c re to l n e t e c ', nd ) Gr ) Po aa Co r ci n lCe tr( wh tn re to a ne 1 'a d fnd ns Plitf a De e a t ha tmeyfld TCC' s ee a t. anif nd fnd n s ve i l ie ) moi n frs mmayj g n ( No . 6 ,1 4 1 , n 1 3 a dr s o s s( No .1 3 to s o u r ud me t ECF s 1 2 6 , 71 a d 8 ) n e p n e ECF s 8 , 1 , 1 5 1 7 1 ,1 9, nd 1 3 , n temalri n w rp frds sto 1 Afe r viwi t 84 8 , 8 , 88 8 a 9 ) a d h te s o ie o ipo iin. tr e e ng he rc r , g a tDee d n s moinsf rs e o d I r n f n a t' to o ummayj d me t r u g n. 1 anifsmoinfra e tnso o tme( No 1 9 i ga tdt t e tn ta hsl e rn u Plitf' to o n xe in fi ECF . 7 ) s rne o he xe th t i i moa d m M a Ex iio S x a Asa l i P io '( No 1 1 i.o sd rdi o p sto t Dee d ns ds stv nd hbt f e u l sutn rsn'ECF . 9 )sc n iee n p o i n o fn a t' ipoiie i moié .No eo Plitf' n meo oh rrs nss( No . 9 , 9 1 5 20 , 0 , 2, 3 a d2 4 c nbe to s n f an ifs u rus te epo e ECF s 1 1 1 2, 9 , 0 2 1 20 20 , n 0 ) a consder tmel fl i r s ns t Deenda s'dipostvemotons a Pl ntf i ed i y ied n e po e o f nt s ii i , nd ai ifhasno s t oughtt ha t c t o ve he our c n ie te o to tme CfFe . Ci. 6b( )B) ECFNos 1 6,1 9 seJ u dnv.a , 51F.d1 ,1 9 o sd rh m u fi . . d R. v P. ()l( , ' . 6 7 , e o r a Jbe 9 2 08 0 . 1 (t Ci. 9 )( ligt tap o. l ia ti n t n ie t s e ilc n ieaint e c eafitet f l w a 0 6h r 1 91 hodn ha r K ig n s o e tt d o p ca o sd rto t x us alr o ol t l ? l o srihfr r poe ua rq i metht 1ypro cncmpe eda esl a alwf r; l r v C r o , t g towad rcd rleur n taa a esn a o rh n s ai s a ejBal d . al n a e y a s Farley v. Stoots et al 8 2F.d9 , 6(t Ci.1 8 )(tt ta p o. l ia t aetu jc t tet rq ie nsa rs c frc u t 8 2 3 9 4h r 9 9 sai h t r K ig ns r t be to h i e urme t nd epet o o r ng t s me o d r wi u whc efcie u iil d ùsrto wo l b i sil'; Do adv. a Crmia Ct r es t t ih fe tv j dca a miitain ud e mposbe' Mc n l He d i n l . ho l S nevs rOfie, 5 F.d1 , 2 ( Ci. 9 8 (( 1iepr . lia t ma i g nea d sremoelne t u rio fcr 8 0 2 21 l 4 2d r 1 8 ) (W h1 oK ig ns y n e rl e ev r e in 1 t Doc. 206 team e t n t er es ntd bycouns l alltgant,i udi p o s s ha a oblgai t c r t nt ha hos epr e e e, 1 ii s ncl ng r e , ve n i ton o ompl wihcou t y t r o d r.Wh nte to th to lg to te ,l a1lia t, tsfe tec nsq e e o terato s' . r es e h y l u ta biain h y Qe 1 i g nsmus u fr h o e u ncs fh i cin .) t ' Inot t t e e f s ec esofg iva e a medialr or , antf' o he r s e andm otons e ha, xc pt or om opi re nc s nd c ec ds Pli ifs t r epons s i frs mmayj d me tc n ito ag me t to t ee a te d n e F temo e 1n t t t ant fcn o us a o u r u g n o ss f r u n wi u rlv n vie c . urh r r, oe ha Pli i a n t e h f rs o s t amoinfrs mmayj d me t oa ndo c re t c mpan.Cla n e v M c vt 5 5F. 3 4 ep n e o to o u r u g n t me r orc a o lit o nic r . De i 5 3d 2 , t 3 (t Ci. 0 ) Totee tn Plitf aksfrad futu g n i o o hi rs nssb cus h b l ve 36 4h r2 09. h xe t anif s o ea lj d me tn ne f s epo e e a e e ei s e defnda Fa di notwor unde colro saelw ortm el r s e nt w d k r o f tt a i y e pond t aco pl nto c to de s t r que ti o m ai r our r r ,he e s s d ne a baees S e eg, e . Ci. 5 ; n rv Do n lv 4 F.d2 0(t Ci. 9 4 . e id s sls. e , ..F d R. v P. 5 Co ne . n el, 2 3 2 4h r 1 9 ) Dockets.Justia.com J - : Pl i ifa l gest f l w i f c sst ba e ofhi une a ntf le he olo ng a t he s s s num e a e c a m s Fore i r rtd li . as e co pr he i n a r e e ,ls pa a et alegai nsi o eght e cli . m e nso nd ef r nce e r t he l to nt i e n a ms . Cli 1a am () Durngt s pa a ei i t a PCC,Pli tf wa r pe by a i ae,a t bl of i wo e r t ncden s t a n if s a d n nm t nd he ood a oh rimaewh c mmitds cd d o tce 'Plit fss na dmo t ( e o Am. n t e n t o o te uiie ç n a td' ani ki n uh. S c nd c f Co l!2 . Be a s Pli tf wa i t er c ii gpo a PCC a ti tme heha n c lb x i mp . 4) c u e anif s n h e ev n d t t h s i , d o al o n hi c la dha t r l o o fc r i t po frp oe to a dr q e t f rs r ie .(d a !2 . s el n d o ey n fies n he d o r tcih n e u ss o e vc s 1 . t 3) . Cli 1( am b) Ve y s n a trt e i i nt,Pli ifr q se a e r nc gre ncef m ' om r oo fe hes nc de s antf e ue t d n me ge y iva or f r de e nt Ofi rW ade a Ofi e Gr e i or rt r ei medi lc ef t e f nda s fce l nd fc r e n n de o ec ve ca ar or he xpos r t ue o b o da ds me a df rb e dngfo hsa u a dg ntl.( =a !2 . Th o fc r d n e l o n e n n o le i r m i n s n e ias J .t 4) e fie s e id # Splitfln e e me ia c r . i an if e d d dc l ae' g ' * C li 2 am Upon hi a rva a Gr n Roc on M a c 1 201 Pl i ifa ke de e nt Uni s r i l t ee k r h 2, 4, antf s d f nda s t Ma a e wigil a kco nslrchidesfrasn l c l b th ytl plitfta snge n g r n fed n u eo lrs o ige el u te od ani h t i l , f c lswe en t valbea Gr e Ro k.(d. t 2 )Pli tf flda e r e c giv n eo el r o a ia l t e n c I a ! 5. anif ie n meg n y re a c n M a c 30,201 e es i c nc r f rhi s f y duet bengbunke wih Ge g Pe s ,a rh 4, xpr sng o e n o s a et o i d t or e r ons sr ng r mo eviln imaewhois tda dtr ae e Plitf.(d. t!25) Du t to e , r o e t n t n ul n h e tn d an if 1 a e . eo Pli ifsc ant,safmovedPes outofPl ntf scela i os r gai (d.a antf' ompli s tf rons ai if l nd nt eg e ton. I t !2 ) OnAp i 2, 1 Gre Ro kme ia sa f o k pct e o Plitf siju e fo t e 5. rl 20 4, e n c dc l t f t o itl s f an if nti s r m h r a tc by Pe s .2 Pli iff ulsde e nt W i l a Cot e o Chid es f no puti ta k r ons a ntf a t f nda s ngûe d nd ms l r l r s or t tng Pl i ifi asngl ce l antf n i e l. * Cl i 3 am I maeM ilrrplc dPe s n a Plitf sc lmae (d a !2 ) OnAp i 1 , 01 , n t l e a e ro s s an if el t . 1 . t 6. e rl 4 2 4 M il rr pe Pl ntf at le a d ai if lhough Pl n ifco d notr m be t r pe ce ry bec us hebele s aitf ul eme r he a la l a e ive t a hehad been drugged,knockedunconsci ,ori s o kd rn t rp . ( e o dAm. ht ous n h c u ig he a e3 S c n . Co l a !2 . P an iff ut d f n a t S tS o t, ig il , n Chl rs f rno p oe tn mp . t 6) litf a ls e e d n s g . t o s W n fed a d id e s o t r tcig hi .Pl i ifa s f t de e nt Sgt St sa Dr Sc i rf notgi ng li asngl c l m antf lo auls f nda s . oot nd . hne de or vi lm i e e l b c u et e k w P an ifh dbe nav ci o s x a a u ewhl i p io a a ac id (d e a s h y ne litf a e itm f e u l b s i n rs n nd s hl . I . e a !2 ) t 6. @ Cl i 4 am W hie a G r e R oc on M a c 1 201 Pl n i fr que t û r t e t c m s lng' f l t en k r h 2, 4, ai tf e s ed s ea m n / ot e i ' or t Po ttaz tcSr s Dio d r(TTS 'a s x l b e (d. t!27) Alh u h d fn a t s-rl i te s s r e C D' nd e ua a us . 1 a ma ) . t o g ee d n Fa aQu lfe M e t l at P o e so l ( HP' , sa r o hsrq e t f rc t eig w, aiid na He lh r f sina ($ QM ' Wa wae f i e u ss o o ms l , ) n te t n ddn to c ru tl a 20 4.(d. t!2 ) r ame t i o c u n iM y 1 1 a 7. @ C li 5 am W hie i a i oltoh c li t Gr e Ro k m e c lde rme o Aprl22, 4, l n n s a i el n he e n c di a pa t nt n i 201 Plitf fl d wn a dht h c nceefo r (d. t!29) Ofie W is nhep dPlitf it a anif el o n it e o rt lo . l a . fc r lo le an if n o whe c ra as dNur e J ne f as it nc Pl ntf al ge elhai nd ke s o s or ss a e. ai if le s: 2Plitf d e n td srb i tesc n a n dc mplitwh no h w Pes n ij rdhm, ut i anif o s o ecie n h e o d me de o an e r o ro s nu e i b hs ofe rr ues fld onM ach31, 4,sysPes i lc e as ole br s whenheûsamm ed'Pl ntf a a fnde eq t ie r 201 a rons nfit d w ln uie dl ' ai if w y fom t rc lscalbox. r hei el' l 3Gr e Roc saftans rtd Pl ntf t Lync g Ge alHos tlf rr pete t e . ( c n Am. en k t f r po e ai if o hbur ner pia o a r am nt Seo d Co l!26)Plitf h dt l an reta h se tr u hterp d et ame iain. mp. . anif a od us h t e lptho g h a e u o dc to 3 L re J neqwa d s r n ld b c u e o hm a kn h rt a ss me sn e ' s o s s ig u te e a s f i s ig e o sit , ic Nu ot r nur e wer t l ng a drnki c f .... Ntr e J s e n ha he ss e aki nd i ng ofee ls one ve d c once nsi r r t te tng. Ntr e Co a Nur e Do r n ega ds o r a i ls bbs nd s wdy f ie t a ss a ld o s it he whe s a ke t r n he s d hem t he p be us o a pos i e he r q t k .... Iw a o l ca e f s bl a t tac s s e ng s s a lg s r r ng hea ea s a c tpr s ze. A not r of e r e i pot nd i ht , oa i d/ r nd hes es lr he f nde (n t)h l dmeo tE f t ewh ec ars Nu s J n sc ude mieme I imae epe u ol h e lh i o re o e o l xa l . l wa i dsrs sti f ra u Ei e miu e whl Nu s J ne tid t g t s n ite s it o bo t fv q n ts ie re o s re o e ng s omeo t hep me he . l c d o d e aspr i ustm e pa s d. X r y wa ne o l / r oul f i d ec o i se a s done. Not ng gi n t m e f r pan or a hi 1 was whe l d ba k t t hi ve o o i nyt ng. e e c o he ce l X r s ntof t be r ad. Iw asi s r ouspa n s il l. ay e fo e n ei i tl. (d a !2 ) On Ap i 23 201 , an ifflda e r e c g iva c a o shefl a d 1 . t 9. rl , 4 Plitf ie n meg n y re n e b u t al n s eq n m e ca te t e t whih Nur eHa rsr ponde t by s yi t tt e ge y ubs ue t di l r a m n , c s ri es d o a ng ha he mer nc gre nc di notm e tt de i to o a e e ge y and t tPl i ifw a s he e t s e t i va e d e he fnii n f n m r nc ha a ntf s c dul d o e he p y iin.(d. t!30) h sca 1 a . * Cl i 6 am D r Sc i r a Sgt St s bot t d Pl i if çlhi i prs ' t tt y cn tEs o . hne de nd . oot h ol a ntf , ç - s s i on'; ha he nno çt p - e % a hol ' antf ha a t tt y woul no a l Pl i ift wrt t peo eouti of nd d'Pl i ifs nd; nd ha he d t low antf o ie o pl sde Gre Ro kt ma t ep io ço kba . Se o dAm. mpl!31)The as i sn ae t e n c o ke h rs n s o d' c n l '( Co . . y lo n iu td o Plitf t th wa g ya dd s l dt b sx al a tc e (1.t!3 . an if ha e s a n e ewe o e e u l ta k d. JJa 1) y . a * Cl i 7 am Pli ifas G e a he lh' a Dr Scmei rf raC ci a antf ked t ntl a t ' nd . l de o t tm dvoc e'fom ar pec ii m vi at ' r a rss c n e, u Dr S h ed rl e l e 't h l tlngPlitf t d çto (il0 1'(d. t!3 ) e tr b t . c n ie G ci d'o ep,el d n i an if o o ç n h s w1. I a 2. i ' Plitf alg st a Dr S hn ie a dSg . t o strae dhslf a ds ft .(d a !3 ) an if l e h t . c ed r n tS o t h e tne i ie n aey 1 . t 2. e 4 * Cl i 8 am W hiei s gr ton,Pl i ifco d notm e twiht c pl i ora tndr lgiuss r i e . l n e egai antf ul e t he ha an te ei o e v c s (d. t!3 . 1 a 3) * Cl i 9 am Plitf c l dt eVDOC' Prs nRa eEl n to Ac (TREA' hol o J n 8 an if al h e S io p i ain t C mi ' ti n u e , ) ne 201 t rp r bengrpe b imaeRie b c us P an iffl QM HPFa G in'g tgi 4,o e o t i a d y n t ly e a e litf et w t d t e hmj d hep. (d a !3 ) Th n x d y Plitf me wi d fn a t Ali, . h ed r a dQMHP l ' l . t 4. e e t a , an if t t e e d n s v s Dr Sc n i e, n ' h Fa whoa1a td C as 'twa dPlitf.(d a !3 . P an ifwa plc di s ge ain w, 1 ce G rh'o r ah if I . t 4) litf s a e n e r g to h de piebr sng a bledi fom hi a bec us no doc orwason d y a t n s c d no s t uii nd e ng r s nus a e t ut nd he ur e oul t pef r ar p e n n to ( e o Am. mp . 3 ) Plitf alg sh wa d n e f o i ro m a e x miain. S c nd Co l! 4. an if le e e s e id o d n s g e aina dh dt e t i o fc s (d a !3 . P an ifse r e c g iv n e a o tte e r g to n a o a h s wn e e . I . t 4) litf' me g n y re a c s b u h lc o f o a dme ia c r we ed ne , n ( a vo aeis d' (d. t!3 ) a k f o d n d c l ae r e id a d G d c t sue . I a 4. no ' * Cl i 10 am Pli tf bl m e de e a n if n s f ndantPa ksf f ii t pr e thi fom t r pebe us Pa ksha r or alng o ot c m r he a ca e r d d n e Plitf sr q s f rata se.(d a !3 ) e id an if e ue t o rn fr I . t 5. * Cl i 11 am Alho h Pl i ifwr t t Elz beh Tho nt n, heVDOC' PREA Coo di t r a t t ug antf o e o i a t r o t S r na o , bou sxytme t c mpli a o t ste t n , o n o ne e rp id.(d. t!3 . Plitf it i s o o an b u hi rame t Th r tn v r e le 1 a ( 6) anif b le e a1d fn a t a Gre Ro kp rii tdi ac mpag o h r sme ta rtlain.(d eiv s 1 ee d n s t e n c a t pae n a in f aa s n s eaito I . c a !36. t ) 5 . Cl i 1 am 2 Plit falg sg n r lyt a hi ç ia r q e t /nfr l g r )rtr d ani le e e e al h t s d l nd e u ss i o mas we e eu ne f ma una weed, hi G i g s l ta dea dupt 30pl da gq' nd t thi Sega malg s ns r ' s i l waq os nd lye ' ma o us ys,'a ha s t l i wa l l d n e ' (d a !3 . e id. 1 . t 7) ' @ Cl m 13 ai Plitf c mpli t t ewa n t e dM ia da rg sdtrng tt i erviws' ( c n anif o ans ha h s o r a rn 4 i ht li ihe nt e ' Se o d . Am. mpla !38) Co . t . . Cl i 1 am 4 Pl i ifc antf ompli t theS sde e OP 8 1i t gre nc pr e ea tm e a a ns ha ç wa ni d 66. nma e iva e oc dur t i s t b t Gr e Ro k a d ( . (d. t 3 ) oh e n c n PCCI' I a ! 9. ' . Cl i 1 am 5 Pli ifal s Gfhedee ntwhoij e mewa i t s mepo atrIrtln dt antf lege ,ç fnda nurd s n he a d fe elr e o po a i .' Pl i ifalo c pulton ' antf s ompl i t ti aeRie wa hous d i t s m es g e ton lni 5 ans ha nm t ly s e n he n e r ga i l t a Gre Ro ka trRi yalg dyrpe hm.(d a !4 . t e n c fe l l e l a d i I . t 0) e e . Cl i 1 am 6 D e e ntM a s nbtr t I tt i lOm buds a a Gr n Roc t d Pl i ift t f nda s e lg, he ns iutona m n t ee k, ol a ntf ha Plitf wa E nt i ieo ben p t nr srcin t 8 6.. (d. t!41) Plitf alg st a, an if s t hn c n ig u o etito s o 6 1' l a o ' . an if le e h t whe alwe , eus dt egiv nc p o e u ea ia e (4 a !4 ) n lo d h e h re a e r c d r valbl. J. t 3. - 4M ia v. Arz n , 8 U.. 3 ( 9 6. r nda io a 3 4 S 4 6 1 6 ) 5Pli ifdoe noti n iyt defnda . antf s de tf he e nt 6 . Cli 1 am 7 Pli ifalgest theC sbe nuna et ge f l u STD,H1 lb(q r do a antf le ha ç ha e bl o t olow p V/a wo k ne t Gre Roc ' c hebeive s ul bedonei c s t i t M ilro Rie hadH1 ora e n k'whih le s ho d n a e he nmaes le r ly V s x lyta s te ds a e (d a !42 4 ) e ual -rn mitd ie s . 1 . t , 4. 1. 1 A p ryi e tte t sl r j g n i t ep e d n s t d s o r a dd sl sle at s ni d o l l mmay ud me t f h la i g ,he ic vey n ico t r m a e i l on f l a a a fda t s w t tt r i no ge ne di put a t a m a e i lf c . t r a s ie, nd ny f i vis ho ha he e s nui s e s o ny t ra a t Fe R. v. 5 () M aeil a t aet s n c sayt etb iht eee n so ap ry s d. Ci P. 6 a . tra fcs r ho e e e s r o sa ls h lme t f a t' c u eo ato And ro v Li ryLo b I .4 7U. 2 2 2 ( 98 ) A g n ieds t o a s f cin. es n . bet b y.nc, 7 S. 4 , 48 1 6 . e un ipue f m a e ilf c e ssi,i vi wi t r c d a a1r a ona e i e e e dr wn t r fom i a t ra a t xit f n e ng he e or nd l e s bl nf r nc s a he e r n lghtm os f vor bl t t noni t a a e o he movi pa t ar s na e f c -i tco d r t r ave ditf t ng ry, ea o bl a tfnde ul e u n r c or he non- nt J .Themovi pat hast bur nofs ng- thati,poi i outt t mova . #ng ry he de howi G s ntng t o he dititco t t t r i an a e e ofe de et s src ur - hat he e s bs nc vi nc o uppor t nonm o ngpa sc e.' t he vi ly' as ' Ceoe Co p. Cart, U. 31 325( 986) ft mova s tsist sbtr n,he t ltx r v. tet477 S. 7, 1 .I he nt aife hi lde t n he non- ova m us s tf t s ik ,a i s bl f t t tde o ta e t e s e ofa ge ne m nt t e orh pec t dm s i e ac s ha m ns r t he xi t nce nui diput offc f til 1 a 322- A pa' i entte t s s e a t or ra. d. t 23. ty s ild o ummm'j me i t r c dasa t y udg nt f he e or whol c d notlad ar tona ti roff c t fnd i f voroft no mova . W iln v. ifn, e oul e a i l re ato i n a he nnt li ms Grfi 9 2F.d8 0 8 3( t Ci. 9 ) Noa l ,t e et u po tds c lto . . sn t no ht 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 1 91 . tb y imjr ms p re pe u ai n . i o e ug o l d f a as mma yj dg n moin. nsv. tlAs ' o Bus & Ed c Ra i, n .5 F.d e e t u r u me t to ' i Na' sn f . u . do I c, 3 3 'En 55,62 ( h Ci.1 . 4t r 995) 1 11. Dee a t a g ta cams1a, , , t 6t -ug 1 a eb n-dbe a s P an iffie fnd n s r ue h t li () 2 3 al l o h 7 r a e c u e litf ald d u t e us a nitai rme e a ia evi Opeai Pr dur (ç ' 866. whih i t o xha t dmi srtve e dis valbl a rtng oce e (OP' ) 1, c s he 7 a i sr tver m e pr a f VDOC i aes OP 866. pr vi i m a e t a lt t dm nitai e dy ogr m or nm t . 1 o des n t s he biiy o r ol c pl i s a es ve om a nt , ppea adm i s r tve dec s ons a c l nge polc e a pr e es6 A 1 l ni t a i i i , nd hale i i s nd oc dur . 1 i s a egre bl e e i tt i lc c i a m al r be ndt VDOC' c r . s ues r iva e xc pt nsiutona onvitons nd te s yo he S ontol Prort s i o ubmitng agre nc t i t mus m a a good-at e f tt i or l ti i va e, he nma e t ke f ih for o nf maly r s vet is by s e ol he s ue ubmitng ali or a co pl ntf m ,whih i a l bl i housng t t . ti t nf m l m ai or c s vaia e n i mis Howe r a i ae i notr uie t fl a i or lco pl n t r por is ofs xua a e ve , n nm t s eq r d o ie n nf ma m ait o e t ' ues e l bus . s l t i s i no i o ly r s ve t i a e m us tl a r ul rgr e nc w ihi t ry f he s ue s t nf nna l e ol d, he nm t t q e eg a i va e t n hi t c l nda da f om t da e oft occ r nce ori de . Onl o i s pe r ul rgr e nce a e r ys r he t he ur e nci nt y ne s ue r eg a i va m a be a e s d,a r guargre nc m a r c vet e l ve sofr viw .A f c lt swa de y ddr s e nd e l iva es y e ei hr e e l e e a iiy' r n o s r nt nde c r upe i e nt onduc st fr t fLe I' e e . I t i a e i t s ts i d w ih t Le lI t he i s , t vel ' r vi w f he nm t s m a i fe t he ve de e m i ton, he i a e m a a alt de e m i ton w ihi fve da ofr c ptt Le lI , t r na i t nm t y ppe he t r na i t n i ys e ei o ve I whi h i us ly done by a r gi na om buds a Fo m os i s , ve 1 i t f na l ve o c s ua l e o l m n. r t s ues Le l 1 s he i l e l f r vi w . FQrt f w i s s a e e he e s ue ppea a e t Le 1 1 t i a e m a a l bl o vel 1 , he nm t y ppea t Le 1 l he vel 1 de e mi to wihi fveda ofr eptt t De y DiecororDiecoroft VDOC.7 t r nai n t n i ys ec i o he put r t r t he Reg a gre nce t tdo no m e tt flng r quie e sofOP 8 1a e r t m edt t ul r i va s ha t e he ii e r m nt 66. r e u o he i a ewihi t wo ki da fom t da eofr c ptwih i t c i ,whe pos i e a ut nm t t n wo r ng ys r he t e ei t nsnztons n sbl, bo how t i t m a r m e a de i nc .F A n i a ema a a a i a de ii n by s ndi he nma e y e dy ny fc e y nm t y ppe l n nt ke c so e ng t gre nc a t i a dec son t ar gi na ombuds a wihi fveda ofr ept The e he iva e nd he nt ke ii o e o l m n tn i ys ec i . r i no f r he r vi w oft i a de s on. s ut r e e he nt ke ci i 6I aesa eore edt t i aegreva pr edur whe t y e e t VD OC' c t y a w he t nm t r int o he nm t i nce oc e n he ntr he S usod nd n hey a eta f re t ot rVD OC f cltes r rns er d o he a iii . 1A Le Ir s em us beis wihi t ry days a Le 1 a Le I1r pons mus beis vel epons t sued t n hit vel 1 nd vel 1 es es t sued , nd w ihi t t da Expia i oft tm elm i wihoutis nceofar s ea a sageoft pr e s t n weny ys. rton he i i t t s ua è pons t ny t he oc s auoma i ly e ilsa i et a alo t ne tlvel t tcal ntte n nmat o ppe . he x e . t 8A c oft i a decii i ke i t i ae' greva fl. son s pt n he nm t s i nce ie opy he ntke 8 N o a y,a S m e g nc gre nce' snotase t wa d e usi n vi t a i sr tve t bl n & r e y iva 'i e t p o r xha to a he dm nita i r m edy pr n . The pur e o a e e ge y g i va i t pe tç xpe t d s a fr pons s e ogr m pos f n m r nc r e nce s o nni s die t f es e e t alg to t a a ( mae i s b e t oas b tn il ik o i n n sx l b ea dt o l ains h t n i t) s u j c t u sa ta rs f mmie t ç ua a us n o e n stain o c ndto whc ma s be thein t't i daers o s ro p ro a i to s r o i ns ih y u j c t s mae'o mme it ik f eius e s n l u i i ijuyo irp rbeh r ' ( No 1 2 1a 1 . nt' r re a a l am. ECF . 7 - t 9) ' A w a de m a r s r c a c st ad i s r tve r m e esi a i a e a e t s t m r n y e ti t c es o m ni t a i e di f n nm t bus s he ys e w ih ha t lm ius ore s i flngs n i m a ew hos ac es i r ti t d i s ilpe m i t t t biua s e xce sve ii .A n t e c s s esr c e s tl r ted o ûl a l s onei or c e t ea t nf mal ompli ta oner ulrg i va epe we k,à t r srci n c nnot a n nd eg a re nc r e nd he e tito n be i mpos d f m o et n ni t da . e or r ha ney ys Pli ifdi no fl rgulrgre nc sa a al o hi r ulrgiva e weerj ce antf d t ie e a iva e nd ppe s r s eg a re nc s r ee td f rnon- om pla w ih OP 8 .1f rcams1a , 3 a d6tr u h 1 9 Fii e e ge y o c i nce t 66 o li () 2, , n h o g 7. lng m r nc gr e nce c nno c tt e e us i ofa i s r tve r m ed e ,a Pl ntf f ie t pùr ue i va s n t ons i m xha ton dm ni ta i e i s nd ai i f a l d o s a nita i r m e e a utt is r ied i e e ge y g i vanc s 1 A lho h Pl i if dmi sr tve e di s bo he s ues a s n m r nc re e . 0 t ug antf c l swihouts oncude t uppor f cai s1 af 1 t tgre nce we er t ne t ns r d ort t t or l m 2 rd 4 ha i va s r eur d ma we e ha a nita i r medi we enota ia e hef ist s fce l e tbls t tCa de e t i dmi sr tve e es r va lbl , al o ufi inty sa ih ha Gny f c s n e us i w e e ... oc e f om t ac i n ori c i ofpr s of i i l . Aguia - la xha ton r pr ur d r he t o na ton i on f c a s' ' l r Ave l veda v. rel47 F.d1 23 1 2 ( 0hCi. 0 ) Jr i a v. t c l, 0 F.d 1 3 1 3 - 3 Ter l, 8 3 2 , 2 5 1 t r 20 7 ; en g n S u hel 3 4 3 0 0, 0 2 3 ( 0hCi. 0 2 .Ev n i Plitf sa c s t t a mi srtv rme yp o rm wa r srce f r 1 t r 2 0 ) e f anif c e s o he d nitaie e d r g n s etitd o u t ni t days he w a s ila e t f l one i o m a c pl i a one r ul r g i va pe p o ne y , s tl bl o ie nf r l om a nt nd eg a r e nce r 9Twoo terg lrg iv n e atc e t t ec reto a d fnd ns moinfrsmmayj g n wee fh e ua re a c s ta h d o h orcin l ee a t' to o u r ud me t r rjce a itk b cu eo Plitf' fil t fl ifr l o ansf s.Noa l Plitf fi dt e h u t eetd tna e e a s f anifs alr o ie n oma c mplit l t tby, anif al o x a s te r e a iabl a i sr tver m edisby nota alngt i a decso , hi pr cl esm y f t rr viw . val e dm nitai e e ppe i he ntke iins w ch e ud urhe e e N onet e s OP 866. ' i or alc pli e mpton a hels , 1s nf m - om ant xe i bouts xua a edi nota y t t s t or gulr e l bus d ppl o he e w e a greva sbec et t us oft s gre nc w a nott rpo ts xuala e i nce aus he hr t he e iva es s oe r e bus . 1 Inot t tdurnghi f lrm ont conf e en a Gr nRock, Pl ntf fld a la tt 't -ou i or a 0 e ha i s ozh m m t t ee ai if ie t e s hl y f r nf m l r compl nt Thef tt tPl ntf exha td t e ofhi cli s ai s. ac ha ai if use hr e s ams howsheunde soodt greva pr es a ho r t he i nce oc s nd w t e us a i sr tver m edi . o xha t dm nitai e es 9 we k. Adm i sr tver m e eswe eno made( valbl' sm pl d t awee y lmiai o e nita i e di r t s una ia e' i y ue o kl i t ton r b c u esafrj de Plitf' giva e f rn tc mpyngwi OP 8 61 M o e v r Plitf e a s tf ee d an ifs re no s o o o li t h 6 .. ro e , anif c annotm e ey ct a um ea e c s a r l ie n lt d a e boutawo e sprs t pr t ta nita i r m e e m n' ion o ove ha dmi sr tve e di s we e no a ia et hi a PCC orGr e Roc Acc di y, her or esa ihest tPli tf r t val bl o m t en k. or ngl t ec d t bls ha a n if d dno e h us a albl a mi srtv rme isf rcams1 a, 3 a d 6tr ug 1 , n i t x a t v ia e d nitai e e de o li () 2, , n h o h 7 a d D e e n s m otons a e g a e f rt s c a m s f nda t ' i r r nt d o he e l i . 1V . Dee da t c nc d t a Plitf e ha se a miitai rme isf rcams1b , a fn n s o e e h t an if x u td d n srtve e de o li () 4, nd 5 b t h ya g et the aee t ldt q aiidi , u t e r u ha t y r ni e o u lfe mmunt a dsl r j d me t Qu l d t i n l y mmay u g n . ai ie i mmuniypemisGgovenme of il peror ngds rtonayfmci ...(obe s eded t r t û r nt ûcas f mi icei r t tons t j hil fom la lt f c vi da a si of rast rc r ibiiy or i l m ge ns a hei onduc doesno vi a ec e ry e t bls d t t olt l a l sa ihe sa ut r orc tt i na rg sofwhi h ar ' na epe s n woul ha 110w1.'Ha l w v. tt o y onsiuto l i ht c ea o bl r o s d ve :1 4' ro . Fiz e ad, 7U.. 0 , 8( 98 ) tg r l 45 S 8 0 81 1 2 .Onc ad fn a trie t q aiidi e ee d n as s he u lfe mmunt d fns , i ee e a y pli ifbea st bur n t s antf r he de o how t tade e ntsc ha f nda ' onduc vi l t dt pl i ifsrght Br nt t o a e he antf i . ya v. u h 9 4F. 1 8 ,1 8 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Fo tef l wi r a o s 1tn d fn nsae M t , 9 2d 0 2 0 6 4h r 9 3 . r h ol ng e s n , q d ee da t r o e t ldt q aiidi nt a ds mmayj dg n f rt e h use cams1 ni e o u l e mmu iy n u r u me t o he x a td li .1 t f Cli 1b am ( ) Plitf c mp an i cam 1b ta Ofie W a e a dOfie Gr e d dno gv hm a an if o lis n li ( ) h t fc r d l n fc r e n i t ie i n e r nc g i va e f r s hec d ae tmed c sa fa uthi al gedne d f m e ca me ge y re nc o m o oul lr i al t f bo s le e or di l 1 Ot rt n na i Ly ha d, Zaho odne o M ai Clr Huds n asde e nt i t s co a nded 1 he ha m ng nc r r y, r l e k o f nda s n he e nd me c pli ,Pl ntf doesnotalget i pe s na i ve e wih a ofhi cai s.Ac di y,hes dee nt om ant ai if le her r o l nvol m nt t ny slm cor ngl t e fnda s aee t ldt q l idi nt a ds mmayj d me t Se . ..Fih rv. s n tnM er . e Trnst t , r nie o uai e mmu iy n u r u g n. e e:, s e Wahico to Ara a iAuh. t f 6 0F.d. 1 ,l4 (t Ci.1 8 ) 9 2 1 33 1 2 4h r 9 2 . 10 a t to a trbei r pe a ex e t a he i ae' bl .1 Dei r t i fe e e ten i n fe ng a d nd pos d o not r nm t s ood 2 lbe a e ndif r nc r q r a saeac o t ha be n pe s l a a eoff c si cai as t nta rs o s ro e uies t t t r o ve e r onaly w r a t ndi tng ubsa il ik f e i us hnr a t ha r cog z t e se ofs h ars Fa merv.Br nnan,511U . 825,838 m nd o ve e nied he xitnce uc ik. r e S. ( 99 .i lbeaei fee ema bede taedbyet racua i e orrckl s 1 4) t i rt ndifrnc y De monsrt ihe t l ntnt e es dse ad. Mite v. o n 8 6F.d 8 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 ) s ePars e tl Le v. ir g r ' l r Be r , 9 2 48 8 1 4h r 9 0 ; e rih x e. e ' i Clvea 3 F. 29 303( hCi. e lnd, 72 3d 4, 4t r 2004)(d--hee de emus s w t tt ofiili çg q vi nc l t ho ha he fca n q e to s b e tv l rc n z dt a hi a to sweeçn p r p it i lg t ft trs ') ( u si n u j ciey e og ie h t s cin r ia p o rae n i h o ha ik.'. & ' A d fnd n at rc esyb dse adn asb tniliko d n e t tset r o t te ee at cs eklsl y irg rig u sa ta rs ? a g rha i i kn wn o h he de e ntorw hi h w o d be a r ntt a r s na e pe s h i t de e nt sposton. M it e , f nda c ul ppa e o ea o bl r o n he f nda ' ii ' li r ' 8 6F.da 8 -2.A me ia ne ds ro e o g t gv rs t ac nsi to a cam ivov s 9 2 t 513 d c l e eius n u h o ie ie o o tt in l li n le u a c ton t tt be n di gnos d by aphysc a asm a tngte t e oronet ti s ondii ha û has e a e ii n ndai r a m nt ha s o obvi t te n al y pe s woul ea iy r ogni t ne es iy f radoc o ' a tnton. 1 ous ha ve a r on d sl ec ze he c st o t r s te i ' ko ' v.Shrve 535F. 225,241( hCi. ) e , 3d 4t r 2008 . Pl i iff ist aleg s f c e tf c s t s a e a c a m ofde i r t i f e enc by O fi r a ntf a l o l e uf i i n a t o t t l i lbe a e ndif r e fce W a orO fi e Gr n.1 N ow he e i t s co a e d c pl i doe Pl i tf a l t the del f c r ee 3 r n he e nd m nde om a nt s a n if lege ha i or nf med Ofi e W a lorOfi e Gr n a fc r de fc r ee bouthi ne d f medialte t e o a e r nc s e or c r am nt r n me ge y gre ncef m.Pl i ifalege ,i t a,a i va or antf l s n ot l bouthi c s onve s ton wih t s ofi r t tç antf rai t he e fce s ha t i if pl r q e tdfo b t o t eo fc r ( a e a dGr e , ohd f n a t)f ra e r e c e u se r m oh f h fie s W d l n e n b t e e d n s o n meg n y g iva ea df rme ia. S c n Am. mp . ) W lieI yv e ifrnc si alg t s re nc n o dc l'( e o d ' Co l3. l ma iw n e e e n ih mo t l f vor bl t Pl i if 1a notpe m it t c e t f t wher none w e e a l ged i or rt s a e a a a e o a ntf , m r ted o r a e ac s e r le n de o t t 1 Be us Pl ntf di no ha ac l box i hi celt onl w a Pl ntf c d pr 2 ca e ai if d t ve al n s l, he y y ai if oul ompty co m uniae l m ct wih t m e c de rm e ora sa fwasvi t e e ge y gre nc f m om OfierW ade a O f e t he dial pa t nt ny t f a he m r nc iva e or fc l nd fc r Gr e e n. 1 Fu t r e Pli ifdoe no ha aco tm to rghtt a es t V DOC ' gre nc s t m .Adam s 3 rhe mor , antf s t ve nsi inal i o cc s he S iva e yse v Rie 40F.d7 7 (t Ci.1 9 ) . c, 3 2, 5 4h r 9 4 . v a l cam f rPlitf.Se e ..Br c v. ro l 1 7F.d2 , 4 (t Ci.1 9 )( ti , . ibe li o anif e ec, o k Car l, 0 3 41 2 3 4h r 9 7 Lu tg J, c nc n ng ; a det Ci Q - a t n 7 5F.d 1 7 1 7 (t Ci. 9 5 ; r o v. e e o u i ) Be u t v. r fH- o , 7 2 2 4, 2 8 4h r 1 8 ) Go d n Le k , t y mp 5 4F.d 1 4 ,1 5 ( t Ci. 9 ) Plit fd e n talg e ug fcst s w Ofie W a e 7 2 J 7 1 1 4 h r 1 78 . ani o s o le e no h a t o ho fc r d l f orOfi rGr e dir ga de as t nta rs o dange t twa kno t t m ort twoul be fce e n s e r d ubsa il ik f r ha s wn o he ha d a r ntt a r a ona e pe s i t i po ii A c r ngl Of i e W ade a Of i e Gr e ppa e o e s bl r on n he r s ton. co di y, f c r l nd f c r e n a ee tte t q lfe i ni a s mmayj g n . r n ild o uaiid mmu t nd u r ud me t y ( l in 4 za r Forcam 4,Plitf c anst tDr Sc i ra QM HPFa di no pr de li anif ompli ha . hnede nd w d t ovi c ouns lng s r c qui kl e e i e vi es c y nough a t rhe a rve a Gr e Roc o M a c 1 201 fe ri d t e n k n r h 2, 4. Spec sc ly,Pl i tf a l ge i a l a n if le s: W hi a Gre Ro k o M ac 1 , 2 4 ( li t f ak d fr l t en e c n rh 2 01 , Plani s e o f team e / ot s lng i r ga dst PTSD and s xua a e. Anxit hi a r t ntc m e i n e r o e l bus e y gh nd f a i hi s f t Tr t ent ne r t e r ng s a e y. ea m ve ook pl ce un i l e M a 201 Dr a t l at y 4. . Sc de a QMHP Faw wee a r o t s a doz ns of r quet fr hnei r nd r wa e f hi t e e ss o co elng.M yr or s uns i ec d hows1a a rs o s xua a e s frde e so g m t ik f e l bus , ufe pr sin, q hype tnson,PTSD,Dyse c bi a. Pli if wa ijled de lng wih re i lxi, polr antf s ntr ai t t a a. Thi vi a ed m y 8 h n e r um s ol t t m ndm e bec us i w as c el a unus nt a e t nz nd ual p n s me t d n n /ea i me tl h at (d q ae . P an if s fee u ih n e yigd lyng n a e l a e u t) litf u f rd h ba y. dl ( c n Am. mp . ) Se o d Co l4. Cli 4f ist saeacli a i tDr Sc de orQM HP Fa am al o tt am gans . hnei r w.Pli ifscai t t antf' l ms ha Dr Scmede a QM HP Fa weeTa r 'o Pli ifsdo nsofrquessf co ei t t . l i r nd w r swae' f antf' ze e t or unslng,ha h wa Cnu e d aigwi ta ma' ndt a lh sv oae hs8ha n me t ih sbe a s i e s t j r d e ln t ru 'a h ts i i ltd i t me d n rg t c u e t i h t w a c e a unus lpuni hm e de ng de a ng m e a he lh c e 'a e uns ppo t d, s nz l nd ua s nt nyi / l yi nt l a t ar ' r u re c us y a l ga i note tted t a as um pton oft u h. A s r t l ,556 U . 662,678 oncl or le tons n il o n s i rt hc of v. qbal S. - 7 (0 9 . 9 20) 12 Des t Pl ntf ale ton t thedi no r c vem e alheat s r c be wee M a c pie ai ifs l ga i ha d t e ei nt lh e vies t n r h a May201 Pli ifsme c r o ds nd 4, antf' dial ec r howst tPli ifc ule wihaQM HP sxte ha antf ons td t i en tm e a wih aps a rs t c i t f l m o hshewa a Gr e Roc The da a tr i s nd t ychitit wie n he otr nt s t en k. y fe Pli ifarve a Gr e Roc QM HPFa a s se Pli ifsme a heat OnM ac 27, antf ri d t e n k, w s e sd antf ntl lh. rh 201 aQM HP e mi Pli ifbe a eofPli ifsrque tf te t nt a onAprl1 4, xn ned antf c us antf e s or r ame , nd i , 201 ) Dr Sc i rc 4 . hne de onduc e af l up a nt e .4 On Aprl24. 201 . Pli ifa n s w t d olow ppoi m nt' i 1 4, antf gai a aQM HP, notdt tPli ifde e ha nga yme a heat is .Dr Sc i rs who e ha antf nid vi n ntl lh sues . hnede aw Pl i ifa i on M a 2,201 a trPl n ifr poredt s xua a s ul a wa m ove i o antf ga n y 4, fe aitf e t he e l s a t nd s d nt s r ga i Pl i i ft d D r Sc i ra eg e ton. a ntf ol . hne de boutPl i if spa te r e sbe ng s xualy a ntf ' s xpe i nce i e l vitm ied a t tbe ng c i d i s gr to ti r pa tta l a i e re e ,a Dr c i z nd ha i onfne n e egai n rgge ed s r lm tc xpe i nc s nd . Sc i rt dPl ntf t tm e a he lh s l ce woul bepr ded i s gr ga i t m e t hnede ol ai if ha nt l at ewi s d ovi n e e ton o e . ' . Pl i if s ne ds ) OnM a 9, 4, a ntf ' e . 5 y 201 QMHP Fa i e ve dPli if whos i hewa w ntr iwe antf, ad s e re i a et r ae t t alege s xua a sul.QMHP Fa rpo e Pli ifsme ca xpe incng nxi' eltd o he l d e l sa t' y w e rtd antf' di l c ant t medi lsaf a s he e Pli ift r c i i vi c ei fom aQM HP, ompli s o ca t f nd c duld antf o e eve ndi dual ouns lng r who s w Pl ntf on M a 1 201 a not d t tPli tf de e ha ng a m e alhe lh a ai if y 4, 4, nd e ha a n if nid vi ny nt at is s On M a 29,201 Dr Scl i rpr c i sx m e a heat s sonsf rPl i if sue . y 4, . mede es rbed i nt l lh es i o antf bewe n M a 21a J 20, 4.QM HPFa me wihPli ifo Ma 21a 29al Jme6 t e y nd une 201 w t t antf n y nd ld t a 1 201 a a he QM HP me wihPlitf onJ 1 a 1 201 whe QM HP Fa nd 3, 4, nd not r t t anif une 0 nd 8, 4, n w wa no a t prs Att ls s sononJ 1 201 t QMHP notdt tPli ifE s s t t he ion. he a t esi une 8, 4,he e ha antf l wa s n and a s s d f rm e a he lh i s . H e de e ha ng a m ent he t i s s The ee s es e o nt l a t s ues ni d vi ny al alh s ue . 1 Dr pa e, aps hititc r td 9om ousdeofGr e Ro , wasr po i ef pr s rbi Pli ifs 4 . t l yc ars ontace ti e n ck es nsbl or e c i ng antf me a he t mediai ,notDr Scmei r Pl ntf me wih br PaelonAprl1 a M a 1 201 whih ntl alh c tons . l de . ai if t t . t i 8 nd y 6, 4, c r s t i pr s rptonsf Pa la Tr zodo . euled n e c i i or xi nd a ne ' Plitf r m ai i s gr tonf rhi ownperonal otcton a bec us t i si ton i ot 5 an if e ned n e egai o s s pr e i nd a e he nve tgai nt he S XUZ as aul WasOn- ng. C s t goi QMHP di nots a viua sgnst i c t ot r s .'Twowe ksltr Pli ifwa d ee ny s l i o ndiae hewie' e ae , antf s tans e r d outofGr n Roc r f re ee k. Pl i ifsdis tsa ton wih t cozs o c r her c ve ac os num e ousa nt nt antf s aif c i t he lr e f a e e ei d r s r ppoi me s wihDr Sc de a QMHP Fa doe no saeaj1 cam,a t r c ddoesnot t . hnei r nd w s t tt 983 li nd he e or e tbls t i d l rt id fee c .W rc tv Coln , 6 F.d8 , 4 ( t Ci.1 8 ) sa ih her ei ae n if rn e ih . l s 7 6 2 41 8 9 4h r 9 5 ; be i Ru s l v S fe, 28F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 )( rc ra .Dr Sc n i e ddr f s s el . hefr 5 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 pe u im) . h ed r i e u e Pl i ifsr ue t f 'ont c wih ar pec ii ce e whe Pl i ifc dno i ntf t c nt r antf' eq ss orc a t t a rss nt r n antf oul t de iy he e e hewa e a a trVDOC i tga o sde e m i d t al ga i ofr pewe e uns t ta e nt d nd fe nvesi t r t r ne he le tons a r ubsan it d. Dr Scme de e anst tPl i ifawa ha ac es t t VDOC' PREA Hoti i heha a . l i r xpli 'ha antf l ys d c s o he S lne f d ny i s orco pl nt . M or ove ,sng e c la s g e sa e no pos i e atG r e R oc a e n s ues m ai s e r i l - el s i nm nt r t sbl en k, nd ve i t y we e Dr Sc i rdi notha t a hort t m a de sonsa f he r , . hnede d ve he ut iy o ke cii boutho i usng asi nt a Gr e Roc sgnme s t e n k.Ac or ngl Dr Sc i ra QM HP Fa aee ildt quaiid c di y, . hnede nd w r ntte o lfe i nt a s mmayj d me t mmu i nd u r u g n . y C. Cl i 5 am I c am 5, antf co pl nst tNtr e J ne ,Co ,a Dowdy d d notr nde pr pe n l i Pli if m ai ha ls s o s bbs nd i e r o r c r a t heco lps a hi hi he o t colr t foor Pl i iff rhe c a e fer la ed nd t s ad n he lc ee l . antf u t r ompli t t ans ha N ur e H a r sdeni d hi e e ge y gr e nce a s ri e s m r nc i va boutt t e t e f rt f l N e t rco pl i he r a m nt o he al. ihe m a nt en il Pl i i ft r lef ttes a ntf o e i . Ther c d r ve st ton Aprl22,21 Ntr e J e or e al ha i 04, ls oneswa c l t Pli if sc li t s aled o antf el n he obs va i uni ofGr n Roc sm e c de rm e a s Pl i i fl ng on t foor A fe er ton t ee k' di al pa t nt nd aw a ntf yi he l . t r he w a e c t t a e m r ,Pl i i ft d N u s J ne t ta 1he r m em be ed be or f lng s s ored o n xa oom a ntf ol r e o s ha 1 e r f e ali w a f e i di y a f e i pa n i t l f - i ofhi c t Pl i ifa s co pl i d ofpa n i s e lng zz nd e lng i n he e ts de s hes . a ntf l o m a ne i n hi l f a m , i f r he a ba k o hi ne k due t t f l. s e t r r ght o e ad, nd c f s c o he a l 14 Nus J r e ones viuale mi to r ve l d a s al r ie bnls d o Pl i ifsrg ' s xa nai n e a e m l, as d ie n antf i ht f e ad.Nur eJo sus a EKG,dee mi Pl i f ' pupiswe ee n a r a tve,a or he s ne ed n tr ned antf s l r ve nd e c i nd m e ur hi vials gns 1 Noneoft e m i ton r s t i c t t Nur e J as ed s t i . 6 he xa na i e uls ndia ed o s onest tPl n if ha aitf s f r d a e e ge y condii N onehels , s J sc ac e t phys ca on c l a ufe e n m r nc ton. t e s Nur e one ont t d he i in al nd r pored he obs r t o . The phys c a or r d ar X r y oft r g f e d,whi h w a t ke e t r e va i ns i i n de e l a he i ht or hea c sa n t tmor ngand r vea e no fa t et Pl i ifss l ha ni e ld r c ur o antf kul. Pli iff rhe c antf u t r ompli t tNur eDo a ns ha s wdy a Nur e Cobbswoul notas itNlr e nd s d ss zs J ne ,who alege y w astdi g te 'a t d c o s l dl ç s nm l d' nd c ha once nsw ih r ga d t t e tng. Co r r t r t e r o r a i ' nt a y o ' Pli ifsal ga i ,Nur eJ ne a r t ts di notas Nur eDo antf ' le tons s o s ve s ha he d k s wdy orNur eCobb f s or a s s a a a tm e. s it nce t ny i The ne da Ntr eH a sr c ve Pl ntf' e e ge y gre nc t tc xt y, zs ni e ei d ai ifs m r nc iva e ha ompl i a ut aned bo t te t ntbyNtr eJ s Afe r vi wi Pli ifsme c lc r, ls Ha rsdee m i d he r a me ls one . tr e e ng antf di a ha tNtr e r i t r ne t tt f l di notc us any s r ous o i m e a e da r She r ple t t e e ge ha he a l d a e ei r m di t nge . e i d o he m r ncy gre nc no i t tt r wasno e r nc a t tPl i ifc d di c shi c iva e, tng ha he e me ge y nd ha antf oul s us s once nswih r t t phys c an a hi ne a nt e i e g hour . N tr e Cobbs s eq nty de e ne t t he i i t s xt ppoi m nt n i ht s ls ubs ue l t nni d ha Nur e Hani ha ade t l r s s s d qua ey e pondedt Pli tf .1 On Apr124,201 ,Pl i ifwa pr s rbe o a n if 7 i 4 antf s e c i d 8 m g ofi of n f t n da . 00 bupr e or e ys The al ga i a le tons boutN u s Dpwdy a Nu s Cobbsr usngt hep Nur eJ sdoe re nd r e ef i o l s one s notde c i a delbe ae i fe e et as ro m e c ne s rbe ny i r t ndif r nc o e i us dial ed.Eve a s i t al gai ns n s um ng he le to a utN u s D ow dy and N ur e Cobbs a et ue, ai iff ist s bo re s r r Pl ntf a l o how a s r o or sgnii a ny e i us i fc nt 1Th treme srme t o Plitf' bo dpes r (( 'a dhetrt (BPM' wee1 51 lyn 6 e h e au e ns f anifs lo r sue ( ) n a ae $ BP' $ ' r 5 /08 a ig ) BP a 11 BPM ,1 / 2 sti BP a 1 BPM ,a 1 /1 sa ngBP a l BPM . t 0 28 9 itng t 08 nd 48 00 t ndi t 22 1 W hehe at 7 t r ypogr hiale orwasm a ont r s et t i o m a c pli noti pac t a yss ap c n' de he e pons o he nf r l om ant m t he nal i o tecam.( No 1 5 1p . 0) f h li ECF . 6 - g 3 . 15 ij r c u e b Nu s Do y' a dNu s Co bs u wil n s t hepNu s J ne .Theei nu y a s d y re wd s n re b ' n li e s o l re o s r s ng no diput t tN u s J ne e m i d Pl i ifwihoutnee ng as it nc f o et rnur e s e ha r e o s xn ne antf t di s sa e r m ihe s. Furhe m or ,N ur e J s'tea m e tdoesnots k t co c e ,a Pl ntf di s ts a ton t r e s one r t n hoc he ns i nce nd ai i fs s a if c i wih t m a ro e e ofN ur eJ ne 'te t nti a i ufi intba i t r co rt r t he nne r xtnt s o s r a me s n ns fce ss o e ve mde j1 3.M orove ,heei noe de et tt nure o a ot dee tco dprs rbeor 98 e r t r s vi nc ha he s s r ny her fndan ul e ci or rbl dr wn f 1 b wo k,a Nur eHa sa Ntr eCo a eno la ef r vi wi de ood a or a r nd s ni nd ls bbs r t ibl or e e ng Plitf se r e yg iv n e Se . ..S a v. to d, 3F.d7 , 9 ( t Ci. 9 4 ; anif me g nc re a o . e eg, h w Sr u 1 3 91 7 9 4h r 1 9 ) D e ol v.Ra N o. 1 v001 201 U . D i t LEXI 11 2,* 2013 W L 4451 pa a y, 7: 2c 39, 3 S. s . S 718 23, 236,a *8 t ( . Va. ul 22, W D. J y 2013) Ac or ngy, zs J s Cobbs a Do a ee ildt qualfed . c di l Nlres one , , nd wdy r ntte o ii i ni a d s mmayj g n . mmu t n u r ud me t y I lghto t e de i t r or a Pli if sa l a i i t s c ame d n i f he vi nce n he ec d nd antf ' leg tons n he e ond nde c mp an , an ifsmo in f rs mma' j g n mu tb d r e anifc n o r l o o litPlitf' to s o u l ud me t s e el d.Plitf n n t ey n y i buzz ds lbel,orc ujonst sa eavi a i ofaf der lrgh .Be lAt.Cop . wor , a s oncl i o t t olton e a i t l l v. Two l, 5 U. 5 4 5 ( 0 ) Ad ms 40F.da 7 .Veba h r sme ta dil t rast mbv $ 0 S. 4 , 55 20 7 ; a , 3 t 4 r l a a s n n de h e t o a i a e,e n t a e e t ti c us s a i a e f a ore otona a e y,do no c tt e a n nm t ve o n xt nt ha t a e n nm t e r m i l nxi t t ons iut n i son ofany i ntfe lbe t i t r s. Se ,e. ,Em monsv. c yug i 8 F. 351 354 nva i de ii d i ry n e e t e c. M ta hln, 74 2d , (t Ci.1 8 ) Alh u hPlitf rpe tdyivo sP 6h r 9 9 . t o g anif e ae l n ke REA a dVDOC p lce a b sso n oiis s a e f s t tverght,neihe PREA no vi a i ofsa elwso r gulto by sa eofk il ubsan i i s t r r oltons t t a r e ai ns tt t a s pr de abassf r le unde j1 3.Furhe mor Pl ntf doe nothavea i pe nt ovi s i or eif r 98 t r e, ai if s n nde nde c tt i na r g t a r pe co el ,a a l ga i ofne i nc a e nots f c e t r o r ons i o l i ht o a m uns or nd le tons glge e r uf i i nt o ec ve vi j 1 Fa me v. er n,511U. 8 835- ( 99 ;W elrv.De tofSocalSe vce , a 983. r r Br ma S. 25, 37 1 4) le p' i ri s 16 9 F.d38 , 9 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Bal Be k rh No CV 1 - 00 7, 1U.. s. 01 2 7 3 2 4h r 9 0 ; l v. c wo t, . 10 3 201 S Dit LEXI S 1 95 , 11W L 4 75 0 , t* ( M o t Aug 31 201 ) 0 29 20 3 8 6 a 4 D. n . . , 1. Plitf' ag me tha i maes x a voe ei n t i rs nc ndto ' u j c t t an ifs r u n t t n t e u l ilnc s o a t io o iin's b e t o he p e ha sinr q ie n o 4 U. C. 1 9 e a i fio o .Po trv. s l, 3 U. 51 , 3 x u to e urme t f 2 S. j 9 7 () s rv lus re Nu se 5 4 S. 6 5 1 ( 2) W hieOP 866. r quiessaf t a e a rpo o prs rpemadetuoughgre nce 200 . l 1 e r t f o ccpt ny e rt f ion a l iva pr ce e, he O P doe note us a i a e f o e o dur t s xc e n nm t r m xhaus i a opr a e gre tng ppr i t i vanc pr dtr s e oce le a tprs r pe Pli ifi as notr i d ofhi dut t e us a ia e a nita i bou ion a . a ntf s lo eleve s y o xha t val bl dmi sr tve r m e e be us he be i ve s a ff l t f l V D O C po i i s orpr ed l e .W hie Pl i ifi e di s ca e le s t f ais o olow lc e oc tr s l a ntf s a l t a p a ag iva c ' rj cinu o itk frf iigt f lo ap o e u a r l,h t be o p e l re n e s ee t p n na e o aln o ol w r c d r l u e t a o a aldoe no m a a i o ry- e gre nce( xha t d'wihi t men ng of42 U. C. ppe s t ke n mpr pe l vld i va J use ' t n he ni e S. j 1 9 ea .Plitf' c alng t t a t n ii o mo tif r l o an satc e i 9 7 () anifs h l e o he uhe tct f s n o ma c mplit ta h d n e y s p o t fDee d n s mo in f rsl r j g n d e n ta d e shsfit et fl o u p r o fn a t' to s o l mmay ud me t o s o d r s i alr o ie r l a p a r g a g iv n e . No o teag me t i Plitf smoin f rs p e l e ulr re a c s1 ne f h r u ns n anif to s o ummayj g n 8 r ud me t a e pe s s ve, t m otons a e de e r r ua i and he i r ni d. Vl . Fort f r goi r a ons Ig a tPl ntf' m o i f ale e i o tm ea he o e ng e s , r n ai ifs ton or t xt nson f i nd Dee da t ' to sf rs fn ns mo in o ummayj d me ta dd n Plitf' moinsf rsl r u g n . r u g n n e y an ifs to o l mmayj d me t EN TER : s Thi da o y Vic 2015. v t c r , / T Se k U nie St t s D it i tJ or t d a e s r c udge 1 Not y, Pl ntf fld c esoft o i na i onralco pl nt a g iva e a doc te r 11 8 abl ai if ie opi he rgi l nf f m ai s nd re nc s t ke nty , i udi Gr n Rock' OP 866. i e nttonpolc whihnot t temege y gre nc a enos tt ef ncl ng ee s 1 mplme ai iy, c es ha r nc iva es r ubsiut or flng r ul g iva e a a al t e us a i sr tver m edi . ii eg ar re nc s nd ppe s o xha t dm nitai e es
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
