Adams v. Tuck et al, No. 7:2013cv00554 - Document 7 (W.D. Va. 2013)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 12/5/2013. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL S OFFI U.S. ST COURT ERK' CE DI . AT ROANOKE'VA Ff LED I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT N TED S CT X c g5 2 j gg FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STR I OF V I G I I CT R N A Roxxou ol sox vll D EN NIS JA M ES AD A M S, su ooe qsa i z uu ua JL R E CA SE N O .7: 13CV 00554 Pl ntff ai i , M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O CA PT .D O U G TU CK ,E TA L . By: Jam es C.Turk Seni Uni e St e Di t i tJudge or t d at s s r c De e f ndants. t) De s J mesAda s a Vig ni i m a e pr e i pr K ,fl d t s cvi rg s a ton nni a m , r i a n t oc ed ng o ie hi i l i ht c i purua t 42 U. C.j 1 alegi t tt dee ntlw e or men ofie sc s nt o S. 983, l ng ha he fnda a nf ce t fc r onduce td s a c s of t o pr pe te w ihout hi c e a us d e de e f om t e s a c a i t e r he w o ri s t s ons nt nd e vi nc r hos e r hes ga ns hi ,i vi a i ofhi c tt i nalr gh s Upo r vi w oft r or t c ttndst tt m n ol ton s onsiuto i t. n e e he ec d, he our i ha he co pli mus be c tu as a pe ii n f a wrt ofha s co us pur ua t t 28 U . C. m a nt t onsr ed tto or i bea m , s n o S. j2 4, n s mmaiyd s se wi o t rj dc frfi r t e ha s saec u t e d e . 25 a d u rl imisd t u p eu ie o al e o x u t tt o r rme is1 h u I A da s i a pr t i lde a nee a t N ew Ri rV a l y R e ona J i. Hi s a e e of hi m s era t i t he ve le gi l a l s t t m nt s c a m s i ve y s t l i s r hor : g q Ofier e tr t c ria ofPli ifwihoutas rhwar n,co e 1. fc s need he a tlge antf t eac ra t nsnt or p o bl c us . Nor d d t y viw fo sae hi hway a r ba e a e i he e r m tt g ny questonabl actviy. i e i t ( 1 Ofie st n e e e rntlpr ry t wa r nt by a he pes 2. fc r he ntr d e a opet hat s e ed not r ron a e e e t hous on t t pr r y a hel t s ar h and s i ur nd nt r d he e ha ope t nd d he e c ez e fom bot pr rles a ns Pli if r h ope ti l gai t antf. ( ) Duepr s vi atons(l s e til- rque t by Pli if i wrtng 3. oce s ol i ) pe dy ra e sed antf, n ii and vebal ( l wilbea plo 1 mont ofc i me a ne r ly. 2) t l pg r x. 5 hs onfne nt t xt court dat of Januar 13, 2014. Pl ntf has not agreed t any e y ai if o contnuances,pos ponem ent orany ot t ofdel i t s her ype ay. l RUe 4 o t Rue Go r n j225 c s sa t rz st i c ur t s l f he ls venig 4 a e uho ie hs o t o umma i ds s a rl imis y habeascor acton i i i cl fom t f e oft pl ng t pettoneri notentted t r i . pus i f t s ear r he ac he eadi hat ii s il o elef Compl 2. Ada s as a s rs t the has fl s ve alm o i i t W yt Count Cic t . m lo s e t ha ied e r tons n he he y r ui Co tr l t d t hi c i i l pr e ngs f r ove a yea ,w ih no r s ur e a e o s rm na oc edi o r r t e pons . A s r le i t s e e i f n hi a ton,A dn s s e t Cs es q tona e e de e,di m i s a 1c r s r t n ie s t ke ci m e ks o kuppr s ues i bl vi nc s s 1 ha ge , e ur t m a n a rti to f l sofwa ,t s gndjfee ' I nd, erbuin or os ges ool, a r dom. d. ' 11 W he a i a e s e t c le n n nm t e ks o ha l nge t f c o dur ton o hi de e i a c vi rght he a t r a i f s t nton, i l i s co antunde j1 i no t pr lga r me Prierv. Rod i z,411 U. 475 mpli r 983 s t he oper e l e dy. es rgue S. ( 973) Todd v. ke vil 71 F. 70( h Ci.1 ) A deane ma ries h c le s 1 ' , Bas r le, 2 2d 4t r 983 . ti e y as uc halnge t hi de e i onl by f lng a pe ii n f a w rt of ha a c pus f l i e us i of o s t nton y ii tt o or i be s or , olow ng xha ton a albe sae c u t rme is L s e as 28 U. C. j2 5 () (e ad n e h usin v i l tt o r e de . d e lo a =; S. 2 41 rg r i g x a to 7 rquie nt. e r me ) A di t i tc ti notco tai d by a ltga ' syl ofpl di o r ques f r le a sr c our s nsr ne ii nt s t e ea ng r e t or e i f nd ma lbealy c tueaci lrg sc anta aha speiin,purua t j225 Ha i y i r l onsr vi iht ompli s bea tto s nt o 4. mln v.W arn,664 F, 29,30 ( h Ci. 1 ) To dee ne whehe a a ton i pr ry re 2d 4t r 981. tnni t r n ci s opel c i r a ha as c pus peii r quii e usi of sa e c tr m e es purua t onsde ed be or tton e rng xha ton tt our e di s nt o j2254(9,rt rt n acvi rg sc antu rj 1 ac tmus c i rwhehe t 1 ahe ha i l iht ompli nde 983, our t onsde t r he i or ' oft ltga ' c a m c s e ' he ii nt s l i once ns t f c o dlr to o t ltga ' co i m e , Pr i e c r he a t r z a i n f he ii nt s nf ne nt e s r v.Rod i z, 1U. 475( 973) Toddv. s r l 71 F. 70(t Ci.1 ) rcue 41 S. 1 4 Ba ke dle, 2 2d 4h r 983 . l hi tr tt o c a m s A da s a l gest tt de enda ofi e s c n s i s w l i , m le ha he f nt fc r onduded unr as bl e ona e s r he a s i e e de lt r us d a ns hi i c i i lpr e ng . I es e e,he ea c s nd e z d vi nce a e e gai t m n rm na oce di s n s nc cl i s t tt de e nt 'a tons i vi a i ofhi Fourh A m e m e r g s i t n,c us d a m ha he f nda s c i n ol ton s t nd nt i ht , n ur a e hi t be wr uly eonfned. Si iary, i t t rd cl m , A dnm s aleges t t ul am ed m o ongf l i m l l n he hi ai l ha m per sons have deprved hi oft rghtt a s i m he i o peedy t i ,caus ng hi t be wr ral i m o ongfuly contned l i f m or t n a y r Be us Ada s cli s t c es t f t a dur ton of hi or e ha ea . ca e m ' am hus ont t he ac nd ai s c i m e i t V i gi a pr s s t m ,hi cl i s f r di m i s l of hi c r s a r l s ont ne nt n he r ni i on ys e s am o s s a s ha ge nd e ea e fom confne ntae notcog z bl unde j l98 a hi s e rme i t brng a ha a r i me r nia e r 3, nd s ol e dy s o i be s peii u tton nder28 U. C.j2254. Prie,s a. Theef e,t cour c l st tAda s S. es r upr r or he t oncude ha m' c a m s ar a opr a el c tued as a pe ii f a wrt of ha s com us unde 28 U . C. li e ppr i t y ons r tton or i bea r S. j225 2 4. Pr de t ta ne y c tue j 2254 petton me t t tr hol rquie nt fr ovi d ha wl onsr d ii es he l es d e rme s o z ha s ac i ns u r t s s c i t c t c n add es t pe ii s c a m s on t m e is bea to nde hi e ton, he our a r s he tton' l i he rt . Hanesv.Kenlr 40 U. 51 ( 72) Unde 28 U. C.j225 1 howe r a fdealc t i e, 4 S. 9 19 . r S. 4(9, ve , e r our c nnot gr nt a ha s pe ii unl s t pe ii ne has e us e t r m e es a l e i t a a bea tton e s he tto r xha t d he e di vaiabl n he c t oft sae i whih peii r wa co ce ours he tt n c ttone s nvi td. O' lva v.Boe c ,526 U. 838, Suli n r kel S. 842 ( 999) l t peiine hasf ld t e us sae c tr dis t fdealc tmus 1 . f he tto r aie o xha t tt our eme e , he e r our t dimist j225 peii wihou prj iet alow hi t rt n t sae c t Slyt v. s s he 4 tton t t eudc o l m o eur o tt our. a on Smih,404U. 53( 971 . t S. 1 ) I i c e r f om t c pl i a s a e c tr c ds a l bl o i t A da sha not t s la r he om a nt nd t t our e or vaia e nlne hat m s ye s ood t i o hi pe ng c i i l c r s I upc i t i l c tpr ce di , he m a t t ral n s ndi rm na ha ge . n om ng r a our o e ngs y r i e hi c a m s o unr s bl s r h a s i e,s es i of e de , a s e ti l as s li f ea ona e ea c nd e zur uppr s on vi nce nd pe dy r a pr e s l c obl m . f onvi t he w ilt n a s have a la e and ha as c pus r m edi ava l bl t c ed, l he l o ppe l t be or e es ia e o hi i t s a e c t . Be us A da s c ea l ha no e us e a ia e sa e c tr m edi s m n he t t our s ca e m l ry s t xha t d va l bl t t our e e a t i tme t i c u tmu ts mmai ds s te p tto wi u p eu iet alw hi t t h s i , hs o r s u rl imis h eiin t t rj dc o l y ho o m o pur ue hi cl i s fr ti s a e c ' Sl yt s r . An a opr a e o derw ile e t s da s s a m i s n t t oul . a on, up a t ppr i t r l nt r hi y. 2 To t ext ntt Ada ss he e hat m eeksm onet r da agesbas on t def nt aleged ac i , hi ay m ed he enda s' l tons s camsaeb redu e He kv. li r a r nd r c Humph e 51 U. 4 , 6 8 ( 9 4)(idigt talg dvi ai s ry, 2 S. 77 48 - 7 1 9 fn n ha le e olton o pl nifsc nsi i a rg t aeno a ton bl u e j 1 3 i afn ngi pl ntf sf v rwo d f aitf o tt on l ih s r t ci a e nd r 98 f idi n ai if a o ul ut n c s a i iv iaehi dee tono p n n c r so hi c n cin) e e s rl n ald t s tn i n e dig hage r s o vito . y The Cl k i diec e t s er s r t d o end c es of t s m e or ndum o ni a ac om panyi opi hi m a pi on nd c ng or ert pl ntf . d o ai i f 5. d yo oe e e, a f cmb r E E:h NTR Ti s 21. r) 03J . , . Se . -. s rUnie St t D it i tJ t d a es s rc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
