-RSB Tuck v. Director of Medical Services et al, No. 7:2011cv00450 - Document 29 (W.D. Va. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/27/2011. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERKS OFFI U. DI COURT C; S. ST. AT r<>NOKE VA 2'@ Fl i7 ê '-- i i I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A R OA N O K E D I I O N V SI CLY D E TU CK , DE2 2 ? 2 1 21 J A C. ' 1% CLERK ULI 'D'027 BY; C ASE N O .7: C V 00450 11 Pl ntf , ai if M EM O R AN D U M O PI O N NI VS. DI RECTOR,c & , By: Gl E.Conrad en C hi U ni ed St esD i tri Judge ef t at s ct De e f ndants. t) Cl Tuc a V i gi a i a e pr ee ng pr K ,i pur ui t s c vi r g s a ton yde k, r ni nm t oc di o s s ng hi i l i ht c i purua t 42U. C.j 1983, s nto S. amongot t ngsalgi t tt defndantprs ofi as her hi le ng ha he e ion fcil ha no pr ded a qua e f l up ca e f hi a tr he ha s ger i J nua y 2011 f ve t ovi de t olow r or m f e d ur y n a r or t oa ca e , ve notpr ded hi wih a s c a di tasr com m e d by a s c a i tt hr t nc r ha ovi m t pe i l e e nde pe i ls o a e sunr a e mout ul r a l dl c us d by f ale gis 1an dha no teae hi ddr s elt d h ce s lege y a e ood lr e , ve t r td m a o it l f tfuc ua i bl pr s ur ' He a s s e a es t hi me c lr c ds ppr pra ey or tl t tng ood e s e. ' lo e ks cc s o s di a e or . Af e t c t s ue an or rdie tng t c e k t s r Tuck' c pl i ton t de e nt , t r he our i s d de r c i he l r o e ve s om a n he f nda s h fldamoinf ri d aeij nci rle. e ie to o mme it nu t eif ve Asap ei nay ijmdi ntmp rrl af r sa e ta r i r rme yp irt tilt e r l r nt o e o aiy fo d n xr o dnay e d ro o ra,h mi p rys e igt p ei n r ij nci nmu td mo srt t t ( )t ei l eyt s c e do a t e kn he r l ay nu to s e n tae ha: 1 s s i l o u c e n mi h k t me is'( û i lkeyt s frir paa eham i t abs eofprlmi r rle , ( ) he rty'2) s s i l o ufe re rbl r n he enc he ei nay eif' 3 ' dh baa eo e u te tpsi hsfv r'a d( )t nij n to i i t ep bl itr s. Se û e lnc f q iis i n i a o r n 4 i n u cin s n h u i ne et' e t ' a c ' W i e v. t a Re our sDefns Cot i.l ,555U. 7, 1 S.Ct365, ( . ntr Naurl s ce e e mcl nc. S. 29 . 374 2008) l l hi amended com pl nt Tuck alegest ta s ci itw ho exam i hi mout ul s n s ai , l ha pe als ned s h cer tor r 't tTuc be tansf r d t a pr s f lt wher hecoul be pr ded wih t tcom mon û de ed' ha k r er e o i on aciiy e d ovi t he i Fa e' e, c h b ive woul alvit h sf odalr s t .Th c r tke u ca no ie r 'dit whih e ele s d le ae i o legy ymp oms e ou t a sj diil tc oft f tt t Comm on Far di i desi d t be conssentw ih t r i ousdi sr r by he ac hat he e et s gne o it t he elgi et equied varousr i ousf t gr . Tuck doesnotalege t thehasany r i ousbassf s ng t sdit i elgi aih oups l ha elgi i or eeki hi e . s howi ofa S tong pos i iiy' ofha m i i ufi i nt bec us t sa r r r a s w i ng fr s s lt ' r s ns tc e , a e he t nda d equies ho ng t tha m i t i l ' l ha r s i ke y.' d. a h oft e f f t s m us be s ts i be or i e l ut r l c hes our ac or t a i ted f e nt r oc o y ijmcier l fi warn d.Re l uhAb u Oba .n . . EC,5 F.d3 2, 4 ( t nt tv ei s ra t e a Trt o t ma Ic v F 75 3 4 3 7 4h Ci. 0 9 , a ae b r a d db c r. rne 1 0S. . 71( 01 ) ra fr di p ls r2 0 )v ctd e n e e t a td, 3 Ct23 2 0 , e fime n a' t rma dby,607F. 35 ( hCi. 0) Be us t prma ypur eofij tverle i e nde 3d 4t r 201 . ca e he i r pos n unci eif s t pr e v t sat quo e w e n t pa tes pe ng a r s uton on t m e is i e l ut y o es r e he t us t e he r i , ndi e ol i he rt , nt roc or ij n tv rle whc c g stesausq op n igtili l tdt c s swheedh n u ci e eif ih h e h tt u e dn ra s i e o a e mi r te t e ge e oft st ton dem a s h r le ' t s e r r na y r m e c nnotbe k va l of xi nci s he iua i nd uc e i f , hi xtao di r e dy n . ç ied a t s ur apice alti .'W eze v.Edwads 635F. 283,286( h Ci.1 0) o ec e e me ral tl r , 2d 4t r 98 . U pon r vi w oft r c d,t cou tc l st tTuc s m o i f i e l ut y e e h e or he r onc ude ha k' ton or nt r oc or ij n tv r l fmu tb d n e .Fis, c d e n talg f csd mo sr t t a h wil nu cie ei s e id rt Tu k o s o le e a t e n tai h t e l e ng s f r ir pa abl ha m w ihouti m e a e co ti e ve t o Alhough t co ta s d Tuc uf e r e r e r m di t ur nt r n i n. t he ur dvi e k oft ne t pr de s ii de a l a he ed o ovi pe tc t is bouthi c tons hi r ques sf m e ca t e t e , s ondii , s e t or di l r a m nt a t rs nd he e pons he ha r ce ve hi n e d c pl i tc i t pr m a iy ofconc us y es s i d, s m nde om a n ons s s i r l l or as e to . Tuc a l gesn f c sconc r ng s ii ha m he w ils f rf om no ha ng f l s ri ns k le at e ni pec f c r l uf e r t vi olow up vi isr a ed t hi pa s ge y orf om no ha ng ac es t hi m e c r c ds M o e r st el t o s s ur r r t vi c s o s di al e or . r ove , w hie he aleg t tt o he m e ca condii a i s s e i esca e hi s e dicom f r l l es ha he r di l tons t s ue om tm us m om s ot ( nfom t mout ul sa hea c sfom t bl pr sur c nge )2hi ale tons pai r he h ce nd da he r he ood e s e ha s, s lgai a o he s i s onsa1 i c t t tpr s m e c ls a fr s nd t r ubm s i s ndi a e ha i on di a t f e pond t hi c pl i t a thi o s om a n s bou s m e ca pr e s a pr i hi w ih s e te m en : m out a h a ale na i m e di l obl m nd o de m t om r at t hw s nd t r tve nu c c t a l a e t u1 r ,Tyl nolf he da he pa n,a ot rm edi a i n a r nty hoi es o levi t he c s e or a c i nd he c t o ppa e l 2 Tuck as erst t i bl pr ur goesup and down, acondii t the beleveshasca ed s t ha s ood ess e ton ha i us hi dpr onged di nes ,h adm ç ol zzi s aches pai i hi eyes and mi sr ' on uns fi occasonsi , nn s , nor tokes' peci ed i n t pas. he t 2 : i r a ed t hi t oa s ge y. W hie t e t e t e sm a notpr de t m e c r i e t t el t o s hr t ur r l hes r a m nt y ovi he di al eg m n ha Tuc be i ve t c ts ul or rof i i l t pr de f hi , he f c t tpr s n m e ca k le s he our ho d de fc a s o ovi or m t a t ha i o di l pe s r onnela e addr s i hi m e c lc tonsw e g ag ns a fndi t the w ils f r r e s ng s di a ondii i hs ai t i ng ha l ufe irp rbl h l i t ea e c of h r q etditro uo yij n tv r le. re aa e a' n h bs n e t e e u se nelc t r n u cie eif m Furhe m or r t t n m ai ai ng t s a us quo be w ee t pa tes gr ntng t t r e, a her ha nt ni he t t t n he r i , a i he r quese r i w o d r r pr s n of i i l t e nd s t i lef or and r s c a e t d elef ul equie i o fc a s o xpe ubsanta f t e our es nd w oul c r ve e t bls VD O C pr e esf de e ni a opra e m e c lt e t e d icum nt s a i hed oc dur or t nni ng ppr i t di a r a m nt a housng f Tuc D e e nt s d notbeputt t s bur nsbef r ha ng a c nc t nd i or k. f nda s houl o he e de o e vi ha e o de opt is tuought nor lltgainpr se ,whih aewelunder vel he sues l he ma ii to oce ss c r l way.J The . Z co ts r e Tuck' a ende c pl i o t de e ur e v d s m d om a nt n he f ndant i m i N o m be 2011, nd a s n d- ve r a r po i pl adi i due i J nua y 201 es nsve e ng s n a r 2. Fort r a ons s a e t co tfndst tTuc ha f ie t a l e f c s s t c e t he e s t t d, he ur i ha k s a l d o leg a t ufi i nt o stsya1 f h fu fco so teW itrsa d r t d mo srt t t ne lc t r ij n tv aif 1 o t e o r a t r f h n e tn ad o e n tae ha i tro u o y nu cie r le i wa r nt Rea Tr h,5 F. a 347.Tuc sm oto wilbede e An a opra e e if s ra ed. l ut 75 3d t k' in l nid. ppr it or rwili s t s da de l s ue hi y. The C l r i di e t d t s nd c e oft sm e or e k s r c e o e opi s hi m andum opi on a a om pa ng ni nd cc nyi or rt pl i if de o a ntf . y ENTER:Thi 19 d yo De e e, 01 . s . a f c mb r2 1 ' G , Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ e t d a es s r c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
