Switzer v. Town of Stanley et al, No. 5:2011cv00021 - Document 125 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/19/2012. (jat)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
e pv s o- l u. Dl cour cE s, sm AT * I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W EST ERN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI H A RR ISO N BUR G D I ISIO N V 1 soNBuRa VA Fl Gn l 80V 18 2 1 22 JUL C. 't CL . F EM 2 TH O M A S SW ITZER , Pl ntf , ai if C i lA c i N o. 5: v021 vi t on : 11c V. TO W N O F STA N LEY ,e .al, t . By:H on.M i chaelF.U rbanski U nied St esD i t i tJudge t at src D e e nt f nda . M EM O R AND U M O PI O N NI Be or t c ti Pl i i fThom asSw ize ' M oton f Tr ns rpts e ng pa e of f e he our s a ntf t rs i or a c i e ki ym nt ta c i sa t g r ntsexpe e. ( kt N o 1 ) I t moton,pl ntf not t thei r nsrpt t he ovenme ' ns 1 D . 24. n he i ai if es ha s . pr ee ngm f mana rs s ntt Fe R. oc di i or upe i.Purua o d. App.P.2 a( ,pli ifnee nots kpror 4()3) antf d ee i a ovalt pr e L f mapa rsi hewaspe mitdt pr e L f mapa rsi t ppr o oce d q or upei f r te o oc ed q or upei n he dit i tc tac i unl st di t i tc tc rii s t tt a ali no t ke i good f t s rc our ton es he sr c our e tte ha he ppe s t a n n aih. S eF d R. v. 2 ()3 ( . e e . Ci P. 4 a ()A) (l t a enc ofs m e e den i pr rmotve t a iantsgood f ih i e t bls d tn he bs e o vi t m ope i , he pplc ' at s sa ihe by t pr s nt ton ofa i s t ti notpl i y fi ous ' Eli v.Unied St t s 356 U . he e e a i ny s ue ha s a nl r vol .' ls t ae, S. 67 67 (1 ) Frvol a l lc fa agua eba i et ri lw ori fct' SeeNeiz 4, 4 958 . i ous ppeas a k <n r bl ss ihe n a na . ' tke v.W iln ,490U. 319,3 ( 989) l ohe wor , a li no fi ousi i i v lims S. 25 1 . n t r ds an ppea s t rvol f t nvoles lgalis a gua eont i meis l ;s eas Ada v.Rie,40F. 72,74( h Ci. e sues r bl her rt. d. e lo ms c 3d 4t r 1 4) 99 . lPtr ua t 28 U .SC. l 5 c( )u o afn igta plitf i p o e dn . fr pa p rs tec ut y ls nt o . j 9l ()2, p n idn h t an i s r c e igt o ma u ei,h o rma f q die pa e byt Unied stt oft e r ct ym nt he t aes he xpens soft rntng t r co d onappe ...,i s prntng i r quied e ' i i he e r p al f uch i i s e r byt a l ec t' he ppelat our. ' Pli tf sprm a y cai i t thi Fourh Am e a n if i r l m s ha s t ndme rghtwasvi a e whe nt i ol t d n de e n e e ed hi hom e w iho a w a r nt On A ugus 1 201 t cour hel t t f nda t nt r s t ut ra . t 0, 2, he t d ha pl ntf ' Fourh A m e entr ght w e e notvi a e prm a iy be us pl i ifha be n ai i f s t ndm i s r ol t d i rl ca e a ntf d e l ly e l d fom t f l r i nc pu s tt asat cour pr t c i or r Ther f e egal xc ude r he amiy esde e r uan o t e- t o e tve de . e or , a t tme oft ares,pli tf wasil ly a wr ngf l i t r sde e i vi ai n ofs i t he i he r t a n if lega l nd o uly n he e i nc n ol to ad or ra ha noras bl e cai ofprva yi t f l r i nc ( . 1 ) de nd d e ona e xpe tton i c n he amiy esde e. Dkt No. 00. Addii ly, hecour not d t te n i pli ifc d e t bls acogni bl e caton of tonal t t e ha ve f antf oul sa ih za e xpe t i prvac i t prmie ,hi Fourh Ame ntrght weenotvi aedbe us ( )gi nt i y n he e s s s t ndme i s r olt ca e 1 ve he domesi a e st ton i t home,e de e by t pr t c i or ra ns pl ntf, tc bus iua i n he vi nc d he o e tve de gai t ai if de e f ndan ' w a r ntes e l i o t f m iy r s de i s t s r a l s nt' nt he n l e i nce s uppo t d by t Fourh Am e e ' y re he t ndm nt s e e i f e ge crumsa sa ( pl ntf swie, ngt aut iyt c e t xc pton or xi nt ic tnce nd 2) ai if f havi he hort o onsnt o e r i o t f m iy hom e, e l gave he vald co e t def nda . nty nt he a l cl ary r i ns nt o e nt Plitf a e l t i c u tso d rd n n s v r l o tj d me tmo in fldb anif pp as h s o r' r e e yig e ea p s-u g n to s ie y pl ntf t tt c tconsr e a moto f rconsdeai purua t Fe R.Ci P 59() ai if ha he our tu d s ins or e i rton s nt o d. v. e a d 6 () ( tNo. 1 . I te epo t u g n mo in , anifs ug tt o frn w n 0b . Dk . 1 9) n h s s- d me t to s plitf o h o fe e j e de e f o hi w ie a s e on t ta l ge y c r c e e de t tt M a sr t vi nc r m s f nd t ps ha le dl ontadi t d vi nce ha he gi ta e J udge r le upon w hen m aki hi r po ta r om m e ton. Pa tc a l pl i ifar ue e id ng s e r nd ec nda i r i ul r y, a ntf g d t thi s e on' s a e ent co a ne i t M a c 15, 2 a fda tw e e m ade unde dur s , ha s t ps s t t m s nt i d n he r h 201 f i vi r r es be us de e e c ca e f ns ouns lpr s ur d hi s e on t s g t afi vi .The or r de ng t pos e e s e s t ps o i n he f da t de nyi he t j udgme motonsnotd,howe r t tpl nifpr nt i e ve ,ha aitf oduce onl oneafda tfom hi se o d y fi vi r s tps n whi h di no hi m or t n co i t e s e e ofa s a e c tpr e tve or r The new c d t ng e ha nfnn he xit nc t t - our ot c i de . af i tf om t s epson doesnots fdavi r he t ugges t hi proraf i tw as coer and ot w i e t hat s i f davi ced her s f is t unde m i t l galc us on t tpl i ifha no r as na e e c a i ofprva i al o r ne he e oncl i ha a ntf d e o bl xpe t ton i cy n hi f m iy r i nc Ther i sm pl no is of1 w lf f r ol i on a a a t r o e s n l esde e. esi y s ue a e t or es uton ppe l nd he ef r , pl ntf sa a i f i ous A c or ngl t cour fndst tt a a s ul notbe c r ii d ai i f ppe l s rvol . c di y, he t i ha he ppe l ho d e tfe ast ken i good f t a pl i ifs M oton f Tr ns i b de e a n aih, nd a ntf i or a crpt e ni d. The Cl r i die ed t s nd co e oft sM e o andum Opi on a t ac om pa ng e k s r ct o e pi s hi m r ni nd he c nyi O r rt pl i if de o a ntf . Ent r d: N ove be 1 201 ee m r 9, 2 / - -im 4/.?,4 -4 J ' n 2 - . M i ha lF. r ns c e U ba ki Unie St t Di t i tJ t d a es s rc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
