Cox et al v. Alpha Land and Reserves, LLC et al, No. 2:2013cv00029 - Document 22 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 08/29/2013. (rkc)

Download PDF

M I TH E U N I D STAT ES D I N TE STR I CO U R T CT FO R T H E W ESTER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A Å e OFFI u.:. sT. URT CE D6 K ATRoANou , VA ACFD1 t3<9 #23 I L 2 E J Q DUDLE LL UM X ERK W; c BIG STONE GAP DIVISION NEL L LO U I CO X ,etal, SE . C i lA c i N o. 1 C V vi t on 2: 3- 29 Pl i if , a ntf s M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O A LPH A LAN D A ND R ESERV ES,LLC ,e al, t . By: Sam uelG .W ison l U ni ed St es D i ri Judge t at st ct D ef endant . s On J 7,201 pl ntfsNe lLo s Cox,J mesE.Coli ,i vi ual a J mesE. une 3, ai if l ui e a lns ndi d ly, nd a Coli ,Tr t e ofJ m esE.Coli Tr s A gr e e D a e J 18 1 f l d t s a ton lns us e a lns u t e m nt t d une , 997 ie hi c i a s rig s b e matr u id cinu e 2 U. C. 1 3 a ans t ed fn a t c n enn a s et u j d te j rs ito nd r 8 S. j 3 2 g i t h e e d n s o c r ig n diput ove r alpr ry i Vigi a. Thede e nt i l Al La a Res r es LLC; s e r e ope t n r ni f nda s ncude pha nd nd e v , A CI ,LLC;and V igi a El c dc Pow e Co. b a D o i on V igi a Powe Co. LLC . N r ni e t r d/ / m ni r ni r , Thedee nt mo dt c todimist c s unde Fed.R.Ci P.1 b)1 f fnda s ve he our t s s he a e r v. 2( ( ) or l k ofc pl t di r iy of c tz ns p on J y 25,2011 The pl i if ha fl no ac om e e ve s t ii e hi ul . a ntf s ve ied o po i o a dt d a l ef rrs n igt e W . Va Ci R.1 () 1 h se pr d l p st n n he e di o epo dn md r D. . v. 1c () a x ie . n i n ac z nc wih W . Va.Ci R.11b)a Fe R.Ci P.78( ,t cour wildee net co da e t D. v. ( nd d. v. b) he t l tnni he m oton wihouta or lhe rng. The c t i t tt ca e l ksc i t n a ai our fnds ha he s ac ompl t di r iy of e e ve st * ciiens punde 28U. C.j 1 a wilt eor dimisi. tz hi r S. 332 nd l,herf e, s s t The de e nt a guet tt ciie hi ofde e ntACI LLC desr co e e f nda s r ha he tz ns p f nda N, toys mplt dv riy Fo p r s so dv riyj s ito nod fn a tc n s a ectz n hpwi a y i est . r u po e f iest mi dcin, ee d n a h r iie s i t n h pli if 28 U. C.j 1 a .Ac di t t Com pl nt t pl ntfsar a1ctze of antf . S. 332( ) cor ng o he ai , he ai if e 1 ii ns *The def endant alo m oved t cour t dim ist cas underFed. R. v. 1 b)6) Thec r, s s he t o s s he e Ci P. 2( ( . ou ts fndigund rFe R. v. 1 b)1 rndesa iin lr lngsun c sa y. i n e d. Ci P. 2( ( ) e r ddto a ui ne e s r 1 r Te m es e A sa lm ied labiiy c pa t c tze hi ofA CI ,LLC i de e ne by t l s e. i t i lt om ny, he ii ns p N s t nni d he dtz hi ofism e iens p t mber . SeeGe Tec Applcai ns l v.Exr Lt ,38 F. 11 1 s n. h. i to e nc. o da 8 3d 4, 21 (t Ci. 4h r 2004) Theunco rdit fdsbefr t c ti cae: . nta ced a o e he our ndi t ( )ACI LLC i wholyo 1 N, s l wnedbyNRP ( rtng)LLC; Opeai ( )Nlp ( eaig LLC i whol o e byNal a Re ozc Pa t r, a d 2 t Op rtn ) s l wn d y tl l s l e rnes LP; n r r ( whent pli if c 3) he antfs omme dt sacin, t alRe ourePa t r,LPha nce hi to Naur s c rnes d one orm o e lm ie pa t r who w e e c tze ofTe m es e r i t d r ne s r ii ns r s e. A s a lm ie pa t r hi N a ur lR e o z c Pa t r ,LP ha t c tz hi ofa 1ofis i t d r ne s p, t a s lr e rne s s he ii ens p 1 t pa t r ,bot ge r la lm ied. Se N e Y o k St t Te he sR e i e e Sys e v. a kus r ne s h ne a nd i t e w r a e ac r tr m nt t m K l , 764F. 1 1 9( t Ci.1 5) Isciie hi and,heefr ,hectze hi ofdee nt 2d 015, 01 4h r 98 . t tz ns p t r o e t ii ns p fnda A CI ,LLC i l s Te s e Be us t pl i t fs a A CI ,LLC s r c tz hi i N nc ude nne s e. ca e he a n if nd N ha e ii ens p n Te s e,c nnes e ompl t di r iy ofctze hi doesnote s. ee ve st ii ns p xit F rt f rgon ra o ,hec u t o cud st a ilc s be t te j rs ito o he o e ig e s ns t o r c n l e h t t a ks u j c matr u id cin unde 28U. C.j1 r S. 332.TheCour wil a c di y,dimist c e. t l, c or ngl s s he as ENTER: Au us - u 2 3 g t - ' 01 . 1. ) Z I J DS XY . e A 2 EsDI TRI JJ S CT IDGE

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.