Hollomond v. Ray, No. 3:2019cv00884 - Document 29 (E.D. Va. 2020)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Magistrate Judge Roderick C. Young on 09/15/2020. Copy mailed to Petitioner. (walk, )
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Hollomond v. Ray Doc. 29 KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" HQT"VJG"GCUVGTP"FKUVTKEV"QH"XKTIKPKC" Tkejoqpf"Fkxkukqp" " DGTPCTF"F0"JQNNQOQPF." " " Rgvkvkqpgt." x0" " " " " " " " " Ekxkn"Cevkqp"Pq0"5<3;EX::6" " VTCE["TC[." " " Tgurqpfgpv0" " " OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP" " Dgtpctf" F0" Jqnnqoqpf."c"Xktikpkc"uvcvg"rtkuqpgt"rtqeggfkpi"pro se." dtkpiu" vjku" rgvkvkqp" rwtuwcpv"vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸"4476"*и"4476"Rgvkvkqp.Ñ"GEH"Pq0"3+"ejcnngpikpi"jku"4239"eqpxkevkqpu"kp" vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"qh"vjg"Ekv{"qh"Ejgucrgcmg."Xktikpkc"*ÐEktewkv"EqwtvÑ+0""Jqnnqoqpf"ctiwgu"vjcv" jg"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"tgnkgh"qp"vjg"hqnnqykpi"itqwpfu<3" " Encko"Qpg<" ÐFgpkcn"qh"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn0Ñ""*Id."cv"70+" " Encko"Vyq<" ÐUwhhkekgpe{"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg0Ñ""*Id."cv"90+" Encko"Vjtgg<" ÐKpghhgevkxg"Cuukuvcpeg"qh"Eqwpugn"Î"hckngf"vq"rtqvgev"RgvkvkqpgtÓu"tkijv"vq"c" lwt{"vtkcn0Ñ""*Id."cv":0+" " Tgurqpfgpv"oqxgu"vq"fkuokuu"qp"vjg"itqwpf."inter alia. vjcv"JqnnqoqpfÓu"enckou"ncem"ogtkv0"" Jqnnqoqpf"jcu"tgurqpfgf0""*GEH"Pqu0"42Î440+""Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy."vjg"Oqvkqp"vq" Fkuokuu"*GEH"Pq0"36+"yknn"dg"ITCPVGF."vjg"¸"4476"Rgvkvkqp"yknn"dg"FGPKGF."cpf"vjg"cevkqp" yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF0" " " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 3 "Vjg"Eqwtv"gornq{u"vjg"rcikpcvkqp"cuukipgf"d{"vjg"EO1GEH"fqemgvkpi"u{uvgo"hqt"ekvcvkqpu"vq"vjg" rctvkguÓ"uwdokuukqpu0""" " " Dockets.Justia.com K0" RTQEGFWTCN"JKUVQT[" Qp"Fgegodgt"38."4237."vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"fgpkgf"JqnnqoqpfÓu"oqvkqp"hqt"c"okuvtkcn."cpf"c" oqvkqp"vq"uvtkmg."cpf"eqpxkevgf"Jqnnqoqpf"qh"vyq"eqwpvu"qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"cpf"rquuguukqp"ykvj"kpvgpv" vq"fkuvtkdwvg"c"Uejgfwng"K"qt"KK"eqpvtqnngf"uwduvcpeg."vjktf"qt"uwdugswgpv"qhhgpug0""*GEH"Pq0"38Î3." cv" 3Î4" *ekvkpi" Xc0" Eqfg" Cpp0" ¸" 3:04Î46:*E+" *Yguv" 4242++0+" " Vjg" Ektewkv" Eqwtv" ugpvgpegf" Jqnnqoqpf" vq" vgp" {gctu" qp" gcej" eqwpv" hqt" c" vqvcn" qh" vygpv{" {gctu" qh" kpectegtcvkqp0" " *Id." cv" 60+"" Jqnnqoqpf"crrgcngf."ctiwkpi"vjcv"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"ÐÒgttgf"kp"pqv"itcpvkpi"]jku_"oqvkqp"vq"uvtkmg" cu"ygnn"cu"vjg"tgpgycn"qh"vjg"oqvkqp."cu"vq"cnn"vjg"ejctiguÓÑ"cpf"Ðgttgf"kp"fgp{kpi"jku"oqvkqp"hqt"c" okuvtkcn"cpf"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev"Òqp"vjg"dcuku"qh"]jku_"fguktg"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"qh" jku"lwt{"vtkcn"tkijvu0ÓÑ""*GEH"Pq0"38Î4."cv"3."6"*cnvgtcvkqpu"kp"qtkikpcn+0+""Vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh" Xktikpkc"fgpkgf"jku"rgvkvkqp"hqt"crrgcn0""*Id."cv"30+""Vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"qh"Xktikpkc"tghwugf"vjg" rgvkvkqp"hqt"crrgcn0""*GEH"Pq0"38Î5."cv"30+" " "Jqnnqoqpf"hkngf"c"rgvkvkqp"hqt"c"ytkv"qh"jcdgcu"eqtrwu"kp"vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"qh"Xktikpkc" tckukpi"enckou"ukoknct"vq"Enckou"Qpg"cpf"Vjtgg"qh"jku"¸"4476"Rgvkvkqp0""*GEH"Pq0"38Î6."cv"3."50+"" Vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"qh"Xktikpkc"fkuokuugf"vjg"jcdgcu"rgvkvkqp0""*Id."cv"50+""Jqnnqoqpf"uwdugswgpvn{" hkngf" vjg" kpuvcpv" ¸" 4476" Rgvkvkqp0" " Wpfgtn{kpi" JqnnqoqpfÓu" enckou" ku" vjg" igpgtcn" rtgokug" vjcv" gxgt{qpg" gzegrv" hqt" Jqnnqoqpf" ujqwnf" dg" fkuetgfkvgf" cu" nkctu." kpenwfkpi" eqwpugn" cpf" vjg" EqooqpygcnvjÓu"ejkgh"ykvpguu"cv"vtkcn0""Cu"fkuewuugf"dgnqy."vjku"rtgokug"ku"dgnkgf"d{"vjg"tgeqtf0" KK0" CRRNKECDNG"EQPUVTCKPVU"WRQP"JCDGCU"TGXKGY" Kp"qtfgt"vq"qdvckp"hgfgtcn"jcdgcu"tgnkgh."cv"c"okpkowo."c"rgvkvkqpgt"owuv"fgoqpuvtcvg"vjcv" jg" ku" Ðkp" ewuvqf{" kp" xkqncvkqp" qh" vjg" Eqpuvkvwvkqp" qt" ncyu" qt" vtgcvkgu" qh" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu0Ñ"" 4:"W0U0E0"¸"4476*c+0""Vjg"Cpvkvgttqtkuo"cpf"Ghhgevkxg"Fgcvj"Rgpcnv{"qh"3;;8"*ÐCGFRCÑ+"hwtvjgt" ektewouetkdgu"vjku"EqwtvÓu"cwvjqtkv{"vq"itcpv"tgnkgh"d{"yc{"qh"c"ytkv"qh"jcdgcu"eqtrwu0""Urgekhkecnn{." Ð]u_vcvg"eqwtv"hcevwcn"fgvgtokpcvkqpu"ctg"rtguwogf"vq"dg"eqttgev"cpf"oc{"dg"tgdwvvgf"qpn{"d{"engct" " " 4" cpf"eqpxkpekpi"gxkfgpeg0Ñ""Gray v. Branker."74;"H05f"442."44:"*6vj"Ekt0"422:+"*ekvkpi"4:"W0U0E0" ¸"4476*g+*3++0""Cffkvkqpcnn{."wpfgt"4:"W0U0E0"¸"4476*f+."c"hgfgtcn"eqwtv"oc{"pqv"itcpv"c"ytkv"qh" jcdgcu" eqtrwu" dcugf" qp" cp{" encko" vjcv" ycu" cflwfkecvgf" qp" vjg" ogtkvu" kp" uvcvg" eqwtv" wpnguu" vjg" cflwfkecvgf"encko<" *3+" tguwnvgf" kp" c" fgekukqp" vjcv" ycu" eqpvtct{" vq." qt" kpxqnxgf" cp" wptgcuqpcdng" crrnkecvkqp"qh."engctn{"guvcdnkujgf"Hgfgtcn"ncy."cu"fgvgtokpgf"d{"vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv" qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu="qt" *4+"tguwnvgf"kp"c"fgekukqp"vjcv"ycu"dcugf"qp"cp"wptgcuqpcdng"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"vjg" hcevu"kp"nkijv"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"rtgugpvgf"kp"vjg"Uvcvg"eqwtv"rtqeggfkpi0" 4:" W0U0E0" ¸" 4476*f+0" " Vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" jcu" gorjcuk|gf" vjcv" vjg" swguvkqp" Ðku" pqv" yjgvjgt" c" hgfgtcn"eqwtv"dgnkgxgu"vjg"uvcvg"eqwtvÓu"fgvgtokpcvkqp"ycu"kpeqttgev"dwv"yjgvjgt"vjcv"fgvgtokpcvkqp" ycu"wptgcuqpcdngÏc"uwduvcpvkcnn{"jkijgt"vjtgujqnf0Ñ""Schriro v. Landrigan."772"W0U0"687."695" *4229+"*ekvkpi Williams v. Taylor."74;"W0U0"584."632"*4222++0 KKK0" UWHHKEKGPE["QH"VJG"GXKFGPEG" Kp"Encko"Vyq."Jqnnqoqpf"ctiwgu"Ðvjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"pqv"eqpuvkvwvkqpcnn{"uwhhkekgpv"vq"rtqxg" dg{qpf"c"tgcuqpcdng"fqwdv"vjcv"Rgvkvkqpgt"rquuguugf"ykvj"vjg"kpvgpv"vq"fkuvtkdwvg"c"uejgfwng"K1KK" eqpvtqnngf" uwduvcpeg." vjktf" qhhgpug=" vyq" eqwpvu0Ñ" *GEH" Pq0" 3." cv" 390+4" " Kp" guugpeg." Jqnnqoqpf" ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"rtqxkfgf"hcnug"vguvkoqp{"vq"kpetkokpcvg"Jqnnqoqpf"cpf"vjcv" kpuwhhkekgpv"ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"gzkuvgf"qh"jku"kpvgpv"vq"fkuvtkdwvg"etcem"eqeckpg0""" Kp"tglgevkpi"JqnnqoqpfÓu"uwhhkekgpe{"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ctiwogpv."vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh" Xktikpkc"crvn{"hqwpf<" " ÐYjgp" eqpukfgtkpi" qp" crrgcn" vjg" uwhhkekgpe{" qh" vjg" gxkfgpeg" rtgugpvgf" dgnqy."yg"Òrtguwog"vjg"lwfiogpv"qh"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"vq"dg"eqttgevÓ"cpf"tgxgtug"qpn{" kh"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtvÓu"fgekukqp"ku"Òrnckpn{"ytqpi"qt"ykvjqwv"gxkfgpeg"vq"uwrrqtv"kv0ÓÑ"" Kelly v. Commonwealth."63"Xc0"Crr0"472."479."7:6"U0G04f"666."669"*4225+"*en banc+"*swqvkpi"Davis v. Commonwealth."5;"Xc0"Crr0";8.";;."792"U0G04f":97.":98Î 99"*4224++0""ÐQp"crrgcn."yg"yknn"eqpukfgt"vjg"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"nkijv"oquv"hcxqtcdng" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 4 "Vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"kv"crrtqrtkcvg"vq"cfftguu"Encko"Vyq"hktuv"dgecwug"Enckou"Qpg"cpf"Vjtgg"ctg"dqvj" dcugf"qp"vjg"wpfgtn{kpi"eqpvgpvkqp"vjcv"Jqnnqoqpf"fguktgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn."pqv"c"vtkcn"d{"vjg"lwfig0" " " 5" vq" vjg" Eqooqpygcnvj." cu" kv" rtgxckngf" kp" vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv0Ñ" " Whitehurst v. Commonwealth."85"Xc0"Crr0"354."355."976"U0G04f";32.";32"*4236+0" " Uq"xkgygf."vjg"gxkfgpeg"guvcdnkujgf"vjcv"qp"Octej"8."4237."Lcuqp"Ykpp"ycu" yqtmkpi" cu" c" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocvkqp" hqt" vjg" Ejgucrgcmg" Rqnkeg" Fgrctvogpv" Pcteqvkeu"Wpkv0""Ykpp"ecnngf"c"rgtuqp"mpqyp"cu"ÐD/Ocem.Ñ"yjq"ycu"ncvgt"kfgpvkhkgf" cu"crrgnncpv."vq"cttcpig"c"oggvkpi"vq"rwtejcug"&322"yqtvj"qh"ftwiu."cnvjqwij"pq" yqtfu"kfgpvkh{kpi"yjcv"ycu"dgkpi"rwtejcugf"ygtg"wugf0""Rtkqt"vq"YkppÓu"oggvkpi" ykvj"D/Ocem."vjg"rqnkeg"ugctejgf"YkppÓu"rgtuqp"cpf"xgjkeng"cpf"icxg"jko"&3220"" Vjg"rqnkeg"cnuq"cttcpigf"hqt"cwfkq"cpf"xkuwcn"tgeqtfkpi"qh"vjg"oggvkpi0""Ykpp"icxg" D/Ocem"vjg"&322"cpf."kp"gzejcpig."tgegkxgf"etcem"eqeckpg0""Chvgt"Ykpp"ogv"ykvj" D/Ocem." vjg" rqnkeg" ugctejgf" Ykpp" cpf" hqwpf" pqvjkpi" qvjgt" vjcp" vjg"eqeckpg" jg" rwtejcugf0" " Qp"Octej"34."4237."Ykpp"cickp"ecnngf"D/Ocem"cpf"cttcpigf"c"oggvkpi"vq" rwtejcug"&372"yqtvj"qh"eqeckpg0""Rtkqt"vq"vjg"oggvkpi."vjg"rqnkeg"ugctejgf"Ykpp" cpf"jku"xgjkeng0""Vjg"rqnkeg"icxg"Ykpp"&372"cpf"gswkrrgf"jku"ect"ykvj"cwfkq"cpf" xkfgq"tgeqtfkpi0""Ykpp"ygpv"vq"vjg"fgukipcvgf"oggvkpi"urqv."c"jqvgn0""Vjg"rqnkeg" ykvpguugf"crrgnncpv"ectt{kpi"c"nqcf"qh"ncwpft{"kpvq"YkppÓu"ect."cpf"vjg"ect"ftqxg" ctqwpf"vq"vjg"qvjgt"ukfg"qh"vjg"jqvgn0""Chvgt"vjg"oggvkpi."vjg"rqnkeg"ugctejgf"Ykpp" cpf"hqwpf"pqvjkpi"qvjgt"vjcp"vjg"etcem"eqeckpg"jg"rwtejcugf0" " Vjg"rqnkeg"ugpv"vjg"ftwiu"qdvckpgf"htqo"vjg"gxgpvu"vq"vjg"ncd"hqt"cpcn{uku0"" Vjg"ncd"eqphktogf"vjcv"vjg"ftwiu"ygtg"etcem"eqeckpg"cpf"ygkijgf"crrtqzkocvgn{" 2066"itco"cpf"2089"itco."tgurgevkxgn{0""" " Cv" vjg" eqpenwukqp" qh" vjg" EqooqpygcnvjÓu" gxkfgpeg." crrgnncpv" ocfg" c" oqvkqp"vq"uvtkmg."yjkej"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fgpkgf0""Crrgnncpv"vguvkhkgf"cpf"fgpkgf"ugnnkpi" ftwiu"vq"Ykpp0""Crrgnncpv"uckf"vjcv"qp"Octej"8."4237."jg"ogv"ykvj"Ykpp"vq"vcnm"vq" Ykpp"cdqwv"uqog"ycvejgu"cpf"oqpg{"vjcv"Ykpp"qygf"jko0""Crrgnncpv"uckf"vjcv"qp" Octej"34."4237."jg"cickp"ogv"ykvj"Ykpp"vq"vcnm"cdqwv"vjg"ycvejgu"cpf"oqpg{"qygf" jko0""Crrgnncpv"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"jg"ycu"ectt{kpi"enqvjgu"vq"Ykpp"vq"ugg"kh"Ykpp"ycu" kpvgtguvgf"kp"cp{"qh"vjgo0""Crrgnncpv"cfokvvgf"vjcv"jg"jcf"c"rncuvke"dci"kp"jku"jcpf" qp"dqvj"qeecukqpu"vjcv"jg"ogv"ykvj"Ykpp0" " Cv"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"cnn"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg."crrgnncpv"tgpgygf"jku"oqvkqp"vq" uvtkmg."yjkej"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fgpkgf0""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"hqwpf"crrgnncpv"iwknv{"qh"vyq" eqwpvu"qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"eqeckpg."vjktf"qhhgpug0]5_" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ]5_"Crrgnncpv"ekvgu"vyq"rcigu"kp"vjg"Fgegodgt"38."4237"vtcpuetkrv"vq"ujqy"yjgtg" vjg" ctiwogpv" ycu" rtgugtxgf0" " Qp" rcig" 94." vjg" hqnnqykpi" gzejcpig" qeewttgf" dgvyggp"crrgnncpvÓu"eqwpugn"cpf"vjg"eqwtv<" Ou0" Jcffggf<" " [qwt" Jqpqt." K" yqwnf" ocmg" c" oqvkqp" vq" uvtkmg" hqt" hcknwtg"vq"rtgugpv"uwhhkekgpv"gxkfgpeg"cu"vq"dqvj"eqwpvu0" Vjg"Eqwtv<""VjcvÓu"kvA" Ou0"Jcffggf<""VjcvÓu"kv0" Vjg"Eqwtv<""Oqvkqp"fgpkgf"qp"dqvj"eqwpvu0" Qp"rcig":;."vjg"hqnnqykpi"gzejcpig"qeewttgf"dgvyggp"crrgnncpvÓu"eqwpugn"cpf"vjg" eqwtv<" Ou0"Jcfggf<""[qwt"Jqpqt."K"yqwnf"tgpgy"o{"oqvkqp"vq"uvtkmg0" Vjg"Eqwtv<""Qp"vjg"ucog"dcuku"cu"dghqtgA" Ou0"Jcfggf<""Eqttgev0" " " 6" " Cuuwokpi"vjcv"yg"tgcej"vjg"uwduvcpeg"qh"crrgnncpvÓu"tcvjgt"xciwg"ctiwogpvu" vq"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv."crrgnncpv"pqy"ctiwgu"qp"crrgcn"vjcv"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"gttgf"kp"hkpfkpi" vjcv"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ycu"uwhhkekgpv"vq"eqpxkev"jko"qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"eqeckpg"dgecwug" vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp"ycu"pqv"tgnkcdng0""Hktuv."jg"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"rqnkeg"fkf" pqv"cfgswcvgn{"ugctej"Ykpp"dgecwug"kv"ycu"pqv"cp"ÐgzjcwuvkxgÑ"ugctej0""Jg"cuugtvu" vjcv" vjg" tgeqxgtgf" ftwiu" ygtg" kp" uocnn" coqwpvu." uq" Ykpp" eqwnf" jcxg" eqpegcngf" ftwiu"Ðkp"qvjgt"rctvu"qh"jku"rgtuqp0Ñ""Ugeqpf."jg"pqvgu"vjcv"Ykpp"jcf"qwvuvcpfkpi" ftwi"ejctigu"cpf"ycu"cp"cfokvvgf"eqeckpg"cffkev0""Ncuvn{."crrgnncpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg" cwfkq"cpf"xkfgq"tgeqtfkpiu"fkf"pqv"ujqy"cp"gzejcpig"qh"ftwiu."pqt"fkf"vjg{"ecrvwtg" crrgnncpv" cpf" Ykpp" fkuewuukpi" vjg" rwtejcug" qh" ftwiu0" " Crrgnncpv" eqpvgpfu" jku" gzrncpcvkqp"qh"yjcv"vtcpurktgf"kp"vjg"ect"ycu"rncwukdng0" " Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"jcf"vjg"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"ugg"cpf"jgct"vjg"ykvpguugu."cu"ygnn"cu" vjg"cwfkq"cpf"xkfgq"tgeqtfkpiu0""Vjg"rqnkeg"qhhkegtu"vguvkhkgf"cdqwv"vjgkt"ugctejgu"qh" Ykpp" cpf" jku" xgjkeng" dghqtg" cpf" chvgt" jku" oggvkpiu" ykvj" crrgnncpv0" " Vjg" rqnkeg" gzrnckpgf"vjcv"vjg{"ugctejgf"Ykpp."jku"rqemgvu."cpf"jku"ujqgu0""Vjg"rqnkeg"ugctejgf" YkppÓu"xgjkeng."kpenwfkpi"vjg"Ðinqxg"dqz."ocr"rqemgvu."egpvgt"eqpuqng."wpfgt"vjg" ugcv."kp"vjg"ugcv.Ñ"cpf"wpfgt"vjg"twiu0""Vjg"rqnkeg"fkf"pqv"fkueqxgt"cp{"eqpvtcdcpf" qp"YkppÓu"rgtuqp"qt"kp"jku"ect0""Vjg"rqnkeg"hwtvjgt"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"vjg{"fkf"pqv"rtqokug" Ykpp" cp{vjkpi" kp" gzejcpig" hqt" jku" eqqrgtcvkqp" kp" vjg" eqpvtqnngf" dw{u0" " Chvgt" jgctkpi"vjg"EqooqpygcnvjÓu"ykvpguugu"cpf"crrgnncpv"vguvkh{."vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"hqwpf" vjg"EqooqpygcnvjÓu"ykvpguugu"vq"dg"oqtg"etgfkdng0" " Ð]F_gvgtokpkpi"vjg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"vjg"ykvpguugu"cpf"vjg"ygkijv"chhqtfgf"vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" vjqug" ykvpguugu" ctg" ocvvgtu" nghv" vq" vjg" vtkgt" qh" hcev0Ñ" " Parham v. Commonwealth."86"Xc0"Crr0"782."787."992"U0G04f"426."429"*4237+0""ÐKp"kvu"tqng"qh" lwfikpi"ykvpguu"etgfkdknkv{."vjg"hcev"hkpfgt"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"fkudgnkgxg"vjg"ugnh/ugtxkpi" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" Vjg"Eqwtv<""Qp"gcej"ejctig."vjg"Eqwtv"yknn"fgp{"vjg"oqvkqp"vq"uvtkmg0" Fwtkpi"enqukpi"ctiwogpv."crrgnncpv"ctiwgf"cu"hqnnqyu<" Vjcpm" {qw." [qwt" Jqpqt0" " Cv" pq" rqkpv" ycu" Ot0" Ykpp" ]vjg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpv_" pqv" wpfgt" uwtxgknncpeg" d{" vjg" rqnkeg" fgrctvogpv0" " Vjqug" ctg" Ou0" Cddg{Óu" yqtfu" ykvj" tgictfu" vq" vjg" uwtxgknncpeg"cpf"vjg"uq/ecnngf"eqpvtqnngf"dw{0""VjcvÓu"pqv"cevwcnn{" vjg"ecug"dgecwug"vjgtgÓu"pq"qpg"kp"vjg"xgjkeng"ykvj"Ot0"Ykpp"dgukfgu" c" mg{" ejckp" xkfgq" ecogtc" vjcv" fqgupÓv" ujqy" owej" qh" cp{vjkpi." gurgekcnn{"pqv"qp"Octej"340""Kv"fqgupÓv"ujqy"Ot0"Ykpp"cpf"yjcv" jgÓu" fqkpi0"" Pq" qpg" gnug" ku" kp" vjg" ect" ykvj" jko." cpf" cnvjqwij" vjg" fgvgevkxgu"encko"vjcv"vjg{"ugctejgf"jko."vjg{"fkfpÓv"nkhv"wr"jku"ujktv" rcuv"jku"yckuvdcpf0""Vjg{"fkfpÓv"jcxg"jko"ftqr"jku"ftcygtu0""Jg"ycu" pqv"vjqtqwijn{"ugctejgf0"Jg"ycu"mkpf"qh"rcvvgf"fqyp0" 0"0"0"0" K"yqwnf"uwdokv"vq"vjg"Eqwtv."vjgtgÓu"corng"qrrqtvwpkv{"hqt"Ot0"Ykpp" yjq"uvcpfu"vq"ickp"c"nqv0""[gu."jg"ycupÓv"rtqokugf"cp{vjkpi."dwv"K" jkijn{"fqwdv"vjcv"Ot0"Ykpp"ku"jgtg"vqfc{"qwv"qh"vjg"iqqfpguu"qh"jku" jgctv"vq"fq"vjg"tkijv"vjkpi."cpf"jg"fqgupÓv"vjkpm"vjcv"jgÓu"iqkpi"vq" igv" uqogvjkpi" kp" gzejcpig" hqt" dqvj" jku" eqqrgtcvkqp" cpf" jku" vguvkoqp{0""Jg"jcu"c"nqv"vq"ickp0""JgÓu"hcekpi"c"hgnqp{"ejctig"jkougnh0" " " " 7" vguvkoqp{"qh"vjg"ceewugf"cpf"vq"eqpenwfg"vjcv"vjg"ceewugf"ku"n{kpi"vq"eqpegcn"jku" iwknv0Ñ""Flanagan v. Commonwealth."7:"Xc0"Crr0"8:3."924."936"U0G04f"434."444" *4233+"*swqvkpi"Marable v. Commonwealth."49"Xc0"Crr0"727."72;Î32."722"U0G04f" 445."457"*3;;:++0" " Eqpvtct{"vq"crrgnncpvÓu"ctiwogpvu."vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fkf"pqv"gtt"kp"fgp{kpi"vjg" oqvkqpu"vq"uvtkmg."cu"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ycu"uwhhkekgpv"vq"eqpxkev"crrgnncpv"qh"vyq"eqwpvu" qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"eqeckpg0" " *GEH"Pq0"38Î4."cv"3Î6"*hqqvpqvg"pwodgt"cnvgtgf"htqo"qtkikpcn+"*cnvgtcvkqpu"kp"qtkikpcn+"*qokuukqp" kp"qtkikpcn+0+"" Kp"eqpfwevkpi"vjg"rtgugpv"hgfgtcn"jcdgcu"tgxkgy."vjg"hkpfkpiu"qh"hcev"d{"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv" cpf"vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh"Xktikpkc"ctg"rtguwogf"eqttgev0""See 4:"W0U0E0"¸"4476*g+=" Gray v. Branker." 74;" H05f" 442." 44:" *6vj" Ekt0" 422:+0" " Jqnnqoqpf" jcu" vjg" dwtfgp" qh" tgdwvvkpi" vjcv" rtguworvkqp"d{"engct"cpf"eqpxkevkpi"gxkfgpeg0""See"¸"4476*g+*3+0""Eqpvtct{"vq"JqnnqoqpfÓu"fguktg" jgtg."hgfgtcn"eqwtvu"ukvvkpi"kp"jcdgcu"jcxg"Ðpq"nkegpug"vq"tgfgvgtokpg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"ykvpguugu"yjqug" fgogcpqt"jcu"dggp"qdugtxgf"d{"vjg"uvcvg"vtkcn"eqwtv."dwv"pqv"d{"vjgo0Ñ""Cagle v. Branker."742"H05f" 542."546"*6vj"Ekt0"422:+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+="see United States v. Arrington."93;"H04f"923."926"*6vj" Ekt0"3;:5+"*ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+"*jqnfkpi"vjcv"hgfgtcn"jcdgcu"eqwtvu."yjgp"ocmkpi"c"uwhhkekgpe{"qh" vjg"gxkfgpeg"fgvgtokpcvkqp."fq"pqv"ygkij"vjg"gxkfgpeg"qt"tgxkgy"vjg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"ykvpguugu+0""C" hgfgtcn"jcdgcu"rgvkvkqp"ycttcpvu"tgnkgh"qp"c"ejcnngpig"vq"vjg"uwhhkekgpe{"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"qpn{"kh"Ðpq" tcvkqpcn"vtkgt"qh"hcev"eqwnf"hkpf"]rtqqh"qh_"iwknv"dg{qpf"c"tgcuqpcdng"fqwdv0Ñ""Jackson v. Virginia." 665"W0U0"529."539"*3;9;+0""Vjg"tgngxcpv"swguvkqp"kp"eqpfwevkpi"uwej"c"tgxkgy"ku"yjgvjgt."Ðchvgt" xkgykpi"vjg"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"nkijv"oquv"hcxqtcdng"vq"vjg"rtqugewvkqp."any"tcvkqpcn"vtkgt"qh"hcev"eqwnf" jcxg" hqwpf" vjg" guugpvkcn" gngogpvu" qh" vjg" etkog" dg{qpf" c" tgcuqpcdng" fqwdv0Ñ" " Id." cv" 53;" *ekvkpi Johnson v. Louisiana."628"W0U0"578."584"*3;94++0""Vjg"etkvkecn"kpswkt{"qp"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"uwhhkekgpe{" qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vq"uwrrqtv"c"etkokpcn"eqpxkevkqp"ku"Ðyjgvjgt"vjg"tgeqtf"gxkfgpeg"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{" uwrrqtv"c"hkpfkpi"qh"iwknv"dg{qpf"c"tgcuqpcdng"fqwdv0Ñ""Id."cv"53:0""Fgurkvg"JqnnqoqpfÓu"ctiwogpv" " " 8" vq"vjg"eqpvtct{."vjg"gxkfgpeg"ycu"uwhhkekgpv"hqt"cp{"tcvkqpcn"hcevhkpfgt"vq"jcxg"hqwpf"Jqnnqoqpf" iwknv{"qh"vyq"eqwpvu"qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"eqeckpg."vjktf"qhhgpug0" " Vjg"gxkfgpeg"engctn{"guvcdnkujgf"vjcv"Jqnnqoqpf"vykeg"uqnf"etcem"eqeckpg"vq"c"eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpv0""Vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"ecnngf"Jqnnqoqpf"kp"vjg"rtgugpeg"qh"fgvgevkxgu."ugv"wr"vjg" oggvkpiu."cpf"vjg"ecnnu"ygtg"tgeqtfgf0""*See, e.g.."Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"34Î35."45Î46."63."75Î760+"" Vjg"fgvgevkxgu"hqnnqygf"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"vq"vjg"ukvgu"qh"vjg"vtcpucevkqpu."uwtxgknngf"vjg" ukvg."cpf"vjg"vtcpucevkqpu"ygtg"tgeqtfgf"d{"cwfkq"cpf"xkfgq0""*See, e.g.. Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"38Î39." 44Î48."63."75Î770+""Uwdugswgpvn{."vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"vwtpgf"vjg"eqeckpg"qxgt"vq"rqnkeg" chvgt" tgegkxkpi" kv" htqo" Jqnnqoqpf0" " *See, e.g0." Fge0" 32." 4237" Vt0" 39Î3:." 48." 660+" " Jqnnqoqpf" uwiiguvu"vjcv"dgecwug"Ðvjgtg"ku"pq"fktgev"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp{"ucng"qh"pcteqvkeu"vq"vjg"EKÑ"jg"eqwnf"pqv" dg"hqwpf"iwknv{0""*GEH"Pq0"43."cv":0+""Hktuv."Jqnnqoqpf"ku"kpeqttgev."cu"vjgtg"ycu"fktgev"gxkfgpeg" qh"jko"gzejcpikpi"ÐW0U0"ewttgpe{"hqt"etcem"eqeckpg"ykvj"vjg"EKÑ"tgeqtfgf"d{"xkfgq"qh"vjg"hktuv" ftwi"ucng0""*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"63."750+6""Qxgtyjgnokpi"ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"cnuq"gzkuvgf"vjcv" Jqnnqoqpf" vykeg" uqnf" eqeckpg" vq" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpv." cpf" eqpvtct{" vq" JqnnqoqpfÓu" uwiiguvkqp."uwej"gxkfgpeg"cnuq"guvcdnkujgf"jku"iwknv0""Oqtgqxgt."JqnnqoqpfÓu"kpukuvgpeg"vjcv"vjg" kphqtocpv"jcf"vjg"ftwiu"dghqtgjcpf."cpf"kv"ycu"c"ÐugvwrÑ"*see e.g.,"GEH"Pq0"43."cv":+."cpf"vjg" rqnkeg"fkf"pqv"ugctej"vjg"kphqtocpv"ygnn"gpqwij."ku"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"cp{vjkpi"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0""Tcvjgt." vjg"tgeqtf"guvcdnkujgu"vjcv"vjg"rqnkeg"vjqtqwijn{"ugctejgf"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"cpf"jku"ect" rtkqt"vq"cpf"chvgt"jg"rwtejcugf"vjg"eqeckpg"htqo"Jqnnqoqpf0""*See, e.g.."Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"38."3:." 45Î48."64Î65."75Î78."86Î87.":8Î::0+""Vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"jgctf"vjg"eqpukuvgpv"vguvkoqp{"qh" vjg" rqnkeg" cpf" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpv." cpf" vjgp" jgctf" JqnnqoqpfÓu" ceeqwpv" qh" vjg" gxgpvu." cpf" hqwpf" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpvÓu" vguvkoqp{" etgfkdng." cpf" JqnnqoqpfÓu" vguvkoqp{" kpetgfkdng0"" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 6 "Jqnnqoqpf"cfokvvgf"fwtkpi"jku"vguvkoqp{"vjcv"vjg"xkfgq"ujqygf"jku"jcpf"ykvj"c"rncuvke"dciikg" kp"kv0""*Fge0"38."4237"Vt0":5Î:70+""" " " 9" Cnvjqwij"Jqnnqoqpf"ycpvu"vjku"Eqwtv"vq"fkuetgfkv"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"cu"ugnh/ ugtxkpi.7"vjku"Eqwtv"ku"dqwpf"d{"vjg"Ektewkv"EqwtvÓu"etgfkdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp"dgecwug"Jqnnqoqpf" jcu"pqv"rtgugpvgf"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"gxkfgpeg"vq"tgdwv"vjg"Ektewkv"EqwtvÓu"hkpfkpiu0""See Gray." 74;"H05f"cv"44:0" Cu"crvn{"uwooctk|gf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh"Xktikpkc."vjg"gxkfgpeg"rtgugpvgf"cv"vtkcn" ycu"uwhhkekgpv"hqt"cp{"tcvkqpcn"hcevhkpfgt"vq"eqpxkev"Jqnnqoqpf"qh"vyq"eqwpvu"qh"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh" eqeckpg."vjktf"qhhgpug0""Vjgtghqtg."wrqp"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"tgeqtf"kp"vjku"ecug."vjg"Eqwtv"eqpenwfgu"vjcv" vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh"XktikpkcÓu"fgekukqp"ycu"pqv"cp"wptgcuqpcdng"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"vjg"hcevu"kp" nkijv"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"rtgugpvgf"cv"vtkcn0""See 4:"W0U0E"¸"4476*f+0""Hqt"vjgug"tgcuqpu."Encko"Vyq" ncemu"ogtkv"cpf"yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF0" KX0" " LWT["VTKCN"TKIJV" Kp"Encko"Qpg."Jqnnqoqpf"ctiwgu"vjcv"jg"ycu"fgpkgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn08""Jqnnqoqpf" eqpvgpfu"vjcv"rtkqt"vq"vtkcn"jg"kpfkecvgf"vq"eqwpugn"vjcv"jg"ycpvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn."dwv"qp"vjg"fc{"qh"vtkcn." ujg"vqnf"Jqnnqoqpf"lwuv"vq"iq"cjgcf"ykvj"c"dgpej"vtkcn0""*GEH"Pq0"3."cv"370+""Jqnnqoqpf"eqpvgpfu" vjcv"eqwpugn"Ðfkf"pqv"hwnn{"gzrnckp"vq"jko"vjcv"jg"jcf"c"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"cpf"yjcv" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 7 " Fgvgevkxgu" gzrnckpgf" vjcv" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocpv" ycu" cttguvgf" rtkqt" vq" Octej" 8vj." cpf" jg" citggf"vq"cuukuv"rqnkeg"vq"ocmg"jku"ukvwcvkqp"dgvvgt0""*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"890+""Vjg"kphqtocpv"vguvkhkgf" vjcv"jg"ycu"c"eqpxkevgf"hgnqp."jcf"rgpfkpi"ftwi"ejctigu."cpf"ycu"jgnrkpi"rqnkeg"dgecwug"kv"ycu" Ðvjg"tkijv"vjkpi"vq"fq.Ñ"cpf"dgecwug"jg"ycu"jqrkpi"hqt"uqog"dgpghkv"qp"jku"ejctig."dwv"vjcv"jg"jcf" pqv"dggp"rtqokugf"cp{vjkpi"kp"gzejcpig"hqt"jku"eqqrgtcvkqp0""*Fge0"38."4237"Vt0"82Î83."850+""Jg" cnuq"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jg"jcf"dggp"c"ftwi"cffkev"hqt"vgp"{gctu0""*Fge0"38."4237"Vt0"890+""Vjwu."vjg"Ektewkv" Eqwtv"jgctf"vjku"vguvkoqp{"dwv"pgxgtvjgnguu"hqwpf"vjg"kphqtocpv"etgfkdng0" " 8 "Jqnnqoqpf"ctiwgu"vjku"encko"ku"dtqwijv"wpfgt"vjg"Hqwtvggpvj"Cogpfogpv="jqygxgt."vjku"ku"c" Ukzvj" Cogpfogpv" tkijv" crrnkecdng" vq" vjg" uvcvgu" vjtqwij" vjg" Hqwtvggpvj" Cogpfogpv0" " See" W0U0" Eqpuv0"cogpf0"XK0""*ÐKp"cnn"etkokpcn"rtqugewvkqpu."vjg"ceewugf"ujcnn"gplq{"vjg"tkijv"vq"c"urggf{"cpf" rwdnke" vtkcn." d{" cp" korctvkcn" lwt{" qh" vjg" Uvcvg" cpf" fkuvtkev" yjgtgkp" vjg" etkog" ujcnn" jcxg" dggp" eqookvvgf" 0"0"0"0Ñ+" " Oqtgqxgt." vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" jg" enckou" vjku" ku" c" xkqncvkqp" qh" vjg" Xktikpkc" Eqpuvkvwvkqp."uwej"c"encko"ku"pqv"eqipk|cdng"kp"hgfgtcn"jcdgcu0""Lewis v. Jeffers."6;9"W0U0"986."9:2" *3;;2+"*gzrnckpkpi"vjcv"Ðhgfgtcn"jcdgcu"eqtrwu"tgnkgh"fqgu"pqv"nkg"hqt"gttqtu"qh"uvcvg"ncyÑ+0" " " " :" yckxkpi"vjcv"tkijv"cevwcnn{"ogcpv0Ñ""*Id."cv"380+""Vjwu."jg"ctiwgu"vjcv"Ðjg"fkf"pqv"yckxg"jku"tkijv"vq" c"lwt{"vtkcn"cpf"jg"fguktgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn"cv"cnn"vkoguÑ"cpf"Ðkh"]jg_"kpcfxgtvgpvn{"yckxgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c" lwt{"vtkcn."kv"ycu"pqv"mpqykpin{"cpf"kpvgnnkigpvn{"yckxgf0Ñ""*Id."cv"390+" " Vjg"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh"Xktikpkc"tgxkgygf"vjku"encko"cpf"hqwpf"kv"ncemkpi"kp"ogtkv0""Vjg" Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"qh"Xktikpkc"gzrnckpgf"cu"hqnnqyu<" " Crrgnncpv"pgzv"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"gttgf"kp"fgp{kpi"jku"oqvkqp"hqt"c" okuvtkcn"cpf"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev"Ðqp"vjg"dcuku"qh"]jku_"fguktg"vq"ykvjftcy" jku"yckxgt"qh"jku"lwt{"vtkcn"tkijvu0Ñ" " Qp" Fgegodgt" 32." 4237." crrgnncpv" rngf" pqv" iwknv{" vq" vjg" vyq" ejctigu" qh" fkuvtkdwvkqp" qh" eqeckpg0" " Vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv" gpicigf" kp" c" eqnnqsw{" ykvj" crrgnncpv" tgictfkpi"jku"rngc0""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"cnuq"jcf"vjg"hqnnqykpi"fkuewuukqp"ykvj"crrgnncpv" cdqwv"jku"yckxgt"qh"c"lwt{"vtkcn<" VJG"EQWTV<""Ctg"{qw"tgcf{"hqt"vtkcn"vqfc{A""Ctg"{qw"tgcf{"vq"iq" cjgcf"ykvj"vtkcn"vqfc{A" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu0" VJG"EQWTV<""Fq"{qw"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"{qw"ctg"dgkpi"vtkgf"d{"vjg" Eqwtv."vjcv"{qw"yqwnf"jcxg"jcf"c"tkijv"vq"dg"vtkgf"d{"c"lwt{."dwv"{qw" jcxg"ikxgp"wr"vjcv"tkijv"cpf"cum"vq"dg"vtkgf"d{"vjg"lwfig."yjkej"ku" {qwtu"vtwn{A" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""K"vjqwijv"vjcv"K"yqwnf"dg"vtkgf"d{"c"lwt{0" VJG"EQWTV<""[qw"vjqwijv"{qw"yqwnf"dg"vtkgf"d{"c"lwt{A" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."ukt0" VJG"EQWTV<""Fkf"{qw"fkuewuu"vtkcn"d{"lwt{"ykvj"{qwt"eqwpugnA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."yg"fkf0" VJG"EQWTV<""YgÓtg"jgtg"vqfc{"ykvjqwv"c"lwt{0""Ku"vjcv"c"uwtrtkug" vq"{qwA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."kv"ku0" VJG"EQWTV<""Ou0"JcfggfA" OU0"JCFGGF<""Kh"K"oc{"jcxg"c"oqogpv"vq"eqphgt"ykvj"o{"enkgpv0" VJG"EQWTV<""Uwtg0" " Chvgt"fkuewuukpi"vjg"ocvvgt"ykvj"jku"eqwpugn."crrgnncpv"vqnf"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv" vjcv"jg"ycu"tgcf{"vq"rtqeggf"ykvjqwv"c"lwt{0""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"cumgf"crrgnncpv<""Ð[qw" wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"{qw"jcxg"c"tkijv"vq"]c"lwt{"vtkcn_."dwv"pqy"{qwÓtg"yckxkpi"vjcv"tkijv" cpf"rtqeggfkpiAÑ""Crrgnncpv"tgurqpfgf"chhktocvkxgn{0" " Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"hqwpf"vjcv"crrgnncpv"ocfg"jku"rngcu"mpqykpin{."kpvgnnkigpvn{." cpf"xqnwpvctkn{0""Vjg"dgpej"vtkcn"eqoogpegf."dwv"fkf"pqv"hkpkuj."qp"Fgegodgt"32." 42370""Vjg"ocvvgt"ycu"eqpvkpwgf"vq"Fgegodgt"38."42370""Crrgnncpv"hkngf"c"oqvkqp" hqt" okuvtkcn" cpf" ctiwgf" vjcv" jg" fkf" pqv" yckxg" jku" tkijv" vq" c" vtkcn" d{" lwt{0" " Qp" Fgegodgt"38."4237."vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fgpkgf"crrgnncpvÓu"oqvkqp"hqt"okuvtkcn"cpf"uvcvgf" vjcv"kv"Ðyqwnf"ceegrv"vjg"oqvkqp"oqtg"cu"c"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"c"yckxgt"qh"vjg"lwt{" vtkcn"cu"qrrqugf"vq"c"okuvtkcn0Ñ""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"jgnf"vjcv"crrgnncpvÓu"yckxgt"qh"c"lwt{" vtkcn"Ðycu"ocfg"mpqykpin{"cpf"kpvgnnkigpvn{Ñ"cpf"Ðchvgt"hwnn"cfxkeg"qh"eqwpugn0Ñ" " " ;" Chvgt" vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv" hqwpf" crrgnncpv" iwknv{" qh" vjg" qhhgpugu." dwv" dghqtg" ugpvgpekpi."crrgnncpv"hkngf"c"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev0""Cickp."jg"ctiwgf"vjcv" jg"fkf"pqv"yckxg"jku"tkijv"vq"c"vtkcn"d{"lwt{0""Cv"vjg"dgikppkpi"qh"vjg"ugpvgpekpi" jgctkpi."vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"jgctf"gxkfgpeg"cpf"ctiwogpv"tgictfkpi"crrgnncpvÓu"oqvkqp0"" Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fgpkgf"vjg"oqvkqp0""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"uvcvgf<" Vjg"Eqwtv"nqqmgf"dcem"cv"vjg"eqnnqsw{"vjcv"gpuwgf"dgvyggp"{qwtu" vtwn{"cpf"]crrgnncpv_"ykvj"tgictf"vq"vjg"kuuwg"qh"vjg"lwt{"vtkcn."cpf"vjg" Eqwtv"vq"ygpv"vq"uqog"ngpivj"vq"ocmg"uwtg."cu"K"vjkpm"vjg"vtcpuetkrv" tghngevu."vq"ocmg"uwtg"vjcv"]crrgnncpv_"wpfgtuvqqf"yjcv"ycu"iqkpi"qp" cpf"yjcv"jku"tkijvu"ygtg0" Crrgnncpv" ctiwgu" vjcv" vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv" gttgf" d{" fgp{kpi" jku" oqvkqpu" hqt" okuvtkcn"cpf"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev"dgecwug"jg"ycpvgf"c"vtkcn"d{"lwt{0""Jg"eqpvgpfu" jg"ujqwnf"jcxg"dggp"cnnqygf"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"qh"c"lwt{"vtkcn0" ÐVjg" tkijv" qh" c" fghgpfcpv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn" kp" c" etkokpcn" ecug" ku" ugewtgf" d{" Ctvkeng"3."¸":"qh"vjg"Eqpuvkvwvkqp"qh"Xktikpkc0Ñ""Commonwealth v. Williams."484"Xc0" 883."893."775"U0G04f"982."986"*4223+0""Ð]Q_peg"c"fghgpfcpv"ocmgu"c"xqnwpvct{"cpf" kpvgnnkigpv"yckxgt"qh"vjku"tkijv."jku"tgswguv"vq"ykvjftcy"vjcv"yckxgt"cpf"dg"vtkgf"d{" c"lwt{"ku"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"ektewkv"eqwtvÓu"fkuetgvkqp0Ñ""Id. Ð]C_"oqvkqp"hqt"ykvjftcycn"qh"yckxgt"ocfg"chvgt"vjg"eqoogpegogpv"qh"vjg" vtkcn" ku" pqv" vkogn{" cpf" ujqwnf" pqv" dg" cnnqygf0Ñ" " Id." " *swqvkpi" Thomas v. Commonwealth."43:"Xc0"775."777."45:"U0G04f":56.":57"*3;99++0" Kp" vjku" ecug." crrgnncpv" mpqykpin{" yckxgf" jku" tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn" cv" vjg" dgikppkpi"qh"vjg"vtkcn0""Jg"fkuewuugf"vjg"ocvvgt"ykvj"jku"eqwpugn"cpf"kphqtogf"vjg" eqwtv"vjcv"jg"ycu"tgcf{"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"c"dgpej"vtkcn0""Vjgp."chvgt"vjg"vtkcn"jcf"dgiwp" cpf"jcf"vq"dg"eqpvkpwgf"vq"c"fkhhgtgpv"fcvg"fwg"vq"vjg"ncvg"jqwt."crrgnncpv"hkngf"c" oqvkqp"hqt"c"okuvtkcn."yjkej"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"eqpukfgtgf"c"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"lwt{" yckxgt0""Vjg"Eqooqpygcnvj"cntgcf{"jcf"rtgugpvgf"hqwt"ykvpguugu"cpf"kpvtqfwegf" ugxgtcn" gzjkdkvu." kpenwfkpi" vjg" cwfkq" cpf" xkfgq" tgeqtfkpiu0" " Kp" tgurqpug" vq" crrgnncpvÓu" oqvkqp" qp" vjg" ugeqpf" fc{" qh" vjg" vtkcn." vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv" pqvgf." Ð]l_wuv" dgecwug"vjgtgÓu"c"ncrug"qh"vkog"dgvyggp"vjg"32vj"cpf"vqfc{"kp"tguwokpi"vjg"vtkcn" fqgupÓv"ejcpig"vjcv"curgev"qh"kv0Ñ""Vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"hqwpf"vjcv"crrgnncpvÓu"oqvkqp"jcf" Ðgxgt{"kpfkekc"qh"qduvtwevkqp"cpf"uggmkpi"vq"ickp"c"dgpghkv"ukorn{"dgecwug"yg"jcf" vq"eqpvkpwg"vjg"vtkcn"htqo"qpg"fc{"vq"vjg"pgzv.Ñ"uq"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fgpkgf"vjg"oqvkqp0" Chvgt"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"jgctf"cnn"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"cpf"hqwpf"crrgnncpv"iwknv{." crrgnncpv"hkngf"c"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev"cpf"tgswguvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""Cv"vjcv" rqkpv"qh"vjg"rtqeggfkpi."jku"oqvkqp"ycu"pqv"vkogn{0""Id."" Vjgtghqtg."vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fkf"pqv"gtt"kp"fgp{kpi"crrgnncpvÓu"oqvkqpu0""Vjg" vtkcn" eqwtv" hqwpf" crrgnncpvÓu" yckxgt" vq" dg" mpqykpin{" cpf" xqnwpvctkn{" ocfg0"" CrrgnncpvÓu"oqvkqpu"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"ygtg"pqv"vkogn{."cpf"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"fkf" pqv" cdwug" kvu" fkuetgvkqp" d{" fgp{kpi" crrgnncpvÓu" oqvkqpu" hqt" c" okuvtkcn" cpf" vq" ugv" cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev0" " *GEH"Pq0"38Î4."cv"6Î9"*cnvgtcvkqpu"kp"qtkikpcn+0+""" Vjg"Ukzvj"Cogpfogpv"rtqxkfgu."vjcv"Ðvjg"ceewugf"ujcnn"gplq{"c"tkijv"vq"c"0"0"0"vtkcn."d{"cp" korctvkcn"lwt{"0"0"0"0Ñ""W0U0"Eqpuv0"cogpf0"XK0""Jqygxgt."c"fghgpfcpv"oc{"yckxg"jku"qt"jgt"tkijv"vq" " " 32" c"lwt{"vtkcn0""Rwtuwcpv"vq"ugevkqp"3;04Î479"qh"vjg"Xktikpkc"Eqfg."Ðkh"vjg"ceewugf"rngcf"pqv"iwknv{." ykvj" jku" eqpugpv" chvgt" dgkpi" cfxkugf" d{" eqwpugn" cpf" vjg" eqpewttgpeg" qh" vjg" cvvqtpg{" hqt" vjg" Eqooqpygcnvj."cpf"qh"vjg"eqwtv"gpvgtgf"qh"tgeqtf."vjg"eqwtv"ujcnn"jgct"cpf"fgvgtokpg"vjg"ecug" ykvjqwv" vjg" kpvgtxgpvkqp" qh" c" lwt{0Ñ" " Xc0" Eqfg" Cpp0" ¸" 3;04Î479" *Yguv" 4242+09" " Cu" vjg" tgeqtf" guvcdnkujgu." Jqnnqoqpf" mpqykpin{"cpf"xqnwpvctkn{"yckxgf"jku"tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn0" "Jqnnqoqpf" eqpvgpfu"vjcv"eqwpugn"Ðfkf"pqv"hwnn{"gzrnckp"vq"jko"vjcv"jg"jcf"c"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn" cpf"yjcv"yckxkpi"vjcv"tkijv"cevwcnn{"ogcpv0Ñ""*GEH"Pq0"3."cv"380+""Cu"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"cpf"vjg" Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"fgvgtokpgf."vjku"uvcvgogpv"fghkgu"dgnkgh0" Oqtgqxgt."pq"ocvvgt"yjcv"eqwpugn"gzrnckpgf"vq"Jqnnqoqpf."vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"urgekhkecnn{" gzrnckpgf"vq"Jqnnqoqpf"vjcv"jg"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"cpf"Jqnnqoqpf"citggf"ugxgtcn"vkogu"vjcv"jg" wpfgtuvqqf"vjcv"tkijv"dwv"ycu"ejqqukpi"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"c"vtkcn"d{"lwfig0""Vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"hktuv" cumgf"Jqnnqoqpf<""ÐFq"{qw"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"{qw"ctg"dgkpi"vtkgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv."vjcv"{qw"yqwnf"jcxg" jcf"c"tkijv"vq"dg"vtkgf"d{"c"lwt{."dwv"{qw"jcxg"ikxgp"wr"vjcv"tkijv"cpf"cumgf"vq"dg"vtkgf"d{"vjg"lwfig." yjkej"ku"{qwtu"vtwn{AÑ""*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0":0+""Jqnnqoqpf"gzrtguugf"eqphwukqp"cpf"ycu"cnnqygf" vq"eqphgt"ykvj"eqwpugn0""*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0":0+""Chvgt"Jqnnqoqpf"eqphgttgf"ykvj"eqwpugn."vjg"Ektewkv" Eqwtv"swguvkqpgf"Jqnnqoqpf"cu"hqnnqyu<""" VJG" EQWTV<" " O{" swguvkqp" hqt" {qw." Ot0" Jqnnqoqpf." ku<" " Fq" {qw" wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"ygÓtg"jgtg"vqfc{"hqt"c"vtkcn"ykvj"vjg"lwfig."pqv"c"lwt{A" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."K"fq0" VJG"EQWTV<""[qwÓtg"rtgrctgf"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"vtkcn"d{"lwfig"cpf"pqv"c" lwt{A" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."ukt0" VJG"EQWTV<""[qw"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"{qw"jcxg"c"tkijv"vq"vjcv."dwv"pqy"{qwÓtg" yckxkpi"vjcv"tkijv"cpf"rtqeggfkpiA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."ukt0" VJG"EQWTV<""Cpf"vjg"Eqooqpygcnvj"eqpewtu"kp"vjcvA" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 9 "Jqnnqoqpf"ekvgu"Hgfgtcn"Twng"qh"Etkokpcn"Rtqegfwtg"Twng"45*c+"yjkej"tgswktgu"c"yckxgt"qh"vjg" tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"kp"ytkvkpi0"*GEH"Pq0"4."cv"49Î4;0+""Jqnnqoqpf"ycu"vtkgf"kp"uvcvg"eqwtv."pqv" hgfgtcn" eqwtv." vjwu." Twng" 45*c+" fqgu" pqv" crrn{" vq" jku" etkokpcn" rtqeggfkpiu0" " Xktikpkc" jcu" pq" tgswktgogpv"vjcv"c"ytkvvgp"yckxgt"owuv"dg"gzgewvgf0" " " 33" OU0"CDDG[<""[gu."{qwt"Jqpqt0" VJG"EQWTV<""Vjg"Eqwtv"eqpewtu"kp"vjcv0""Fkf"{qw"wpfgtuvcpf"cnn"qh"vjg" swguvkqpu"vjcv"KÓxg"cumgf"qh"{qw."uktA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu."K"fq."ukt0" VJG"EQWTV<""Cpf"fq"{qw"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"kh"vjg"Eqwtv"vtkgu"{qw"vjcv"vjku" Eqwtv"yqwnf"cnuq"ugpvgpeg"{qw"kh"{qwÓtg"eqpxkevgfA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""[gu0" VJG"EQWTV<""Cp{"swguvkqp"{qw"ycpv"vq"cum"og"cdqwv"yjcv"K"lwuv"ygpv" vjtqwijA" VJG"FGHGPFCPV<""Pq."K"fq"pqv0" VJG"EQWTV<""Vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"{qwt"pqv"iwknv{"rngcu"jcxg"dggp"ocfg"htggn{" cpf"xqnwpvctkn{0""Vjg"Eqwtv"ceegrvu"vjqug"rngcu"qh"pqv"iwknv{0" " "*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0";Î320+""JqnnqoqpfÓu"eqpvgpvkqp"vjcv"eqwpugn"vqnf"jko"lwuv"vq"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj" vjg"dgpej"vtkcn."cpf"uq"jg"fkf."dwv"ykvjqwv"wpfgtuvcpfkpi"vjcv"jg"ycu"yckxkpi"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{" vtkcn."ku"eqpvtct{"vq"jku"urgekhke."uyqtp"uvcvgogpvu"vq"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv0""Jqnnqoqpf."kp"guugpeg." pqy"uwiiguvu"vjcv"jku"cpuygtu"vq"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"ygtg"pqv"vtwg0""Jqygxgt."Jqnnqoqpf"ku"dqwpf" d{"vjg"uvcvgogpvu"jg"ocfg"wpfgt"qcvj"vjcv"jg"ycu"mpqykpin{"yckxkpi"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""Cf. Escamilla v. Jungwirth."648"H05f":8:.":92"*9vj"Ekt0"4227+."abrogated by"McQuiggin v. Perkins." 78;"W0U0"5:5"*4235+="Fields v. Att’y Gen. of Md..";78"H04f"34;2."34;;"*6vj"Ekt0"3;;4+"*ekvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+"*gzrnckpkpi"vjcv"Ð]c_dugpv"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"gxkfgpeg"vq"vjg"eqpvtct{."c"fghgpfcpv"ku" dqwpf" d{" vjg" tgrtgugpvcvkqpu" jg" ocmgu" wpfgt" qcvj" fwtkpi" c" rngc" eqnnqsw{0Ñ+" " Cffkvkqpcnn{." vjg" Ektewkv"Eqwtv"qdugtxgf"JqnnqoqpfÓu"fgogcpqt"fwtkpi"kvu"swguvkqpkpi"qh"Jqnnqoqpf"dqvj"rtkqt"vq" jku"vtkcn"cpf"fwtkpi"vjg"rquv/vtkcn"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev."cpf"hqwpf"vjcv"JqnnqoqpfÓu"yckxgt" qh"jku"lwt{"vtkcn"tkijv"ycu"mpqykpi"cpf"xqnwpvct{0:""" Hkpcnn{."JqnnqoqpfÓu"cnngicvkqpu"ctg"cnuq"kpvgtpcnn{"kpeqpukuvgpv"cpf"tghngev"JqnnqoqpfÓu" vgpfgpe{"vq"dgpf"vjg"vtwvj0""Kp"jku"Ogoqtcpfwo"kp"Uwrrqtv."Jqnnqoqpf"Ðeqpvgpfu"vjcv"jg"citggf" vq"vjg"lwfig"rtgukfkpi"qxgt"vjg"rtqeggfkpi"qp"Fgegodgt"32."4237"dgecwug"Jcfggf"cfxkugf"jko" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" : " Vjg" Ektewkv" Eqwtv" cnuq" hqwpf" JqnnqoqpfÓu" ncvg" cvvgorvu" vq" fgocpf" c" lwt{" vtkcn" ygtg" ogtgn{" fkncvqt{"kp"pcvwtg0""Vjku"eqpenwukqp"ku"gokpgpvn{"tgcuqpcdng"ikxgp"vjg"tgeqtf0" " " " 34" lwuv"vq"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj"vjg"lwfig."yjkej"jg"vqqm"vq"ogcp"vjcv"vjg"lwfig"yqwnf"qpn{"dg"rtgukfkpi" hqt"vjcv"fc{"cpf"uqogvkog"ncvgt"jg"yqwnf"dg"vtkgf"d{"lwt{0Ñ""*GEH"Pq0"4."cv"60+""Cu"c"rtgnkokpct{" ocvvgt."kp"vjku"uvcvgogpv."Jqnnqoqpf"guugpvkcnn{"chhktou"vjcv"jg"mpqykpin{"citggf"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj" c"lwfig."pqv"c"lwt{."fgurkvg"jku"rwtrqtvgf"wpyckxgtkpi"fguktg"hqt"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""Vjg"tgockpfgt"qh" JqnnqoqpfÓu"eqpvgpvkqp"yjqnn{"fghkgu"dgnkgh"cpf"ku"kpetgfkdng0""Jqnnqoqpf"dcukecnn{"uwiiguvu"vjcv" jg"vjqwijv"jg"yqwnf"jcxg"vyq"vtkcnu."qpg"ykvj"c"lwfig"vjcv"fc{."cpf"c"ncvgt"vtkcn"d{"c"lwt{0;""Cv"vjg" vkog"Jqnnqoqpf"citggf"vq"yckxg"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"cpf"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"c"vtkcn"d{"lwfig."pq"qpg." kpenwfkpi" Jqnnqoqpf." mpgy" vjcv" vjg" vtkcn" yqwnf" pqv" eqpenwfg" vjcv" fc{" cpf" yqwnf" pggf" vq" dg" eqpvkpwgf0""*See"Fge0"32."4237"Vt0"92Î93.":60+32""Vjg"Eqwtv"pggf"pqv"hwtvjgt"cfftguu"vjku"gpvktgn{" htkxqnqwu"ctiwogpv"vjcv"ku"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"vjg"tgeqtf0""Kp"uwo."Jqnnqoqpf"hcknu"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg" vjcv"vjg"uvcvg"eqwtvÓu"fgvgtokpcvkqp"vjcv"jg"mpqykpin{"yckxgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"ycu"kpeqttgev." owej"nguu"wptgcuqpcdng0""See"4:"W0U0E0"¸"4476*f+*3+Î*4+033"" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ; "Cu"Tgurqpfgpv"rqkpvu"qwv."vjku"ycu"pqv"JqnnqoqpfÓu"hktuv"gzrgtkgpeg"ykvj"vjg"Xktikpkc"etkokpcn" lwuvkeg"u{uvgo0""Kp"hcev."Jqnnqoqpf"ycu"ejctigf"ykvj"vyq"eqwpvu"qh"ftwi"fkuvtkdwvkqp."third offense." cpf" jg" jcf" rtgxkqwun{" dggp" eqpxkevgf" qh" ukz" hgnqpkgu" cpf" Ðpwogtqwu" okufgogcpqtu0Ñ" " *GEH" Pq0"38."cv"39"*ekvkpi"Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"45Î46++0""Vjwu."JqnnqoqpfÓu"uwiiguvkqp"vjcv"jg"vjqwijv"c" lwfig"yqwnf"rtgukfg"qxgt"vjg"vtkcn"vjcv"fc{."cpf"vjgp"cv"c"ncvgt"vkog"jg"yqwnf"cnuq"jcxg"c"lwt{"vtkcn." ku"ukorn{"kpetgfkdng0" " 32 "Pqvcdn{."vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocpv"fkf"pqv"vguvkh{"qp"vjg"Fgegodgt"32."4237"vtkcn"fcvg"dwv"ycu" tguejgfwngf"vq"vguvkh{"qp"vjg"Fgegodgt"38."4237"eqpvkpwgf"fcvg0""*Fge0"32."4237"Vt0":6Î:70+""" " 33 "Tgurqpfgpv"hcktn{"eqpuvtwgu"Jqnnqoqpf"cnuq"vq"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"gttgf"kp"fgp{kpi"jku" oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"qt"itcpv"c"okuvtkcn0"*See"GEH"Pq0"38."cv"9Î:="GEH"Pq0"3."cv"380+"" Vjg" Eqwtv" qh" Crrgcnu" qh" Xktikpkc" cnuq" cfftguugf" vjku" encko" kp" vjg" cdqxg/swqvgf" rqtvkqp" qh" kvu" qrkpkqp"fgp{kpi"vjg"rgvkvkqp"hqt"crrgcn"cpf"hqwpf"uwej"c"encko"wpvkogn{"ocfg0""*GEH"Pq0"38Î4." cv"8Î90+""Tgurqpfgpv"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjku"encko"ku"fghcwnvgf"dgecwug"Jqnnqoqpf"hckngf"vq"tckug"vjku" encko"cv"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"vkog0""*See"GEH"Pq0"38."cv":0+""Kp"jku"Tgurqpug"*GEH"Pq0"43+."Jqnnqoqpf" urgekhkecnn{"uvcvgu<""" Kv"crrgctu"vjcv"vjg"Tgurqpfgpv"jcu"okueqpuvtwgf"RgvkvkqpgtÓu"encko0""Kv"crrgctu"vjcv" TgurqpfgpvÓu" dgnkgh" ku" vjcv" Rgvkvkqpgt" ku" ejcnngpikpi" vjg" uvcvg" eqwtvÓu" fgekukqp" fgp{kpi"RgvkvkqpgtÓu"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"qtcn"yckxgt."cpf"c"oqvkqp"hqt"c"okuvtkcn." yjkej" ku" kpeqttgev0" " Rgvkvkqpgt" ku" ukorn{" enckokpi" vjcv" vjg" uvcvg" fgpkgf" jku" eqpuvkvwvkqpcn" tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn0" " Cp{" tghgtgpegu" vq" vjg" uvcvg" eqwtvÓu" fgekukqp" " " 35" Ceeqtfkpin{."Encko"Qpg"ncemu"ogtkv"cpf"yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF0" X0" KPGHHGEVKXG"CUUKUVCPEG"QH"EQWPUGN" Vq"fgoqpuvtcvg"kpghhgevkxg"cuukuvcpeg"qh"eqwpugn."c"eqpxkevgf"fghgpfcpv"owuv"ujqy."hktuv." vjcv"eqwpugnÓu"tgrtgugpvcvkqp"ycu"fghkekgpv"cpf."ugeqpf."vjcv"vjg"fghkekgpv"rgthqtocpeg"rtglwfkegf" vjg" fghgpug0" " Strickland v. Washington." 688" W0U0" 88:." 8:9" *3;:6+0" " Vq" ucvkuh{" vjg" fghkekgpv" rgthqtocpeg" rtqpi" qh" Strickland." vjg" eqpxkevgf" fghgpfcpv" owuv" qxgteqog" vjg" ÐÒuvtqpi" rtguworvkqpÓ" vjcv" eqwpugnÓu" uvtcvgi{" cpf" vcevkeu" hcnn" Òykvjkp" vjg" ykfg" tcpig" qh" tgcuqpcdng" rtqhguukqpcn" cuukuvcpeg0ÓÑ" " Burch v. Corcoran." 495" H05f" 799." 7::" *6vj" Ekt0" 4223+" *swqvkpi Strickland."688"W0U0"cv"8:;+0""Vjg"rtglwfkeg"eqorqpgpv"tgswktgu"c"eqpxkevgf"fghgpfcpv"vq"Ðujqy" vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"tgcuqpcdng"rtqdcdknkv{"vjcv."dwv"hqt"eqwpugnÓu"wprtqhguukqpcn"gttqtu."vjg"tguwnv"qh"vjg" rtqeggfkpi" yqwnf" jcxg" dggp" fkhhgtgpv0" " C" tgcuqpcdng" rtqdcdknkv{" ku" c" rtqdcdknkv{" uwhhkekgpv" vq" wpfgtokpg" eqphkfgpeg" kp" vjg" qwveqog0Ñ" " Strickland." 688" W0U0" cv" 8;60" " Kp" cpcn{|kpi" kpghhgevkxg" cuukuvcpeg" qh" eqwpugn" enckou." kv" ku" pqv" pgeguuct{" vq" fgvgtokpg" yjgvjgt" eqwpugn" rgthqtogf" fghkekgpvn{"kh"vjg"encko"ku"tgcfkn{"fkuokuugf"hqt"ncem"qh"rtglwfkeg0" Id."cv"8;90""" " Kp"Encko"Vjtgg."Jqnnqoqpf"hcwnvu"eqwpugn"hqt"hcknkpi"vq"gpuwtg"vjcv"jku"Ðtkijvu"vq"c"lwt{" vtkcn"ygtg"rtgugtxgf0Ñ""*GEH"Pq0"3."cv"3;0+""Jqnnqoqpf"tckugf"vjku"encko"kp"jku"jcdgcu"rgvkvkqp" dghqtg" vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" qh" Xktikpkc0" " Kp" tglgevkpi" vjku" encko." vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" qh" Xktikpkc" gzrnckpgf"cu"hqnnqyu<" Kp"cp"wppwodgtgf"encko."rgvkvkqpgt"eqpvgpfu"jg"ycu"fgpkgf"vjg"ghhgevkxg" cuukuvcpeg" qh" eqwpugn" dgecwug" eqwpugn." Ujcppqp" Jcfggf" *ÐJcfggfÑ+." hckngf" vq" rtqvgev" rgvkvkqpgtÓu" tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn" cpf" eqgtegf" jko" kpvq" rtqeggfkpi" ykvj" c" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" fgp{kpi"RgvkvkqpgtÓu"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"qtcn"yckxgt"qt"oqvkqp"hqt"okuvtkcn"ctg" qpn{"vq"uwduvcpvkcvg"jku"encko"vjcv"jg"ycu"fgpkgf"jku"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{" vtkcn."yjkej"vjg"uvcvg"eqpegfgf"vq"dg"gzjcwuvgf0" *GEH"Pq0"43."cv"7Î80+""Vjwu."Rgvkvkqpgt"jcu"kpfkecvgf"urgekhkecnn{"vjcv"jg"ku"not"tckukpi"c"encko" ejcnngpikpi"vjg"Ektewkv"EqwtvÓu"fgpkcn"qh"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"qt"itcpv"c"okuvtkcn."cpf" vjg"Eqwtv"pggf"pqv"cfftguu"cp{"rtqegfwtcn"fghcwnv"dctu0" " " " 36" dgpej"vtkcn0""Cnvjqwij"jg"cempqyngfigu"yckxkpi"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn."rgvkvkqpgt" ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"yckxgt"ycu"pqv"mpqykpi"cpf"kpvgnnkigpv"fwg"vq"JcfggfÓu"fghkekgpv" rgthqtocpeg0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"jqnfu"vjku"0"0"0"encko"hcknu"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"ÐrtglwfkegÑ"rtqpi"qh"vjg" vyq/rctv"vguv"gpwpekcvgf"kp"Strickland v. Washington."688"W0U0"88:."8:9"*3;:6+0"" Vjg" tgeqtf." kpenwfkpi" vjg" vtkcn" cpf" ugpvgpekpi" vtcpuetkrvu" cpf" vjg" oqvkqpu" hqt" okuvtkcn"cpf"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev."fgoqpuvtcvgu"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"cumgf"rgvkvkqpgt"cv" vjg"qwvugv"qh"vtkcn"kh"rgvkvkqpgt"uqwijv"vq"yckxg"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"cpf"rtqeggf"ykvj" c"dgpej"vtkcn0""Rgvkvkqpgt"tgrnkgf"jg"vjqwijv"jg"yqwnf"dg"vtkgf"d{"c"lwt{"cpf"ycu" uwtrtkugf" d{" kvu" cdugpeg0" " Chvgt" dgkpi" itcpvgf" c" tgeguu" vq" eqphgt" ykvj" Jcfggf." rgvkvkqpgt"vqnf"vjg"eqwtv"jg"wpfgtuvqqf"jg"crrgctgf"kp"eqwtv"hqt"c"dgpej"vtkcn."ycu" yknnkpi"vq"yckxg"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn."cpf"ycu"rtgrctgf"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"vjg"dgpej" vtkcn0""Vjg"Eqooqpygcnvj"cpf"vjg"eqwtv"eqpewttgf"kp"vjg"yckxgt"qh"c"lwt{"vtkcn."cpf" vjg"Eqooqpygcnvj"rtgugpvgf"c"rqtvkqp"qh"kvu"gxkfgpeg"dghqtg"vjg"hktuv"fc{"qh"vtkcn" eqpenwfgf0" " Ukz"fc{u"ncvgt."yjgp"vjg"dgpej"vtkcn"tguwogf."Jcfggf"hkngf"c"oqvkqp"hqt"c" okuvtkcn"eqpvgpfkpi"rgvkvkqpgt"jcf"dggp"fgpkgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""See Cokes v. Commonwealth." 4:2" Xc0" ;4." ;9" *4232+" *fkuewuukpi" fghgpfcpvÓu" eqpuvkvwvkqpcn" cpf" uvcvwvqt{" tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn+0" " Vjg" oqvkqp" cuugtvgf" rgvkvkqpgt" Ðcv" cnn" vkogu" fguktgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn.Ñ"fkf"pqv"Ðwpfgtuvcpf"vjg"rwtrqugÑ"qh"vjg"eqnnqsw{"qp"vjg"hktuv" fc{"qh"vtkcn."cpf"vjqwijv"jg"Ðyqwnf"uvknn"jcxg"vtkcn"d{"lwt{."dwv"qp"c"fkhhgtgpv"fcvg0Ñ"" Vjg"eqwtv"jgnf"rgvkvkqpgt"mpqykpin{"cpf"kpvgnnkigpvn{"yckxgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn."fgenkpgf" vq"gpvgt"c"okuvtkcn."cpf"hqwpf"rgvkvkqpgt"iwknv{"cu"ejctigf"cv"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"vtkcn0"" Jcfggf"oqxgf"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev"qp"vjg"ucog"itqwpfu"cpf"qdvckpgf"ngcxg"vq" ykvjftcy0" " C" fkhhgtgpv" eqwtv/crrqkpvgf" cvvqtpg{" tgrtgugpvgf" rgvkvkqpgt" cv" ugpvgpekpi." yjgp" vjg" eqwtv" eqpukfgtgf" vjg" oqvkqp" vq" ugv" cukfg" vjg" xgtfkev0" " Chvgt" rgvkvkqpgt" yckxgf" cvvqtpg{/enkgpv" rtkxkngig." Jcfggf" vguvkhkgf" ujg" eqpfwevgf" rtg/vtkcn" fkuewuukqpu"ykvj" rgvkvkqpgt" eqpegtpkpi" yjgvjgt"vq" tgswguv" c" lwt{"vtkcn"qt"c"dgpej" vtkcn0""Rgvkvkqpgt"uckf"jg"ycpvgf"c"dgpej"vtkcn"cpf"tgchhktogf"vjku"rtghgtgpeg"fwtkpi" eqpxgtucvkqpu"qp"vjg"oqtpkpi"qh"vjg"hktuv"fc{"qh"vtkcn0""Jcfggf"pgxgt"jgctf"rgvkvkqpgt" uc{"jg"ycpvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn"wpvkn"vjg"eqnnqsw{"ykvj"vjg"eqwtv"qeewttgf0""Vjgtgchvgt." fwtkpi"vjg"tgeguu."Jcfggf"cumgf"rgvkvkqpgt"kh"jg"jcf"ejcpigf"jku"okpf"cpf"yjgvjgt" jg"ycpvgf"vq"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj"vjg"lwfig"qt"c"lwt{0""Rgvkvkqpgt"cpuygtgf."ÐVjg"Lwfig0Ñ"" Jcfggf"tgrnkgf."ÐVjku"ku"vjg"lwfig0""Vjg"vtkcn"yknn"dg"kp"htqpv"qh"vjku"lwfig"pqy0Ñ"" Dghqtg"vjg"ugeqpf"fc{"qh"vtkcn"dgicp."rgvkvkqpgt"cumgf"yjgp"vjg"lwt{"ycu"iqkpi"vq" Ðujqy"wr0Ñ""Jcfggf"tgurqpfgf"c"lwt{"yqwnf"pqv"dg"rtgugpv"dgecwug"rgvkvkqpgt"jcf" eqpugpvgf"vq"c"dgpej"vtkcn0" " Rgvkvkqpgt"vguvkhkgf"jg"vqnf"Jcfggf"jg"ycpvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn"cpf"dgnkgxgf"jg" crrgctgf"kp"eqwtv"hqt"qpg0""Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"rgvkvkqpgtÓu"eqphwukqp"vjcv"c"lwt{"ycu" pqv"rtgugpv."Jcfggf"kpuvtwevgf"jko"fwtkpi"vjg"tgeguu"vq"Ð]l_wuv"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj"kv0Ñ"" Gxgp"vjqwij"vjg"vtkcn"dgicp"dghqtg"vjg"lwfig."rgvkvkqpgt"vtwuvgf"Jcfggf"cpf"vjqwijv" ujg" ycu" Ðiqkpi" vq" igv" og" c" lwt{" vtkcn0Ñ" " Ykvjqwv" eqoogpvkpi" qp" Jcfggf" qt" rgvkvkqpgtÓu" etgfkdknkv{." vjg" eqwtv" cfjgtgf" vq" kvu" gctnkgt" twnkpi" vjcv" rgvkvkqpgt" mpqykpin{"cpf"kpvgnnkigpvn{"yckxgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn0" " " 37" " Rgvkvkqpgt"hcknu"vq"cnngig"qt"fgoqpuvtcvg"kp"yjcv"tgurgev"vjg"yckxgt"qh"c"lwt{" vtkcn"chhgevgf"vjg"qwveqog"qh"vtkcn0]34_""Vjwu."rgvkvkqpgt"jcu"hckngf"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg" vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"tgcuqpcdng"rtqdcdknkv{"vjcv."dwv"hqt"eqwpugnÓu"cnngigf"gttqtu."vjg"tguwnv" qh"vjg"rtqeggfkpi"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"fkhhgtgpv0" " *GEH"Pq0"38Î6."cv"3Î5"*hqqvpqvg"pwodgt"cnvgtgf"htqo"qtkikpcn+"*hktuv"cnvgtcvkqp"kp"qtkikpcn+0""Vjg" Eqwtv"fkuegtpu"pq"wptgcuqpcdng"crrnkecvkqp"qh"vjg"ncy"cpf"pq"wptgcuqpcdng"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"vjg" hcevu" d{" vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" qh" Xktikpkc" kp" vjg" fkuokuucn" qh" Encko" Vjtgg0" " See" 4:" W0U0E0" ¸"4476*f+*3+Î*4+0""" " Cu"c"rtgnkokpct{"ocvvgt."vjku"Eqwtv"jcu"cntgcf{"hqwpf"vjcv"vjg"uvcvg"eqwtvÓu"fgvgtokpcvkqp" vjcv"Jqnnqoqpf"mpqykpin{"cpf"xqnwpvctkn{"yckxgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"ycu"pqv"wptgcuqpcdng" dcugf" qp" vjg" tgeqtf0" " Vjwu." dgecwug" jg" yckxgf" jku" tkijv" vq" c" lwt{" vtkcn." Jqnnqoqpf" hcknu" vq" fgoqpuvtcvg"cp{"rtglwfkeg"htqo"eqwpugnÓu"rwtrqtvgf"hcknwtg"vq"gpuwtg"vjcv"Jqnnqoqpf"tgegkxgf"c" vtkcn"d{"lwt{0""Oqtgqxgt."qxgtyjgnokpi"gxkfgpeg"gzkuvgf"qh"JqnnqoqpfÓu"iwknv"qh"vyq"eqwpvu"qh" ftwi"fkuvtkdwvkqp0""Vjg"lwt{."owej"nkmg"vjg"lwfig."yqwnf"jcxg"jgctf"vjg"vguvkoqp{"qh"vjg"ykvpguugu." cpf"cu"vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"cntgcf{"eqpenwfgf."cp{"tcvkqpcn"vtkgt"qh"hcev"yqwnf"jcxg"hqwpf"Jqnnqoqpf" iwknv{0""Vjwu."Jqnnqoqpf"hcknu"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjcv."kh"eqwpugn"jcf"oqtg"vjqtqwijn{"gzrnckpgf"vq"jko" jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"uq"jg"eqwnf"rtgugtxg"jku"tkijv."cpf"jg"jcf"cevwcnn{"jcf"jku"ecug"vtkgf"dghqtg"c" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " " ]34_"Cnvjqwij"rtglwfkeg"oc{"dg"rtguwogf"kp"tctg"ecugu"yjgtg"vjg"fghgpfcpv" ycu"eqorngvgn{"qt"eqpuvtwevkxgn{"fgpkgf"eqwpugn."see United States v. Ragin.":42" H05f"82;."83:Î3;"*6vj"Ekt0"4238+"*rtglwfkeg"rtguwogf"yjgtg"eqwpugn"ungrv"vjtqwij" ukipkhkecpv"rqtvkqpu"qh"vtkcn+."Ðrtglwfkeg"jcu"pqv"dggp"rtguwogf"kp"ecugu"kpxqnxkpi" enckou"qh"kpghhgevkxg"cuukuvcpeg"qh"eqwpugn"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"lwt{/vtkcn"yckxgtu0Ñ"" State v. Feregino."978"P0Y04f"922."929"*Kqyc"422:+"*ekvkpi"Sowell v. Bradshaw." 594"H05f":43.":58Î5:"*8vj"Ekt0"4226+="Parrish v. Fulcomer."372"H05f"548."54:"*5f" Ekt0" 3;;:++=" see also Commonwealth v. Mallory." ;63" C04f" 8:8." 8;9Î;:" *Rgpp0" 422:+"*ÐVjku"pqv"wpeqooqp"o{/tgeqtf/yckxgt/ycu/o{/ncy{gtÓu/hcwnv"encko"ku"hct" tgoqxgf"htqo"vjg"Òeqpuvkvwvkqpcn."uvtwevwtcnÓ"gttqt"vjcv"yqwnf"dg"cv"kuuwg"kh"c"vkogn{" lwt{"fgocpf"ycu"ytqpin{"fgpkgf0Ñ+0""Vjgtghqtg."rgvkvkqpgt"ycu"tgswktgf"vq"ujqy"c" tgcuqpcdn{"rtqdcdknkv{"vjcv"JcfggfÓu"cnngigf"hcknwtg"rtglwfkegf"vjg"qwveqog"qh"jku" ecug0""See Strickland."688"W0U0"cv"8:90" " 38" lwt{."vjg"tguwnv"qh"vjg"vtkcn"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"fkhhgtgpv0""Vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"qh"XktikpkcÓu"eqpenwukqp" vjcv" vjku" encko" ncemgf" ogtkv" dgecwug" Jqnnqoqpf" hckngf" vq" fgoqpuvtcvg" cp{" rtglwfkeg" ycu" pqv" wptgcuqpcdng0""Hqt"vjku"tgcuqp"cnqpg."Encko"Vjtgg"oc{"dg"FKUOKUUGF0" " Cffkvkqpcnn{."cnvjqwij"vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"qh"Xktikpkc"fkuokuugf"vjku"encko"uqngn{"dgecwug" Jqnnqoqpf" hckngf" vq" fgoqpuvtcvg" cp{" rtglwfkeg." vjg" tgeqtf" cnuq" tghngevu" vjcv" eqwpugn" ycu" pqv" fghkekgpv0""Cu"vjg"tgeqtf"guvcdnkujgu."eqwpugn"ycu"fgcnkpi"ykvj"c"fkhhkewnv"enkgpv0""Eqwpugn."cv"ngcuv" vykeg."dtqwijv"JqnnqoqpfÓu"rwtrqtvgf"eqphwukqp"cdqwv"jku"lwt{"vtkcn"yckxgt"vq"vjg"Ektewkv"EqwtvÓu" cvvgpvkqp0""Rtkqt"vq"vjg"ugeqpf"fc{"qh"vtkcn."eqwpugn"hkngf"c"oqvkqp"hqt"c"okuvtkcn"cpf"ctiwgf"vjcv" Jqnnqoqpf"ujqwnf"dg"rgtokvvgf"vq"ykvjftcy"jku"yckxgt"fwtkpi"vjg"okffng"qh"vtkcn"dgecwug"jg"fkf" pqv"wpfgtuvcpf"vjg"yckxgt0""*Fge0"38."4237"Vt0";Î330+""Vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"fgpkgf"vjg"oqvkqp"cu" jcxkpi" Ðgxgt{" kpfkekc" qh" qduvtwevkqp" cpf" uggmkpi" vq" ickp" c" dgpghkv" ukorn{" dgecwug" yg" jcf" vq" eqpvkpwg" vjg" vtkcn.Ñ" cpf" dgecwug" vjg" tgeqtf" guvcdnkujgf" Jqnnqoqpf" mpqykpin{" cpf" xqnwpvctkn{" yckxgf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{0""*Fge0"38."4237"Vt0"34Î350+""" Rtkqt" vq" vjg" ugpvgpekpi" jgctkpi." eqwpugn" hkngf" c" oqvkqp" vq" ugv" cukfg" vjg" xgtfkev" Ðkp" vjg" cdwpfcpeg"qh"ecwvkqpÑ"dcugf"qp"JqnnqoqpfÓu"eqornckpvu"cdqwv"jku"fguktg"hqt"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""*Hgd0"5." 4239"Vt0"350+""Eqwpugn"cnuq"oqxgf"vq"ykvjftcy0""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"350+""Vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"jgctf" vguvkoqp{"htqo"dqvj"eqwpugn"cpf"Jqnnqoqpf0""Eqwpugn"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"fkuewuugf"ykvj"Jqnnqoqpf" yjgvjgt"jg"ycpvgf"c"vtkcn"d{"lwfig"qt"lwt{"cv"ngcuv"vykeg"dghqtg"vjg"hktuv"fc{"qh"jku"vtkcn0""*Hgd0"5." 4239"Vt0";Î320+""Eqwpugn"gzrnckpgf"vjg"fkhhgtgpegu"cpf"rqvgpvkcn"qwveqogu"qh"gcej."cpf"Jqnnqoqpf" kpfkecvgf"vjcv"jg"ycpvgf"c"vtkcn"d{"lwfig0""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0";Î320+""Eqwpugn"ogv"ykvj"jko"ownvkrng" vkogu" vjg" fc{" qh" vtkcn" dgecwug" ujg" ycu" uvknn" tgeqoogpfkpi" hqt" jko" vq" vcmg" vjg" rngc" qhhgt." cpf" Jqnnqoqpf"chhktogf"jku"fguktg"vq"iq"vq"vtkcn."cpf"vq"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj"c"vtkcn"d{"c"lwfig0""*Hgd0"35." 4239"Vt0"320+""Eqwpugn"cickp"gzrnckpgf"vq"Jqnnqoqpf"jku"tkijv"vq"c"lwt{"fwtkpi"vjg"rngc"eqnnqsw{" yjgtg"ujg"" " " 39" tgkvgtcvgf"ygÓxg"dggp"qxgt"vjku0""Ctg"{qw"ejcpikpi"{qwt"okpfA""Yjcv"fq"{qw"ycpv" vq"fqA""Fq"{qw"ycpv"vq"iq"hqtyctf"ykvj"vjg"lwfig"qt"vjg"lwt{A""Cpf"jg"uckf."]v_jg" lwfig0""K"uckf."]v_jku"ku"vjg"lwfig0""Vjg"vtkcn"yknn"dg"kp"htqpv"qh"vjku"lwfig"tkijv"pqy0"" Vjku"ku"yjgp"yg"ygtg"vcmkpi"qwt"nkvvng"okpk"tgeguu"cv"eqwpugn"vcdng."cpf"jg"vwtpgf"vq" vjg"Lwfig."cpf"yg"eqpvkpwgf"vjg"uqnknqsw{."cpf"jg"uckf."[gu."c"vtkcn"d{"lwfig."cpf" vjg"vtkcn"dgicp0" " *Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"32Î330+""Rtkqt"vq"vjg"ugeqpf"fc{"qh"vtkcn."Jqnnqoqpf"cumgf"jgt"Ðyjgp"vjg"lwt{" ycu"iqkpi"vq"ujqy"wr0Ñ""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"330+""Eqwpugn"gzrnckpgf"Ðvjcv"vjg"lwt{"ycu"pqv"iqkpi"vq" dg"ujqykpi"wr."vjcv"yg"uvctvgf"vjg"vtkcn"cpf"vjcv"jg"ycu"dgkpi"vtkgf"d{"vjg"Lwfig0""Yg"jcf"fkuewuugf" cv"vjcv"rqkpv"ownvkrng"vkogu"cv"vjg"lckn."oggvkpi"ykvj"jko"rtkqt"vq"vjg"vtkcn"uvctvkpi."cpf"jgtg"cv"eqwtv" kp"vjg"dcem"rtkqt"vq"vjg"vtkcn"uvctvkpi0Ñ""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"330+" " Rtkqt"vq"ugpvgpekpi."Jqnnqoqpf"ugpv"eqwpugn"ownvkrng"ngvvgtu"uggmkpi"c"fkxgtukqp"rtqitco" kpuvgcf"qh"ugpvgpekpi0""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"340+""Eqwpugn"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"jg"fkf"pqv"swcnkh{."cpf"cv"vjcv" rqkpv"vjg"Ðpcvwtg"qh"jku"ngvvgtu"ejcpigf."cpf"jg"ugpv"dqvj"o{ugnh"cpf"vjg"Eqwtv"ngvvgtu"tgictfkpi" jqy"jg"hgnv"jku"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijvu"jcf"dggp"xkqncvgf"cpf"vjcv"jg"engctn{"ycpvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn"vjg" yjqng"vkog0Ñ""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"340+""Kp"tgurqpug"vq"vjgug"ngvvgtu."eqwpugn"hkngf"c"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg" vjg"xgtfkev"cpf."uwdugswgpvn{."c"ugeqpf"oqvkqp"vq"ykvjftcy""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"350+" " Jqnnqoqpf"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jg"vqnf"eqwpugn"vjcv"jg"ycpvgf"c"lwt{."cpf"vjcv"eqwpugn"vqnf"jko" ujg"yqwnf"hkng"c"oqvkqp"hqt"c"okuvtkcn"rtkqt"vq"vjg"ugeqpf"fc{"qh"vtkcn."yjkej"ujg."kp"hcev."fkf0""*Hgd0" 5."4239"Vt0"3:0+""Jqnnqoqpf"kpfkecvgf"vjcv"chvgt"jku"vtkcn."jg"ÐfkfpÓv"mpqy"cdqwv"]jku_"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn" cogpfogpv"cv"vjcv"vkog.Ñ"cpf"vjtgcvgpgf"eqwpugn"kp"c"ngvvgt"Ðvjcv"K"yqwnf"nkmg"hqt"{qw"vq"vt{"vq"ugg" kh"{qw"ecp"igv"og"uqog"v{rg"qh"jgnr"qt"uqog"v{rg"qh"rtqitco."cpf"KÓo"iqkpi"vq"ngv"Lwfig"Ytkijv" mpqy"vjcv"{qw"vtkemgf"og"kpvq"c"dgpej"vtkcn"0"0"0"0Ñ""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"3;0+""Jqnnqoqpf"gzrnckpgf" vjcv"jg"qpn{"ngctpgf"cdqwv"jku"Ðeqpuvkvwvkqpcn"cogpfogpvÑ"chvgt"vtkcn"yjgp"jg"Ðuvctvgf"uvwf{kpi"vjg" ncydqqmuÑ"chvgt"vtkcn0""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"420+""Jqnnqoqpf"ncvgt"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jg"qpn{"ngctpgf"cdqwv" jku"Ukzvj"Cogpfogpv"vq"c"lwt{"vtkcn"chvgt"eqwpugn"ugpv"jko"vjg"oqvkqp"vq"ugv"cukfg"vjg"xgtfkev0""*Hgd0" " " 3:" 5." 4239" Vt0"57Î580+" " Jqnnqoqpf"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"eqwpugnÓu"vguvkoqp{"fwtkpi"vjg"jgctkpi"ycu"Ðpqv" vtwgÑ"cpf"vjcv"cv"cnn"vkogu"jg"vqnf"jgt"jg"ycpvgf"c"lwt{"vtkcn0""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"42Î440+" " Chvgt"jgctkpi"vjg"vguvkoqp{"qh"dqvj"eqwpugn"cpf"Jqnnqoqpf."vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"pqvgf"vjcv" ÐygÓxg"dggp"qxgt"vjku"pqy"c"eqwrng"qh"vkogu.Ñ"cpf"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"Ðvjg"Eqwtv"ygpv"vq"uqog"ngpivj" vq"ocmg"uwtg."cu"K"vjkpm"vjg"vtcpuetkrv"tghngevu."vq"ocmg"uwtg"vjcv"Ot0"Jqnnqoqpf"wpfgtuvqqf"yjcv" ycu"iqkpi"qp"cpf"yjcv"jku"tkijvu"ygtg0Ñ""*Hgd0"5."4239"Vt0"58Î590+""Vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"tghwugf"vq" ceegrv" JqnnqoqpfÓu" xgtukqp" qh" vjg" gxgpvu" cpf" fgpkgf" vjg" oqvkqp0" " *Hgd0" 5." 4239" Vt0" 58Î590+"" Cnvjqwij"eqwpugn"cvvgorvgf"vq"jcxg"vjg"vtkcn"ugv"cukfg."vjg"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"ukorn{"fkf"pqv"dgnkgxg" JqnnqoqpfÓu"eqpvgpvkqp"vjcv"jku"lwt{"vtkcn"yckxgt"ycu"cp{vjkpi"qvjgt"vjcp"mpqykpi"cpf"xqnwpvct{0"" Vjgtghqtg."Jqnnqoqpf"hcknu"vq"uwiiguv"yjcv"hwtvjgt"cevkqp"eqwpugn"eqwnf"jcxg"vcmgp0""Vjg"Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Jqnnqoqpf"hcknu"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg"vjcv"eqwpugn"ycu"fghkekgpv"qt"vjcv"jg"ycu"rtglwfkegf0"" Ceeqtfkpin{."Encko"Vjtgg"ncemu"ogtkv"cpf"yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF0" XK0" " EQPENWUKQP" Hqt" vjg" hqtgiqkpi" tgcuqpu." TgurqpfgpvÓu" Oqvkqp" vq" Fkuokuu" *GEH" Pq0"36+" yknn" dg" ITCPVGF0""JqnnqoqpfÓu"enckou"yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF."cpf"jku"¸"4476"Rgvkvkqp"*GEH"Pq0"3+"yknn" dg"FGPKGF0""Vjg"cevkqp"yknn"dg"FKUOKUUGF0""C"egtvkhkecvg"qh"crrgcncdknkv{"yknn"dg"FGPKGF035" " " " Cp"crrtqrtkcvg"Hkpcn"Qtfgt"ujcnn"kuuwg0" " " " " " " " Fcvg<" Ugrvgodgt"37."4242" " Tkejoqpf."Xktikpkc " " " 1" " " " """""1u1" " Tqfgtkem"E0"[qwpi" Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig" " "Cp"crrgcn"oc{"pqv"dg"vcmgp"htqo"vjg"hkpcn"qtfgt"kp"c"¸"4476"rtqeggfkpi"wpnguu"c"lwfig"kuuwgu"c" egtvkhkecvg"qh"crrgcncdknkv{"*ÐEQCÑ+0""4:"W0U0E0"¸"4475*e+*3+*C+0""C"EQC"yknn"pqv"kuuwg"wpnguu"c" rtkuqpgt" ocmgu" Ðc" uwduvcpvkcn" ujqykpi" qh" vjg" fgpkcn" qh" c" eqpuvkvwvkqpcn" tkijv0Ñ" " 4:" W0U0E0" ¸"4475*e+*4+0""Vjku"tgswktgogpv"ku"ucvkuhkgf"qpn{"yjgp"Ðtgcuqpcdng"lwtkuvu"eqwnf"fgdcvg"yjgvjgt" *qt."hqt"vjcv"ocvvgt."citgg"vjcv+"vjg"rgvkvkqp"ujqwnf"jcxg"dggp"tguqnxgf"kp"c"fkhhgtgpv"ocppgt"qt"vjcv" vjg" kuuwgu" rtgugpvgf" ygtg" Òcfgswcvg" vq" fgugtxg" gpeqwtcigogpv" vq" rtqeggf" hwtvjgt0ÓÑ Slack v. McDaniel."74;"W0U0"695."6:6"*4222+"*swqvkpi Barefoot v. Estelle."685"W0U0"::2.":;5"p06"*3;:5++0"" Jqnnqoqpf"hcknu"vq"oggv"vjku"uvcpfctf0"""" 35 3;"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
