Murray v. South Carolina Department of Corrections et al, No. 6:2019cv00100 - Document 52 (D.S.C. 2020)
Court Description: ORDER AND OPINION: The Court ADOPTS the R & R (Dkt. No. 48) as the order of the Court. Defendants motion for summary judgment (Dkt. No. 37) is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. AND IT IS SO ORDERED. Signed by Honorable Richard M Gergel on 7/1/20.(ltap, )
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Murray v. South Carolina Department of Corrections et al Doc. 52 59 >41 ?95>10 =>->1= 05=><5/> /:?<> 05=><5/> :2 =:?>4 /-<:7593<119@5771 05@5=5:9 >NZN_Pb` Ab__Nf% # # DYNV[aVSS% # # c' # # F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N 8R]N_aZR[a ¥S 7¥__RPaV¥[`4 # JN_QR[ @R_¥f 7N_aYRQTR% =A8=I=8H5??L 5A8 # =A <=F B::=7=5? 75C57=GL 5F J5E89A B: # .7&BE@=7> &BEE97G=BA5? +AFG=GHG=BA4 # JN_QR[ AVPUNRY FaR]UN[% =A8=I=8H5??L 5A8 # =A <=F B::=7=5? 75C57=GL 5F J5E89A B: # .7&BE@=7> &BEE97G=BA5? +AFG=GHG=BA% # # # 8RSR[QN[a`' # MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM # 7VcVY 5PaV¥[ B¥' /3*2&)*))&EA; :<01< -90 :;595:9 6RS¥_R aUR 7¥b_a V` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` ER]¥_a N[Q ERP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ "jE ! Ek# "8Xa' B¥' -1# _RP¥ZZR[QV[T aUNa 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ S¥_ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a OR T_N[aRQ V[ ]N_a N[Q QR[VRQ V[ ]N_a' :¥_ aUR _RN`¥[` `Ra S¥_aU ORY¥d% aUR 7¥b_a NQ¥]a` aUR E ! E N` aUR ¥_QR_ ¥S aUR 7¥b_a a¥ T_N[a V[ ]N_a N[Q QR[f V[ ]N_a 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ S¥_ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a' "8Xa' B¥' ,0'# 5$ .BDLHRPUOE DYNV[aVSS >NZN_Pb` Ab__Nf dN` N[ V[ZNaR V[PN_PR_NaRQ Na AP7¥_ZVPX 7¥__RPaV¥[NY =[`aVabaV¥[ dUR[% ¥[ ¥_ NO¥ba 5]_VY */% +)*/% UR dN` NaaNPXRQ Of SRYY¥d V[ZNaR`' GUR V[ZNaR` N]]_¥NPURQ UVZ V[ N[ NV`YR S_¥Z ORUV[Q% P¥cR_RQ UV` URNQ dVaU N WNPXRa% Q_NTTRQ UVZ V[a¥ N _¥¥Z N[Q N``NbYaRQ UVZ Of ORNaV[T N[Q `aNOOV[T UVZ V[ aUR SNPR% URNQ N[Q PUR`a' Ab__Nf NYYRTR` aUNa ad¥ P¥__RPaV¥[NY ¥SSVPR_` dR_R V[ aUR `NYYf ]¥_a dVaU O¥aU ]_V`¥[ dV[T Q¥¥_` YRSa b[Y¥PXRQ% V[ cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S ]_V`¥[ ]¥YVPf' GUR P¥__RPaV¥[NY ¥SSVPR_` NYYRTRQYf `Nd Ab__Nf VZZRQVNaRYf NSaR_ aUR NaaNPX% Oba QVQ [¥a URY] UVZ' <R aUR_RNSaR_ _RPRVcRQ ZRQVPNY N``V`aN[PR% V[PYbQV[T S¥_ aUR `aNOOV[T d¥b[Q `Ve V[PUR` S_¥Z UV` URN_a% S_¥Z aUR ]_V`¥[ [b_`R N[Q YNaR_ Na FRYS ARZ¥_VNY <¥`]VaNY' &*& Dockets.Justia.com Ab__Nf Sb_aUR_ NYYRTR` aUNa UV` V[Wb_VR`% `bPU N` `U¥_a[R`` ¥S O_RNaU N[Q N[ V[Wb_RQ WNd% dR_R aUR QV_RPa _R`bYa ¥S aUR F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N 8R]N_aZR[a ¥S 7¥__RPaV¥[m` "jF787k# T_¥`` [RTYVTR[PR Of SNVYV[T a¥ RZ]Y¥f `bSSVPVR[a P¥__RPaV¥[NY ¥SSVPR_` ¥_ a¥ R[S¥_PR `bSSVPVR[a a_NV[V[T ]¥YVPVR` N[Q ]_¥PRQb_R`% N` dRYY N` aUR _R`bYa ¥S 8RSR[QN[a JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTRm` N[Q(¥_ JN_QR[ FaR]UN[m` T_¥`` [RTYVTR[PR Of SNVYV[T a¥ R[`b_R aUNa P¥__RPaV¥[NY ¥SSVPR_` P¥Z]YVRQ dVaU aUR ReV`aV[T F787 ]¥YVPVR` N[Q ]_¥PRQb_R`' "8Xa' B¥' +&* ii *+*&*-*'#' Ab__Nf O_V[T` S¥b_ PNb`R` ¥S NPaV¥[3 "*# N PYNVZ NTNV[`a NYY 8RSR[QN[a` S¥_ aRZ]¥_N_f N[Q ]R_ZN[R[a V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS a¥ Pb_aNVY aURV_ QRYVOR_NaR V[QVSSR_R[PR N[Q [RTYVTR[PR _R`bYaV[T V[ V[ZNaR&¥[&V[ZNaR N``NbYa`% ]b_`bN[a a¥ F'7' 7¥QR' 5[[' h *.&-,&,)% F'7' E' 7Vc' D' /."O#% N[Q H'F'7' h *21,4 "+# N PYNVZ NTNV[`a JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTR jN[Q(¥_k JN_QR[ FaR]UN[ ]b_`bN[a a¥ -+ H'F'7' h *21, S¥_ cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S Ab__Nfm` 9VTUaU N[Q :¥b_aRR[aU NZR[QZR[a _VTUa` Of% =AG9E 5?=5% [RTYVTR[aYf N[Q dN[a¥[Yf NYY¥dV[T aUR V[ZNaR&¥[&V[ZNaR N``NbYa`4 ",# N PYNVZ NTNV[`a JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTR jN[Q(¥_k JN_QR[ FaR]UN[ ]b_`bN[a a¥ -+ H'F'7' h *21, S¥_ `b]R_cV`¥_f YVNOVYVaf N[Q SNVYb_R a¥ a_NV[ ¥SSVPR_`4 N[Q "-# N PYNVZ NTNV[`a F787 S¥_ cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S aUR F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N G¥_a 7YNVZ` 5Pa "jF7G75k#% F'7' 7¥QR 5[[' h *.&01&*)% 9G F9D#% N` YVNOYR S¥_ Va` RZ]Y¥fRR`m T_¥`` [RTYVTR[PR dVaUV[ aUR `P¥]R ¥S aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY QbaVR`' "+8# ii *-+&.0'#' GUR PYNVZ` NTNV[`a JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTR N[Q JN_QR[ FaR]UN[ N_R O_¥bTUa NTNV[`a RNPU V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY N[Q ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR`' 7N_aYRQTR% FaR]UN[ N[Q F787 UR_R W¥V[aYf Z¥cR a¥ QV`ZV`` NYY PYNVZ` ¥[ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a' 55$ 7FHBM =TBOEBRE -$ <FVJFW PG < ! < GUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTR ZNXR` ¥[Yf N _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ aUV` 7¥b_a' GUR _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ UN` [¥ ]_R`bZ]aVcR dRVTUa N[Q aUR _R`]¥[`VOVYVaf a¥ ZNXR N SV[NY QRaR_ZV[NaV¥[ _RZNV[` dVaU aUR 7¥b_a' 199" 9#;#% .5G<9JF I# 3969E% -+, H'F' +/*% +0)&0* "*20/#' GUR 7¥b_a ZNf jNPPR]a% _RWRPa% ¥_ Z¥QVSf% V[ dU¥YR ¥_ V[ ]N_a% aUR SV[QV[T` ¥_ _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[` ZNQR Of aUR ZNTV`a_NaR WbQTR'k &+& +1 H'F'7' h /,/"O#"*#"7#' JUR_R aUR_R N_R `]RPVSVP ¥OWRPaV¥[` a¥ aUR E ! E% aUR 7¥b_a jZNXR` N 89 ABIB QRaR_ZV[NaV¥[ ¥S aU¥`R ]¥_aV¥[` ¥S aUR _R]¥_a ¥_ `]RPVSVRQ ]_¥]¥`RQ SV[QV[T` ¥_ _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[` a¥ dUVPU ¥OWRPaV¥[ V` ZNQR'k +8' =[ aUR NO`R[PR ¥S ¥OWRPaV¥[`% aUR 7¥b_a _RcVRd` aUR E ! E a¥ j¥[Yf `NaV`Sf Va`RYS aUNa aUR_R V` [¥ PYRN_ R__¥_ ¥[ aUR SNPR ¥S aUR _RP¥_Q V[ ¥_QR_ a¥ NPPR]a aUR _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥['k :RQ' E' 7Vc' D' 0+ NQcV`¥_f P¥ZZVaaRRm` [¥aR4 F99 5?FB &5@6L I# '5I=F% 0*1 :'+Q *21% *22 "-aU 7V_' *21,# "j=[ aUR NO`R[PR ¥S ¥OWRPaV¥[ ' ' ' dR Q¥ [¥a ORYVRcR aUNa Va _R^bV_R` N[f Re]YN[NaV¥['k#' .$ 8PTJPO GPR =UNNBRX 6UEHNFOT FbZZN_f WbQTZR[a V` N]]_¥]_VNaR jVS aUR Z¥cN[a `U¥d` aUNa aUR_R V` [¥ TR[bV[R QV`]baR N` a¥ N[f ZNaR_VNY SNPa N[Q aUR Z¥cN[a V` R[aVaYRQ a¥ WbQTZR[a N` N ZNaaR_ ¥S YNd'k :RQ' E' 7Vc' D' ./"N#' GUR Z¥cN[a UN` aUR Ob_QR[ ¥S VQR[aVSfV[T aUR ]¥_aV¥[` ¥S aUR j]YRNQV[T`% QR]¥`VaV¥[`% N[`dR_` a¥ V[aR__¥TNa¥_VR`% N[f NQZV``V¥[` ¥[ SVYR% a¥TRaUR_ dVaU aUR NSSVQNcVa`% VS N[f% dUVPU `U¥d aUR_R V` [¥ TR[bV[R V``bR N` a¥ N[f ZNaR_VNY SNPa N[Q aUNa aUR Z¥cV[T ]N_af V` R[aVaYRQ a¥ WbQTZR[a N` N ZNaaR_ ¥S YNd'k &9?BG9K &BEC# I# &5GE9GG% -00 H'F' ,*0% ,++ "*21/#' GUR QV`a_VPa P¥b_a dVYY P¥[`a_bR NYY V[SR_R[PR` N[Q NZOVTbVaVR` V[ SNc¥_ ¥S aUR [¥[&Z¥cN[a' 21# I# '=96B?8" +A7#% ,/2 H'F' /.-% /.. "*2/+#' GUR ReV`aR[PR ¥S N ZR_R `PV[aVYYN ¥S RcVQR[PR V[ `b]]¥_a ¥S aUR [¥[&Z¥cN[am` ]¥`VaV¥[ V` V[`bSSVPVR[a a¥ dVaU`aN[Q N Z¥aV¥[ S¥_ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a' $A89EFBA I# -=69EGL -B66L" +A7#% -00 H'F' +-+% +.+ "*21/#' 5[ V``bR ¥S ZNaR_VNY SNPa V` TR[bV[R VS aUR RcVQR[PR V` `bPU aUNa N _RN`¥[NOYR Wb_f P¥bYQ _Rab_[ N cR_QVPa V[ SNc¥_ ¥S aUR [¥[&Z¥cN[a' +8# Na +.0' 555$ 0JSDUSSJPO GUR 7¥b_a P¥[QbPaRQ N 89 ABIB _RcVRd ¥S aUR _RP¥_Q ¥[ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a% V[ YVTUa ¥S F787m` N[Q JN_QR[ FaR]UN[m` ¥OWRPaV¥[` a¥ aUR E ! E "8Xa' B¥' .-#% N[Q SV[Q` aUNa aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTR NOYf NQQ_R``RQ aUR V``bR` V[ N P¥Z]_RUR[`VcR S¥_af&ad¥&]NTR E ! E% P¥__RPaYf QRaR_ZV[V[T aUNa 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ `U¥bYQ OR T_N[aRQ V[ ]N_a N[Q QR[VRQ V[ ]N_a' &,& -$ /PUOT :OF GPR 5OKUODTJVF <FMJFG BS TP -MM 0FGFOEBOTS J$ ;URSUBOT TP )' ?$=$/$ Y &,+( :V_`a% N` a¥ JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTR N[Q JN_QR[ FaR]UN[% SRQR_NY P¥b_a` ZNf R[W¥V[ `aNaR ¥SSVPVNY` V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR`' (K C5EG9 4BHA;% +)2 H'F' *+,% *..&./ "*2)1#' 6ba JN_QR[ 7N_aYRQTR N[Q JN_QR[ FaR]UN[ PN[[¥a OR `bRQ V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR` S¥_ aUR ]_¥`]RPaVcR V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS `¥bTUa UR_R ORPNb`R aURf N_R [¥ Y¥[TR_ RZ]Y¥fRQ Na AP7¥_ZVPX 7¥__RPaV¥[NY =[`aVabaV¥[' "8Xa' B¥`' ,0&* Na +% ,0&+'# 199 3=?FBA I# 2A=G98 1G5G9F% ,,+ :'E'8' .).% .+1 "F'8' J'IN' +)*2#' B¥_ P¥bYQ aURf OR YVNOYR S¥_ aUR ]_¥`]RPaVcR V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS `¥bTUa V[ aURV_ V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR` ORPNb`R jN ]YNV[aVSS `U¥bYQ [¥a OR NOYR a¥ `bR N QRSR[QN[a V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf S¥_ N[ V[Wb[PaV¥[ V[ `VabNaV¥[` V[ dUVPU aUR V[Wb[PaV¥[ _RYNaR` ¥[Yf a¥ aUR ¥SSVPVNY`m W¥O% =#9#% UV` ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaf'k &B@@HA=GL .9AG5? *95?G< 19EIF# B: %9?@BAG I# .9AG5? *95?G< ! 097BI9EL %8#% *.) :' 5]]e' ,12% -)* "/aU 7V_' +)).#' GUR 7¥b_a aUR_RS¥_R NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` Ab__Nfm` PYNVZ S¥_ V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS b[QR_ h *21, NTNV[`a 7N_aYRQTR N[Q FaR]UN[% V[ RNPUm` ¥SSVPVNY N[Q V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR`' BRea% N` a¥ F787% aUR 9YRcR[aU 5ZR[QZR[a ]_¥UVOVa` SRQR_NY P¥b_a` S_¥Z R[aR_aNV[V[T N[ NPaV¥[ NTNV[`a N `aNaR' 3=?? I# .=7<# '9CNG B: 1G5G9 /B?=79% -2* H'F' .1% // "*212#' GUV` V` ORPNb`R 9YRcR[aU 5ZR[QZR[a VZZb[Vaf jReaR[Q` a¥ N_ZK`L ¥S aUR FaNaR% V[PYbQV[T `aNaR NTR[PVR`'k &EB@9E I# %EBJA% 11 :',Q *,*.% *,,+ "-aU 7V_' *22/#' j5` N `aNaR NTR[Pf% F787 V` N[ N_Z ¥S aUR FaNaR ¥S F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N'k $6969 I# 1#&# '9CNG &BEE#% B¥' )3)2&Pc&,***&A6F&D>% +)*) J@ +22*.2.% Na $+ "8'F'7' >bYf +% +)*)#' GUR 7¥b_a aUR_RS¥_R NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` aUR PYNVZ S¥_ V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS b[QR_ h *21, NTNV[`a F787' JJ$ ;URSUBOT TP =$/$ /PEF -OO$ Y &*#)(#(% 8RSR[QN[a` N_TbR aUNa aUV` PYNVZ S¥_ V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS b[QR_ `aNaR YNd V` Z¥¥a ORPNb`R Ab__Nf V` [¥ Y¥[TR_ V[PN_PR_NaRQ Na N[f F787 ]_V`¥[ SNPVYVaf' "8Xa' B¥' ,0&- Na ,'# jK5L PN`R V` &-& Z¥¥a dUR[ aUR V``bR` ]_R`R[aRQ N_R [¥ Y¥[TR_ lYVcRm ¥_ aUR ]N_aVR` YNPX N YRTNYYf P¥T[VgNOYR V[aR_R`a V[ aUR ¥ba&P¥ZR'k /BJ9?? I# .7&BE@57>% ,2. H'F' -1/% -2/ "*2/2#' jGUR :¥b_aU 7V_PbVa UN` P¥[`V`aR[aYf URYQ aUNa dUR_R N ]_V`¥[R_ V` [¥ Y¥[TR_ `bOWRPa a¥ aUR NYYRTRQ b[P¥[`aVabaV¥[NY P¥[QVaV¥[% aUR PYNVZ V` Z¥¥a'k 3E=;<G I# %9AA9GG% B¥' .3)1&Pc&,*+2&6C% +)*) J@ ,)0..*2% Na $, "9'8'B'7' 5bT' -% +)*)#' F¥ a¥¥% UR_R% Ab__Nfm` jPYNVZ S¥_ V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS dN` _R[QR_RQ Z¥¥a Of UV` _RYRN`Rk S_¥Z ]_V`¥[ jKQLb_V[T aUR ]R[QR[Pf ¥S UV` PN`R'k .BA9<L5A I# ,9??9E% ./, :RQ' 5]]e' +./% +.1 "-aU 7V_' +)*-#' GUR 7¥b_a aUR_RS¥_R NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ T_N[a 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` aUV` PYNVZ N` a¥ 7N_aYRQTR% FaR]UN[ N[Q F787' .$ /PUOT >WP GPR @JPMBTJPO PG 1JHITI BOE 2PURTFFOTI -NFOENFOT <JHITS" ;URSUBOT TP Y &,+(" CX ABREFO /BRTMFEHF BOE ABREFO =TFQIBO 7N_aYRQTR N[Q FaR]UN[ N_R RNPU `bRQ V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY N[Q V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR`' :V_`a% N` a¥ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaf YVNOVYVaf% aUR 7¥b_a NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` aUV` PYNVZ N` a¥ O¥aU 7N_aYRQTR N[Q FaR]UN[ ORPNb`R VZZb[Vaf S_¥Z `bVa b[QR_ aUR 9YRcR[aU 5ZR[QZR[a jReaR[Q` a¥ ' ' ' `aNaR ¥SSVPR_` NPaV[T V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaf'k &EB@9E I# %EBJA% 11 :',Q *,*.% *,,+ "-aU 7V_' *22/#' jFaNaR ¥SSVPVNY` ZNf ¥[Yf OR `bRQ V[ aURV_ V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR`'k 0<B89A I# 1#&# '9CNG &BEE#% B¥' -3*0&Pc&+.,0&<A<&G9E% +)*0 J@ 2+11+*0% Na $, "8'F'7' CPa' -% +)*0#' 6ba% N` a¥ V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf YVNOVYVaf% aUR j]R_`¥[NY ]N_aVPV]NaV¥[ ¥S N QRSR[QN[a V` N [RPR``N_f RYRZR[a ¥S N FRPaV¥[ *21, PYNVZ NTNV[`a T¥cR_[ZR[a ¥SSVPVNY` V[ aURV_ V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR`'k %?9FF=A; I# 175GHEB% B¥' /3*/&Pc&*1,+&6<<&?:A% +)*0 J@ ,.0.0,+% Na $2 "8'F'7' >bYf +1% +)*0#' ERTN_QV[T 7N_aYRQTR% N _RN`¥[NOYR Wb_V`a P¥bYQ SV[Q S_¥Z aUR _RP¥_Q% dUR[ P¥[`a_bRQ V[ N YVTUa Z¥`a SNc¥_NOYR a¥ aUR [¥[&Z¥cN[a% aUNa UR UNQ aUR _R^bV`VaR NPabNY X[¥dYRQTR ¥S N[Q QV`_RTN_QRQ N `bO`aN[aVNY _V`X ¥S UN_Z a¥ Ab__Nf' GUR E¥aU ER]¥_a% V[ ]N_aVPbYN_% _R]RNaRQYf RZ]UN`VgR` aUNa &.& j¥cR_NYY N``NbYa` ¥PPb_ Na N UVTUR_ aUN[ NPPR]aNOYR YRcRY Na A7='k "8Xa' B¥' ,2&1 Na *,2&--'#' 199 )5E@9E I# %E9AA5A% .** H'F' 1+.% 1-+ "*22-# "P¥[`VQR_V[T dURaUR_ QRSR[QN[a jX[Rd ¥S N `bO`aN[aVNY _V`X S_¥Z aUR cR_f SNPa aUNa aUR _V`X dN` ¥OcV¥b`k#' ERYNaRQYf% aUR _RP¥_Q _RSYRPa` N TR[bV[R V``bR ¥S ZNaR_VNY SNPa N` a¥ dURaUR_ 7N_aYRQTR NPaRQ dVaU QRYVOR_NaR V[QVSSR_R[PR Of SNVYV[T a¥ _R`]¥[Q j_RN`¥[NOYf a¥ aUR _V`Xk ¥S UN_Z a¥ Ab__Nf N` N[ V[ZNaR' +8# Na 1--' GUR 7¥b_a aUR_RS¥_R NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ N[Q QR[VR` 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` 7¥b[a Gd¥ N` a¥ 7N_aYRQTR V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf' ERTN_QV[T FaR]UN[% UR N_TbR` aUNa UR P¥bYQ [¥a UNcR ]R_`¥[NYYf ]N_aVPV]NaRQ ORPNb`R UR QVQ [¥a ORP¥ZR dN_QR[ b[aVY ¥cR_ ¥[R fRN_ NSaR_ aUR NYYRTRQ NaaNPX' Ab__Nf P¥[PRQR` aUV` ]¥V[a' GUR_RS¥_R% aUR 7¥b_a NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` 7¥b[a Gd¥ N` a¥ FaR]UN[ V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf' /$ /PUOT >IRFF GPR =UQFRVJSPRX 7JBCJMJTX BOE 2BJMURF TP >RBJO" ;URSUBOT TP Y &,+(" CX ABREFO /BRTMFEHF BOE ABREFO =TFQIBO 5` QV`Pb``RQ NO¥cR% 7N_aYRQTR N[Q FaR]UN[ N_R NSS¥_QRQ VZZb[Vaf S_¥Z `bVa V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR` b[QR_ aUR 9YRcR[aU 5ZR[QZR[a' GUR 7¥b_a% aUR_RS¥_R% NQ¥]a` ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QV`ZV`` 7¥b[a GU_RR N` a¥ 7N_aYRQTR N[Q FaR]UN[ V[ RNPUm` ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaf' 5` a¥ 7N_aYRQTRm` YVNOVYVaf V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf% aUR _RP¥_Q% dUR[ P¥[`a_bRQ V[ N YVTUa Z¥`a SNc¥_NOYR a¥ Ab__Nf% _RSYRPa` _RZNV[V[T QV`]baR` ¥S ZNaR_VNY SNPa _RYRcN[a a¥ UV` `b]R_cV`¥_f YVNOVYVaf% `bPU N` dURaUR_ UR dN` NdN_R ¥S AP7¥_ZVPXm` `bO`aN[aVNY `aNSS `U¥_aNTR N[Q a¥¥X `aR]` a¥ NZRYV¥_NaR aUNa V[NQR^bNPf Of% S¥_ V[`aN[PR% ]_¥]R_Yf a_NV[V[T P¥__RPaV¥[NY ¥SSVPR_` ¥_ QV`PV]YV[V[T aURZ S¥_ cV¥YNaV[T aUR ReV`aV[T aUR ]¥YVPVR`' "8Xa' B¥' -*&0 Na *,2&--'# 199 &5EG9E I# .BEE=F% */- :',Q /-*% /-/ "-aU 7V_' *222#' 7¥b[a Gd¥ V` aUR_RS¥_R [¥a QV`ZV``RQ N` a¥ 7N_aYRQTR V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf' 5` a¥ FaR]UN[m` V[QVcVQbNY YVNOVYVaf% NTNV[% aUR_R V` [¥ _RYRcN[a QV`]baR &/& ¥S ZNaR_VNY SNPa ORPNb`R Ab__Nf P¥[PRQR` UR dN` [¥a dN_QR[ b[aVY NSaR_ aUR NYYRTRQ NaaNPX' 7¥b[a GU_RR V` aUR_RS¥_R QV`ZV``RQ N` a¥ FaR]UN[ V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf' 0$ /PUOT 2PUR GPR @JPMBTJPO PG TIF =/>/- CX =/0/ F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N UN` TR[R_NYYf P¥[`R[aRQ a¥ `bVa S¥_ a¥_a PYNVZ` SVYRQ NTNV[`a Va aU_¥bTU R[NPaZR[a ¥S aUR F7G75' %E=;;F I# 1BHG< &5EB?=A5 '9CNG &BEEF#% B¥' *3*,&Pc&*,-1% +)*- J@ *+01*0,% Na $+* "8'F'7' AN_' +0% +)*-#4 F'7' 7¥QR 5[[' h *.&01&/)"+.#' G¥ QRSRNa aUV` ]_RZV`R% 8RSR[QN[a` N_TbR aUNa aUR _RP¥_Q Q¥R` [¥a _RSYRPa N[f QRYVOR_NaR V[QVSSR_R[PR Of F787 ¥[ aUR QNaR ¥S Ab__Nfm` N``NbYa' 5` dVaU Ab__Nfm` 9VTUaU 5ZR[QZR[a PYNVZ` NTNV[`a 7N_aYRQTR% aUR_R _RZNV[ QV`]baR` ¥S ZNaR_VNY SNPa N` a¥ dURaUR_ dUNa aUR E¥aU ER]¥_a YNORYRQ aUR jP¥[aV[b¥b` QRPYV[R V[ `aNSSV[T YRcRY`k aUNa dR_R jN P_VaVPNY P¥[PR_[ Na AP7¥_ZVPX S¥_ N[ ReaR[QRQ ]R_V¥Qk "8Xa' B¥' -*& 0 Na *,2#% P¥[`aVabaRQ aUR ON`V` S¥_ N[f T_¥`` [RTYVTR[PR Of F787' 199 $#/# 9K# 09?# %5M9E@5A I# )95I9E% B¥' )-&*./-.% +))1 J@ ,10)/20% Na $*+ "**aU 7V_' 5bT' +*% +))1# "jK8LRYVOR_NaR V[QVSSR_R[PR _R^bV_R` N ZbPU UVTUR_ `aN[QN_Q ¥S SNbYa aUN[ ZR_R ¥_ RcR[ T_¥`` [RTYVTR[PRK'Lk#' :¥_ aUR`R _RN`¥[`% aUR 7¥b_a NQ¥]a` aUR ANTV`a_NaR >bQTRm` _RP¥ZZR[QNaV¥[ a¥ QR[f `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a N` a¥ 7¥b[a :¥b_' 5@$ /PODMUSJPO :¥_ aUR S¥_RT¥V[T _RN`¥[`% aUR 7¥b_a -0:;>= aUR E ! E "8Xa' B¥' -1# N` aUR ¥_QR_ ¥S aUR 7¥b_a' 8RSR[QN[a`m Z¥aV¥[ S¥_ `bZZN_f WbQTZR[a "8Xa' B¥' ,0# V` 3<-9>10 59 ;-<> BOE 019510 59 ;-<>' 7¥b[a C[R% `RRXV[T V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS b[QR_ h *21, NTNV[`a 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR N[Q 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ V[ RNPUm` ¥SSVPVNY N[Q V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaVR`% N` dRYY N` a¥ 8RSR[QN[a F787% V` EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a C[R% `RRXV[T V[Wb[PaVcR _RYVRS b[QR_ F'7' 7¥QR 5[[' h *.&-,&,) N` a¥ 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR% 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ N[Q 8RSR[QN[a F787% V` EJSNJSSFE' &0& 7¥b[a Gd¥% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR N[Q 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR`% V` EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a Gd¥% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf% V` OPT EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a Gd¥% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf% V` EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a GU_RR% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of `b]R_cV`¥_f YVNOVYVaf N` a¥ 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR N[Q 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ V[ aURV_ ¥SSVPVNY PN]NPVaVR`% V` EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a GU_RR% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of `b]R_cV`¥_f YVNOVYVaf N` a¥ 8RSR[QN[a 7N_aYRQTR V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf% V` OPT EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a GU_RR% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S -+ H'F'7' h *21, Of `b]R_cV`¥_f YVNOVYVaf N` a¥ 8RSR[QN[a FaR]UN[ V[ UV` V[QVcVQbNY PN]NPVaf% V` EJSNJSSFE' 7¥b[a :¥b_% NYYRTV[T cV¥YNaV¥[ ¥S aUR F7G75 Of 8RSR[QN[a F787% V` OPT EJSNJSSFE' -90 5> 5= =: :<01<10$ `( EVPUN_Q AN_X ;R_TRY EVPUN_Q AN_X ;R_TRY H[VaRQ FaNaR` 8V`a_VPa >bQTR >bYf *% +)+) 7UN_YR`a¥[% F¥baU 7N_¥YV[N &1&
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
