Thomasson v. Premo et al, No. 6:2014cv01788 - Document 95 (D. Or. 2017)

Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER. For the reasons stated in this Opinion and Order, I GRANT Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment 82 and DISMISS Mr. Thomasson's claims with prejudice. Signed on 06/02/2017 by Judge Michael W. Mosman. (rs)

Download PDF
Thomasson v. Premo et al Doc. 95 U I E S A E DS RC C U T NT D T T S I TI T O R F RT EDS RC O O E O O H I TI T F R G N E G N D VS O U E E I II N J R I HT OM S O , E EM A H A S N v . N 6 4 v078 O o : - -18-M . 1c Pi i, l nf a tf OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E J F P EM ,tl E F R Oe a, . D edn. e na s f t M SM NJ O A,., M To a o b ns w ci s g n D ena sb hetdoaee v lin r h ms n r gt ol m aa s e dn, o r a t l gdi a os . s i a it f t t le l ot o h cni t n r h. D edn fe a M in o S m ay ug e [2 ag nta fi ost i a i t e na si d o o fr u m Jd mn 8] ru gh s tuo l g s f t l t r t , i t te a e ietjd mnite fvr n o o M To a o sl m M To a o hyr nt doug e nh rao o b h f r h ms n ci s r h ms n e tl t i t . s a . . s rsoddn pot n 8]adD edn rpe[0 Frhraost e b o, epnei opsi [7 n e na se i 9] oteesnstd e wI io , f t ld . a l G A TD edn M in o S m ay ug e [2 R N e na s o o fr u m Jd mn 8] f t t r t . B C G O N A K R U D M To a oi ai m e ev g sn new hh O gnDp t e o r h ms ns nn a s i ae ec i te r o ea mn f . s t rn t t e r t Cr c os O O) Hi cr n y osdn a sp mxfci i F r a nea o ein( D C es u e l huei rt . rt ue a al yn l i ud n r it od r are e b we O gn n F r a u unt a I et eCr c osC ma. M g mn e en r o ad l i pr a o n n r a o ein o pc r e t t e od s t t st rt t . 1 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E Dockets.Justia.com To a oi o C s Mng mn stsnF r aad s rs th ci s es e i h ms ns n l e aae e t ui l i , n a aeu, el m hi h dn s o t a od l a l s i riot n o 2 hu a a ot ys a o fr 3 or dy la li s . P ot M To a o srn et F r a h ws osdn d i s a v sg gin r ro r h ms n t s ro l i , e a huei a m irie er a o i . s af od nt t et aa r oi O gn H ci s ews osdh e o 2 dy b o hrc vd n ie f t psnn r o el m h a huete fr 6 as e r eee e a oc o i e . a r fe i t ha n o Fbu y 321 W l M To a o de n d p e h hrc vd h e ig n era 1 04 he r h ms n os o i u ta eee ete r r , . i . s t st t i n ieh bivstws e c nbcuetws drset ao ei mt Ae dy a e oc e eeei a d i e easi a ad sdo n h n ae f w asf r t , l fi t e tr . t h ha n M To a o wsrn e et F r a i e ig r h ms n a t s r do l i . s r , . s a fr od Teesn bh d M To a o stynd i s a v sg gin rrn et a hraos e n r h ms n s ia m irie er ao ot s ro i . s a nt t et af st pne i y nF r ar n ai u it s ae Rg d s oteesn M t e e tna i l i a o ts e nh cs ea l s fhraos r a i tr od e t s i . re , . To a o ci sh D edn hv v l e h Fu en A ed e poeu l u h ms nl mta e na s aei a d i or e h mn mn rcdr de s a t f t ot s t t t a poe r h b () uigii s i r cn n mn w hu ep nin()aigo rcs i t y 1 p t h n ot y of e e i o s gs t n m la i t t t x aa o 2fl t l t , in po d h mw h dqa n ie f ha n ad 3t n eigi t F r aw hua rv ei i aeu e o c oa e ig n ()r s r n h mo l i i o i t t t r , a fr od t t ha n I adin M To a o ci sh tern e hs mee h acstte e ig n d t , r h ms nl mta ht s r ai pddi ce oh r . io . s a t af s s cus eas h de n hv acst O gn a m e a i F r a w c v l e h or bcue e os o ae ce o r o l w a rl n l i , h hi a si t t s e ti s o d i ot s cni t n r h. ost i a i t tuo l g s M To a o seso o sv aid iua cne ette rgnDp t e o r h ms n ekt h d ee ln v l onc doh O o ea mn f . s l r id s t e r t Cr c osib frh aee vot n o h cni t n r h. Se f a yh b ns o einl l otel gdili s fi ost i a i t pci l, e r g rt ae l ao s tuo l g s i cl i ci s g n () e P m teSp i ednoa O gnt ePsn()C l eS l m aa s 1J f r o h ue n ne f n r o St r o 2 oe . a it f e , rt t e a i , lt P e,h D e o o Cr c os sh O g nDp t e o Cr c os()Du Yne a e r te i c r f o ein ate r o ea mn f o ein 3 og acy ts rt rt e r t rt , , m me oteScr yTra Mng mn U iaa O gnSt Psnad 4 M he F e b fh eut h t aae e n tt n r o t e r o n () i a . r i e t e a i , c l G w,h A i a D e o o Cr c osth O gnDpt e o Cr c os B h o e te s s n i c r f o ein ate r o ea mn f o ein o r st t r t rt e r t rt . t ci sr bog aa sa fuid iu s nh r e oaad f cl aat l m a ruh g n l orn v a ite p sn n oi acpc y a e t it l idl i r l fi i. 2 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E L G LS A D R E A T N A D S m ay ug e i poe i temvnso sh te i n gn n d p e so u m jd mn s rp f h oa h wta h es o eu ei u at r t r t t r i st aym e afcadh mvni e iet jd mna amt ol w Fd R C.P n a rla nte oa s nt do ug e s ae fa. e . i . ti t t tl t tr . v 5(.Teni bre fr mt n os m ayug e i otemv g a yodnf 6 ) hi tl udn oa o o fr u m jd mn s nh o n p ttie iy a ia i r t i r t te bec oa eu esu o m e afc C o xCr v C rt 47US3733 h asne f gn ni e f a rla.e t op . a e , 7 .. 1 2 i s ti t l e . tt , (96 Octabreisiid h bre s f tte o- o n p tt d mnr e 18) neh udns as e te udn ht oh nn mv g a yo e os a, . t tf , is i r tt truhh pouin f v ecltdnFd.C.P5( () tate r m n a hogte rdc o oe dnei ei e R i . 6 )1 h h ee a s t i s . v c , t r i gn ni ufrrl C o x 47USa34 Te o- o n p t my or y pnh eu es e ot a e t , 7 ..t 2 h nn mv g a y a n e uote i s i. l e . i r tl p a n aea osB no v L d Rs J n Vn r , 3F d 0414 ( hC. 95 l d gl gin r sn. i a oe o t e ue 5 . 14 09 9 i 19) ei l t , i n i t 3 , t r (t gFd R C.P 6 ) o uspo e cn c r ocn uoyt e e s Hradz ci e . i 5( ) r nupr d o e u r oc sr st mn, enne in . v e, t jt e l a t vSae b MdIc 33F d 1711 ( hC. 03 A raoa e ob ad . pc as e n , 4 . 10 12 9 i 20) l esnb du s n l . . 3 , t r . l l t if ecso e r w fo tea srt b v wdnhl h mtao b tte on rnet b d nr mhfc a o e i eitei t o fvr l oh nn e a t e e g s ae mv g a y M ss t E cIds C,L..Zn hRd Cr 45US5457 18) o n p t a uh a l . nu o t v e t a o op 7 .. 7 8 (96 i r. t i e . . d i i ., , . DS U S O I C SI N M To a o b ns w ci s g n D edn.I Ci I M To a o r h ms n r gt ol m aa s e na s n l m, r h ms n . s i a it f t a . s aeeta D edn v l e h poeu l u poesih ud teFu en l gsh e na si a di rcdr de rcsr t ne h or e h l t f t ot s a gs r t t A ed e .I Ci I M To a o aeet a D edn v l e h Fs Fu had mn mn n l mI r h ms nl gs ht e na si a di it or, n t a , . s l f t ot s r, t Fu en A ed e r h b f l go rv ei w h ce t air yw hm e a o or e h mn mn i t ya i t po d h m i acs o l a i a rl n t t t gs in i t s b r t ti s O gna,h ey brc n hs ce tte or. D edn agehyr e iet r ol w e b os uigi acs oh cus e na srute a nt do e tr t t s t f t e tl s m ayug e o b hl m bcue M To a o hsae t so tate v l e u m jd mn n o ci s eas r h ms n afld o h w h hy i a d r t t a . s i t ot h cni t n r h. Ee ite i aa u d p e s owe ete v l e M i ost i a i t vn fh es fc a i u at h h hyi a d r s tuo l g s r tl st tr ot . To a o s ost in r h,D edn agete a e iet qaf d m u t Fr h ms n cni t a i t e na sru hyr nt do ui ei mn y o s tuo l g s f t e tl li i. teesn epie b o, f dh D e a sr e iet s m ayug e o b h hraos x a d e wIi ta e n n a nt do u m jd mn n o ln l n t f d t e tl r t t 3 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E ci s BcueD edn a e iet s m ayug e otem i otel m I o l m eas e na sr nt do u m jd mn nh et fh ci s d a . f t e tl r t rs a , n cn d we ete a e iet qaf d m u t o os e h h hyr nt do ui ei mn y t ir tr e tl li i. I . Poe ua DePoe V lt n rcdr u rcs i a os l s oi M To a o age D edn v l e h poeu l u poe r h b () r h ms nrus e na si a d i rcdr de rcs i t y 1 . s f t ot s a s gs p t gi i s i r cn n mnfr 6 asw huep nt n r dqa n ie f ui h mn ot y of e e o 2 dy i o x aa o oaeu e oc oa tn la i t t t l i t t ha n ad 2sn n h mo psnnF rd we hr m ni s i riot n e ig n () ed gi t a r oi l ia h e ee a sn ot ys a o r , i i o , r i la li . D edn agehyr e iet s m ayjd mn o t slm ne b hho e e na srute a nt do u m f t e tl r ug e n h ciud o ter s t i a r t i bcue M To a o hsaet so te v l e a r e el e y n rs e h ud eas r h ms n afldo h whyi a d po c di r i e t i e ne . s i ot t t b t t e, t r r teDePoe C uete o ud stl w SeL F u v No ,:2C -03-I21 h u rcs l si l r ne t ea. e al r. o h 2 - V067S 04 s a sf ra e t 1 , W 1318a* (.O M. 521) Te DePoe C ue fh Fu en L 263 t 3 D r a 2 04( h u rcs l s ote or e h , . r , s a t t A ed e po c l e yn rssh as e h ud teluete o ud stl w mn mn r e si r i e t ta r ei e ne h c si l r ne t ea. t t t bt t e ti tr r a sf ra (t g hpe v Mnevl , 0 F d 0216 ( hC. 03. Frhf l w g ci Capl. adrl 76 . 15 02 9 i 21) ote o oi in l ie 3 , t r ) l n raos M To a o hsaet so taD edn v l e ai e y n rsc a d esn r h ms n afldo h wh e na si a d l r i e tr t , . s i tf t ot b t t e ee ud teDePoe C uete o ud s tl w Asc IG A T u m yug e ne h u rcs l si l r ne t ea. s uh R N s m a jd mn r s a sf r a , r t i D edn fvr nCi I n e na s ao o l m. f t a ADePoe V l i nA sn Fo teC uete . u rcs i a o ri g r m h l s I l s ot i a sf TeDePoe C uente de n po ceey hne nh cn t n o h u rcs l sii l os o r e v cag ite odi s f s a sf t tt r io cn n mn hv g sb a i av si pcote r oe Sn n.Cne 55US of e e a n a us na de e ma nh psn. ad v onr 1 .. i t i t tl r t i r i , 4248 19)ca o o ie)selo Wk sn.As n 55US2921 20) 7 7 (95(tin mtd e a , it t ; s ii o v ui, 4 .. 0 2 (05 ln t , ( Th Cni t nte de n g eieo l e yn rsi ao igrn et mr []e ost i i l os o i r t ai r i e tn v d t s ro o tuo sf t v s bt t e in af e av s cn t n ocn n mn (tin mtd. S n n a n i de n cn r de e odi s f of e e. ca o o ie) t d gl e t os o of a r io i t it t ) a i o, t e l e yn rsi f eo fo te odin o dg e f of e e od al cn m a d i r i e tnr d mr mh cn t s r er ocn n mn r n i o e pt bt t e e io e i t i ry t l e b a r o sn ne L F u, 04 W 1318a* selo ad , 1 USa40 y psn e ec i t . al r 21 L 263 t 3 e a Sn n 55 ..t 8 e , ; s i 4 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E (x a igh teDePoe C ue cn r nl e yn rsi f eo fo st ain epi nta h u rcs l s of s oi r i e t nr d mr mt e c o ln t s a e bt t e e a t tknw h tec m a sn ne moe (tin mtd( t n qot nm k ae i i h[ i i l e eci psd ca o o ie)i e a u a o a s tn r n] t . it t n r l ti r o ie) [ ]ln ate odin o dg e f of e e t w cte r oei mtd. A og s h cn t s r er ocn n mn o h hh psn s t ) s io e i t i i r sb c dsw h te e eci psd pni ..h Dercs C ue os oii e u e ei i i h sn ne moe uo h m.te u Poe l s de n nt l jt tn t s a t sf sb cai m e t a mnb psn u ot sou cl v s h Capl 76F dt u e nn a sr t e y r o a hri tjdi oei t hpe , 0 . a jt t e t i t ie i a r g. l 3 16 (u ig o ay v Hy e 47US2622 17) 03 qo n Mn ne. a ms, 2 .. 3 4 (96. t t , ) A r oe srn et am x m m eut fci oa r o w hmr bres m psn t s r o ai u scr yal y r psn i o udno e i r af i it i t e cn t ni w h te o m l ms rag o cs d taat emy moe n n i e odi ss i i h nr a i i orne f u oy h st ai ps ad o t l io tn l t t t a t sf a u poe v lin Sn na48ca o o ie) T ss o eas eei l en n de rcs i a o ad , 7 (tin mtd h is bcue vnf i i oe s ot . i t it t . i f psnsmc mr d areb ta i ao e sc c c m acs o ote s vs r o i uh o i g a e hn n n h, uhi u s ne d n h me e i e s e l tr r t t l i pc e Fu en A e mnl e y n rs Mah m.Fn 47US2525 17) m ia a or e h mn e i r i e t ecu v ao, 2 .. 1 2 (96 l t t t d t b t t e. , ( T n e b weist in..r mdfr v i y fesn ad f nno e omr r s r e enni t s. a ae o a a e oraos n o eiv v n o a fs t tuo e rt t l e ta ifr e p dt n at wa wu [ bss vist in scr y r h s e ad hn no md r ii s s o h o d] e e e ni t a eut ote a t n e co t l t r tuo l i fy w f e fhi m e) seloO m. Wk eoa 41US28 4-6 18)ao ig e a ote n a. ; e a l v a nkn, 6 .. 3 254 (93(dp n lr t s i i , t Mah m frn r a t n e ad x a igh a i m e a njsfb epct n. ecu oi et er s r n epi nta n n a hs oui ae xe a o.. t st a f s ln t t til ti tah wl ena e tdn n p t urSt ) S ma y e pr y lc mni h e i bic c a i ay ai l t e. i i r , mo r p e e n t l r re rc a a ll t a a t a m irie ergin os oi e cni t a u poe v lin My.B di d i s a v sg a o de n t l ost e de rcs i a o a v a w nt t et t sf tu s ot . l n, 19F d 5 55 9 C. 97 0 . 57 6 ( h i 19) 3 , t r . H eud Mah m,ad , i , nMy,tslata M To a o sl m e, ne ecu Sn nO m ada ii c rh r h ms n ci s r r i l e t . s a gonei h p c mni a m irie ergin nt n et F r a o o s n n ruddni l e e n d i s a v sg a o adr s ro l i d n,t d g s a t nt t et af od t ai a n r e o hlv oa ost in de rcs v lin Acr n y D edn a l e i t teee f cni t a u poe i a o cod g , e na sr o,s l tuo l s ot . il f t e e ietjd mna amtr fa o Ci I n htertate v l e M nt doug e s ae ol w n l m o te hoyh hyi a d r tl t t a t ot . 5 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E To a o sFu en A ed e poeu lde rcsr h s m y ylc gi i h ms n or e h mn mn rcdr u poe i t i p b p i h mn s t t t a s gs l an a m irie ergin ntet n eigi t F r a d i s a v sg a o adhnr s r n h mo l i . nt t et a fr od B S t Ce e L e y n rs . t e ra d i r It e s a- t bt e t Ud c t ni u s ne stsmyraeie y n rs taa e ie t ne e a c c m acs t e a c t l r i e t h r nt d o r ri r t , a e b t t e s t e tl po c o bteDePoe C ue Sn n 55USt 8-4 St c a die yn rs r ein yh u rcs l s ad , 1 .. 438 t e r t l r i e t tt s a . i a . a- e e bt t es as wetet ei psstp aadinia h dh oten a i r a otte r e hnh st moe a i l n s i cn a s p nhi m enet noh i a yc gf t r i t li od ayn dn o psni. I a44 I sc css h DePoe C ueeu e r n ic e s f r ol e d t 8 n uh ae te u rcs l srq rs ir i t i f . . , s a i m i u poeu s.tisrtatet e ra dihi n abr i arg e i m m rcdr ..onu h h st c t r ts o r t r y boa d n e e t a- e e g t i al t. Mah m, 7 USa26ca o o ie) n ra qot n m k o ie) ecu 42 ..t 2 (tin mtd( t n u a o a s mtd it t i e l ti r t . []e i n s g s nad o d e m i we ea r o h dhpstp aad Th es oi l t d fr e r i n h h psn a sii a i l n r ne a r t ng t r i r yc s nia adh aa s . .eu e cs b cs fc b fccn d a o Capl 76 i i cn nta n y s . rq rs ae y ae a ya os e t n hpe , 0 gf t t li i , t t i ri . l F dt 04ca o o ie)i en qot nm k o ie) Tee fcss n a . a16 (tin mtd( t a u a o a s mtd hts oue o n 3 it t n r l ti r t . t ea ia o ote adh cue bte r o s hlne ainet eoh bs x m t n fh h s p asd yh psn caegd c o r a vtte a c ni r i i l t li i cn t n ol e s psn. Mce v Dp k, 5F d 1 52 9 C. 96( t n odi s fi a a r oe i hl. un 7 . 57 2 ( h i 19)i e a io f i r t l i 3 , t r nr l qot nm k o ie) u a o a s mtd ti r t . TeN t C c t aie iidh em k sbsd nad , o d e m igwe e h i h i u hsdnf etr a e, ae oSn n fr e r i n h h n ri t e rr i t n tr a adh i a p aadinia i r aotte r n yn dn o psni. h s pst i l n s i cn net noh od a ic e s f r ol e r i yc g f t li ir i t i f Capl 76F dt 04Fs cus os e we e te odin ocn n mn hpe , 0 . a16 it or cn d l 3 . r, t i r h h h cn t s f of e e tr io i t mrrdhs cn t ni psd pnn a sn n oosic t n y of e e i o toe odi s moe uoi m ei aa gu d ri a cn n mn r e io t l s eo r i t st g I a16-5i en qot nm k o ie) T ssy cl aa - tn v ei s d t 046 ( t a u a o a s mtd h itp a y fci es e tn . . n r l ti r t . i il tn i iq rtarq rs bd oe dne o e o mh c ma t e n y s Se ad n 55 nu yh eu e a oy f v ect p fr te o p a v aa s. e Sn i, 1 i t i i r ri li l USa458 (odc n aa - tn v aa s s o p ighi m eis e n o s e ..t 8-6cnuig fci es e n y i c ma nten a sn d ad ui t tn i l r t i td te hlne cn t n. Sc dcusokth drin ni es y fh cn t n h caegd odi s e n or lo ate u t adn nt ote odi s l io ) o , t ao t i io 6 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E ocn n mn Capl 76F dt 05 T r telo a we ete hnen f of e e. hpe , 0 . a16 h d hyokt h h h cagi i t l 3 . i, tr cn n mn wu ie tb a e te u t n fte r oe ssn ne I of e e o d nva yf c h dri o[ psn ] e ec i t l i l ft ao h i r t . d . M To a o agetatei m acs u on n h p c mni r h ms nrush h c cu s ne sr ud gi l e e n . s t r t r i s a t a m irie erginha n adrn et F r aw ea p aad asd s nia d i s a v sg a o e ig nt s ro l i e t i l n cue ai i cn nt t et , r , af od r y c gf t h dh i r a otte r n yn dn o psni.A aeu, eas h ws o a s pnet noh od a ic e s f r ol e s rs tbcue e a n r i li ir i t i f l t a odd o e u poe, erusD edn ain h d e h st c a die y f re s m de rcs h age e na s c osi e di t e r t l r f s f t t n r s a- e e bt i e s adi a d fi DePoe R h. A epie b o, f dh M To a o n r t n v l e o h u rcs i t s x a d e wIi ta r h ms n t es ot s s gs ln l n t . s hsaet so h s yn d i s a v sg gin nt n et F r anoe at e afldo h wi t i a m irie er a o adr s ro l i ivkd st i sa nt t et af od ac a die yn rsrq r g o e u poes Asc h ws oe iet s m de r t l r i e teui s m de rcs s uh e a n nt do o e u e e bt t e in . , t tl poe b o toe c os cu e Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ay rcs e r hs ain ocr d cod g, e na sr nt do u m s fe t r. il f t e tl r jd mno Ci I netehoyh te vl e D edns u poe r h bsd n ug e n l m ud hterta hyia d e na de rcs i t ae o t a r t ot f t s gs at e ra die yn rs st c t l r i e t a - e e b t t e. 1 A ii rt eSgea o . dmnta v ergt n s i i I gn a a m irie erginn n oi e de n i pc e po c d n ee l d i s a v sg a oi ad ft l os o m ia a r e e r, nt t et sf t l t tt l e y n rs Srao.Fac , 4 F d 0117 ( hC. 03 Fr x m ea i r i e t e n v rn s 35 . 17 08 9 i 20) oea p, b t t e. r i 3 , t r . l r a v y r ftynic l ay ergin os o ii e,noe l e yn rs et e b es i d i i r sg a o de n,nt l ivk ai r i e t li l i a s pn et t sf b t t e. Sn n 55USa46epi ntaa 0dyt d n ivk aie yn rs; e a o ad , 1 ..t 8 (x a igh 3-a syi o noe l r i e t sel i ln t a d t b t t e) s R hrsn.Rne , 9 F d 6 62 9 C. 00(x a igh fte dy o i ado v un s 54 . 66 7 ( h i 21)epi nta i en as f c l 3 , t r ln tf sg gini n cni t a a p aadinia h dh i r a o t te r n y er a o d o ost e nt i l n s i cn a s p net n o h od a et d t tu yc gf t r i li ir ic e s f r ol e B aid i t drinns a o oanr a y a h odin n dn o psni ) u nne ne u t iio t n r bo ml h s cn t s i t i f. t fi ao li l r io my as a a p aadinia h dh. Se Wk sn 55USa24 Ide a cue nt i l n s i cn a s p e ii o, 4 ..t 2 ned yc gf t r i ln . , 7 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E cn t nta wu o e w ei a teE h A ed e wu i ps a a p aad odi sh o dt ri v l eh i t mn mn o d moe nt i l n io t l h s ot gh t l yc s nia h dh . Kea v H l 8 F d 0318 ( hC. 96 i i cn a s p enn. a , 3 . 18 09 9 i 19) gf t r i1 l 3 , t r . I L F u, oea p,h Cu h dh ai m ewows osd n d i s a v n al r fr x m e i or e ta nn a h a hue i a m irie e l ts t l t t nt t sg gin o 8 dy w hua e ig wihi a d nO gneut nd n er a o fr 6 as i o ha n hc v l e a r o rg a o i o et t t r , ot e li , d t ep ine ntp aadinia h dh c ma d o h od ay n dn o h l e n xe ec a a i l n s i cn a s p o p e t te r n ic e s f i i i r yc gf t r i r ir i t sf psn 21 W 1318a* JdeS mn ae h h d g nhfc ta M LF u s r o 04 L 263 t 5 ug i o bsd i o i otea sh r al r i . , . s ln t t . e sg ginws oid i t adh cn t n o h s yn d i s a v sg ginw e er a o a n ne ne nte odi s fi t i a m irie er a o e et t fi io sa nt t et r r a v y o m.I et e nr a d li l l . S ma yh e M To a o hs oaee fc fo w c oe o d oc d h i i r, e, r h ms n a n l gda sr m h h n cu cn uei ll r . s tl t i l l s p c mni a m irie ergin ost e a a p aadinia h dh, uh l e e n d i s a v sg a o cni td nt i l n s i cn a s psc a t nt t et tu yc gf t r i taiivkd st c a di r i e s Ud teit hpe fc r M To a o h tnoe at e r t l e yn r t ne hfsCapl a o r h ms n t a - e e bt t e. r r l t, . s hs ostda so ugs te c acn t ni a m irie erginw en l a e a n t e fc t sge h a u odi s n d i s a v sg a o e i o rb ta t t t l io nt t et r te l c ma doh od ay odin o psni. Ud te eodhpe fc r h o p ette r n cn t s f r ol e ne h scnCapl a o te r ir io i f r l t, drinwset e so. H wsn ot y of e e fr 8 as w cir a v y ut a o ar a v y hr e ai s i r cn n mn o 2 dy h hset e li l t la i t , i li l so ad oln eog bi e tivk aie yn rs F a yud teh da o hr n n og nuh yt l onoe l r i e t i l, ne ht r fc r t t sf b t t e. nl r i t, te i n e dneo h wh M To a o slc mni a m irie ergin h es o v ect so t t r h ms n p e e n d i s a v sg a o r i a . s a t nt t et e eddhln h fiic c a o Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ay x neteeg o h na e t n cod g, e na sr nt do u m t t s r ri . il f t e tl r I m esieo ee c sgeig h te odint w c i m ei s i r cn n mna sb c d a snt t rsa h ugs n ta h cn t so h h n a sn ot y of e e r u e e iv r t t io i t la i t e jt o e lat poon pyh o c p ifrhi m ead s uh h ue f ot y of e e i e my f nedo rfud sco g a el oten a, n asc te s os i r cn n mn t l a t l il r t , la i t sf i pc e nE h A ed e v linSeR z.Txs 17S C 14 (07(ry,.d sn n) a s m ia a i t mn mn i a o e u v ea, 3 . t 26 21) B e J i e ig Dv l t gh t ot . i . er , s t ; i v Aa , 3 S C 28 (05( end J cnuig( su ig [ h h mno wog b e edde m . y a 15 . t 17 21) Kney . ocr n) d cs n t e u a t l ruh y x net s l . ,, r i s ] l t t r oiot n ;A xKz s, o eTa Da 15Y eL. ou 20213 (06( cu igee c fs a o ) l o nk Wr hn e h, 2 a . Fr m 3 3-3 21)r on n rsa h li e i i s t l J , e t r rg d ghi pc s i r cn n mnhs n r oe ad o n iso d o e s o upsta ea i te ma s ot y of e e a o psn s n n ig t hu c m a n srr eh rn t la i t i r t l i t ic c a o i s i r cue ] ee eaebin reu ec o p e s n i ns ote pe ac oa na e t nn ot y as ssv e xc a o or r ne f r xt gl e, rh apa ne f n r ri la [ r rt cr e ii l s r au mnll e iid iu swo a p v u y enre f n sc i ns (tin mtd. B t ss c e e ai ns nn v a h hd r i s be f oay uhl e t t l s idl e ol e l s ca o o ie) u h i it t ) ti n tea otead Se Wk sn.As n 55USa242 (o ntaln- r s i r cn n mn o hl w fhln e ii o v ui, 4 ..t 2-5 n igh og e m ot y of e e t . ln t t t t la i t i e i n ucni t n ) e a oH t v F ny 47US6865 17)epi n tas i r t l s o nost i a; el u o. i e, 3 .. 7 8 (98(x a igh ot y sf t tuo l s s t n , ln t la cn n mn w l afr o pn h e sb ct s u n ud E h A ed e s nad i n i e of e e, he o m f u s mn u e o c t y ne i t mn mn t d s s o t l i t i i t j t ri r gh t a r, t sf ucni t n ) nost i a. tuo l 1 8 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E jd mn o tel mh p t g M To a oi a m irie ergin o 2 dy ug e n h ci ta ui r h ms nn d i s a v sg a o fr 8 as t a t tn . s nt t et w hua e igi a di poeu l u poe r h ud teFu en A ed e . i o ha n v l e h rcdr de rcs i t ne h or e h mn mn t t r ot s a s gs r t t t 2 Ha n . er g i M To a o agetate e ig e c vdw li a m irie ergin r h ms nrush h ha n hree e hen d i s a v sg a o . s t r i i nt t et wsndqa. B, eas M To a o ws o e iet de rcsfri b es yn aiaeu e u bcue r h ms n a n nt do u poe o h r ft i t t . s t tl s si a a m irie ergina epie aoeh ws oe iet a e r gtl Tu d i s a v sg a o s x a d bv e a n nt do h a n aa. hs nt t et , ln , t tl i l , a m irie r rcdr e o tah aee ocr dt h ha n cnos v ate d i s a v o poeu lr r h el gs cu e ate e ig an e e sh nt t a rs t l r r t r bs fr v lin fh Fu en A ed e sDePoe C ue a s oai a o ote or e h mn mn u rcs l s i ot t t t s a . Ee i M To a o hd h w ta hs odini a m irie ergin vnf r h ms n a so n h i cn t sn d i s a v sg a o . s t io nt t et cni td ntp aadinia h dh, ntui pc e a r e el e yn rs ost e a a i l n s i cn a s padhs m ia d po c di r i e t tu yc gf t r i l t t t b t t e, h hsaet so h ws oa odd h m i a de rcsrq rd u n h e afldo h w e a n f re te i m u poe eu e dr g i i tf n l s i i s a m irie ergin e ig [ ]e rcsrq rs rcdr po c os eo a d i s a v sg a o ha n nt t et r . Du poe eu e poeu l r ein b r s i a tt fe psnn a cn e er e oa r e el e yn rs Spr tne, Ms Cr Is r oi m e a b dp vd f po c di r i e t ue n dn a. o. n. i t i t t b t t e. ie t s r t , W p e.Hl, 7 US4543 18)B oi a mso y p o dten a w h a o v i 42 .. 4 5 (95 u f cl u n ll l , . t fi s t l rv ehi m e i i t t s m n ie fh cags g n h m n a opr n yo rsnh v wtte r o o e oc ote h e aa s i ad n po u tt p e i i soh psn t r it ti e t s e i oi acagd Bue.Yt 31F d 2318 ( hC. 03(tin mtd( t n f cl h e fi r . rc v i , 5 . 18 27 9 i 20)ca o o ie)i e a s 3 , t r it t nr l qot nm k o ie) I adinoi a mshv s m e dnet spo te u a o a s mtd. n d t , f cl u ae o e v ec o upr h r ti r t ) i o fi s t i t i ud l n dcinomv ai m en a m irie ergin Hl 42US t 5-6 ne y g e s t oe nn a i o d i s a v sg a o i , 7 .. 455 ri io t t nt t et . l a ( Thr ea qeinswe ete i ay v eciteeodh cu spo te []ee vn us oi h h h es n e dnenhrcrta o d upr h l t t tr r i t l t cn u o ) oc s n . li . M To a o age h ws opo ddwi m i ade rcs bcue n h r h ms nrus e a n rv e . s t i t i m u poe eas ao e h n l s tr i m e n m wswt n n i n ie f e ig A aeu, erus ews nb t n a s a e a rt o h oc o ha n s rs th age h a ua e o t ie s t r . l l p snfc o m e a w nset poeiincne D edn cnee h mtk r e a s r a rl i e so rv h noec e na s ocdt s i ae e t t ti t s s . f t i s 9 OI I NA DO D R PNO N R E ocr db te sttero wsie oteeodth ha n M To a o age cu e u hyt eh e r af d nh rcr ate e ig r h ms nrus r, t a r x r . . s tai n tu Rg d s ayorp c e o bi e i n a ui e aea o fr de h s o re ea l s tpg h a r r yt l s o sf c n l gin oa u t t . r e, a il r sf t fi t l t poe v lin M To a o de n aee ed n aedh han otah d n rcs i a o r h ms n os o l g h i o t nte e i rh ei o s ot . . s tl d tt rg t d t rc v ay oc oteesn frisg gin Mrf d mnl, e os oaee ee e n n ie fhraos o h er a o i t s e t . o u a e a yh de n l g en tl tl tahtog te e ig ocws oi edd o h mtl ad e os oepi wy e h ehuh h ha n n iea n n ne fri aa, n h de n x a h h t t r t tt l t ln ws nb t p snha n oi a w h fc o w nseate e ig a ua eo r e e ig f cl i a s r i e s h ha n l e t r fi s t t t s t r . D edn hv a o rv e s m e dn eo uprte dcinolc M e na s ael po dd o e v e ct spo h r e s t p e r f t s i i t i io a . To a oi o d i s a v sg gin h wste u e oaivt a oi o psn h ms nn a m irie er a o e a h sb c f nnei t nn a r o s t nt t et jt s gi t i gn s os rct hv atf m meate r o a a td Rg d s o we e h ag cnp ayo ae s f e b th psn s ue ea l s f h h i i a r i sl . re tr s p tia oi p no sa t s f m me wsreh aeeiv v mni a os rc ai pinnl t a u at f e b atu i l gdno e e n cnp ay rc t a sl a r , sl l t i i s m e dnet spo te lc mn Tu M To a o hsae t so fc s o e v ec o upr h p e e . hs r h ms n afld o h wa s i t a t , . s i t fo w c auy o did ews oa odd m i a de rcs ah a m irie r m h h jr cu f h a n f re i m u poe ti d i s a v i l n tf n l s s nt t sg gin e igso d e ae en nt d o u poe aa. Acr n y D edn er a o ha n hu h hv be e ie t de rcs tl cod g, e na s et r , l tl s l il f t a e iet s m ayug e otehoyh te fldofod M To a o de r nt do u m jd mn nhterta hyaet a r r h ms n u e tl r t t i f . s poe wete gv h m n ie f ha ntan md n h i m e rcs hnhy aei a oc o a e igh a e ao e n a. s t r t tr t 3 Tas r oF rd . r n et l i a f o F a y M To a o aee h iv u ayrn et F r a ost e a i l , r h ms nl gsi no n rt s ro l i cni td nl . s l s lt af od tu dp vin fi poeu l u poe r h. Se f a y M To a o age h ws er a o o h rcdr de rcs i t pci l, r h ms nrus e a it s a s gs i cl . s e iet a r t n e ha n bfr h ws e t F r a nt do p - as r e ig eo e asn o l i . tl er f r e t od Bcue M To a o ws oe iet a r t n e ha n ud teDePoe eas r h ms n a n nt do p - as r e ig ne h u rcs . s t tl er f r r s C uete, s x a e aoe h ci cno y rcei h ws nt do u poe l si l a epi d bv t sl m a n poedf e a e iet de rcs a sf ln ,i a l tl s bsd n st c a die yn rs Se ad 55USa438 selo Wk sn 55 ae o at e r t l r i e t e Sn n 1 ..t 8-4 e a a - e e b t t e. i ; s ii o, 4 ln USa212 Ide a huh n e, M To a sn pe sol g tah cn t n o ..t 2-2 ned l og uc a r h m so apa t aee h i odi s f . ,t lr . r l t s io 1 OI I NA DO D R 0 PNO N R E cn n mni F r a ost e ntp aadinia h dh i c masno r n y of e e n l i cni t a a i l n s i cn a s pn o p iot od a i t od tu yc gf t r i r ir ic e s f r ol eadhs hy m ia a r e el e yn rs Se f a y M n dn o psni, ntu tei pce po c di r i ee. pci l, r i t i f , l t t t bt t t i cl . To a o agetah ws osdn ee l out nnO gnb i F r a e a h ms nrush e a huei gn a pp a oi r o u n l i h hs s t r li e , t od be a indo nl gd sp mx psn we h sed 2 hus dyn ot y en s get a aee ue a r o h e e pns 3 or a ai s i r s l r i , r la iot n M To a o aeet s odi oic c a o hs en moe fr n s a o r h ms nl gsh cn t n fna e t n a bei psd o a li . . s l i io r ri id i t p id fi ead erusts a h admrrsiiehnwaa O gn ne ne e o ot m n h ageii h se n o ert ta h n r o fi r , r r e tcv t e i m e o d e xe et edr Fr e m eh aee h p id f of e e ws n a cu b epc do nu. u h o, el gsi e o ocn n mn a t l t e tr r l s r i t e edd pnit n et F r a x ne uo h r s ro l i . t s af od Te pciter ud w c M To a o bssi ci i uc a Fr x m e h se f hoy ne h h r h ms n ae h l ms n e. oea p, ic r i . s s a lr l h my e ru gh h cn t n ocn n mni F r ar h sei c masnoh e a b ag nta i odi s f of e e n l i a a h n o p iotte i t s io i t od e r r r cn t n ocn n mntao ei m ei F r a xe ec Taci,nte, o d odi s f of e e h t rn a sn l i ep ine h l m i l cu io i t t h t od r . t a i sf l n b md aa spsn f cli O gnh wv, easte a n rsos lfr o e ae g n r o oi a n r o o ee bcuehyr o epn b o t it i fi s e , r e t ie M To a o s odin ocn n mni F r a nete n r a Cr c osC ma. r h ms n cn t s f of e e n lo d ud hI et e o ein o pc . s io i t i r t st rt t Se e St§ 2 25 21) I o e wrsso di cn t n ocn n mni F r a e Rv t. 41 4 (04 nt r od hu h odi s f of e e n l i . a . . h , l s io i t od v l ei cni t n r h, emsb n al m g n te rp oi a i F r a i a h ost i a i t h u r g c i aa s h poe f cl n l i . ot s t u o l g s ti a it r fi s od Sl M To a o cu p u b ci t ah ws nt do o e u poe tl r h ms n o d l s l l mht e a e iet s m de rcs i, . s l ai y a tl s b o h t n et F r a netehoyh D edn ke h wu ep ine e r i r s ro l i ud hterta e na s n w e o d xe ec fe s af od r t f t l r cn t n ocn n mnte tacni t a a p aadi i cnh dh i odi s f of e e h eh ost e nt i l n s nia a s pn io i t r t tu yc gf t r i c masnoi cn t n ocn n mni O gn Ide t ssh ci M To a o o p iot h odi s f of e e n r o ned h itel m r h ms n r s io i t e . ,i a . s se s o mki h A eddC m anad pot no u m yug e . e mt ae n i mne o p i n opsi t s m a jd mn s l t io r t I od t d e m ewe e M To a o srn ei psd ntp aad n re o e r i h h r h m sn t s r moe a a i l n r t n tr . s af yc s nia h dh o h mnet n o h od ayn dn o psni tah ep ine i i cn a s p ni i r a ot te r nric e s f r ol eh e xe ecd gf t r i li i i t i f t r i O gnImsap te h ea o ao ei Capl Teita orq rsmt nr o e , u p yhtr fc r dp dn hpe . hfsfc reu e e o t l e ts t l r t i 1 OI I NA DO D R 1 PNO N R E d e m ewe ete odin os i riot nnF r amrrh cn t ni psd e r i h h h cn t s f ot ys a oi l i i ote odi s moe t n tr io la li od r io uoi m ei aa gust g T b sr,ts n e h w algust g a pnn a sn n oos ei s o e u ii uc a o noos ei s r t l tn . e lr a tn e d ie ud t se. Se f a y ts oc a we eI hu lo as mast g o e nd ne h ts pci l , i n l r h h so dokti i r ei s f f ri t ic l i t e tr l l tn s i r cn n mni F r a r i i r eigi O gnI o onet as et s ot y of e e n l i o s mast sn r o d n edo n w h la i t od l tn e . t ri qeinh wv, eas M To a o hsae t aeea s h w gh h cn t n us o o ee bcue r h ms n afldol gfc soi ta i odi s t , r . s i l t n t s io ocn n mna a p a ad oe s nia h dh ud e h sea o f of e e r t i l n ps ai i cn a s p ne i e cn i i t e yc gf t r i rtr r. M To a o mks oc sr a eiosh n psn i O gnwu b r h ms n ae cn uoy s r nta o r oe n r o o d e . s l st t i r e l sb c doh e r m y a h n rsiie odin tah ep inei F r a nta u e ette x e e h s adert cn t s h e xe ecsn l i adh jt t l r tcv io t r od t cn n mn ud C s Mng mnstssn alsf a oi O gn B toe of e e ne l e aae e t ui o c si t nn r o u hs i t r o ta t a i ci e . t cn uoy sein a n spo e w ha s Fr x m e M To a o d n ceo oc sr a r osr o upr d i fc. oea p, r h ms ni o i t l st e t t t t l . s d tt O gnt u srg a oso p i e gv nnte s o nnue f ot ys a oi r o st e eut n r oc s oe i gh ue r o-s os i riot nn e a t , li , li r la li O gn W l h my eee ot ys a o i n uei O gn h er s m y oa s r o e . he e a biv s i riot n s o sdn r o te a i p n fc i l la li t e , r e l t t sb a i eh bi. Tte x nt t e eeete odin ocn n mni o us na ta ee oh e e h h bivsh cn t s f of e e n t tt t l f tt a l io i t s i riot nnO gnrls rsiie r ee tate odini F r ah aa ot ys a oi r o a e ert osv ehnh cn t sn l i , e g n la li e e s tcv r io od i fldol g aya souprtabi. Tte x n I hu c ma M To a o s aet aee n fc t spo h ee oh e e so d o p e r h ms n i l t t t lf tt l r . s cn t n ocn n mni s i riot notepsn snF r ah hsaet odi s f of e e n ot ys a ot o rr oe i l i , e afldo io i t la li h i r od i aee n fc t spo a ag mnta h isb c dotp acn t ni c masn l g aya s o upr nru e h e s u e et a i l odi sn o p io l t t t t jt yc io r t o e F r an a s A od g ,h er n fc t so ta M To a o s ot r l i i m e c r n y e a oa so h w h r h ms n h od t. c i l t r e t t . s cn t n ocn n mna a p ao h si c masnoh cn t ni aa gu odi s f of e e r t i l r a hn o p iotte odi sn n oos io i t e yc r r io l st g ei s tn . Ud te eodCaplfc rIokth drin ni es y f M ne h scn hpe a o lo ate ut adn nt o r r l t, ao t i . To a o s of e e i s i riot no e r iewe ete a a p ao h s h ms n cn n mn n ot ys a ot d e m s i t la li t n h h hyr t i l r a h tr e yc r. M To a o age h s yn s i riot ns ehpid i t I rs mt smas r h ms nrusi t i ot ys a oi p asne ne p u eh en . s sa la li r f i. e i 1 OI I NA DO D R 2 PNO N R E hi ua a oa a i w c h wl eeundo ee l out n M To a o a o es n w e f d en h h e i brtret gn app a o r h ms nl r t i l r li . . s s stsh hiiotd o 2 hu a a I g ew h M Toa ota O gn r o t eta ess a fr 3 or dy ar i r h msnh r o psn a t le s . e t . s t e i oi a my ae wdi s m de rcs bfrt n eigi t F r afhy n w f cl a hv o e h m o e u poe eo r s r n h mo l i ite ke fi s s e a fr od tah ws o go ene ne sb c do ot ys a o w huay u poe i h e a g nt bid i t y u e et s i riot n i o n de rcs n t i f il j t la li t t s F r a B te i n e dneo uprali taoi a i O gn n w r hu hv l i . u h es o v ect spo c mh f cl n r o ke oso d ae od t r i t a t fi s e l ko nh M To a o sC s Mng mnca i cinwu bid i t o w hu n wta r h ms n l e aae e lsf a o o d ene ne r i o t . s o t si t l fi t t s m de rcs a oddo M To a o o e u poe f ret r h ms n sf . s. Ide a eh i po dd y M To a o so stesoe e o ce e o h ned n x b rv e b r h ms n h w ala n p id rv w fi it i . s t r i i s c sf a oi C s Mng mnhs cu e s c h aiei F r a Te e o c l si t nn l e aae e a ocr di e er vdn l i . h p id a i ci o t r n r od r i rv w we h wsl wdo rsne dneo h bh focr d bus mn sf r e e, h e e a a o et p e v ec ni ea, cu e ao i o h a e i r l e t i s l r t x t t h aiei F r a T s v ec cn a c h a einh h s yn ot ys a o i er vdn l i . h e dne o rdt i s r ota i t i s i r iot ns r od i i t i s s st t sa la li id i t bcuet h w h h s ys c ay ne p id rv w ne ne easisos a i t i a ul ud e o ce e. fi tt s a tl r r i i F a yatteh d hpe fc r M To a o ci sir es d e a be i l , soht r Capl a o r h ms nl m h e ae a hs en nl i l t, . s a sl t e eddic h t n et F rd adhs ht n ea e ete u t n fisn ne x ne s ei r s ro l ia ntu ter s rf c dh dri o h e ec t n s af o , , a f ft ao s t . T spo h ci, M To a o p n t a oue fo te r oi F r ah sts o upr i l m r h ms n o t o dc mn r mh psnn l i ta t e t s a . s is t i od t a h r es d esFbu y 823 D edn ageh h r es dt hs ocagd n i e ae a i era 2 09 e na sruta i e ae ae a n hne ad sl t r , . f t t sl t te aahd dc rinr mh P iy M ae oteOie fO ed Ifr a o ad hyt ce a e a t fo te oc a g fh f c o f ne no min n t l ao l n r f f r t Sn neC mut n wot e ta M To a o se ae a r m nJn 2 23 e ec o p a o h sts h r h ms n r es d ee a s ue 8 06 t ti , a t . s l t i , . O gnRv e St e 41 4 w c gv n O eo s ai pin nhI et e r o e sd t u § 2 25 h h oe s r gn p tia o ite n r a e i at . , i r rc t t st Cr c osC ma,t eta O gnwlm nijr dt n v M To a o frh o ein o pc stsh r o i a t nus c o oe r h ms n ote rt t a t e l i a i ii r . s proe oe e uigir es o poa o o p o, ri d cagfo cs d O upss ff c a n h e ae n rbin r a l oh i h er m u oy r ft t sl t re s s r t . . Rv St§ 2 25A. V usc 3 21) Asc O gns epn b fr e r i n e t. 41 4 r I sbe (04 s uh r oirsos l o d e m ig . a . t . . , e ie t n M To a o se ae a, o F r a Tte x n F r a a m c c a dh d e ts r h ms n r es d en lo d oh e e l i hs i a ut t s a, i . s l t t i. t t od slle i t i 1 OI I NA DO D R 3 PNO N R E n cn oigadhsauy o d ocn ue ae s e o a ou e fo F r ah o o r l , ntu jr cu n oc d bsd ol n dc mn r m l i ta t t ln , l t l ly t od t M To a o se ae a hs en e edd s rs t fit n e r h ms n r es d e a be x ne a aeu o h r s r . s l t t l s a f. A erv w g h Caplfc r Iidh M To a o srn et F r a f re ei te hpe a o, f ta r h m sn t s ro l i t i n l ts n t . s af od w hua r t n e ha n d n v l ei poeuade rcsr h ud te i o p - as r e i gi o i a h rcdr u poe i t ne h t t er f r d t ot s l s gs r Fu en A ed e bcue e a n so nhtht n eivkd st c a die y or e h mn mn eas h hs o h wt ater s rnoe at e r t l r t t t t af a- e e bt i e s Acr n y D edn a e iet s m ayug e ot shoy fibi n r t cod g, e na sr nt do u m jd mn nh ter ol it t e. il f t e tl r t i aly frCi I o l m. a I I . Acst teC u s ce o h or s t M To a o s eodl ms ruddn h a einh h ic c a oi r h ms n scn ci i gonei i s r ota i na e t nn . s a s st t s r ri F r as me n h cni t n r hoacst te or i O gn Se f a yh l i ii pd gi ost i a i t f ce o h cus n r o pci l , e od i s tuo l g s t e . i cl age h ws nb t fe w c ici s n u n al m etdo l e21 s yn rus e a ua eoi t oi ll m ic d g ci r a t aa -03t i l l v a , li a le t a d c l ay ergin ot et-w dy ad ci r ado rp tta wsm s g i i i r sg a o fr wny o as n al met t poe yh a i i s pn et t a le r t sn a e h wse ae fo d c l ay ergin I adin M To a o ci s ews f r e ar esdr mi i i r sg a o n d t , r h ms nl m h a t l s pn et . io . s a ua eo b ct am in oe es n f i e n hba csta ws ed gnh nb t o e o o o fr x n o o t m o a aes aeh a pn nit s l jt t t i t i i Cu. H age D edn a rsos lfrt si a o bcuehyi erc m edd or erus e na sr epn b o h v lin easte e h eo mne t f t e ie i ot tr h t n et F r a r easte d n efrel gd rvin ote n r a i r s ro l i o bcuehyi o no aee po s s fhI et e s af od d t c l io t st Cr c osC ma tah ci seu ete ed gni t n t esr h m nis ce o ein o pc h el mrq rsh sn nist i rt t t a i i t u o o nu e a t n acs e ia s t neelg m e a iteee igni t n o eddea a rl nhrc v ist i . l ti s i n tuo D edn mvfr u m yug e o M .To a o s ce - -or ci o e na s oe os m a jd mn n r h ms n acst cusl m n f t r t s so t a sv agons Fs D edn ageh h hs ce t O gnea m e a. B ee l rud it e na sruta e a acs o r olg a rl y r . r, f t t s e l ti s rg a o M To a o cn ekea m e a ad s s ner mn a lg a i a s eut n r h ms n a selg a rl n a i acfo i m eea s s n li , . s l tis st t l st t truh o epnec d e et air y or n oaayO gnDp t e o hog cr sodnei c do l a cod a rt n r o ea mn f r rt br it e r t 1 OI I NA DO D R 4 PNO N R E Cr c osal y2 Acr n y hyt eh h cno h wa amt ol w h h ws o einfci . cod g, e stta e an so, s ae fa, a e a rt it ilt a t t tr tt dn d ce tte or. Scn D edn ageh aa - necu n cn ueh e e acs oh cus eod e na sruta fcf d o d o oc dta i s t , f t t ti r l t l t h sf rdhtp o p jd e ee ayot e n ce - -or ci. Se f a yh e u e teye f r u c ncs rt st a acst cusl m pci l,i fe e i s a so t a i cl s poe yl ms oteye fci t w c h r ht acs cust ce adi rp t ci i n htp o l mo h hi i to ce or aahs n h r a t a i sg s t t , s ia l yo b ct a av s y rqe frx n o ot mi n sf c n y r u cl nbi t o e o n de a seus oe es n fi es o ui e l p jdi. it jt rr t t i t fi t e i a F a y D edn age M To a o cnoso tate cue h i uy easte i l, e na sru r h ms n an h w h hy asdi n r bcueh e nl f t . s t t sj r a n fc soighy a ayno e e w hh acstl r ym e a.I o e r oa s h w te hd niv v mn i i ce oi a a rl nt r e t n l t t s s b r ti s h wrsh hs udh wog e na s od e asete rn d edn. , f t M To a o ci s e a ae p d o izl wir yeor snO gno o r h ms nl m h hst m e t utiea l a rsu ei r ot n . s a t t l br c e aa. Se f a yh sts e a wt nh O gnt e e tnaya l r ymn vl pci l, et e h hs rt te r o st pnei l wi a ay i i cl a ie e a i tr br t ms n hsi e g n rsos a e y rsos oaog e o ot m p tl i e ad a e h o oepne d ae epne f ln p id fi e ai tr t , l d r , ra dc mn ojsteae heoa ou e. Fr e h stsh h cnoc m e ou e s ru hfc se f dc mn t t t t u h, et eta e an o pt tr a t t le c m a tfri ci sw hute e oaeaa i a woskoldeb i O gn o pi s o h l m i o h h p f lg s s n hi n w ga en r o ln s a t t l l st t e l e l w F a yh a es h h cno sea iema nf lg m e a w huacst a. i l, e s r ta e an hp d nl st t t r z en gu ea a rl i o ce o i l l ti t t s te ok po ddnO gns ]a l r y Frhf l w gesn Iidhs h bos rv ei r o [ cl wi a . ote o oi raos f tee i e i br l n , n aea oso enui e t poeD edn v l e M To a o s ost in r h l gint bisf c n o rv e na si a d r h ms n cni t a i t l t fi t f t ot . s tuo l g t acste or, ntu D edn a e iet s m ayug e o Ci I o ce h cusadhs e na sr nt do u m jd mn n l mI s t , f t e tl r t a . Ic c a dn v u s ae fna e acni t n r ht acste or i na e t id i a hv a ud mnl ost i a i to ce h cusn r re i d l t tuo l g s t od tlia teea t ote d e in r hlne h cn t n ote cn n mn re oi g ehlgl y fh r e n o ocaegte odi s fh r of e e, r t t i i tt l io i i t ad r o oi a cnoaie i e e w h h rt m s o rp eeadc mn. e n psn f cl an c v yn r r i te ae p t p a lg ou e sSe i fi s t t l tf e t i t t er l t 2 Tee vnrg a o sts hr ea eut nt e l t li a : O gnn a sr m u o stfcie( a adee l my ce O gnearsa h r oi m efo o -ft ealisst n fd a a acs r olg ee c e t t - a it t e r) s e l r m e a ad s s ner m s gei m eea a i a shog cr sodnei c do a rl n a i acfo a indn a lg s s n truh o epnec d e et ti s st s t l st t r rt air y or n o oa O gn o ein fci. Rqe s ol wir y ev efo l a cod a r f n r o cr c oa al y eus fra l a s i sr m br it e r t l it t br r c O gnn a sn u o st fcie wl e rcse whesnb diec r o i m ei o -ft e alis i b poe d i raoa ei gne e t t -a it l s t l l . O A m.R211903() 21) r d i . 9-3-056(07 . n . 1 OI I NA DO D R 5 PNO N R E L w v Csy 58US333035 19) B a r o ss m ed opo d ei . ae, 1 .. 4 5 5 (96 u psn y e ne n rv e s , , . t i t t i mx m m r vn p m lv oacs Rd ge v Co , 6 F d 1617 ( hC. a u oee o i a ee f ce. or uz. ok 19 . 17 19 9 i i t l l s i 3 , t r 19) I m e mso y efoddhto t aakh r e ecsd el oc l e l, 99 n a s u n b a reteo s o t cte sn ne i c y r oa rl . t t l f l t i t , rt lt a y adn ret caegte odin ote cn n mn L w , 1 USa345 I ni od o hlneh cn t s fh r of e e . ei 58 ..t 5-5 n r l io i i t s . fc cuseon eh [ ma mnoay hr i gig aat is m y n ote a, or rcg zta i p r e f no e lia n cpc ysi p oe fh t t i t ] i t t t t i l ic e a(n p fc y ost in ) osqecs fovt n nic c a o I n dnlad e el cni t a cneune ocn c o adna e t n d i t r t tuo l ii r ri . . Ai m e hln n h acstte or i a aiu ral yms poe e nn a caeg gi ce oh cus n p t l fc t u rv h t l i s s t rc a i i t sf rd n a u i uy w c rq rsi t d mnr e h [ s nnio ulg ue a c a nr fe t l j , h heu e h m o e os a ta h] of v osea i i tt t i r l l ci h s be fur e o ws e g mee bte r o I a33selo oe v l m a ] enrs a d r a b ni pdd yh psn d t 5 e a Jns. a [ tt i i . . ; s B ns 33F d 1 96 9 C. 04(oc n ghia l yoi a o pi o d ed l a, 9 . 98 3 ( h i 20)cne i tenbi t fe c m a t r e n a 3 , t r rn it l ln f aa sa h g. Aa u t so taa nnio ulg ci hs enrs a dif a g n ca e flr o h wh it r) i e t of v osea l m a be fur e sal r l l a tt t tte ce t cu ci. ei, 33&.. oh acs o or l mL w a 5 n4 s t a st Fr e ten a ms d mnr eh tel gd hr o igiteir y r u h,hi m e u e os a ta h aee so c m snhl a o tr t t tt t l t n br lg a i ac por mid e h e oso u u aeaci. I a31 H myfr ea s s ne rg h e di f r t pr e lg l m d t 5 e a o l st a n r s ft s l a . . , ea p, h wh a o pi wsi m sd oflrt si y tcn arq r mnta x m eso ta c m a t a d i e fr a u o as aeh c eu e e h l t ln s s i e tf il i t t h cu n hv ko n bu g ete e c n e ite r o seaai acfcie e o d o ae n w ao,i nh d i ec s nh psn lg ss nealis l t t v fi i i l st it . I S ma yh my h wh h ws s m d yiaeuc s fhl wir yt ee fe d i i r, e a so ta e a t i b ndqa e otea l a o vni . ll t y e i br l a o pi o a aga y c oa e a mtah sf rd I Ui al acst cu c m a t n n rub ainb h ln l t l r h e u e . d l m e, ce o or t fe . t ty s t ci s ruhaa spsn f cl msb jde w h te e rnarb c funr. l m bog g n r o oi a u e ugd i i h d e tl ur oTre v a t it i fi s t tn f ei i S e , 8 US7 8 (97 we a r o rg a o i p g g n n a scni t n al 42 .. 8 9 18) h e psneut n m n n o i m e ost i a fy , , r i li ii t tuo l r h i viiiir snb r a do lgi a pn o c i e s Hre v Pe o i t s a dftse oa yet t ae t m e eo g a n r t apr. r m , gs l a l le i t l i l t e. N 6 3 v007 O21 W 1030 a* (.O M. 821)o rcn dr inn o : - -09-M, 04 L 397 t 7 D r a 2 04 n eos ea oi . 1c , . r , , i t pr N 6 3C -09-M, 04 W 3161 D O Ag421) Acr n ya oc a , o : - V007 O21 L 888 (. r u , 04 cod g, p iy t . 1 . . . il l 1 OI I NA DO D R 6 PNO N R E tacuei m et ep ine r a v y ht e ynee igh rea m e a i h assn a so xe ec aet e s rd ai rc v te lg a rl s t t r li l o l in i l ti s cni t nl acp b weiirinl r a d oe t m e eo g ai e s Sed ost i a y ce a e hntsa oayet t lgi a pn o c n r t ei tuo l tl t l le i t l i l t e. . H e M To a o siiu y ce igO gna lg m e a de n r eo e, r h ms n df l acs n r ol wea a rl os o i t r . s fct s e l ti s ts teee oa ost in v lin Te a r a doi m s g rp ti n oeetd hlv f cni t a i a o h cs et t h i i p e ys o nr a l t u o l ot . e le s sn o r t le t caeg gisn n n o o e w e hl g gi cn t n ocn n mn Sc a o hln n h e ec g rt ri cae i h odi s f of e e . uh l i s t i h s ln n s i o i t cs q t s m ya on t oe fhs ic e acneune ocn c o ad ae uei p , mu s o n otoe n dnl osqecs f ovt n n , i l t i t ii ic c a o S ma yh c m a t bubn ua eo b ct aeusfr x n o o na e t n i i r,i o pi ao e g nb t o e o rqe oe es n f r ri . ll s ln t i l jt t t i t mi h hba cs de n cni t a i uyh r etteeeoa ost in i e n i aes ae os o ost e n n rta i sohlv f cni t a s t tu j ts l tuo l v lin M To a o cu s lpru h hba pi o s te i n e dneh h i a o r h ms n o d tl u ei aes et n o h es o v ecta i ot . . s l i s s ti , r i t s ci ws mee l m ai pdd a . Te n r m n gl gin e e o M To a o sl gintah ws nb h o ye a i aea o cn r n r h ms n aea o h e a ua e l in l t ts . s l t t l t fe ci frwah aee ws nl g cn n mni d c l a sg gin Sc a oi al m o h el gs a aiea of e e ni i i r er a o uh l a t l l l i t s pn y e t . ci sudi a cn t n ocn n mn caeg frw c M To a o wu hv l m onsn odi s f of e e hlne o h h r h ms n o d ae a io i t l , i . s l a ost in r ht acste or fre e. B M To a o hs oso nh h cni t a i to ce h cus ord s u r h ms n a n h wta i tuo l g s t rs t . s t t s acst cus o u ut sl mws c a y mee ce o or t pr e h ci a a uli pdd s t s i a tl . O gneut n po dfr mca s f r u o sti m et rc vlg r o rg a os rv e oa ehn m o o -ft en a soee eea e li i i t -a t i l a i ac o O gna.Se r A m.R211903() 21) W l M To a o s s ne n r ol w e O d i . 9-3-056( 07 st e . n . he r h ms n i . s aee h cn c d e tna ei O gnh de n poie n e dne fwo e l gs e o a e pne ir sn r o e os o rvd ay v ec o h h l tt i t i e , t i cn c d n we H eh i ic drqe s h h apa t hv snttea l r y o a e ad hn i x bsn ueeus ta e pe so ae e ohl wi a tt . s it l t t r t br i F r a ow c hrc vdepneida nteeus dm e a w e oaaa e nl i , o d t h h eee e rsossn cighrqe e a rl e n vlb i i it t ti s r t i l otah cu o yeus m e a r a do F r aa. H po ds o v ect so rh e o d n rqe a rl et t l i l w e rve n e dneo h w t l l t ti s l e od i i hf l wdO gn pou s o o -ft e n a soee eO gna m e a. e o o e r o s rcr fr u o st i m et rc v r ol w a rl l e e t -a t i e ti s Acr n ybcueD edn hv so n M To a o hd m hd orc v g h cod g, eas e na s ae h w r h ms n a a e o free i te il f t . s t in 1 OI I NA DO D R 7 PNO N R E cni t nl- q rd s s nead eas M To a o hs oso n hs ost i a y eu e a i ac n bcue r h ms n a n h w toe tuo l r i st , . s t poeu sw e oaaa eoh m D edn a e ietjd mna amt ol w n rcdr e n vlb t i, e na sr nt doug e s ae fa o e r t i l f t e tl t tr toesus hsi e s . C N L SO O C UI N Frhraost e aoeIG A TD e dn M in o S m ay ug e [2 oteesnstd bv a , R N e na s o o fr u m Jd mn 8] f t t r t adDSMS M To a o sl m w h r u c n I I S r h ms n ci s i p jd e . s a t e i. II S O D R D T S O R E E. D T Dh 2d dy f ue21 A E ts n i a oJn 07 , . / M he W Ms a_____ s i a . o mn____ / c l MC A L W M SM N IHE . O A C e U tdStsDt cJde h f ne t e irt ug i i a si 1 OI I NA DO D R 8 PNO N R E

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.