Oregon Advocacy Center et al v. Mink et al, No. 3:2002cv00339 - Document 256 (D. Or. 2022)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER: Defendant's Request for Judicial Notice [ECF 252 ] is GRANTED. I take judicial notice of the materials provided. Plaintiffs' Motion for Order to Implement Neutral Expert's Recommendations [ECF 253] is GRAN TED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. The Parties shall implement the recommendations in the Court's Neutral Expert's January and June 2022 reports. Dr. Pinals may grant extensions of other deadlines in her recommendations after conferring wit h the parties. Any such extensions shall be documented in Defendants' monthly progress reports. To the extent contempt proceedings arise out of the efforts state litigants are making in this case, I ENJOIN any action that seeks to hold those associated with this case in contempt for their efforts to comply with the permanent injunction. Signed on 8/16/2022 by Judge Michael W. Mosman. (joha) (Main Document 256 replaced on 8/16/2022) (cw).
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Oregon Advocacy Center et al v. Mink et al Doc. 256 Case 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 1 of 6 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF OREGON PORTLAND DIVISION DISABILITY RIGHTS OREGON, METROPOLITAN PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES, INC., and A.J. MADISON, 23,1,21 $1' 25'(5 Plaintiffs, Case No. 3:02-cv-00339-MO (Lead Case) v. PATRICK ALLEN, in his official capacity as head of the Oregon Health Authority, and DOLORES MATTEUCCI, in her official capacity as Superintendent of the Oregon State Hospital, Defendants. JARROD BOWMAN, JOSHAWN DOUGLAS-SIMPSON Plaintiffs, Case No. 3:21-cv-01637-02 (Trailing Case) v. DOLORES MATTEUCI, Superintendent of the Oregon State Hospital, in her individual and official capacity, PATRICK ALLEN, Director of the Oregon Health Authority, in his individual and official capacity, Defendants. This matter comes before me on the Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion for Order to Implement Neutral Expert’s Recommendations (“Motion to Implement”) [ECF 253]1 and Defendants’ Unopposed Request for Judicial Notice Relating to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Implement Neutral Expert’s Recommendations (“Request for Judicial Notice”) [ECF 252]. For the reasons explained further below, I grant the Request for Judicial Notice, and grant in part and deny in part the Motion to Implement. 1 All ECF references are to the lead case, No. 3:02-cv-00339-MO. 1—23,1,21 $1' 25'(5 Dockets.Justia.com Case 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 2 of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ase 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 3 of 6 EàmÞn· éÊ mÅmé ¸nf® n¦h\Ê ®§Åé \¸né \Êé ihÅé à Ê é fm½Í\ §é ÅÊ\Êmé ]àé ¸nµØ ·m n¨ÊÆ é [¦hm¸é fÙÀ·n¦Êé ÆÊ]Êné \à é\ é ®·é ¦m\¸ äé \ é 7 ié \¦hé 8ÆÆ ÅÊé 8 9 éDØ Êèé @fm±Ëé I§Å]§mé DAI é]¦héf ß åéf ÊÊnhé²\Ê m¦ÊÆé \ÞméÊ né¸ ÌéÊédné]h ÌÍnjéÊéRYF é©Êé ØÅÊéÊ Åmé à é mmÊéfo¸Ó\ ¦ém±mi Êmké\i ÅÅ ®§éf· Êm¸ \ é PÍ!éÊéJ ± m m¨Êé\Êé*( é YÊ\Êmé ]àé] Å®é^ àÆé Æ® méÊæ³mÅé®qé±\Ê m©ÊÅéÊ®éÅÊ]äé\ÊéRYGé·éزéÊ®éÊ ·mméäm]·Æé ®· é ©éÅ® méf\ÅnÅ é^éÅ ¹Ín¸é±m· hé ®réÊ ¡méhm±n©i § é©éà \ÊéÅm¦Êm¦fméÊ mäéf®Ù hé \ßméenm¦éf©ß fÊnhé®u ¢Úf é © n¸éÊ \¦é Ê mé4(éi\äÆéÊé]éän]¸é<¸ éT §\ Æ Åé·mf® £n¦i\Ê ®©ÅéÆÛ mÅÊ"é f Ê § éRVYé*0*#.2( *) é 8¨hé ] ·m\jä é =mw©j\¦ÊÅ é ·ndz®§Åné Ê®é Ê mé \h ËÍ\©fmé g¸ Å Åé \Åé f·m\Êmhé ÅÊ^Êm mÞm é f®§~ fÊ$é KéÊ\ mé Øi f ] é§Ê fméréÊ méÞ\¸ ®ØÅéR¸m ¦éÅÊ]Ênéf®ØÁ×Åé²·fmmh § Æ鮦éà mÊ m·éÊ mé RYEé^¦i'°·éÊ néR¸m ©éHm\ Ê é9ØÊ ®¸ Êæé RH: éÆ ®Ø jédmé m jé ¦éf©Êm ³Êéبim·éR¸n ®¦é \àé ¸é¦Îé\i ÊÑ ¦ é±n·Å§ÆéÊ®éRYE é Woµ é ¹éOÜj f ] éQÊ fm é T \ ©Ï zÅ éPÏ ¦é ·Ó m·é m± \ ¦ÅéÊ \Êé§méÅÊ^Êméf®Ø¹Íé Øj mé \Åénßn¦éÊ ·m\Êm§njéÊé ] é]¨éRF9é®s|f \ é\Åé^éÅ]¦fÊ §é¸é ¦Êé\h ÏÓ ª é\éf ß äéf£¥ ÊÔmié±^Ê m«Ö%é P®Ê&éÊéI ± m m©Êé^Ëé+( é I¦éÊ mé ÊéqéÊ nÆm鲸mÅÅ ¬ é ÆÆØmÅ éLé m hé\¦ém±nh Êmhé m_¸ ¦ é©éT ^ ¦Ê {Å éPÊ ¦é ©é8Ø ØÅÎé+1 é-(-- é Z mé ]¤é m ] é ÅÅÚmé m¸né Æé à mÊ mº Ðé n§¸fmé \§é ¦ ݧfÊ ¦é ´·ÊmfÊ ¨ é ;¦ÅË ËÚÊ ª\ é¸ ÏÅ Mé\¡é±n¸ ÊÍmkéÊ®ém¦Êm¸é\©é®¸hm¸é_ ®à ¦ éÅÊ\Êpé\ m§f mÈéÊ®év éÊ®éf¡± åé à Ê éÅÊ\Êmé `àÅéÊ ]Ëéhé¨Êévf \ æé ¦ § méÑ mé;§ÆÊ ÊØÊ §^ é· ÊÅé]Êé ÆÆÚn éà Ê éÊ mé\iinlé á» § néÊ \ÒéË néÅÊ^Êmé Øi f \Åé] ·n\hæé \hméms ÄÅéÊém©·fméÊ nÅméÞmÁèéÅ\ mé ]àÅé] ^ ¦ÅÊé Ê méÅÊ]Êné] n¨f nÆ é Cmhm·^ Å éf®¦fmÅé\¼mé¯dß ØÅ äé ¥² m m¨Êmié n·m é\Åéj ÅfØÅÅnjé ¹Ê m½é em à é :éj ÅÊ· fÊéf®Ø¹Óé ¦ém©¾f © é\¦é § اfÔ ¦éÅØf é\ÅéÊ né¦mé\Êé ÅÅØné m¸mémm·f ÅmÆé ÊÅé mʸ]®¸h §\¿è énµØ Êäé±àm·Æ éà f é¦mfnÅÅ Ê]Êmé]éf¦Å im¸bÕ ®¦étéxim·c Å éf¦fmÃÅé©é\é f\Æm dä faÉmée\Å Å é 503éC -ié3/( 30(é 4Í é; · é ,45- é I§é n¡² ç © éÊ n ·éd·\jén¶Ø Ê\d mé²àn¸Å éyin·^ éf®Ø¹ÑÆéÅ Ø iémão¸f ÅméË mé m\ÅÊé±ÅÅ e mé ±àm¸é_hm¶Ø]ÊméÊ®éÊ mém¦hé³·®²®Åmj6é ·mé §Ñ¸ØÅ ßmé m]¦Åé\¸mé¦ äé ØÅÊ }_d méà m¦éÊ mé m\ÅÊé . RUIQIRQé7Q?éRX?BX Case 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 4 of 6 r ¨ rZ¹ ZK ¹oKZ¹asZT ¹ &B K ¹.+" +# ¹ Eos ¹s ¹P[QK¨ Z¹ HKJ¨ o s¸r l¹K T¹Tr ZQ r l¹ QK¹ m Z Z ¹s s ¨ r ¹ ¹TZs Z¹M T¹s Z Z ¹ Z ZUtZ ¹ ¹ µ¹ ZQ ¹ oZ¹k Q s ¹ ]¹ o Z¹s r ¨ r ¹P© ¹ ¹K ¹ KQZ ¹ pZ¹ Z sPss§µ¹h ¹ ¨ t ¹ ¹ oZ¹ PZ ¹ ¹¨ ¹ o Z¹¯o ¹oKZ¹ pZ ZZ ¹Q [K ZV¹ oZ¹ PZ ¹ -994=8-B> B '1.-19 B(0*¹F D ¹'' ¹*#¹ #10" ¹ 3Q ©Lr¸r m¹ os ¹ K TK T ¹ pZ¹?s o¹5u Q¨v ¹oK ¹Z oM w¸[T¹ pK ¹ © Z ¹K¹ ¡M Z¹K°¹s ¹ i¨ T¹ ¹ r K [¹ K¹ cTZ K¹ K¯ ¹ ¹ ¨ Z ¹ ¡oZ¹ HrJ |¨ R s ¹ s ¹ h¨ V¹ ZRZ K ¶¹ ¹ Z [Wµ¹ K¹ Q s ¨ r K ¹{ K s ¹ cTZ Ks ¹ s Rr \ ¹ Z ©v Z¹ p[¹ ZQ QrsK s ¹ ^¹ oZ¹ K Z¹K±¹ K T¹ cTZ K¹s }¨ R s ¹ !"/%->-"B> B $+@"8A'1'))'8 B*00¹: 'T¹0/( ¹00*¹ 0 o¹6s ¹%"#" A Z¹²K¶¹s ¹¯ovRo¹ K Z¹K± ¹®s K Z¹cTZ K¹K±¹r ¹°q[ ¹ oZµ¹K Z¹ N ¤sQªK µ¹Z KQ ZV¹ ¹jª N¢Z¹cTZ K¹K³¹ ¹ rlo ¹ 44.B> B 8-A41"B '5 :B4(B 488 B#",¹: 'T¹#'0, ¹#)"'¹ 0 o¹ 5r ¹ #00- ¹ = ¹ oZ Z¹ s ©K r ¹cTZ K¹K±¹QZO ¶¹ [ sTZ ¹K µ¹Q QZ ¹KP ¨ ¹Q µr m¹ ³r q¹ ¡K Z¹K² ¹ 4© ¹ qZ¹K¯ ¹BKx sd ¹ ZZ~¹ ¹Ts ZmK V¹oZ Z¹T ¹ ¹b¹t ¹ oK ¹RK Zm ·2¹ oZµ¹ K [¹bQsKµ¹ Z¨ K¹M T¹¯Z \¹ ¹Z KR [T¹ ¹jª N¢[¹ oZ¹&""&¹r |¨ R r ¹Gs o¹ or ¹r ¹ s T ¹ cVZ K¹Q ¨ ¤ ¹K Z¹o\ r K ¹ ¹K Z¹rK¹s |¨ Q r ¹ ¡K Z¹KQ ¹ S rK QZ¹¯s o¹ K Z¹ K° ¹ oK ¹KP¨ ¹P¨ ¹T ¹ ¹Vr [Q ¶¹Q grQ ¹°r o¹cUZ K¹K¯ ¹ 406"8'B :41' B0+.¹; %X¹/*"¹O ¹.+(¹ \k s l¹ ¹K Z¹K¹Tr sQ ¹Q © ¦ ¹r }¨ Q t ¹ pM ¹K ¯ZT¹K¹ oZ se¹ ¹s K Z¹ ¡K [¹K´¹r ¹ YZ ¹ ¹ ZK Z¹ r ¹ R ¯Vr m ¹ @-:,B "# 0; B :8":'*B :8 B ? B 49B 1)'/'9B 2< B ':84 B 8"397 B =:, B %+'¹ ; 'T¹ #")$ ¹ $"*#¹ 0 o¹ 5y !¹ %""# ¹ K z m¹ K¹ Q Z ¹ TZQ ZZ¹ PZQK¨ Z¹ bs¨ Z¹ ¹i ±¹ oZ¹ Z ¨s Z Z ¹ _¹ oZ¹ K TK Z ¹K ¹s ¨Z¹´M ¹ ¹K¹s K r ¹ ]¹I K ZJ¹ K¯ ¹ <s Kµ ¹r ¹s ¹r ¡K ¹ ¹ [¹ oK ¹ oZ¹D¨ Z Z¹6 ¨ ¡¹qKT¹ KsT¹s ¹r ¹ T{`fR¨ ¹ ¹s Kls Z¹ K ¹KQ rr ·¹r ¹´psQo¹K¹D£K Z¹pK ¹K¹ l[ ¹s Z Z ¹ ¹ Z¹ pK ¹s ¹ Z¹r rQK Zµ¹P ¨ T¹¨ ¹¯s o¹ ¤K Z¹K° ¹ Zn«K r ¹K V¹ QZT¬Z ¹ oK ¹ o[¹KV v w N¥v ¹ ]¹s ¹ z ¹ :42' B0+.¹: %T¹ b " ,b b b W8b !@R b 4F,=J6bVW&W/b B&_bPQ/^&;B/- b &I,b ^'+&W=G7b ;M\G+W=NI b _9/Q/b GNb ,/W/QC;G&W<NGb C&,/b *`b -@VWR=+Wb +N\UZb X8'Wb W:/b =HA\I+W>NIb _(Vb G/+/VV)Qab WOb Q/D/.`b &b +NHVW=[]W;NG&Bb^=NB&W=NJ b b" ,b b b Y:b!;Q b $#%8/bV+NP/bN12/-/Q&Bb?HA\K+W=^/bQ/B;/0b &6&=JVWb &Gb'6/G+ab N0bVW&W/b6N^/TLC/HWbE\VWb &B_&`Vb */bG&SQN_B`bW'@BNQ/,bWNb/G5Q+/b 3,/Q&Bb+NIVW@W]W>NH&Bb &G,b VY&W]WNQabB&_bNGB` b ( OPINION AND ORDER Case 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 5 of 6 % ÛI²Û%" Û ¤Ã ²u kÛ ÛG D Û $! Û ' ' Û ($ Û +VQIñVÛ XÛ²mv± ÛI SÛ NVQIıVÛQ èÀ±Û IQ}ÛVÔ V§³u±VÛu Û¨Ä u kÛ ¨w± ± Û\TV§I ÛR Ä«¶±Û±m Ä SÛkV V§I ÕÛSV]§Û´ Û vQÕÛ SVQu±v ±Û XÛ §u± Û YcQuI ± Û 5V§V Û @ Iv ²v_±Û mIËVÛ ©Iv±VTÛ ±V¨v Ã±Û Q QV°±Û IN Ã²Û ²nVv§Û INv v²ØÛ ² Û Q ÕÛ Ïw´oÛ J Û w {à Q²v Û ³oI²Û ÏJ±Û Ä²Û v Û JRVÛ ´ Û ±VQɧVÛ - ±²v²Ã²u I Û §ukpµ± Û 5 ÏVÌV¨ Û 7Û Ä±´Û ±VV~Û ´ Û I§® Ï ÖÛ²Iu §ÛI ÖÛ ¨TV¨Û² Û v v²Ûu²±Ûu jx kV V ³Û Û±¶I²VÛ IÐ Û EqW©VÛu±ÛIÛ}VÕÛTv±·y Q¶x Û² ÛNVÛ ITVÛOV²ÏVV Û § ²VQ²u kÛ.V] TI ²± Û IOv u·×Û² ÛÏ §Û ³ ÑI¨T±Û ± Ä·v ±Û ² Û ²pVÛ IT v·¸I QVÛ R§v±u± ÏnI²Û ´oVÛ Û v {Å Q²v Û ÏI±Û Æ²Û v Û IRVÛ ² Û IQ²ÇI vÙV I TÛO I²I ¿ ÕÛI÷m §uÚu kÛ Q vI RVÛÏx²pÛ± VQudQÛ ¨ Ìv±u ±Û ZÛ±³I²VÛ IÏÛ²oVÖÛ Û kV¨ÛÐv±m Ûg§Ûk SÛ§VI± Û² ÛQ ÖÛÏu²m Û @§ ²VQ·v kÛ¨W± VQ²±Û²nVÛVÔVQIJuÌVÛI SÛv²±Û§ VÛ u Ûv V V ²u kÛ uQÕÛ ±u²u ±)ÛIIJo §wÙu kÛ Q vI QWÛ´§I V±Û Û²pVÛ§ VÛ XÛ²mVÛ±¶I²VÛ Vku± KʧWÛ³ ÛÒ¨u³VÛ Iϱ ÛIÛ| NÛ XÛÏnvQmÛ7ÛI Û Vv²oV§ÛQI IN VÛ ¨Ûh§ÛÏmuRoÛ7ÛÏI±ÛI u ²VS Û ;VV u kÛ²qV±VÛ±V LK¹u Û XÛ ÏV§±Ûu±±ÃV±Ûu Û v S Û '"%Û4 SÛ% ÛI²Û&# Û8۲à ۲ Û @ Iu ²u`± Û A§ ±VTÛ?¨SV§ Û @IªIk©I¡n±Û VÛ I SÛ iÄ¨Û §SV§Û ²mVÛx V V ºI²x Û XÛ²oVÛ =Vô§I Û1Ô V¨Á ±Û CV ªÀ± Û Emx±Ûv±Û V¨ u±±vO VÛN§ IT ÖÛ±¢VI u kÛI SÛv Û²mVÛIN±³§IQ· ÛI TÛ9ÛoIÍVÛ Û¥ÃI ±ÛIO Ȳ۱à ¯·u kÛ ²rVÛmI§TÛÓ ¨}Û²oI²ÛoI±ÛNVV ÛU VÛv Û³mu±Û¨VkI§S Û 6 ÏVÌV¨ Û@I¨Ik§I£m±Û²Ñ ÛI SÛ¶m§VVÛ § ÍvTVÛ g§Û± VQueQÛ± IJu ± »n ±VÛTu±Qı±VSÛIN ÌV ¼nI²Û¨V¥Ãv§VÛ.V] TI ²±Û³ ÛTu§VQ² ÕÛTu±§VkI«SÛ ±²I²VÛ IÐÛ¬V¦Ãu§V V ²± Û Fnv±Û7ÛQI ²Û §SV§Ûi§Û²pVÛ¨VI± ±Û7ÛoIÌVÛ±¶I²VS ÛI ²o ÄkoÛ7ÛV Q çIkVÛ .V] TI ½±Û² ÛÐ ¨ ÛÏu³oÛ µsV©Û I¨À±Û XÛ²tVÛ?§Vk Û2ÔVQóuÌVÛ,©I Qm ÛI±ÛÏV ÛI±Û²mVÛ<Vkw± I²uÎVÛ I SÛ :ÃSuQzI§× Û ² Û u V V ·Û²oV±VÛQmI kV±ÛI±Û± Û I±Û ±±zP VÛ I SÛ NÕÛÏmI³VÌV§Û VI ±Û I§WÛ TV·V¨ v WTÛ² ÛPVÛ ±³ÛVÔ VSv²v ñÛI SÛVaVQ²vÎV Û 4v M Ö Û B Ix ²xb± Û @¨ ±VSÛ?§TV§ÛS W±Û ²Û ITT§V±±Û ²mVÛQ ¾V ³ÛI SÛQ ²V ² u VÛ ¨ QVVTv l±ÛIkIu ±²Û.V] TI ²±Ûg¨Û.V^ TI ²± Û[v Ä«VÛ· ÛIT u²ÛQV¨ÀIu Û I´xV ¶± Û Hu²mÛ§VkI§TÛ ² ÛµmW±VÛ±¶I²VÛR Ǩ³Û § RVVTu k± Û7Ûf SÛ³mI²ÛµoVÛ Ûu {à Q²v Ûv±Û±²u Û VQV±±I§ØÛ² Û § ²VR½Û²pVÛ - ±³x²Ä²u I Û§vksµ±ÛI½Ûu±±ÄVÛu Û ²m ±WÛ ¨ QVVSu k± Û 7 Û §SV¨Û² Û §VÌV ²Û²nVÛÍv I²u Û XÛ´oV±VÛ ?@7=7?=Û*=0Û?C03C Case 3:02-cv-00339-MO Document 256 Filed 08/16/22 Page 6 of 6 M>;<PO X -2.H,(HPOXFROPX*-X(*E-XPIXK-M2JMFXP<->MXMIE-OX>HXTIMD>H;XPIX>FKMIS-XP<-X(,F>PQ(H+-X KMI+-OO-OX),XKMI+-,RM-O X>HXIM,-MXP<(PXP<-VXI*-VXP<-X+IFF(H,OXI/XP<-X% # X IHOP>PRP>IH X X 9MP<-MX 2BH,X P<(PX P<-X M-;IHX OP(P-X +IRMQX +IHP-FKPX KMI+--,>H;OX >FK(>MX -5H,(HPO X (*>E>P>-OXPIXM-F-,VXP<-O-XS>IE(P>IHO X $<-VXOIF-P>F-OX,IXOIX,>M-+PEV X*VXKRH>O<>H;XOP(P-X(+PIMOX T<IX(M-X E>P>;(HPOX>HXP<>OX+(O-X6MXP<->MX-07MQOXPIXO(P>O:X P<-X IHOP>PRP>IH(EXM-LR>M-F-HPO X PX *-OP XP<-VX+M-(P-XFIHRF-HP(EX,>O>H+-HP>S-OXPIXTIMDXPIT(M,OX(XOVOP-F>+X(KKMI(+<XP<(PXO(P>O2B-OX P<-X IHOP>PRP>IH X*VXP=M-(P-H>H;XPIXC(>EXP<IO-XT<IX(M-XF-M-EVXPMV>H;XPIXM-OIES-XP<-X>OOR-OX>HXP<>OX +(O- X $IXP<-X-UP-HPXP<-O-X+IHP-FKPXKMI+--,>H;OX(M>O-XIRPXI/XP<-XS- WX-17MQOXOP(P-XE>P>;(HPOX(M-X F(D>H;X>HXP<>OX+(O- XP<-VX2NROPM(P-XP<-XOP(P- OX(*>E>PVXPIXI*-VXP<-X IHOP>PRP>IH X H,XOIXPIXP<(PX -UP-HP X X-HCI>HX(HVX(+P>IHXP<(PXO--DOXPIX<IE,XP<IO-X(OOI+>(P-,XT>P<XP<>OX+(O-X>HX+IHP-FKPX2JMX P<->MX-17MPOXPIX+IFKEVXT>P<XP<-XK-MF(H-HPX>HCRH+P>IH X IMX P<-X 2JM-;I>H;X M-(OIHO X -5H,(HP OX -LR-OPX 2JMX R,>+>(EX IP>+-X & X 'X >OX $ X XP(D-XCR,>+>(EXHIP>+-XI/XP<-XF(P-M>(EOXKMIS>,-, X E(>HP>23O X IP>IHX6MX M,-MXPIX FKE-F-HPX -RPM(EX UK-@? OX -+IFF-H,(P>IHOX & X 'X >OX ! $ X X $X (H,X X X $ X $<-X (A?>-OXO<(EEX>FKE-F-HPXP<-XM-+IFF-H,(P>IHOX>HXP<-X IRMQ OX -RPM(EX UK-MQ OX (HR(MVX(H,X RH-X XM-K ?O X M X >H(EOXF(VX;M(HPX-UP-HO>IHOXI/XIP<-MX,-(,E>H-OX>HX <-MX M-+IFF-H,(P>IHOX (8-MX +IH2.MM>H;X T>P<X P<-X K(MQ>-O X HVX OR+<X -UP-HO>IHOX O<(EEX *-X ,I+RF-HP-,X>HX -2.H,(HPO XFIHP<EVXKMI;M-OOXM-KIMQO X $IXP<-X-UP-HPX +IHP-FKPXKMI+--,>H;OX (M>O-XIRPXI/XP<-X-24IMQOXOP(P-XE>P>;(HPOX(M-XF(D>H;X>HXP<>OX+(O- X X X(HVX(+P>IHXP<(PXO--DOX PIX <IE,X P<IO-X (OOI+>(P-,X T>P<X P<>OX +(O-X >HX +IHP-FKPX 2JMX P<->MX -17 ?OX PIX +IFKEVX T>P<X P<-X K- G(H-HPX>HCRH+P>IH X $X #X# X X $ X X X
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
