Swatch S.A. et al v. Tick Tock, Inc. et al, No. 1:2010cv23241 - Document 31 (S.D. Fla. 2011)
Court Description: FINAL JUDGMENT AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION ON CONSENT. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/5/2011. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Swatch S.A. et al v. Tick Tock, Inc. et al Doc. 31 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA MIAMI DIVISION CASE NO.: 1:10-cv-23241-JLK SWATCH S.A a/k/a SWATCH A.G.; and THE SWATCH GROUP (U.S.) Inc., Plaintiffs, v. TICK TOCK, INC., INTERNATIONAL TIME, INC., THE PFEFFER GROUP LLC, JACOB PFEFFER, JOSE PFEFFER, ERIC PFEFFER, TERESA PFEFFER, CARLA PFEFFER, JOHN and JANE DOE 1-10, and JOHN DOE CORPORATIONS 1-10, all whose true names are unknown Defendants. FINAL JUDGMENT AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION ON CONSENT This matter, having come for consideration upon the Plaintiffs Swatch S.A alk/a Swatch AG. ("Swatch") and The Swatch Group (U.S.) Inc.'s ("TSG") (collectively "Plaintiffs") Complaint for trademark infringement, copyright infringement, patent infringement and related causes of action based on Defendants Tick Tock, Inc., International Time, Inc., The Pfeffer Group LLC, Jacob Pfeffer, Jose Pfeffer, Eric Pfeffer, Teresa Pfeffer, and Carla Pfeffer's ("Defendants") alleged acts of unlawful importation, material alteration and offering for sale and sale of infringing SWATCH-branded goods, and the Parties now having represented to this Court that they have settled their differences, individually and collectively hereby agree to entry of the within Final Judgment and Permanent Injunction on Consent ("Consent Judgment"), IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT: Dockets.Justia.com 1. This Court has jurisdiction over each of the parties to this Consent Judgment, and over the subject matter in issue. Venue is proper in this Court. 2. The Plaintiffs alleged that the Defendants, individually and collectively, have infringed and/or have induced or and/or contributed to infringement of one or more of the rights owned by Plaintiffs, including the registrations attached hereto as Exhibit 1 ("Plaintiffs' Intellectual Property"). 3. The Defendants, individually and collectively, have elected not to litigate the Plaintiffs' allegations. 4. The Defendants, individually and collectively, and their parents, affiliates, subsidiaries, agents, servants, employees, partners, business entities, attorneys, and/or persons controlled directly or indirectly by the Defendants or acting on their behalf or in concert with them and all those person in active concert or participation with them or anyone of them are HEREBY ENJOINED from the: sale, transfer, importation, offering for sale, advertisement (including online advertisement via the Internet), movement, distribution and/or marketing of any products constituting, embodying or bearing the Plaintiffs' Intellectual Property and/or rendering of any assistance whatsoever in the sale, transfer, importation advertisement, movement, modification, manufacture or distribution of such products or products colorably resembling any of Plaintiffs' Intellectual Property, unless expressly authorized by Swatch and TSG. 5. The Defendants, individually and collectively, REPRESENT that they do not possess any timepieces or other goods constituting, embodying or bearing any of the Plaintiffs' Intellectual Property. 2 6. The Defendants, individually and collectively, represent that they have PERMANENTLY CEASED and DESISTED from importing, selling, distributing, advertising, andlor promoting timepieces or other goods constituting, embodying or bearing any of the Plaintiffs' Intellectual Property and further warrant and represent that they have ceased and desisted all activities enabling such activities listed above. 7. This Consent Judgment shall be BINDING ON and INURE TO the benefit of the executors, administrators, personal representatives, heirs, successors and assigns of each party. 8. The Clerk shall CLOSE this case and DENY as moot all pending motions. 9. This Court RETAINS over the parties and the subject matter for the purpose of enforcing compliance with the terms stated herein and for enabling the parties to apply to this Court for further orders and to remediate violations hereof. Upon finding a party to be in violation of a provision of this Consent Judgment, the Court will issue an order directing the violating party to comply with the violated provisions. Any such application to enforce the terms hereof may be served on the parties' respective counsel by reputable overnight courier at counsel's address existing at such time. In the event that any of the Defendants is found by the Court to have violated or to be in default of paragraph 4 of the Consent Judgment then the Court shall also assess liquidated damages of $300.00 per unit of product, and award reasonable attorneys fees and costs for the enforcement of the Order, including investigative fees and expenses. In the event that any of the Defendants is found by the Court not to have violated or to be in default of paragraph 4 of the Consent Judgment, the Court shall award reasonable attorneys' fees and costs for ddending against the alleged violation or default, including investigative fees and expenses. 3 10. This Consent Judgment RESOLVES all claims in the above-styled matter. This Consent Judgment shall be entered WITHOUT the taxation of costs, damages or attorneys fees. DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers, at the James Lawrence King Federal Justice Building and United States Courthouse in Miami, Florida, this 5th day of August, 2011. ES LAWRENCE KING ITED STATES DISTRICT J 4 CONSENTED TO: BAKER. DONELSON. BEARMAN, ITZ, PC CALE-WELb,&J3 COLLEN IP By: Jeff A. Lindenbaum COLLEN IP The Holyoke-Manhattan Building 80 South Highland A venue Ossining. New York 10562 (914) 941-5668 (914) 941-6091 jlindenbaum@co\lenip.com Attorneys for Plaintiffs Dated: Baker. Donelson, Bearman. Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 920 Massachusetts A venue, NW, Suite 900 Washington, DC 2000 I 202.508.3490 (tel) 202.220.2290 (fax) pzane@bakerdonelson.com Atlornel'f:ndanrs 11-, 2011 Dated: K628_Draft consent judgmenU 10208.DOC 5 k _ _ ,2011 EXHIBIT 1 EXHIBIT 1 Case 1:10-cv-23241-XXXX Document 1-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 2 of 15 lilt. CL: 14 , Prior U.s, Cl.: rr' , Reg. No. 1,356,512 Office ........ A.iIa. Z1, ms . United States Patent and Trademark TRADEMARK IIJUNClPAL REGISTER BTl. SA PABlUQUESD'EBAUCHE.! ZEI' COlUlOltATION) ORENCHBN, SWITZ'B1U.AND 2540 (swrr. POaa W.A.TCHI!S AND PAR.TS "I'HElUroF. IN CLA.III 14 (U.s. CL m. PIRST USE S-JI-In2; 5-31-1M2. ,.'. ,;. ," ,; IN OWNER. OP 1.2'2.863. u.s. REO. NOS. 1,22'7,456 AND llODr:R T PEVERADA.. BXAMJNINO .A.Tl'OJ.. NEY Case 1: 1O-cv-23241-XXXX Document 1-2 Enterod on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 3 of 15 Page 1 of] USPTO Assignments on the Web A..lgnments on the Web> Trademark Query Tra demark Assignment Abstract of Title TOUI Aalgnmentll: 2 Flllnll Dt: 11/02/1964 . . . . . : ll5.lIalHd Reo #: b,1sInnt: ETA S.A. fABRIC)< IES O'eeAUOiES ...rtc SWATCH Alalgnment: 1 .....'Framll: 0505102f9 R.eah,,,d: Rec:onkd: COnWYllKe1 ASSIGNS nt E [;NTIRE INTEREST AND THE GOODWILL AMi,nor: ETA 5 A 09/1311985 PIlI_ 2 I!xeC Db 08/15/1985 I!ntIty'1llMI COI\PORAnOIi Cltlzen""p: SWITZERlAND AUIg.... : SWATCH S A Entlty1'yJM1 CORPORAnON Citizenship: SWrrlElUAND ROUTE O[ 250Z-8IENNE, SWITZERlANO 9, CorreIponchnt r JTILf MCGLEW AN.) 28 WEST 44TH ST. NEW ynPK, NY 1M3!; Assignment: :I .....' ..... m.: JlS17J0992 RecIIIlv.d: ...... 3 02/1811986 Conve-"...' 11TH"'. nON 8V 5L1PERINT!'NOANT IV THE JOINT S'TO('1( COMPA"IY, BIEHN!; COMMEIlOAL Rl!GISTEIt SHOWING .- .' C"",,, r: Of A[,)')RESS Aulln",: S',,· 1C: :.: (c NOV. 18, 1 J>l5 (IN FRENCH WI IH ENGLISH TRANSLAnON ATTACH!D <Y .'.ICtl. LTQ.J lXac Dtl 12/11/1985 1'yJM1 UNKNOWN Cltlzenllhlp: NONE Aaeig""': 5W 'TC!! ,0.''; {CWATCH SJJ.lSWATCH LID} 9i fWf CoI'nIIpondent; L _, I AEMPfU Enttty Type: UNKNOWN CltizeMhlPl NONE MCGLEW Al<O l1lTTlE 28 WeST 44TH ST. NM NY IfY)J6 I http://assignments.usptn _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _•• .<,' I 1'i0EX1 su.RCH p (" •• hL,>si I eBUSINE8S I CONTACT US I t.:l/q?db=tm&sn<r'73 50684 8 6/11/2009 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. . ._ _ _ _• Case 1:10-cv-23241-X/": Document 1-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 4 of 15 IDt. 0.: 42 Prior U.s. O.! 101 , Rea. No. 1,849,657 United Patent and Trademark Office ........ UN I Aaa.,. SERVICE MARK PRINrTPAL REGISTER swatch SWATCH TION) (SWT":"nJlLAND "'- RUB JAKOB STP H Pf'"U 501 SIENNE, S'" rr !, , POa.: RETAIL ST'-,!> CORPORA. FIRST USE 11-26-1993; IN COMMBllCE 11-26-1993, OWNER OF U.S. REG. NOS. 1,490.111, 1,6 'I,P71i, AND CYT1lERS.. SIRVICES; NAMELY, l\BTAU.. SHQPS }-, 'IT1JRII;n, SUNr.T.,.;q<W-s AND SLEc'nlONI(:, fN CLASS 42 (U ____ Cl[3 101). SN 74--248,413,'FTLED 2-21-1992. S.' -- I ' \. CA P THR. EXAMININo ATI'ORNEY . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -...... ----,r-f::vt . _____ -- _____________......- - - . Case 1 :10-cv-23241-X' :.'·X D0cument 1-2 USPTO Assignments on tf.c \1, ·b Entererl on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 5 of 15 Page 1 of 1 Assignments on the Web> Trademark Query No assignment has been recor'ded at the USPTO For Serial Number: 74248413 If ycu h""" .ny comment, or q..-lono CIOIlCOII'rOng til. dIU displayed, COf!i¥j PRO I AMignmenis. 571-272-33!0. 'Web In1IIfface lest modIIIed: Odcbow 18. 21lO11 ".2.0.2 I .W>ME I Irmo I SEARCH I 88USINESS I CONTAC'r US I http://assignments.uspto.gov/assignrnents/q?dtr=trn&sno=7424841J PRIVACY STATEMENT Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 6 of 15 Case 1:10-cv-23241-X"'''< Dorunlcnt 1-2 .. '. ",t. Cl.: 14 PrIor U.s. , a.: 27' " ' '., , ' , ' , Reg. . United States Patent and Trademark·Office R. . . . . -.7,'lJt2, ,TRADEMARK AL REGISTER SWATCH SWATCH S,A. (SWIT7J',RLAND C()RPOIlA. nON) 94 RUE JAKOB STAMPrT J BIENNE. FIRST USE 11-12"'198J. 11-12-1911: IN COMMERCE· se... NO. 74-079.22O"FlLED 7-:17-1990. " FOR: 'WATCHES, ' CI OCJ(S' AND TJIBIlEOF. ,IN CLA < 1 ' 'I: D, PARTS ALICE.SUE 'CA TORNEY .. ... ' EXANININO , ".:' ..... . , .,. , , -.' """"-----------------------:::.",...,. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ D't·.. a .•• . ._ _ _ _, _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. . Case USPTO Assignments on the Web Document 1-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 7 of 15 Page lof! tIt\ United States Patont and Tradernark Office ., HomelSlte Index I Sure" I GuldesIContact.!eBu9Ine.. leBlz alert. INewslHelp Assignments on the Web> Trademark Query No assignment has been recorded at the USPTO For' Sertal Number: 74079220 If you h...,.,. ""y com"",,",,, or QU<>5fun. concerrl"ll the data cI.payed, contN:1 PRO I V..Iet IIlIeIfIw:e I." modiIIect. O<*lber 18. zoos v.2.0.2 I .WlVE I 1000ni SF ARCH I eeUSIHESS I CONTACT US http://assignments. uspto .gov/as si gnmcnts/q?db=tm&sno=74079220 I 571-272-3350. PfHVACY STATEMENT Case Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 8 of 15 DoclJrnent 1-2 Int. a.: 14 PrIor U.s. Os.: 2, 27, 28 nOO 50 United Stntes Patent and Trademark Office TRADEMARK PRINGPAL REGISTE R SWATCH SW,t.TCH SA. «'VATCH A.G.) (SWATCH Lm.) (SWr17l'. _ iJ CO 'n i) 94, RUE JAKuB :, r AMPFU IIIENNB, sv.'r17 ) rA 'f) rH. 2 'I'! OWNER OF u.s. REG. Nos. l,3S6,SI2, 2,217,461 ANDOnmR5. SER.l"O. 78·124,477, fU.ED 4-26-2002. PIRST USB APRIL L. rN COMMERCE 84-> ' NE'" BXAMlNING A'J"J'OR· . ------------------. - - - - - - - - - · · · - · · · · - - - · - · · · · - · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.......IoIJIJ---JI .. Case 1:10-cv-::', .. ; 1- USPTO Assignments (1:1 .- :'::nten::d 0:1 F!_SO Docket 09/08/2010 Page90f15 1-:- :1:(, . Page 1 of 1 Assignments on the We h > Trad em Cl rk Q tI r ..y No assignment has been recorded at the USPTO Ft)r Serial Number: 78124477 If you h , ... """ In""""nt. orc,J<I.tions """,eme.; !tl. dabI diapi.oyed. \f;"b Intelf;\o .... I ""ME I INI'lEXI ""n!N;t Ign_" PRO I A.. Odober 18, ;'(.-08 v.2.0.2 571-272-33S0. I ..eWINESS I CONTACT US I PRrvACY STATEMENT ----------- .-------. http://assignments.uspto.gov/assignmentslq?d b=tm.';: SClI' , 78124477 6/3012C , -.. 1-- Case 1:10-cv-23241-XXY'< DocLlrnc!" 1-:' Entered 15 011 FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page Wof Prior U.S. Cl.: 27 . United States P:1 tent and Trademark Office Reg. No. 1,664,054 ReKistered Nov. 11, 1991 TH.t\ OEMARK L REGISTER S\VATCl I SCUBA 200 SWATCH TION) SA (SWIT7:EII L,\ND CORPORA. 94, RUE JAKOB BIENNE, SWITZERLAf'.T) FOR: WAT':'!,::',', '1'1"'" 1"·,';'<; CESSORIES, IN CLASS 14 (U,S, CL. 27), FIRST USE 5-9-199 n; IN 5-9-1990. OWNER OF SWITZERLAND "' ') 378412. DATED 4-12-1990, EXPIRES 4-1 >2C J. --------------, ,_. __ . OWNER OF U,S. REG. NOS. 1,252,863, 1.356,512. AND U35,443. NO CLAIM 1" MADE TO THE EXCLUSIVE RIGHT TO USE "SCUBA", APART FROM THE \'" ".S Sf '\YN, SER. NO. 74-051,641, FILED 4-23-1990. ALler' CUE CARRUTHERS, EXAMINING ATTOl,r-;EY -''''''---- USPTO OIl 11'e Weh Case 1:1 Document 1-2 Entered United States Patent ;:md Tradem:trk OfficlP IIi\ '8' HomelSitelnd('xlscMchl Assignments on the Web> 0:1 FLS ) Docket 09/08/2010 Page 11 'Id,', IContact, ',"'lJslncssleBil ,': "sINew' IHeip I rill.! c m.ru:kJ2lJ.!"-cIY No assignment has been recorded at the USPTO For Serial Number: 74051641 If you have any con;monls or qu",,;ons concemng the data displayod, wnlac1 PRO I ,\ ..Ignmenls 81571·272·3350. Web intertace last modified: Qctoe:..( 1B. :1008 v.2.0.2 I ,HOME I INDEX I SEARCH I IIBUSINESS I CONTACT US I http://assignments.uspto.gov/assignrnents/q?db=tm&sno=74051641 PRIVACY STATEMENT 1 of 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 12 of 15 ' Case 1:10-cv-23241-XXXX Document 1-2 Int. CI.: 14 PrIor U.S. Os.: 2,27, 2R and 50 United States Patent and Trademark Office Reg. No. 1,938,930 RegisteredNOl'.18,t995 TRADEMARK PRINCIPAL REGISTEH TRONY SWATCH AO (SWATCH SA) (SWATCH LTD.) (SWITZf'l'.LA' . rn"PO',\" 94, RUEJAKOU s r,\MI'FLl 2SOO BIENNE, SWIT7.F.RT_ANn ' FIRST POR: WATCHES AND TIII:IR PARTS, IN CLASS 14 (U.S. CLS. 2, 27,28 AND 50) . USE 11-79-1994; IN COMMERCE N/), 71-'" ,21<\ FILED 3-1()-199!1. JERI J, FICKES, EXA MINING AlTORNEY USPTO Assignments on 11,,, '.',1,,1, Case 1:1 O-cv-23: ; k/XX ['Qcument 1-2 Entrrcd on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 1 United States JI1'j TrademZlrk Offic _ HomelSltc Index I J3 (ill Cui.:."" i ContacL: I I luslnc'>s lel1;L "I 'Its News Help Assignments on the Web> Tradem.il..r!LQuery No assignment has been recorded at the USPTO For Serial Number: If you h 3,." any comments Of qu"slions COIl<'ernjng the dll1B dloplayed. contact PRO / f,!S/gnrnenta Web inl erfac 0 last modified October lB, 2008v,2,Q,2 I ,HOME IINDEXI SEARCH I t>BUSINESS I CONTACT US at 671·272·3360, I P8tVACYSTATEMENT J .......... 0 Case 1: 1O-cv-23241-XXXX Document 1-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 140f 15 . . Int. 0.: 14 Prior U.S. Cls.: 2, 27, 28 and SO United States Patent and TradCJnark Office Reg. No. 1,942,870 Regf8tered Dec. 19, 1995 TRADEl\1.ARK PRINCIPAL REGISI'ER I 'watc' h r (SWATCH LTD.) SWATCH AG (;,WAICli (SWITZER.LAND CORPORAnON) 94, RUE JAKOB STAMPFLI 2SOO BIENNE. swrrZERLAND PRlORIT'? CLAIMED UNDER SEC. 44(0) ON SWITZERL "'ND APPUCATION NO. 5835.1994.1. rTf,En , . FOR: WATCHES AND rnElR PARTS, IN CLASS 14 (U.S. CLS. 2, :7, AND FIRST USE' 11-29-1')').1; IN COMMEIU'8 11-29-1994. . ---------- 8-F>-1994, REO. NO. 413479, DATED )94, EX PIRES 8-26-2004. SER. NO. 74-628,211, PILED 2-1-199'. JF RI , FICf: ES, EXAMINING ATTORNEY ...... ... . _--- --- USPTO Assignments on the \Vch Case 1:10-cv-23;J·11-XX'i'/ 1-2 tIi\ United States Pa'ent ".,,' ""demark . , HomelSite Index 15r>uch I Entered (in Assignments on the Web> Rny hC1S 1 '. cornm·en!· I .HOME I I been recolrded at the USPTO Seri<11 NI Jmhl'r: 74628211 ·... Jcb ... • QUery r()t" hH'.,.oe Docket 09/08/2010 Page 150" I ContactsieBusiness' eBiz alerts' New.' Help No assignment: If you Pagf 1 of 1 .. SE.I\RCH ,. - (j ",tSi" kut I fi-xj' i tltv'·... ;. ," ....,fl1rli'1 I at 571 ..272·3350. Cdal>er 1t:, 20CU v.2.0.2 I US I PPIVACY STATEMENT .... http://www.wipo.intlcgi-hagiguesUiktch5?ENG+111\( ;l) [-,\ Lt .. \'<111+ I." ERS E+(}i()+ I JO:7+F+ 1+ I ' I+25+SEP-OIHITNUM,B..+IDN%2tDM%2IDS8481+ Case 1:1 O-cv-23241-XXXX D '('Ilmont 1-3 En1r;rcd en FLSD Docket 09/08/2010 Page 2 of 5 "" 1 ofl ,-----------------------Depots publies selon l'Acte de 19GO I Deposits Published Under U-;8 19GO Art (11) DM/058481 (15) 14.01.2002 (18) 14.01.2012 (73) r :rD.), 94, J8kob Stampfli, CH-2502 BIENNE SWATCH AG (S\V J\ T('"1 SA) (CH) (86) (87) (88) CH (74) THE SWATCH GROUP SA (THE SV/;\TCII CJ!\Ot lP ;\C) (TI-li': SWATCH GROUP LTD.) Faubourg du Lac 6, CII-2502 BIENNE (CI [) (28) 1 (54) Bolte de montre / Watch case (51) Cl. 10-07 (81) I. AN, EG, ES, ID, TN, VA. II. BX, CH, DE, FR, GR, IT, KP, LI, MA, MC, MD, ME, MK, MN, RO, RS, SI (45) 28.02.2002 bttp:llwww.wipo.intlcgi-hagigucsG'j f'.'tchS?ENG+1I,\GUE-ALL.vdb+ 1... ERSE+O+O+ 130nf F+ 1+ 1 , t25+SEP-OIHITNUM,B .. +IDN%2IDM%2f058481 + Case 1:1 O-cv-2321J 1-XXXX Document 1-3 1.1 Entered on FLS[ Docket 09/08/2010 Page 3 of 5 1.2 1.4 1.3 - 1 .7 1.5 c:Jciilprn http://www.wipo.inUcgi-hag.h·"l.:T.il... l·h5?ENGHIAGUE.Al.1 .. Case 1:10-cv-2:-ei1-XXXX Document 1-3 .. +IDN%2fDM%2tD67074+ [ntercd 01 FLS) Docket 09/08/2010 Page4of5 lofl Enregistrements intQrnationaux iSSLJS de dcmandes internationales regies EUOU l'Acte de 1960/ exclusivement ou partiellement par l'Acte de 1 International Registrations Resulting from Internaticnal Applications Governed Exclusively or Partly by the 1999 Act and/or the 1960 Act (11) DM/067074 (15) 14.10.2005 (18) 14.10.2010 (22) 14.10.2005 (73) SWATCH AG (S\VArCH SA) (SWATCll LTD.), 94, Rue Jakoh Stampfli, CH-2502 BIENNE (CH) (86) (87) (88) (85) CH (85) CH (74) THE SWATCH G1U): lp SA (TIlE S\VATCI [GROlTP }\(J) (TH: SWATCH GROUP LTD.) Faubourg du La r, ' (,, ! '[ r , ·02 BI!:';NE (C' I) (72) Alfredo BELLAVEC L1 ;\, SWATCH SA, rue Jakob Stampfli 94, CH-2502 BIENNE (28) 1 (51) Cl. 10-02 (54) Montre-bracelet / Wristwatch (81) http://www.wipo.intJq·;-kll'/ .iik:,'h5?ENG+! I ViUE-;\ LI \."', +-I ... Case 1:1U-cv< 24',-XXXX UOCUIIlI, 1-3 L" Ii U+ 2 1I,26+F+ 1+ I 1+ 25+SEP-O/HITNUM,B,,+IDN%2tDM%2f067074+ ()n FLSD Docket09/0S/2010 Page SofS 1. AN, ID, TN.H. B(;, BX, BZ, DE, FR, (iR, IT, KP, MA, MC, t\lE, MK, MN, RS. III. CH, EE, EG, ES, GE, HR, I i , K( i, U, N!I), SG, S I, 'CR, li:\ (45) 30.11.2005 1 II :\(i ... 26 +1-',·1 'I + 1+:0 . Case 1:1 O-cv-23241-XXXX Document 1-4 United State." (lc) 1 :I'llnt EI KlIdit·j (IS) .------ .. ... -------- (54) (75) Tllvc/' :,'r: (73) k,,,,'nee: SWlltchAG (Swutc:h SA) (S",a(,," lTD)., Bienne (ell) Tern" (21) l'i' middle.· W:l' ('.\'0) ,............................ (5c) I'" (5:\) I'lt II Inl' .. I : IS S D3Yl, :il S [)'11 L ! f) S D·\·:',·.i S (/1) ,\ !/urney, A,I,' Tbe IP; Donald 1. Ranft ClAIM 1'1 [13f11cntal ,'c' i'l1 for a watch case, as shown aod cd. I) ESCRlPTION Cited I2/J977 4/1986 11/19&6 2/1992 6/1992 6/1992 4/1995 911999 llJ/2001 1985-p. 53-2 r - " II! C. Holtje "11, or Firm-CollcD (57) ]' FIn. I is a fnHlt v u.s. L\TENT DOCUf>1 ENTS S D2R' I' I S 1 A D3:.ci:, J) S D.127 ":3 S '"Jr.y .. .......... 1('.' ................. .. I .. .. fl\L{I' ; . (:<1 rt:h ........... ,,,.,, .. ,.. ',', J68/280-282, 27.'>-;";7, 7 Circuilr -Keystone-Aug. " "I center kft.+ Application I'riort!y nat" r.OC (7) CI ................................. .. (56) W.lch & Jewelry Journal-1987-p. 709-Swatch lewt:kr', (51) walches al .H. 12,2002 Jan. 1-1, '.'<12 Jul. 1S, 2003 (ITllER PUBUCATIONS 14 Years Forcl!(ll •• Bloolllingc!ales C tI.-Jun.1994-p. 22-5watch watches.Eurol'''11 loweler (DGZ)-May 1997-p. 42-5 watches at AI'Pi. No,: 29/163,783 (2=) US D477,23S S 512002 Avraaches ................... DI0139 S,?[Xl2 Wyssbrod ................... 368/113 D457,818 S • 2IXI:,'[X)M0'!9 AI' If akim EI KJ,diri, SI;lIlajsc (el n (0.) (30) Patent No.: Dute (Ir PlIteut: --------_ .. _--- WXl" 'II C\SE I 0(') a \\ ,I:. I".,) ,I ............ ":":'.1" Lung ........................... '1/' , MI' ,I II. /2' No •.. , .. " ..................... :1," I Dizier ......................... 1'111,"') Fujihara ...................... 11111''1 1:Sukad ...... , ................ II! II' SchiHvo et al. .............. II I II Ando .......................... I I I!J ! "'- \ - I t:w (.f "Iy Dew and ornamcntal design for \.':.1se; fiG, 2 is a back':' 'V "'creaf; FlO. 3 is a top vi w Ihereof; Fie:. tis" IXlllol: \iew Ihtreof; FI; : S J I: .sht . :de view thereof; " ft si ", view thereof; and, FI' '. •. Fl' : .'" (ibhl t lInt perspective view thereof. 1 "Iulm, 7 Drawing Sheets Case 1:10-cv-: "umcnt 1-/ U.S. ',Ii "nt ,''II. [:ntcrcJ on FLS[' :" 15,200.1 She· t 1 '<at 09/08/2010 Page 3 of 9 or 7 US D477,235 S / tf _/ // i t -, c t ' \,,'1 ,-, 1. Case 1: 1O-cv-: '241-.'XXX 1-4 Jill. IS, 2003 [ntr;rcri Oil FLSr Docket 09/08/2010 Sheet 2 of 7 Page 4 of 9 US D477,235 S * I l(jf- Case 1 Document 1-1) U.S. Patent Jllr. 15,2003 ('n FLSr r'ocket 09/08/2010 Page 5 of 9 SJ,'('t J of 7 US D477,235 S -. C) J- 1 I re "", ,-I - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - -------- - - - - - - - - - - - # - - 9 ' - , 1 - - Case [JnCI!rrcnt U.S. 1';1 tent .JII!. 15, r=:ntewrl (1'1 rl._s' [Jocket09/08/2010 Shed ,I () r 7 ------------------ Figure 4 Page6of9 US D477,235 S Case 1:10-cv-23241-XXXX [)ocument 1-4 u.s. IJ a tcnt .1111. 15, 201!.1 Entered on FLSl Docket 09/08/2010 Page7of9 Sheet S of 7 _e. ---------------------- US D477,235 S Case 1:10-cv-23241-XXXX r-1ocJnlcnt 1-'\ U.S. Patent Entered on FLS' Docket 09/08/2010 Page 80f9 Sh('d(,or7 US 0477,235 S ,.A;-------_ - _.......... _ Case 1:1 O-cv-23241-XXXX DOCLJnlcr- t 1, '\ u.s. Patent .luI. 15, 20()3 E:nterc rl (H, r:LS' 1 [locket 09/08/2010 Sheet 7 of 7 Figure 7 Page 9 of 9 US D477,235 S
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
