Acushnet Company et al v. onlinegolfsale.us et al, No. 0:2013cv61895 - Document 12 (S.D. Fla. 2013)
Court Description: ORDER granting 5 Ex Parte Application for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Setting Hearing on Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by Judge James I. Cohn on 9/13/2013. (npd)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Acushnet Company et al v. onlinegolfsale.us et al Doc. 12 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SO UTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO .1361895- V- HN/ TZER CI CO SEL ' r AçUSHNET COMPANY, taI, ' e , r ! pj nt f , ai is f Vsq , ( ONLI NEGOLFSALE. etaI, US, . I i ( Dee d ns fn a t. / O RDER G RA NTI SX PAR TS APPLI NG CATI FO R ENTRY O F ON TEMPOG RY REiTG i NG ORDi*XNDSE I HEARI iI TTNG NG O N M OTI N FO R PRELI I O M NARY I NJUNGTI N O THI CAUSE i b or t Cour on Pl ni 'Ex Pade Appl ai f Enr o S s ef e he t ait #s i ton or ty i c l T4mp ar Resr nig Or a Pr i nay Ij t I 51 ( iai f k or y tai n der nd el r nunci DE mi on ' c t or Appl on l ' Timp ar Re tai n Or '.Th Cou ha c efl c si e t Appl ai f or y sr nig der) e d s ar ul on derd he ' y i t or c on l 6 Tpmp ar Resr nigOr andi ote- ief l a s d i te pr s . or y tai n der s h s ul dvie n h emies y j g 1 . ; l Pl ni lmo e pade p s an t 1 U. C.j 111 Fe R.Ci P.65 an4 ait #s ve x uru t o 5 S. 6, d, v. - l ( The AIW rs Ac,28 U. C j1 ( ,f enr o a tmp ar rsr nn orer an I i t t S. 651a) or ty f e or y e taiig d , i j 2 i 2 ' u n ex r t o t tor ,a pr i n y ij nci ag n tDe en t f al t po pia i f ha der on el ar n u ton ais f dan s, or l mi ege y q ) viain o teL n a Ac, 5U. C. j1 1 a d1 2 () ilt s fh a h m t1 S. j 1 4 n 1 5a. o ë : 1 l l 1pl n isar Ac sh tComp y ( s et) Cal wa Gol Compan (cal wa ait e u ne ' an ' hn ', l y f Acu ' a y' l y ' a Gpl' Rogerclv an GolCompan I .a d sRl ods Lmi ( n l ' ev and lr) , e el d f y,nc n sp i t j t ' el ed oi y cl Gcl',yltnM adiasGol'oolectiel'ast#sl)n Ty r d Go Cmpn, b'Krua auatrgc(roai yI rni''ad al Mae l o ayj l ) ase nfcuif) cpl tn(' aie ' f n r o 'Pl tn) o f v x Ir. 'a or de- d n (T . 2teen a t aeteP dn rhp a dUnn op rtdAs o it n ie tido f d ns r h a es is n ic roae s cai s d nie n o f sih l ' ' ert (ol t el ' f dans) edue A'h eo c l i y ' en tp. ec v De i I i I l l Dockets.Justia.com l ! I ; ) @ ! l l r 1 . ! ) Fa ual ck ound ct Ba or r ( l $ Th Coud ba es t s Or on t f lwig f t fo Pl n is'Compl n, e s hi der he ol n acs rm ait o # aitr Aqpiat f Temp ar Resr nigOr , ds origevdeni ys mison l i or c on or y tai n der an upp t n i t ub s i s: ar i I 1 1. 4 Pl nt# Acushneti t owneroft f l ng t@demar ont Prnci l ai i s he he ol owi r ks he i pal ) , Ri sero te Uni Stts Paen an TrdemakO#ie (ol tv y,te ' s et git f h t ae t t d a ed r c c l iel h ' hn ! ec Acu l ' ,. 1 M@r s) qk . i kTr adema k r l ; l TI EI l TL ST ( TI EI TL ST Regj rton Regi rton sta i sta i Number Dat e 31 118 6 , August1 , 4 doox 1 '* > 'J cj lGoods ass i I 028 -gol bals C f l l r l 93 406 4, I 028-g fequimen co i ngi C ol p t mpr si Ma 23,1 72 g fb l g fcu g fb , f y 9 ol al ol lbs, ol ags goll s, Ma 2 1 8 g jb l, g lcu sa Jg lb g : y 6, 9 1 of al of lb n of a s s oves and gol headcover f s gI j i- l *#oe >v , @ . 11 57 6 ,5 ,6 iR lM . . 1601,c34 ' i pRo vl 2,0 ,1 8 69 9 i : I o28 -golequi c f pment namel ' y, June 12, 1 9:c I c28 c g fbal ol l s ( b l j j TI EI TL ST ! f Ap2 l ; ) j 2 3,7 8 1 6,25 911 a,8a1, aa,4 yjj yg J n ay2 , j c a- olb l a u r o c 2 g f al s 2 004 Nw emb er j g c z5 28 zcx y sadwe ar , August10, l c28 golcl s c f ub 2o1 c Augu t1 s 0, j g goj cj c a8 f ubs ) . - zj i; j l ) ( . ) ; ; ! ! Fooq ov w l l 1,98,07 1 0 . -J e' un D' 1 982 I o22 -dr shoes. c ess casual s es, g f oes aiei s es, j ho olsh , tltc ho b t , s k an golglv el oc s d f o es s k ) Tq Acs ntMak aeue ic n et nwi tema uatr o g le up n a k l u h e rs r sd n o n ci t h nfcue f of q ime t n e o h l : r at pr t.See Decar i o Lia Ro i Supp ofPl ni Ap iat f dl ed oducs l at f s gan n on od ait #s' pl i or c on ) Timporr Resri n Orer (Ro Dec. $1 4, 5; s alo Uni d Stt ay tanig d ' gan ' l' 1 ' ) ee s t e aeq I l 2 ' t i ) i l k Tr emar Re srton o teAc hn tMarsa isu at h a Co ost Ex bj qd k gitai s f h us e k ts e tac ed s mp i hj j e l i l A i teRo a De l o h g n c. ! @ j p q 2 pl nt, cal ai i l away ool i t owner oft f l ng tademar on t f s he he ol owi r ks hei : , PI rn i lRegit oft Uni d St t Pa en an Tr demar O#ie ( ol t el t ei icpa s er he t e aes t t d a k c c l i y, h ec v j ' ' l ' l GolMars' ça away f k ': ) q ; l Regi r i st aton ITr ademar k ! Regi r i st aton Number Dat e : ' Cl lGoods ass ' p I 028 -golcl golbags,gol C f ubs, f f 5 Od s ey ! ys 1,70 2 4,95 ' ead J y28,1 92 cl er f golccls' s aqs,i f ul 9 cubh or, ffuub hand grps or o s v eads gollb h h ) goI cl and gol bal f ubs, f l s C I 024 -gol t el c f ow s j j lwayGol cal a f i ) 2,60,5 1 17 i I 0 -s rs, wea er ,ac e s, c 25 hi s t s j k t t Ma 2 1 98 has, a an vsor y 6, 9 t c ps d i s l 0 -golcl s, fba a ; c 28 f ub gol gs, nd golcu hea c v s f lb d o er 4 ; p l I o24 -golt s c f owel I wa j I 025-s rs, wea er j k t , : c hi s t s,ac e s t (Go e w j i WV R Z ! 211 6 Jn 2 19 ht,asadv os 6, 9 ue ,98 ascp,n i r 5 s l I 0 -golcu , fbag an C 28 f lbs gol s, d ( g fcl h c er ol ub ead ov s l j ! l y j CzlWa a 2,6 ,3 1 60 3 l j cal wa l y a 2,60,64 3 6 JBgB ra i et h l 2769, 9 31 2 , l FT i 3, 223 263, j FT: 3, 203 593, BP B RT ol t E HA u , o 3, 8 595,21 I l i p - gjyg j j; gy j ar, . goj ojy o y jy, J e2 un 0, aaa a I 028 -golbal C f l s do IW aD Wo dU?U l l p ë j j i l ! s0, mbr c v2 -dloj bglcu ha j et0 3 l 0r ag flbags flb ed y pe e C es nogcf ,o 8 u 3 20 o J y1 2 ul 0, 007 I 0 -g fclbs C 28 ol u l k Mar h 1 c 7, I 028-c v s f golcl s; ol 1 C o er or f ub g f zcc: Mar h 2 c 4, zcc q l 1 ; cj cover golcl ub s; f ubs , l I 028-g fcu h d c v sf C ol lbs; ea o er or gojcu ; fb s; fbal f lbs gol ag gol l s k i ) 3 y i I i l ; l l ! q og *a . I v ! l j FT l i Z - j ! x- HoT 24 l o nv vnv v *' ''' % 'u' ' ( ) ' 3, 7,87 73 6 Sepember1 t , 2009 ganuar 12, y zcjc l 028-g fb ; fbal ; f c ol ags gol l gol s cl ;h dc er f golcu ubs ea ov s or f lbs 4 I 028-gol cl , golcubh C f ubs f l ead i juags and com ponent c er , ov s goI Cu he jb ads ! 3, 857 874, sovem ber:, 2o1o j c2a-gofcu c l lbs 1 . t 2 RAZR Hawk 3, 419 979, June 14, zcjj f ubs I 028 -goI cl C r I The Cal l away Gol Mar ar used i connecton wih t manuf t e of gol f ks e n i t he acur f l I ejupmen an r aed prdu t See Decart o Sona L ii Su od o Pl nis: i t d elt o cs. l ai f i ar n pp f ait on # l ' Appl aton f Tempor y Restaiig Or (.ar oe I' v .,s.s alo uni k ' ) , ee s t! ed i i or c ar r nn der L i c. v , 1 St es Tr at ademar Regi r i of t Cal k statons he l away Gol Mar at i f ks ssue atached a? t ; i : Cimpo i Ex biA t te k i l st hi t o h arDec. e 3 Plit Clv ln Gofi teo e o te flwig t d mars o tJ . ani e ea d l s h wn r f h ol n r e k n h # o a i P'n ia Re itro te untd sae p tn a dTrd mako'c (olciey tk ç cp l gse f h i tts ae t n a e r ie c l t l,h e e v 1 , , ' ev an GolMar s ) ' el d f k : Gl ' l ) rTr k ! adem ar I Regjt.a i s r ton sl r u w NumDer Regite i ua.aton Cl se )ooods a ' ! . q t I o18 -caryaIbagsand c r I l ! u r ls mbel . a ; ! j I 1**- # A-H p l 20 0.5 .7 ' 1 0 ' ' # I 0 -golappar1i and s dst C 25 f ehnamel hi ,ds y, c , s ss t aps vior , wea s j J19570 s ae v ss D e1 , we tr e t. n- I 028-g fcu , fcub h C ol lbs goj l eads i j ! g lcu sa s g fcu gis g Ip of lb h q ,ol lb r r oi p b g ,of a cv r, n g lcu l a sg lb g oes a d of lb @ h c er . ead ov s I 1 1 j t l l r 4 . ' l l l r I o18 -cary al bags and c r l l ; u el s. mbr l a y I 02 -gol a e1 n y, his, C 5 f ppar , amel s r ) t i E ND CL VEG 2070, 054 , caps, vi s sweat ds and sor shi Jjggv0 s ae vss u e1 , we tr ei. n l C i t I 028 -g fcub , gol cl heads, c ol l s f ub l ; g lcu s a s g lcu ggoI cl l b f lbfh qcover lb r s gub o gol bag , of and i i of p ags, s, 2 head cover s. . t y j l j 1 December C ! SRI XON I 028 -golcl and golcl C f ubs, f ub ï 2,0 ,5 3 22 1 o j o h a s n mey wo d ,r sa d j o o e d , a l, o s i n on -' ' ' vvv put s ter I 0 -Golwe , mel,c ps E C 25 f ar na y a . 2 December I 028 -Bags,namel golbags C y, f 9 3,3 9 52 , 1 , 9 7 e up n fr ofe p caj, u 6 19 q ime to g l se ij bk t y notlm i t gol bal gol cl i t o, f l ed s, f ubs. I 028 -Gol cl and gol cl C f ubs f ub 4l GROOVES !P 3463, 468 , h acj,aand ,etdwood-o tgol ef s n l al e ,rype e y ny Jul 8,2008 gojdubsme mwe g s it - p f y ; cl s a he ub nd ads. ! ! ) . Th Clvel d Gol Mars ar u ed i c nne t wi t ma f t e o gol e e an f k e s n o ci on t he nuacur f f h i ù q e up n a d rltdpo ut.Se De lrt n o Se h nGigih i Su p do j ime t n eae rd cs e caai f tp e n r n p o l o c j l ? 1 1 , 1 E Pt nis Ap ia i f Temp ar Re tai n Or (Gi ih De .)$1 4,5:s aitf pl ton or f c or y sr nig der ngr c cl 1 e4 l * j i Uni Stt Trdemar Regsr i s o te Cl ean Gol Mars atis i t ed aes a k itat on f h ev l d f k su 3 ) a h asCo %ac ed mpost Ex biA t t Gigr h Dec. i hi t o he n i e c l ) @ i i 4 ù Pl n i Kart i t o ero t e f l n tademars on t Prn ia! ait , sen s he wn f h ol g r owi k he icp . è ! ! Rè sero t e Unt St t Pa en an Tr emar Ofie (ol c iel,t e ' sed git f h i ed a es t t d ad k f c lt y h ' t c e v Kar ! l ) q @ars': k' ) i l l I i ! l i 8 5 j i ' : ë ) ! j ) i # p jyyy mak ag r q i Re f rt Re s rt oitai on gitai on Number ! r PI NG ! RAPTURE 3, 950 249, q ' l R-QH > ; G/10 i 3' '65 2623 3,454,41 8 l Ra vo , ! V> I 3 : ! 70 5 4,52 538,46 3 , cjs / d a s Goo s Dat e l l 1 Se ember2 pt 0, 1 960 I 28 -Golcub C f l s. June 5,2007 I 28-Golcl C f ubs. f ) r i Jul 1 200 I 28-Golcub y 0, 7 C f l s. ( ! Ju e 2 20 I 28-Golcl . n 4, 08 C f ubs ( k No e e 2 ,j 2 . lcu s v2008r 5 c 8 oof lb mb 1 j . ! ; j RAPTURE V2 3, , 1 541 51 pa my y j j r x ca z o , s ' ' G 15 3, 930 696, Oct ober13 I 2 -Gof q ime tn mel, oi C 8 le up n, a y g l 2009 , cl . ubs i G1 5 k 3716, 878 No emb r 4 cl 2 and gol bags n, a l, oi v2009 2 ,Iubs -Gof fup tn mey g l e C 8 le ime q 3 909, 121 I 25 -He C adgear namel c s an , y ap dl ! vs s iot Januar 18, I 28 y ) 2011 c Gol cu ba Gol cub C f lb gs; f l 1 ! i ! q K15 , , 20 . o oj rj y uyys y . . - cover ool cl s; f ubs. 1 J l I x yN . 3, 3 949,44 , I ! i & a& , . I 2 -Golcubb ;Golcu ; g C 8 f l ags f lbs Head cover f gol cl s or f ubs. 1647, 448 5 I 2 -Hea C 5 dgear n , amel ca an y ps di q i s sor v Aprl 9, 1 i1 201 i t k PNG I ( @ k ' I 1 - lacsoisn mey l C 8 Gof cesr ,a l e June 11,1991 um br l and tavelng bags. el as r l i ( ! I 28-Gol b s; fcu ;Hea ) C f ag Gol lbs d 4,2 71 1 9, 5 Apr 1 201 c v sf golcub i 7, 2 o er or f l s l G2 0 4, 29,86 1 1 l 28 -Golb C f ags; fcl s;He t Gol ub ad Apr 1 201 c v sf golcub i 7, 2 o er or f l s l t h j& & & 4, 2,69 36 0 I 28 -Golb Golcl s;He i C f ags; f ub ad Juy2, 3 c er f gol cu s l 201 ov s or f lb E 4, 1 373, 60 I 28 -Gol bags;G ol cl C f f ubs;Head ' Jul 23,2013 cover f gol cl y s or f ubs i h j ( q i T j ) ' G25 ; q . .. . . . ! i q l 1 . 2 6 ) 2 j . 4 . ! ' ) j 6 I 28-Golbag Golcl s;Hea ) C f s; f ub d qz & % 44978 A r1,02 CVrfro c b ,, 2 3 pi 72 1 OeSogj l s l fu l j 4,32,97 1 6 I 28-Golbags;Golcl Head C f f ubs; Aprl 201 c er f golcl s i24, 2 ov s or f ub ) ' 163 4 , 2,45 Januar <<' bags, golb l an h c er f 1y 991 f al d ead ov s oi s, I 2Q j ! pl No . oo ) 3, 098 230, q ; I 28-Golcl f uni s, ol l C f ubs orj or g f b f j or ,g fgl es, d ags or uni s ol ov an Aprl1 2007 di r rt s f goler Stess i 7, vot epai ool or f s; r r ifbal f h e er s an goj el e l or and x cie d f s 1 ! l 28-Sp nggoo ;n y, i c odi ds amel gol golcl s f ub ( PI NG j bal t l ees . i 15 l 33,3 ,22 77 T 3 7 ( nec ember2 , : zc cbadllasnnmlgl oq I2-oouget ae,o c sngfi , y f j8o fqp u ebm j l I 15 696, 931 , O c ober13, I 28 -Gol equi t C f pment namel gol , y, f 2009 cj ubs : ' ( . ! Kart Mar s ar us d i c ne t wi t man f t e ofg fequi s en k e e n on c i t he on h u acur ol pmen an# t E Tp e l i rit pr cs Se Decar i o J Ha eni Supp to Pl nif Appl ainf el ed odu t. e l at f ud wk n a on or f aitf s' i to or c j ' Tj oay Re tann Ore (Ha en De I' II4,5 s e alo Untd Sae! mp rr sriig d r ' wk d c. I ' ! ) , ' e s i ttq e l Ti emar Regitai sofh Kart Marsa is e atch asComp i ExhbtA ad k srton te sen k ts u ta ed ost e ii ( ' ih Ha e oe l te wk n c tE o l l $ t . 5. Pl n i Ta or de- dias Gol i t e own oft e f lwi tademar s ait yl Ma a d # fs h er h ol ng r o k i ott Prn pal it o te Uni d Stt Paen andTr emar Ofie(ol t l; he ici Regser f h t aes t t e ad k f c l i y c ec ve * ' i t: j l Ma a da GolMar s$ h I or de- di s f k 1: Tay ) r ( q l jTr demar a k i q ; Regl r ton Re sta i sta i gi r ton Num ber Dat e Clssyooods a l i ) ' i i v oRMAD A E p u 12 os 2 ,o ,4 J l6 1 8 I o 8- lcu s uy ,9 2 c 2 oof lb , q i 1 YAYLOR MADE 1374, 009 Dec er3, I 028 -golbagsand golcl emb C f f ub ' I I j , 1985 : ' $ l ! l head cover s. 7 ' l I i ! I jBR E U NR j ! j RESCUE ' i 4 z4,ao a II,w , ,w w= 2,92, 4 0 03 sepemb t er j g c z8 a jx cq : . ' gjls ocb. fu 1 j Au s 26, j c gojcub gu t c z8 f l s. $-ov q ' '' '- l j i . t I o18 -ool um br l , c f el as d and b s,n y, - an st t ag amel non c va o ei b s, or f s. ag f gol er ! . I 02 -clt n , nam el hat c 5 o hig y, s, ! : l r j ' r ae e j ë 2557, 110 , Aprl 2002 i2, l . j j ) I 018 -Golumbr l I C f el uggage @ as, and bags,namel nony, canvast ej ot bags, orgoler f f s. ; I 025 - cl hi g,namel hat c l ot n y, s, ! j * I @# 1 1 I k l vsor c s, i s, kds, ou es, i s, ap shr s i bl s j t s er sl s, sh weat s, ack ods,ac e s, l j kt 25 71 1 Api ,0 2 c as. ulv r,adg n a d ,5 ,1 r2 2 0 Shoesp l es c ria s n l o t, o l 0 8-Gof q ime tn mey c 2 le up n, a l gol cu , fgrp put s f lbs gol is, ter , s qs, olbal g fglve gol ha g f l ol o s, f s, l t ees,gol cl c s,and gol f ub over f ( ! b . ags l ) l RossA i i ! l I R7 2, 220 820, 2I o,aso ge Ma ch2, r zoc4 q n qo n v q j r *' * %'' % K' * ' ' R9 3, 607 652, p l 0c8-Goffgrp putermey i c 2u , le upme tn l, l q i n, a g f lbs gol is, t s, ol shaqs, g fcl c v s, d g f l ol ub o er an ol f bag s. i y, I c 8- le up n, namel ë c 2 oof q ime t June 7,2oo5 gol cl wedges,ions,gol cl , f ubs, r f ub h s, ol cu sh qs. ead g f lb a I i I I 02 -Golequpmen ,n y c 8 f i t amel golcub gofgrp put s f l s, l is ter , t s, fcu c er and gol ee gol lb ov s, f b ags t $ vs r, a s ios c p . s a sg lb l,of lv s g l h q , of al g igoe ,of s i i l q ù ; lg a e r ugg Decem ber 20, 200 5 $ I 028 -G ol equi c f pment namel q , y, i golcl s, ha t golcu c er / f ub s fs, f lb ov s. I 028 -ool equi ent namel ë c f pm , y, ' Jul 7, y 2009 golcl golheads, fcl f ubs, f gol ub ; sas hq . 8 ! ' l i : # i . @ MURNER PL US p 673, 923 , l l ' i 3 J ' , ! i 38 87 3 ,6 ,4 August25, 2009 Oct ober26, 2 0 01 ' l I 028 -Gol cl C f ubs. ' I f2ubs,shaftimebalsmey ! c0 8-ofqs,goln,l gol, l gleup ftn l a f golcl goe , of lbcv r a jg j j lv s g lcu oes n of b ags. l ( I 028-Golequi C f pment qnamel i y, 9ol cl gol grps gol cl f ubs, f i f ub l R1 1 1 39 ,6 Api2 2 1 h d , of lbsa s a dg j y ,510 6 r 6,01 ea sg lcu h à , n of ! l bags. j ( $ The Tayor e- das Gol Mars ar u ed i c n t wi t manu acur o g f l Mad adi f k e s n on ec i t he on h f t e f ol i $ @ e up n a d rltd po cs S e De lrt n o J n B.Zu rh ri Su p r o j ime t n eae rdu t. e caai f e i o ec e n p ot i 4 $ Pt n i 'Appiat f Te ait #s l i or mpor y Res r nig Or erCzu c erDec.)? 4,5;s ' c on ar tai n d er h I' ' e# i adem ar Regi r i of t Tayl M ade- das Gol M ar at k statons he or adi f ks al Unied st es Tr qo t at i ; i; u at edas Compo t Exhbt t t e Zu c erDec. s e t p ach si e iiA o h er h l 1 6 ) Def endant , t ough t I er websies oper i under t domai s hr he nt net t atng he t i , 1 n#mes i t i on Sc dul ' ' h et (he ' bec Domai Names ) h 4 den ied f he e ' ' er o t ' j t A Su n , av j - alv die po td, 'ee fr ae, n /r od, tIa t( g lcu s g lb l , ot i e s d, rmoe o rd o s l a do s l a e s,i of lb , of al g l ) s è ' bl s, gol headcover gol gl ag f s, f oves,headwear gol shoes,and sof goods,bearng whai , f t i y è Pt ni Ac s etha deer ned t b c nerei ,r odu ton an orc or 4 aitf u hn f s t mi o e ou t f t epr ci s, d/ ol abl s 1 t - ilain o teAc s n tMak ;i g lcu s g lb l, ofb g , n c p b aij si t s f h u h e rs () of lb , of al g l a s a d a s e r to i s n q wha pl ni cal y Gol h deer n d t be c t t r o ton an ot t ait , l awa f as t mie o oune/ei eprduci s, d/ s, ! : i clrbei tt n o teCalwa GofMak;(ig lcusa dg lb g b aii poa l mi i s f h l y l rs i) of lb n of a s e r ao a i n j i wha Pl ni Cl el Gol h d er n t b c t t r r ci ,an oi t aitf ev and f as et mied o e oune#ei epodu t f s, ons d/ i l ) c orbl i tton oft Cl el Gol Mars' ( ) gol cub g f b s,an il a e mi i s a he ev and f k , i v f l s, ol ag d r ; 1 ) um br l bearng what Pl ntf Kar en has det m i el as i ai if st er ned t be count f t o ereisk ! ! r r c i s,an / c or e i t to o t e Kart Mars;an ()gol cl s,g f #p odu t on d or ol abl mi ins f h a sen k d v f ub ol 1 1 9 p q r,g l b g ,a d a p rlb aig wh t Plit Ta lr d -dd s Gofh s ù es of a s n p ae e r n a ani yoMa ea ia l a l : i ) dut m i t be count t , r oductons, and/ col abl i t i ier ned o eieis epr i or or e miatons of t y hel i ! Tj l Mad adi Gol Mar s See Rogan Dec. 8- 4*L iDecl11 8 1 Gigrc ë yor e- das f k . lM 1 , ar . 11 - 4; n ih i ' : r l ! 4 D#c. I 8- 4.Ha en DeclI! 8- 4.Zu c erDec.1 8 1 Decar t ofSt en lI! 1 , wk I . I 1 , er h I l 1 - 4; l a i $ on eph r Mioa ' mgan i su n ppod o pl nis Appl ai f Tempor y Resr nig Or f aitf' f i t or c on ar tai n dei i (oafg De .)! 2 a Compo t Exhbi A, C,D, d E t t e Ga gan Dec. ' fian cl, 1 nd d , si e i t B, s an o h #i l 1 i ! 7 . ; i Alhough each Def t endant m ay not copy and i rnge each Pl nt#si nfi ai i ' idvd a t d mak fre c c tg r o g o spoe td Pl nt#s have subm it j n iiu l r e rs o a h ae oy f o d rtce ai i i a te , I p s#iin e ie c s o n ta e c Dee d n h sifig d a Ia to eo moeo t ce t vd n e h wig h t a h fn a t a nr e , te s, n r r j ) n : ! t h 1 2 : tad r emars atis e.See Rogan Dec.! 1 L iDec.1 1 ,Gigrc Dec.1 1 k su l 1 3; ar l 1 3* n ih l 1 3k Hq en Dec.! 1 ,ZuerherDecl! 13.Def wk l 1 3. c .1 endant ar notno norh e t ey ev t s e w, av h ei i b auh ied orI ens d t us r o e,ormak c t t,r odu t sj ien, tor z i e o e, eprduc c e oune/ei epr ci s on : p ' ap / c or e i t ton o t e Ac sh etMar s Calaway Gol M ar Cl and ool I or ol abl mi i s f h u n d a k, l f f ks, evel j ' k l Ma adi s f k c l i y ' n i ! ec v Pl #s Mar Kart Mars, and Tayor de- da Gol Mar s ( ol t el, d ait i ks, s en i l l! ; ar Dec. 1 ; ngr ch cl: ; wk cl1 ; Màrs'. Rogan Dec. 111 L i l! 11 Gi i De . 111 Ha en De .111 k ' See ) l i er Zq cherDeclv 11. . i j j 8. I Plit r e entt e r viwed andvi al i p t t i an i epr s a i e e #s' v su l ns ec ed he t bear y ems i nk j ë Psitf'e p cieta e rso ee frs l tru hteIt n t b i so eaig anis rs e t rd mak # rd o ae ho g h nere we st p rt f v e n 1 ! u h er h su jc oo i Na s a d d tr n d te po cs t b u auh r e ; d te be t man me n eemie h rdu t o e n toi d z I ' 1 n ng n ie v rin o plit s po cs s e Ro a De lII1 -4 L rDe l$ 4 -e un eso s f ani ' rdu t. e g n c. I 21 ; ai c. 1 , ! l 1 1 Gi ihDec.SI1 1 Ha enDec.N 1 1 Zu c erDecl$1 1 1 /-4; ngr c lI 2-4; wk lI 2-4; erh . 1 2-4, 1 l 10 I. I LEG AL STA NDARD re' i ( i I orert Obai atmpor yr tai ngOrer a pady m ustdemonstat '1)M n d o t n e ar esr ni d , l l ! sq s an i I el oo o su c son t e mert , 2)t ati ep abl ij r wi be s #er b t t i i d f c es al k h h i ( h r ar e n u y l u ed s' r l i!h r i i n gr t ,( tatte t eat d ij y ouwei s te har te r i , fi e el s ot aned' 3) h h hr ene nur t gh h ef m h el ef ) ' wpul ifiton t e n - an ;an ( t a t e en r o t e r i woud s v t 4 d nl c h on mov t d 4) h t h ty f h el ef l ere h à c Pi i i er 'Sc a o ex. eI hi erv. hiv 403 F. 1 ?bl nt est' hiv r Sc ndl Sc a o, 3d 223,1 -26 ( t Cir 225 11h r . 2 5)( c i ;se alo L iStau s & Co.v Sunr e IrlTrdic Ic. 51 F.3d t0 per ur aml e s ev r s . i n. an n , s ; l 9 9 ( t Ci.19 (pplig tet tt a pr i n y ijnci i a L ha Ad t2, 85 11h r 95) a yn h es o el ar nu t n an m mi on ( i c s .Addion l a c ma o y isu at or rsri n orerwi tn iq i e) t al i y, oud y nl s e emp al e tanig d t hou ot c t t adver pary oris ator i: o he se t t t ney f i ( sp ic f t i an a d i or a v ied c Al ecf acs n i #iavt er i ompl n ce l sh w t f f ait lar y o ha i mmedit an i ep abl ij y I s ordama wi r ul t t mov j a e d r ar e nur , os , r ge l es t o he l an bef e t or he adver se pady can be hear d i opposii n ton; ani ( t e mo nt ator e c f i wr ig anye t made t gie no ie an ( Blh va ' t n y edies n in s i t #ors o v tc t t r he easonsw hyi shoul notbe r r t d equied. , i ) Fqd R.Ci P.65( )1 . Ex paàe t 7 empor yr taiig orer ' oul be r titd t) ar esr nn d s ' d esr e i sh c v. b () . t h k ei underyi pur r l ng pose ofpr vi t st us quo and pr eser ng he at eventng ir abl i repar : ' s vig ir n 1 h r js s 'o g a i n c s ayt h l a h aig a d n In e . Grn v Go s im u t o ln s s e e s r o od e r n o o g r' a n o : n ' ( r F o s Ic v Bh o Te mses&AuoTrc Dr esL c l . 0o Almed Cnv; i d ,n . . d. f a tr t u k i r o a No 7 f a ia t. v i 4i u, 4 3, 9(9 4. 5 s. 2 43 1 7 ) i l l 11 1. ANALYSI S 1 The decl atons Pl ntfs have submied i suppod of t r Appl i ar i ai i t n t hei i on cat ! T4m por y Res r ni Or suppod t f l i concl ons ofI : ar tai ng der he ol ng ow usi aw ! ' 'j ! l r k l q ! q l A. Pl nt's have a ver s r pr ly ofpr ng atti t consumer q p ai i y tong obabit i ovi ral hat sl 1 l ar l el t be c f s b Deend t'a ediement pr ton,s e,of f s e, i i y o onu ed y f ans dv s k , omoi al fer or al ! : ' r iti t f of lb , of u es g l al g l a s g l e d o es g l ko dsr uino g lcu s g lp q r, ofb l, ofb g , ofh a c v r, of / b o s l an i 1 1 glv , headwear gol shoes, um br l and sof goods bearng count t r p es $ , f el as, t i e/eis' 1 , l r odu t an orc l abl i tton o te Pl ni Mars,an t tte podu t ejr ci ons d/ oor e mi i s f h ait a #s k d ha h r csi ! l Dke d nsaes ln a d po t gaec pe o Plit 'e p cie po u t taE fn a t r elg n rmoi r o is f ani rs e t rd cs h t i n #s v ; $ y i copi oft Pl nt 'M ar s on gol cl , gol puter gol bal gol bags,gol k f ubs b,ar es he ai i 's f t s, f l s, f f l h c v s, fglve h d , fs es, r l , s qgoods iad o er gol o s, ea weargol ho umbel and o as . 1 i B Because of t i rngem ent of Pl n i s' M ar , he nfi ait# ks ( l ) Pani aele tj l ts r il o i# ky : ' ant t s #eri t mmedi e and i ep abl ij y i a t or y r r ni or i notgr ed.I at r ar e nur f emp ar estai ng der s r ) l ; cl l appear fom t f l ng specii f s,as setf t i Pl nt#s, Compl nt' 4ary s r he ol owi fc act orh n ai i ai , l ; ! ar r ni der ng ar i i e, Akpl i f Tem por y Restai ng O r , and accom panyi decl atons on fl r i on or cat I i t! i hj mmedit a i ep abl Is , damage,an ij y wi r s tt Pl n i an t t a e nd r ar e o s r d nur l e ul o ait l #s d : ! k c s s b or Deen t c be he d i op ion unl s Pl ni rqu tf dn umer ef e f dans an ar n post i es ait e es or #s' J l i ! ! ) e pa r ifi gr t d: y de el s an e e l i oef dan s own or con r It n webst bu n s whi en t tol n er et i e sies es ch ! R v t e,Pr t O#erOrS e, d s latI tg fcub golput s, fbal goi j eri omoe, f al an el eas ol l s, f ter gol l 2 s , s, i r b gs,g f h dc v s,gol glv he wear gol s es,u el an s f g # à ol ea o er f o es, ad , f ho mbr l as, d o t ood l ) bl igc nereian ifigigta #arn ou t f t d nrn n rdemarsi vi at o Pl nis r t k n ol i f ait 'i s; on l gh i l 2, l Th e i goo c et b i et tmor c t tan ifigit er s d aus o el ha ev e oune#ei d nrn n r ' pqdu t b ig pl ni 'rsp t e ta o cs earn ait e eci rdemarswi app i te marepl e;ta gs v k l ear n h l k t ac h f l ! c su s ae Iel t b mild,c fs an di poit byt qualy o tesr in mer r i y o e se onu ed, d sap ned he i f h i k t i I pt t and t Pl ntfs m ay su#erI s ofsal f is genui pr t ,and oduc s; hat ai i f os es or t ne oduc s' I ! t 1 t 1 1 i ! 12 ' l ! i j 3. Th ei go c et b i etatiPl ni pr ee onnoietr er s od aus o el h f ait oc d ev #s t o c l ) Dien t onti Appiat f Tempor yResr ni Or ,Deen t c e l f dans hs l i or c on ar tai ng der f dans an asi k I ) aqdquikytan f t e r srto f man ofte Subec Do n Name ormodi c l r ser h egitains or y h j t mai s, f f rjsrt n d t a d c ne t c a g h ss a d rdrc t #c t oh rwe sts! e it i aa n o tn, h n e o t, n è i t r i o te b i ' ao e a e l t ebyt h:r hwadi Pl nt#s'abit t obt nmeani ulr i . ng ai i ly o ai i ngf el ef d ! t i q C. The bal ance ofpot i har t Def ental m o endant i r r ni t rtade i s n estai ng hei r nj j ) i . ! 4 c ne#eiand ifigig br dedgood iat iu t t nrn n an s f empor yr taiig or i i u i f ar esr nn ders ss ed s ai i q oëwei ed b te p eni har t Pl ni tei rsp t e r t i s a g wi t gh y h ot tal m o ait h r e eci epuat #s, v on nd ood l l as m anuf t er and di rbut s ofqualy pr ac ur s sti or i oduct i such r i i noti t s,f el s ef ssued. D, The publ i er tf s i i nt es avor ssuance oft t c he empor y r r ni or i ar estai ng der q o'ert pr ect Pl nt#s'r o ot ai i espectke tademar i er s and pr ec t publ foM i r k nt est ot t he i r c ) ? bii de r edb t pal n ofo c t f tgoo a g nego o Pl ni ) ng faud y he mig f f ounerei ds s enui ods f ait ' #s l è : .t I. v co scuusl N o i 1 F ort e f egoig r s s,ii h or n ea on ts i k l O RDERED AND ADJUDG ED t hat Pl nt#s, Ap iat ai i pl i f Te c on or mpor v a Rh tann ore ( 5 i h rb ORANTED a flws sriig d rDE 1s ee y s ol : o l 1 () 1 Each Def endant i om cer diect s,em pl ,t s s, r or oyees, agent subsi ares, s, di i di i tr an alp s si acie c c orp cpat wi an Deen th ig kr os, d I eron n t on ed adii i t y f dan avn bu v on h 1 r l l . a Fr manuf urng,i podi advedi ng,pr om act i m ng, si omotng,c#erng t i i p n1ie o t sOr ar her yt gt f hi der e eb empo arl r tane c r i es r i d: y j . s l s l g,diti tn ortan f r an p odu t be ig t é el eln s r ig, r s eri , i bu ng y r c s arn h Ac s n t Mak ,Calwa Gof Mak ,Clv a d Gof Mak t u h e rs l y l rs e eln l rs a Kart Mars, an / Tayor - di Gol Mars or an sen k dor l Made a das f k , 9 conf ngl si i usi y m l tadem ar s, ot ar r k her t han t hose act l ual y m anu ac ur ordi rbut by Pl nt#s;and f t ed sti ed ai i I ! - 13 # ) i b . t Fr secr i conc i destoyi selng o#,tans eri or om etng, eal ng, r ng, l i r f rng, ot ie dip i of ( an pr t , not manu acur ot he- s s osng : i y oducs ) f t ed ditiuedbyPl ni be igt Ac hn Mars, lwayGol srb t ait #s, arn he us et k Cal a t M ar Cl and Gol M ar s,Kar en M ar and/ Tayl M adet ks, evel f k st ks, or or q adi Gol Mars, anyc f si ysi i tademars' ()an das f k or on u ngl m l r ar k, i y or i evd:nc r a ig t t e manuac ur i i e eltn o h f t e, mpoda i s e,oferf ton, al f o4 sar dsrl t nGolrnfroevelpoG ol Mb argtstAc sn ! Mlks,Calaway, r M are Cl n andd cs ar iKar en M are! ae, itiui o fa ss, fa y r u t eks, h u hks, bo t k n e f ! i i ! $ and/ Tayl M ade- das Gol M ar or any conf ngl si i or or adi f ks, usi y m l at tadem ar r ks. ! ( 2) l r d:rbut s iti or , ) Eac Def dan ,i o c s,di t s,emply h en t t #ier r or s ec o ees,agens,sub i ar ; t sdi i es ) a d aIp ro s i a t e c n eto p iiain wi a y oee d nk n I es n n ci o c r r adcp t t n fn a t, v o h I hqvi notce of t s Or shal i ! ng i hi der l mmedi el di at y scontnue t use of t Acushne, i he he ! Màr Cal ks, l awayGol Mar f ks,Cl and Gol Mar Kar en Mar and/ Tayl Madel evel f ks, st ks, or or i i a' d Gol Mars oran c f igl si l tade k on ori c eci wi aI dias f k y on usn y mi r mars, ar n onn ton t I h q X ' ' Itre we sts o e an o eae orc nrl d b te icu ig te Itre nen t b i wn d d p rtd, o tol y h m n ldn h nen i e e j j i ' w4b t oper i un t e Subec Domai Na ; si es at ng der h j t n mes I l r (' 3) ' ' ' Each Def endant i o'ier di t s,emply s c s, r or ec o ees,agens,su i ar i t bsdi i es , t . diti t s,and aI p s s i ac ie c ed or p t iat wi an Def nda t t r or bu I er on n t onc v ari p i c on t y e n ? h i ! ' h vn n t e o ti Ore s ali daey ds o t u te u e o te Ac s n t i ig oi f hs d r h l mme itl ic ni e h s f h u h e c n l 7 k cal away f ks Mjrs, l o ol M ar , clv an GolMars,Kart Mars, / Tayor er a e el d f k sen k andor l Mad p ) aji Gol Mar s or an c f sn y si l tade k wi n domai n das f k, y on u igl mi r mar s t @r hi n am: i q e' n in ,meaa s o oh mak r wi i we st s uc c d ,fo u e o a # ke so s ttg r ter res t n b i o re o e rm s n n t h e l ë ! wyb ge (n udi a te tl o an web p ) fom an adv sn l s t oh pa icl ng s h ie f y t age , r y ediig i o tei nk i lbsi es w, t ) f m s ac en ie ' aa a e o c c eme r, n a yoh f m o u h r e rh gn s d tb s s r a h moy a d n teror f s o ! l o! u ht mswhc i vsbet ac mp t u e o s v st dr t o ue s ac e i c er s ih s iil o o uer s r r ere o i c mp tr e rh ; ec $ , l ! t web i r ser by, wned, o ae b e h Deen t icl n te lt n i ù st egit ed o es or pertd y ac f dan ,n udig h nere l wqbst s op a ig un t e Subec Domai Names, i e er tn der h j t n i l I 14 @ ' 1 l 1 l i ! i ( 4) 2 q ) : ( ! Ea Def an bh lno tan f o er i o te Subec Domai ch end t al t r ser wn shp f h jt i f NI M mesdur t p d c o t sAci orun if i he en en y f hi ton, ng t udherOr o t e Coud; l der f h ! I q l ( ) The d n name Re sr s f t e Subec Do n Na ar di c ei 5 omai gitar or h j t mai mes e r t e i t Ir sert pl n i c ns , f d siwi ti coud, mai n c f aesf , tan f o ait ou el or epo t t hs ss' tj o h do n ame edic t ok i 1 tjSubec Domai Names; h jt n l l ( 6) up pl n is'r s , t e p iac p o eci s vc f an subec on ait eque t h r y r t t er ie or y s v on j f D! ' gmai Namesf whihte Regitan u essu hpr c poeci s vc t c e ) n or c h sr t s c i y rt t erie o onc al va on j i t# Re ita t ieni a dc na tifr t naeod rdt ds ls t Plit st4 h gsrn' d ty n o tc nomai r ree o ico e o ani h s t o # I E ti i t i an c t tif ma i o t s Regsr t , r e den ies d onac nor ton f ho e itan s' t 1 1 ( ) upon en r oft s or , pl nt s shal pr de a copy of t or by 7 ty hi der ai i ' l ovi he der ' eyait te r sr o r or f eac o t Subec Do n Names,so ta t l o h egitar f ec d or h f he j t mai h t hi i r sr o r or o ea o te Su j tDomai Na ma i t n,n i eac igitar f ec d f ch f h bec n mes y, n ur oty i f i ë i l r s r toft e Or and pr d n ie oft e Ickng o t e domai na t t qgitan h der ovie ot c h o i fh n me o he r sr to r or Aqerpr i ng s ch n ie t te rgitar s t d n n i *gitan f ec d. ovdi u ot o h e sr s o he omai ame c 1 2 : ; 1 : m ay be I ocked, Pl nt#s shal al pr de notce and a copy of t s Or t t ai i l so ovi i hi der o hQ r'ita t f a hSu jc Do i Na vae it tee ia drs po ie a p r q srn o e c be t man me i malo h mal d e s rvd d s ai g i olhe d nr srt daa f eac o te subec Domai Names i ti i té ?t omai egitai t or h f h on jt n denied n h f i ! Appiat f Te l i or mpor y Res r i ng Or .I an e lad es was n tpr vd as c on ar tani der f mai dr s o o ied : l ; : ppr oft e do n r s r t daa f a Subec Domai Na Pl n i s l ovd t h mai egita i t or on j t n me, ait halpr i: #s 1 1 n!t e a da c p o ti ore t te o eaoso te Itre we stsva a emal ii n o y f hs d r o h p rtr f h ne n t b i i n l c e l I r l i a de sa do o l e s b s in fr po ie o te Itre we sts o eaiq j rs n /r ni u miso oms rvd d n h nen t b i p rt n e n ui s ch su j tDomai Names. der u bec n Aqerf t- i t( )h s ha e el s a t or egh 48 our v ap ed qer h4 y ! ecor he egi r s, ai i l eYain o t s Or t t r s r s of r d and t r stant Pl nt#s shal l g f hi der o he egitar i E ! 1 I l i i i l 15 ' t ; l ! i r po ieac p o ti orerotergsrr a dtergsr sf teSu jc Do i kvd o y fhs d t h e itas n h e iti orh be t mah e 1 Nqmesf t pur or he posesdescrbed i Par aph 8,bel i n agr ow, i ! l () 8 . The domai name Regitar f t e su j t Doman Name s al n s r s or h bec i s h l l ! i dit y as iti c gig t e Re sr ofr or f rt e Sube tDomai Namesr mme a el ss n han n h gitar ec d o h jc n i 1 e c piga ys c d mann me whc s c Re itash v b enn tid i wrig k e t n u h o i a s ih u h gsrr a e e oie n in n f t ! by Pl nt#s have been orwi be di s fom t s aci , t a hol ng accountw ih , ( ai i l l smised r hi ton o t di @ ' R# it ro Plit s c o sn ( e' w Re itan. te e tn teRe itasd gsr f ani ' h o ig t ' a # h Ne gsrr To h xe t h gsrr l ) I , r E n ta ss i c a gn te Re itaso rc r frte d man u d terrs e t l i s itn h n ig h gsrr f e od o h o is n er h i e p ci v c! tol t i on ( )bu n s da' o r eitoft s Or er t t -ev domai ( ' 4n r wihn e 1 sies y f ec p hi d , he op l el n TLD) ' ' Re s r ( t ei ad nita or) f t Su j t Domai Names,wi n f e ( ) giti or h r mi s r t s or he bec es n t i 5 hi v : bqsi daysofr ptoft s Or ,shal,change orassi i changi t Regi r ness ecei hi der l st n ng, he star oïr c d f t Subec Do n Na t e or or he j t mai mes,e ept g an s h domai n xc i n y uc n ames whi i ch stchRegiti have been notfed i wrtng by Pl nt#s have been orwi be di ssed sres ii n ii ai i l l smi ( fi t s aci ,t a hol n ac ou twi t e Ne Regitar As a mat ofIw,t s rm hi ton o dig c n t h w h sr , ter a hi ) j oke s aln In e a pyt a y Dee d n o a s cae d man n me dimis t d r h l o o g r p l o n fn a t r s o itd o i a s se l i fpm t s a t Up t e c an o t e Regita ofr o d f t e Subec Domai r hi c i on. on h h ge f h s r r ec r or h j t t l q Nimes,te Ne Renitarwi mait n ac es t t Subec Domai Names i tu t h w sr l nai c s o he j t l n n rs j ' ' ' 8 t e cour dur g t e p enc oft s aci h t i h end y hi ton n fr q , ' Ad t n l ,h Ne Re it s ap dio al te w gsr h l i y ar ië ) j ' mmedi el i tt e a t at y nsiut empor y 302 dom ai name r r ton whi wi aut ar n ediec i ch l omatcal l i l y ' rdrc a yvstrt te su j tDo i Na st teflwig Unfr Re o ré i i t n ii o h bec man me o h ol n i m s uc e o o o 1 ! ) i è L a or (URL' h /s ncn tc c c /n x.t ic t ' ' on: ewi o ie.om/ wcs ide h ml wh eon c pis o t 4 ) / er o e f h cd lita dal te d c menso fei ti a t naeds ly d Al raiey tJ mpan n loh r o u t n i n hs ci r ipa e . t n t l,h l o e v @ ' N4w Regitarmay upd e t e Domai Name Sy t (DNS' da a i mait nsf t q sr at h n s em ' ' t t nai or h ) @ i ) ) 16 j i I l r sù jc oo i Na s whc I kted mann me t teI a de s swh r tei be t man me , ih i h o i a s o h p d rs e ee h r n i i ( aiocaed p it s websts i e ar e h t , osed t o NS1. EDI M ATEM PLE. NET anj NSZ. ATEMPLE. whi wi c et edo nn st r olet teweb t MEDI NET, ch l aus h mai ame o es v o h l si : i w ' l r cpe o teco litT mp rr Retann ore, n aI ter o u n? ee o is fh mpan, e oay sriig d ra d loh d c me t l i op fe i t s aci ar diply Aqert e New Re s r hase# t t i ch ge, h i n hi t l on e s a ed. h gitar ec ed hs an t # j ' Ml j tDomzi MZm6 S Z1 b Pl e On L k s a u pr v tng t e modic ton oi bCo r l S h I e ac d oc t t s, e en i h f ai i 1 d lt no ted man b teNe Re ita o Dee d ns iei fh o is y h w gsrr r fn at; o 1 s i ( 9) pl n is ma en ert su j tDomai Na ait s y t he bec n mes it oooge' w eb t no ls maser Tp l a d c n e an rdrcin o te d man ta h v b e e trd tee b os n a c l y e i t f h o is h t a e e n nee h r 9 e o ! Dif danswhihr r tta t t c treiop ai st a ne domai n ot en t c edi rmc o he ounef t erton o w ec n ame l I wh st a dtee ye a eteprvso so ti ore; b i n h rb v d h o iin fhs d r e @ i 1 1 l (0) Ea Depn tsh l es re c eso alc uerfl r aig t ti ch f dan alpr ev opi f l omp t i eltn o h ! es . l u! ofany o t Su j tDomai Names an s lt e aIseps n e sa y t rtiv e f he bec n d hal ak I t ec s r o e r : e I cj t fe r aig t te u e o te Su j tDomai Names t tma ha e b impuer i s eltn o h s f h bec l n ha y v een dql edb or teenr o t sOr r iet ef e h ty f hi de ; 1 ( 1 Th 1) i I sT oayRe tann Orer h lrmani e e tu t ted t ft emp rr sriig d s ale i n # c ni h ae o l te h ig onte Moi f Pr i n yIj ci s f b o orunis hf dhet j earn h ton or el ar nun t etodh elw, tl uc u mi on j : dit ass tb teCourorsi at t b tepadi es e y h t t ed o y h pul es; I i l ! ( 2) Thi Tempor r Res r nig Or s lappy t t Su j t Domai 1 s ay tai n der hal l o he bec q l ; 1 i Np s a s cae we sts an a y oh rd man n me a d we sts po el me , s o itd b i , d n te o i a s n b i rp r e e f biugh t te cout at i and v ied b s n a avttatsu h n do i o to h r' tent s on eri y wor md i h c ew mai f 1 q ! nqmes ar b n us d b Def dan s f t e pur e o c n ereiig t e Acu hn e eig e y en t or h pos f ou t f tn h s et ks, or or Mar s Cal way Gol Mar s Clv an GolMar s Kar en M ar and/ Tayl Madek, l a f k , e el d f k , st t l i i i : j ! 17 ' ! l l l q ) ) j a ia GofMak a is ei ti a t na do u fiyc mp t gwi Paniso tJ id s l rs ts u n hs ci n /r nar o ei t lit n h o l n h # ! Wpr wiewe ; l d b d j (3) Purua t 1 U. C. 1 6()5)D)and F R.Ci P.65() Pl ni 1 s nt o 5 S. j 11 d ( ( ed. v. c , ait #: i : 1 E s alpo tab di te amoun o TenThou an Dol san Zer Cens( 0, 00) h l s on n h tf s d l d o t $1 000, , ar ) i i akpa men o dama t whi Deen t ma be eniedf a wr gf ij ci y tf ges o ch f dans y tl or on ulnun toq t okr tai , igte p denc o ti aci orunif erOrer teCoud; esr ntdur h en y f hs ton, t udh d of h n l 1 ! r i I q ( 4) Plit s al s v a c 1 an i h l er e #s opy o t e Complit t Ap iat f ! f h an , he pl i or c on T#mpor y Restai ng Or ,t sOr ,and aIot pl ngsand document on fl i ar r ni der hi der I her eadi s i : i ! i t s aci on eac De en t a des r ab e an b pos i c e o t i n!hi ton h f dan s c i bed ov d y t opis f h ng l k Appl i f Tempor y Restai ng Or and t s Or on t websi I ed at i i on or cat ar r ni : der hi der he t ocat e ; h(rs wic oie.o c sid xhml ti fd -ih (8 h us o c nrlo tJ Q / e n n t c m/wc / e .t wi n o yeg t 4 ) o r f o t f h n/ c n h o ' r ' i si jc Do i Na sb ig c a g d t te co r va te Ne Re it ' h lij be t man me en h n e o h ut i h w gsr s odn ar l i ai oun ,an s ch n ie s gien s al b d c t d u ot o v h l e eemed g an s #i en s vc t r f c ood d u ci t erie he eo t j ' k Pl n i sh lc tn t pr ie no ie of t es pr eedi s a c es o t q ait #s al on iue o ovd tc h e oc ng nd opi f h i I d c me t o fei ti matrt Dee d nsb rg lr u d t gtewe st Ic tt d u ns n i n hs t o fn a t y e ual p ai h b i o ae l e y n e r ! a h n/ e n nte.o c sid xhmlor yoh me n ra o a lc luae t ! q :s win oi c m/wc / e .t b ter a s e s n by ac ltd p / c i 1 gie n tc whih i per te byt e Coud. û o ie c s mi d h t 1 ' ; t earn ef e hi r s or t 013,a 1 09 t 0: 1 1 l ( 5) A h ig b or t s Cou t i SET f Sep ember 25,2 l oom 203E of t Unied St es Courhouse, 299 Eas Br i he t at t aj , i Coudr m. n t owar i r ë Btuev d, For Lau dal Flr At t t h i Def ans an / an o h ? l ar t der e, o i da. ha ear ng, end t d or y t et ! j I ' a td peron ma c l get appopr t es o ti or a mo e t dis v #ece s s y hal en he r i en s f hs der nd v o s ol4 a I : t.e s à ame and t cour wil hear ar , M oti sr pr i nar ej mi y ! he t l gument on pl ntfs ai if on , Ii c i ; l t jun on 1 i p l I l l I ; 18 ! l l ! l i l ! ' ( 6) By Sept 1 ember23,201 De en t an / an o h a t peron 3, f dan s d or y t er #eced s : ! sh lfl wi te coud an s v on Pl ni 'c uns an Res s t Pl ni ' al i t h e h d ere ait o el y pon e o ait ! #s #s) l i Mbt f Pr i n y Ij c i Pl n is sh l i an s i or el ar nun t on mi on. ait f alfl d eNe an Repl b Noon oq f e y y y 1 i i S#p em ber2 2 3. es da esma b r vied up s i a i b aIparis an b t 4, 01 Th e t y ees on t ton y I te d y pul j ' a poa o teco r i rv lfh ut ; l (7) By 2 p. on sept 1 m. ember24,2 3,pl ni Def dans,an oran c1 ait ss, en t d/ y 1 ' l ot aseced per her t sons shalfl W iness Li s i iyi any winesses t t pari li t e st dentf ng t hat he tei 1 e p c t c la te pei n r nu cin h aig Atteo t no te p de , i c i e to al t h rl apijn t e r . h pi f h a is dr t mi o n o e 1 tki n ma b s b t di tefr o wrtna a i ; o v raI fa t wib e t v v e u mie n h om f ie md vt h we e, laf ns l q mo t t s i l j I - - - ' ' s be toleco se a n t na teh aig q jc t i rs x miai th e r . v o n i 1 i ! : ( 8) Alo by 2 p. on Sept ber2 201 Pl n i ,Def dans,an / an 1 s m. em 4, 3, ait #s en t d or # l ohera t peron sh lfl Ex bi Lit i tyn an exhbi tatte p t i t #eced s s al i hi t ss deni ig y i t h h ari e f s e ! i'en t ito c a t pr i nar nun tonh ig.AIe bi sh l e pr lbel n d o nrdu e t he el pij ci ear l mi n l xhi t alb e-a ei s ( i r dance wih t pr t he oposed Exhi t Lit . bi s s ij c n ac o ! Ex bi Ibel mus icu te ca d hi t a s t n lde h s 1 1 n er an gmb ; d q j i ! ( 9) De endan/ ar her notsed t ati t y do nottmel r 1 f e eby i h f he i y espond t) 4 , i t ' Pp ntls'Moton f Pr i nar Ij i and do notappearatt sche ed al i i or elmi y n uncton he dul ! ! hqarn , t cour m ay ent a pr Imi ij ton agal t by def t ! ' i g he nst hem aul. g t er e i nal n unc i i r p DONE AND ORDERED i Ch n amber a or La er e, Br war Cou t ) s t t ud dal o d ny id 8r , n h 3h a f e tmb r2 1 , , Foia o ti 1t d yo s pe e, 0 3 0l 4 . s 3C ! i i ! t . Z S coHs AME l usl STATES DI CT :un E zE STRI do ispo ie t c u s l fe odv pe rvd d o o n e o rc r l CF . l ! I i t 19 l ! SCHEDULE A DEFENDANTS BY DEFENDANT NUM BER A ND SUBJECT DO MAI NAM ES N Def endantNum ber Def endantIDom al Nam e n 1 onl olsal us i ne f e. 2 am at olm ale eur f lcom 2 am at ols or net eur f t e. 2 own olcl com f ubs. 3 amat olsho . eur f net 3 ea I ol e f sho . uk co. 3 eve da ol. fnet 4 au olbest rc com f ie. 4 au olbu ercom f . 5 auschea ol, fcom 6 aus scount ol. di fcom 6 ausonlne ol i tcom 7 bes oI rce. t f i com 8 best onsal ol. e fcom 8 olaustal f ri asho . com 9 bu best oI . f com 10 best olondeal com f s. 10 bu chea ol or com f es. st 11 bu olonsal com f e, 12 au ole ui mentcom f . 1 2 austal ri achea ol. fcom 12 chea ol com f aus. 13 chea olcl f ubsau. com 1 4 chea ' ol. fcom 1 4 new ol . f com 15 da olst es. f or com 15 olsal tcom f ebes , 16 econom onl ol. i ne fcom 16 onlneeconom ol, i fcom 17 en' ol . o f com 17 m ol . f com 18 f ous olsetcom am f . 19 olchea s or c f t es.om 19 olcl t es. uk f ubs or co. 20 olcl our . f ubse ne com 20 oloutet or us f l st e. 20 I olm al. i ke f l com 21 olcl ' . f ubs- com 22 ol scoun ' . f di t com 20 23 24 25 26 26 27 28 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 33 33 34 35 36 37 37 38 38 38 39 40 41 42 42 43 43 43 43 44 45 46 46 47 47 47 48 48 49 oI n. f com olm ala an. f l ' com olm ar usa. f ket com olm adbu . f com olst eoutetus f or l . olm ar . f f com olm arus.om f t c bu oldiectco. f r . uk olsal f eda ,om c olsal f esho . uk co. sal olsho . uk e f co. olsal f esho s. com ols ods ool uk f t , co. olsal f esu I. uk co. olonbest rc com f ie. olsal ehouse. f ewar net olsal f ewhol e. esal com olscl f ubwar ehouse. com olsho onsal co. f e. uk ol f sho soutetcom l. war ehouse ol or net f e. st 118 olshop. f com ol f sho t com ee. ol u#m ar . f st ketcom ol ar M ehouse' . com olzonef. f rcom r sal ol. eat e fcom hot oluk. uk f co. ukhot ol. uk fco. olbest . uk f bu co. i olsho i uk.om f n c or olher com der f e. t olbest e. o f sal com i ols or com n f t es. ' anese olsal com a f e. ' olbu . f com ' olchea . f com bes ol t f onsal co. e. uk ' sho i ol. n fcom r olm ar. o f tnet k olst es. en f or com t olsal or o f e. r olsal c o f e.om 21 49 I olior c uck ft es.om 50 50 51 51 52 52 53 53 54 55 56 57 57 58 58 59 59 60 I ondon olcl c uk f ub.o. nie olonlne. uk c f i co. olr ai onl c fet l er i om ne. onl olaus. i ne f com hot ol s.o, f deal c uk sal olonl co. e f i ne. uk best rce olsal com i f e. sal olons or com e f t e. see ol ub. f cl com s or olonl com t e f i ne. t ol ee f sho , com ea l ol. uk e fco. ukbest rce ol. i fcom sho sal ol e tcom uk ol ubs or com f cl t e. uk ol f su I . uk co. uk olsu I . f com vi s ol. ck fcom 22
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
