AK Steel Corp. v. United States Int'l Trade Comm'n, No. 14-00220 (Ct. Int'l Trade 2016)

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

Si O.1 -18 lp p 6 0 UIE SAE CUTO ITRAINLTAE NTD TTS OR F NENTOA RD --------------------x A SELCROAIN ALGEYLDU, : K TE OPRTO, LEHN ULM LCdbaAIFA RLE POUT, L // T LT OLD RDCS adUIE SELOKR, n NTD TEWRES : : Panif, litfs : v . : UIE SAE ITRAINLTAE NTD TTS NENTOA RD CMISO, OMSIN : Dfnat eedn, : -nad Cnoiae osldtd CutN.1-02 or o 4020 PBI VRIN ULC ESO : TYSNRP EETIA SELGb,AB : HSEKUP LCRCL TE mH B IC,NPO SEL&SMTM MTL N. IPN TE UIOO EA CROAIN adJESELCROAIN : OPRTO, n F TE OPRTO, : Itreo-eedns nevnrDfnat. --------------------x Oiin&Odr pno re [litfs mto frjdmn o aec rcr, Panif’ oin o uget n gny eod cnetn ngtv mtra-nuydtriain otsig eaie aeilijr eemntos bsdteen dne; ato dsisd] ae hro, eid cin imse. Dcdd Nvme 2,21 eie: oebr 3 06 Dvd A Hrqit Jh M Hrmn, Gae W Km ad ai . atus, on . eran rc . i, n Bnai BaeCrl Kle Dy &Wre LP Wsigo,DC, ejmn ls ay, ely re arn L, ahntn .. frtepanif. o h litfs Dmnc L Baci Gnrl Cusl Ade C Cso, oii . inh, eea one, nra . asn Assat Gnrl Cusl fr Ltgto, ad Rod M Hge, sitn eea one o iiain n hna . uhs Atre-dio, Ofc o Gnrl Cusl US Itrainl tonyAvsr fie f eea one, .. nentoa TaeCmiso,Wsigo,DC,frtedfnat rd omsin ahntn .. o h eedn. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae J Kvn Hra ad Mr E Mnabn, dKefr & Hra, . ei ogn n ac . otlie eife ogn PL, Wsigo, DC, fr itreo-eedn Tysnrp LC ahntn .. o nevnrdfnat hseKup Eetia SelGb. lcrcl te mH Jh D Genad ad Urk K Sasn Csiy Lv Kn on . rewl n lia . wno, asd ey et (S)LP Wsigo,DC,fritreo-eedn ABIc UA L, ahntn .. o nevnrdfnat B n. Dnl Hrio, Gbo, Dn & Cuce LP Wsigo, oad arsn isn un rthr L, ahntn DC, fr itreo-eedn Npo Sel & Smtm Mtl .. o nevnrdfnat ipn te uioo ea Croain oprto. R b r H e ,G e o yH s s a ,D v dH c e s n a dM r a J oet uy rgr uiin ai ikro, n ogn . W s , F l y L r n r L P W s i g o , D C ,f r i t r e o - e e d n et oe ade L, ahntn .. o nevnrdfnat JESelCroain F te oprto. AULN, Sno Jde QIIO eir ug: Ti cnoiae ato hs osldtd cin calne tefnlngtv dtriain o teUie Sae hlegs h ia eaie eemntos f h ntd tts Itrainl Tae Cmiso (IC o “omsin) ta nentoa rd omsin “T” r Cmiso” ht ipre gan oine eetia sel (GE” dd nt motd ri retd lcrcl te “OS) i o mtral ijr, o trae mtra ijr t, te US aeily nue r hetn aeil nuy o h .. d m s i i d s r . S eG E F o G r a y J p n a dP l n ,I v oetc nuty e OS rm emn, aa, n oad n. Ns 71T-23 -24 -26(ST Pb 49,Sp.21) ad o. 3-A13, 13, 13 UIC u. 41 et 04, n G E F o C i a C e hR p b i ,S u hK r a a dR s i ,I v N s OS rm hn, zc eulc ot oe, n usa n. o. 71T-0 ad71T-21 -22 -25 -27(ST Pb 40, 0-A55 n 3-A13, 13, 13, 13 UIC u. 50 N v 2 1 ) p b i h dr s e t v l a 7 F d R g 5 7 4( e t 1 , o. 04, ulse epciey t 9 e.e. 44 Sp. 2 2 1 )a d7 F d R g 6 7 9( o .1 ,2 1 ) a f r h ra t c l t d 04 n 9 e.e. 63 Nv 0 04, s ute riuae i Cnieta Ves o te Cmiso (Ves) ad IC Fnl n ofdnil iw f h omsin “iw” n T ia Poreay Saf Rpr dtd Ags 1, 21 (noprtn rpitr tf eot ae uut 4 04 icroaig rvsoso Ag 2,21)(SafRpr”. eiin f u. 0 04 “tf eot) Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae Acrigt teaec rcr dvlpd ta dmsi codn o h gny eod eeoe, ht oetc idsr i cmrsd o to mnfcues A Sel Croain nuty s opie f w auatrr, K te oprto ad Algey Ldu, LC wih hv fld cmlit i ti n lehn ulm L, hc ae ie opans n hs c n o i a e a t o p r u n t 1 U S C § 5 6 ( ) 2 ( ) i ( )a d osldtd cin usat o 9 ... 11aa()A()I n ( ) i ) a d 2 U S C § 5 1c a o g w t t e U i e S e l o k r . B(i n 8 ... 18 ln ih h ntd tewres Tgte a pris panif te hv itroe a mto fr oehr s ate litf, hy ae nepsd oin o jdmn o ta rcr i acrac wt UCTRl 5.. uget n ht eod n codne ih SI ue 62 I Te ppr fld i spot o ta mto (n i h aes ie n upr f ht oin ad n opsto teeo so ta GE i a fa-old aly sel poiin hrt) hw ht OS s ltrle lo te pout wt a ceity ta fcltts te frain o lre rdc ih hmsr ht aiiae h omto f ag gan drn pouto ta ain uiomy i te rlig ris uig rdcin ht lg nfrl n h oln drcin (eghie o sel set ieto lntws) f te he. Sc gan eal te uh ris nbe h s e lt c n u tam g e i f e dw t ah g d g e o e f c e c , te o odc antc il ih ih ere f fiiny rltv t ohrsel. eaie o te tes GE i priual sial fr te mnfcue o OS s atclry utbe o h auatr f crsfrtasomr ue i cneto wt tegnrto ad oe o rnfres sd n oncin ih h eeain n t a s i s o o e e t i i y I i p o u e w t d f e e tl v l rnmsin f lcrct. t s rdcd ih ifrn ees o “emaiiy, ie, te dge o efcec wt wih te f preblt” .. h ere f fiiny ih hc h selcncnutamgei fed te a odc antc il. “ovninl gae o GE hv salr bt ls Cnetoa” rds f OS ae mle, u es peiey oine, gan. rcsl retd ris Te ae tpcly rfre t b hy r yial eerd o y Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae gae etbihd b te Aeia Io ad Sel Isiue ta rds salse y h mrcn rn n te nttt ht rne fo M2 t M6 wt M2 big te tins gue (.0 ag rm o -, ih - en h hnet ag 007 i c e o 0 1 m l i e e s( m ” )a dm s e f c e tm t r a ,a d nhs r .8 ilmtr “m) n ot fiin aeil n M6bigtetiks gue(.18ice o 03 m)adlat - en h hcet ag 003 nhs r .5 m n es efcet fiin. "ihpreblt” GE hs lre, mr peiey Hg-emaiiy OS a agr oe rcsl oine, gan ta rsl i getr efcece (oe retd ris ht eut n rae fiinis lwr oeaig prtn lse) oss rltv eaie t o cnetoa ovninl gae. rds Hg-emaiiy GE my as b sbetd t cran srae ihpreblt OS a lo e ujce o eti ufc tetet (nw a dmi rfnn) ta frhr ehne ramns kon s oan eiig ht ute nac efcec. fiiny A S e lp o u e b t c n e t o a a dh g - e m a i i y K te rdcs oh ovninl n ihpreblt gae. rds Algey Ldu poue cnetoa gae ad ws lehn ulm rdcs ovninl rds n a wrig okn i n 21 03 t o dvlp eeo te h cpct aaiy t o poue rdc h g - e m a i i yG E i c m e c a q a t t e . T e c n u r n l ihpreblt OS n omril uniis hy ocrety fld atdmig ad cutraln- dt pttos wt te ie niupn- n oneviig uy eiin ih h Itrainl Tae Amnsrto, US Dprmn o Cmec nentoa rd diitain .. eatet f omre ( I A )a dt eC m i s o ,a l g n t a ( )i p r so G E f o “T” n h omsin leig ht 1 mot f OS rm C i a t eC e hR p b i ,G r a y J p n K r a P l n a dR s i hn, h zc eulc emn, aa, oe, oad n usa wr bigsl i teUie Sae a ls ta fi vle () ee en od n h ntd tts t es hn ar au; 2 mnfcues poues o epres o GE i Cia wr auatrr, rdcr r xotr f OS n hn ee rciig cutralbe sbiis ad () sc iprs wr eevn onevial usde; n 3 uh mot ee Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 5 ae mtral ijrn ad traeig t ijr te dmsi GE aeily nuig n hetnn o nue h oetc OS idsr. nuty1 Peiiaiy teCmiso dtrie ta teews rlmnrl, h omsin eemnd ht hr a a raoal idcto ta te US idsr ws mtral esnbe niain ht h .. nuty a aeily ijrd b rao o iprs o GE fo te svn sbet nue y esn f mot f OS rm h ee ujc cutis onre. Se GE fo Cia Ceh Rpbi, Gray Jpn e OS rm hn, zc eulc emn, aa, Kra oe, Pln, oad ad n Rsi, usa Iv n. Ns o. 71T-0 0-A55 ad n 71T-2113 (rlm) UICPb 43 (o.21) Po 9. 3-A13-27 Pei., ST u. 49 Nv 03, Dc 1 Cnurnl, IA dtrie ta iprs o GE fo ec o ocrety T eemnd ht mot f OS rm ah f t o ec u t i sw r b i gs l a “ e st a f i v l e ( L F ” 2 hs onre ee en od t ls hn ar au” “TV) Uo rcit o sc ptto() ICs rl i t pn eep f uh eiins, T’ oe s o dtriewehrmtra ijr o tra o sc ijr t te eemn hte aeil nuy r het f uh nuy o h d m s i i d s r i i d e t ec s b r a o o i p r e s l so oetc nuty s ned h ae y esn f motd ae f sbet mrhnie o te lklho o sc sls 1 USC ujc ecads r h ieiod f uh ae. 9 ... § 6 3 ( ) 1 . S e e g ,G r l M t l ,I c v U i e S a e ,1 2 17db() e, .. ead eas n. . ntd tts 3 F3 76 79 (e.i. 19) .d 1, 1 FdCr 97. “By rao o” sbet iprs [] esn f ujc mot mas “o b rao o a mnml o tneta cnrbto t en nt y esn f iia r agnil otiuin o mtra hr cue b” sc iprs aeil am asd y uh mot. Mta Sel Pit Lss itl te on ia Ld v Uie Sae,52F3 87 83(e.i.20) qoig t. . ntd tts 4 .d 6, 7 FdCr 08, utn i . T eC m i s o e a u t st ev l m o s b e ti p r s t e r d h omsin vlae h oue f ujc mot, hi efc uo pie i te US mre fr te dmsi lk fet pn rcs n h .. akt o h oetc ie pout ad ter ipc o dmsi poues “rdcin rdc, n hi mat n oetc rdcr’ pouto oeain” i te cnet o te US mre. prtos n h otx f h .. akt 1 USC 9 ... §677()i. 17()B() 1 Panif’ ppr epaie ta IAsfnlLF litfs aes mhsz ht T’ ia TV m r i sr n e f o 3 6 %f rs b e tm r h n i ef o t eR p b i agn agd rm .8 o ujc ecads rm h eulc o Kra t 219% fr sc mrhnie fo Gray Se GE f oe o 4.1 o uh ecads rm emn. e OS Fo tePol’ Rpbi o Cia FnlDtriaino Sls rm h epes eulc f hn: ia eemnto f ae a LF, 7 FdRg 526 527 (e’ Cmec Ot 1 21) t TV 9 e.e. 92, 92 Dpt omre c. , 04; GE Fo te Rpbi o Kra Fnl Dtriain o Sls a OS rm h eulc f oe: ia eemnto f ae t L F ,7 F d R g 5 2 4 5 2 5( e ’ C m e c O t 1 2 1 ) G E TV 9 e.e. 92, 92 Dpt omre c. , 04; OS (otne.. cniud.) 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 6 ae w t i t em a i go s c i n7 3 b o t eT r f A to 1 3 ,a ihn h enn f eto 3() f h aif c f 90 s aedd 1 USC §63() mne, 9 ... 17bb. Frtefnlpae ICdtrie ta teehdbe o h ia hs, T eemnd ht hr a en pie udreln o sbet mrhnie i te Uie Sae rc neslig f ujc ecads n h ntd tts drn te pro o ivsiain (PI) wih te pris d uig h eid f netgto “O”, hc h ate o n td s u e b tt eC m i s o ’ f n ld t r i a i n b av t o o ipt, u h omsins ia eemnto, y oe f 5 t 1 ws ta udreln dd nt hv sgiiat avre o , a ht neslig i o ae infcn des pieefcsdrn tePI SeVesa 3. rc fet uig h O. e iw t 5 Ta i, atr cnieain ad aayi o te ht s fe osdrto n nlss f h s a u o yf c o so v l m o G E ,d m s i a di p r e ,a dt e tttr atr f oue f OS oetc n motd n h p i ee f c so t es b e ti p r s a s tf r hi t e rV e s rc fet f h ujc mot, s e ot n hi iw, p. 2-1 te mjrt o cmisoes fud ta ms o te p 64, h aoiy f omsinr on ht ot f h i d s r ’ t a e e p o m n ,a df n n i li d c t r d t r o a e nutys rd, mlyet n iaca niaos eeirtd o e t eP Id et ac m i a i no o t u - e a e ( g ,l s o vr h O u o obnto f uptrltd e . os f (.cniud ..otne) Fo teRsinFdrto:FnlDtriaino Slsa LF rm h usa eeain ia eemnto f ae t TV adFnlAfraieDtriaino Ciia Crusacs 7 n ia fimtv eemnto f rtcl icmtne, 9 F d R g 5 2 3 5 2 3( e ’ C m e c O t 1 2 1 ) G E F o t e e.e. 92, 92 Dpt omre c. , 04; OS rm h Pol’ Rpbi o Cia FnlAfraieCutraln Dt epes eulc f hn: ia fimtv oneviig uy Dtriain 7 FdRg 521 522 (e’ Cmec Ot 1 eemnto, 9 e.e. 92, 92 Dpt omre c. , 21) GE Fo teCehRpbi:FnlDtriaino Sls 04; OS rm h zc eulc ia eemnto f ae a t LF TV ad Fnl Afraie Dtriain o n ia fimtv eemnto f Ciia rtcl Crusacs 7 FdRg 534 535(e’ Cmec Sp.2, icmtne, 9 e.e. 82, 82 Dpt omre et 9 21) GE Fo Gray Jpn adPln:FnlDtriain 04; OS rm emn, aa, n oad ia eemntos o Sls a LF ad Cran Fnl Afraie Dtriain o f ae t TV n eti ia fimtv eemnto f Ciia Crusacs 7 FdRg 451 452 (e’ Cmec rtcl icmtne, 9 e.e. 20, 20 Dpt omre Jl 2,21) uy 2 04. 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 7 ae epr simns hge ui css de t ls pouto) ad xot hpet, ihr nt ot u o es rdcin n avre rvne efcs (.. rdcd pie de t lwr rw des eeu fet ie, eue rcs u o oe a m t r a sc s s u u e c p c t ,a di t a i d s r c m e i i n . aeil ot, nsd aaiy n nr-nuty optto) S eV e sa 4 - 3 T e c n l d d h w v r t a t o ec n i i n e iw t 24. hy ocue, oee, ht hs odtos wr de t te dcie i eprs rslig i udrtlzd ee u o h eln n xot, eutn n neuiie cpct admr itnecmeiinoe mre sae adta aaiy n oe nes optto vr akt hr, n ht sbet iprs “i nt tk sgiiat mre sae aa fo ujc mot dd o ae infcn akt hr wy rm te dmsi idsr ad as dd nt hv sgiiat pie h oetc nuty n lo i o ae infcn rc efcs. fet” I. a 4. d t 2 Bcue te dmsi idsr’ ttl eas h oetc nutys oa c p c t r m i e t es m t r u h u t eP Ia da s b c u ei s aaiy eand h ae hogot h O n lo eas t mre saermie esnilysal wiedmsi simns akt hr eand setal tbe hl oetc hpet icesd IC dd nt fn te dmsi idsr t hv be nrae, T i o id h oetc nuty o ae en mtral ijrdb rao o tesbetiprs Sei. aeily nue y esn f h ujc mot. e d Rcgiig te eitne o ptnil dfeecs eonzn h xsec f oeta ifrne b t e nt ei d s r e i t es b e tc u t i s( s e i l yb t e n ewe h nutis n h ujc onre epcal ewe J p na dt eo h r ) I Cf u dr a o a l o e l po c m e i i n aa n h tes, T on esnbe vra f optto aogsbetiprsfo alsvn adbtensbetiprs mn ujc mot rm l ee, n ewe ujc mot fo ec cuty ad te dmsi lk pout teeoe i rm ah onr n h oetc ie rdc; hrfr, t eecsd is dsrto t cmlt sbet iprs fo al o xrie t icein o uuae ujc mot rm l f te. hm Se i. a 4. e d t 7 Bsd teen i fud n tra o ae hro, t on o het f m t r a i j r b r a o o s b e ti p r s a i f u dn r c r aeil nuy y esn f ujc mot, s t on o eod eiec ta te tedn ices i sbet ipr vlm ad vdne ht h rnig nrae n ujc mot oue n Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 8 ae mre sae (n te raos teeo) wud cag i te akt hr ad h esn hrfr ol hne n h i m n n f t r . I a s f u dn e i e c o t er c r t a a y miet uue t lo on o vdne n h eod ht n ices i sbet iprs wud lkl afc te dmsi nrae n ujc mot ol iey fet h oetc idsr avreyi teimnn ftr,iamc a icesn nuty desl n h miet uue nsuh s nraig i p r sh dn ta v r e ya f c e t ed m s i i d s r ,a dt a mot a o desl fetd h oetc nuty n ht te icesn dmn oe te PI ad te cniin o h nraig ead vr h O n h odtos f c m e i i ni t eU S m r e w r u l k l t c a g a p e i b y optto n h .. akt ee niey o hne prcal ( r mt ep r p c i eo t et m o I C si v s i a i n . S ei . fo h esetv f h ie f T’ netgto) e d a 4-9 t 84. IC as fud ta cpct i te cmltd sbet T lo on ht aaiy n h uuae ujc cutis atog hg bt asltl adrltv t aprn onre, lhuh ih oh bouey n eaie o paet US cnupin icesd oe te PI ad ws poetd t .. osmto, nrae vr h O n a rjce o i c e s f r h r U u e c p c t w sg e t ri i t r m2 1 t a nrae ute. nsd aaiy a rae n nei 03 hn i itrm21,adwspoetdt dciefrhri 21 ad n nei 04 n a rjce o eln ute n 04 n frhr sil i 21. Pouto icesd oe te pro ad ute tl n 05 rdcin nrae vr h eid n ws epce t ices i 21 ad 21. Se i. a 4. Te a xetd o nrae n 04 n 05 e d t 9 h Cmiso ntd ta a rte hg prin o te ageae omsin oe ht ahr ih oto f h grgt p o u t o o G E i t es b e tc u t i sw su e t m e t e r rdcin f OS n h ujc onre a sd o et hi rsetv hm mres dmn. epcie oe akt’ ead Simns t te hm mres hpet o h oe akt icesd oe te pro, wih IC epce t cniu t nrae vr h eid hc T xetd o otne o ices. nrae Eprs t ohr mres icesd bten 21 ad xot o te akt nrae ewe 01 n 21,adwr poetdt ices i teftr a wl. Te 03 n ee rjce o nrae n h uue s el h Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 9 ae rtoo sbetepr simnst teUie Sae a asae ai f ujc xot hpet o h ntd tts s hr o ttl simns ws sed truhu te pro ad ws f oa hpet a tay hogot h eid n a poetdt rmi s i teftr. rjce o ean o n h uue IC fud ta te dt idctd te Uie Sae i T on ht h aa niae h ntd tts s n tap i c p le p r m r e f rt ec m l t ds b e ti d s r e . o rnia xot akt o h uuae ujc nutis I ve o te sbet idsre’ poeto o icesn n iw f h ujc nutis rjcin f nraig simns t te hm mres ad eprs t ohr cutis ad hpet o h oe akt n xot o te onre n ter vr lmtd rlac o te US epr mre, te hi ey iie eine n h .. xot akt h Cmiso fud ta sgiiaty icesd iprs o te omsin on ht infcnl nrae mot f h sbetmrhnieit teUie Sae wr ntlkl i te ujc ecads no h ntd tts ee o iey n h t e - m i e tf t r . A t o g I Cr c g i e t a U S p i e f r hnimnn uue lhuh T eonzd ht .. rcs o G E h v b e a dw l l k l c n i u t b h g e t a p i e i OS ae en n il iey otne o e ihr hn rcs n o h rm r e s i i d c t dt a t i i n taf c o t a l dt e te akt, t niae ht hs s o atr ht e h sbetidsre t drc a apeibylre saeo ter ujc nutis o iet n prcal agr hr f hi e p r s i m n st t eU i e S a e f o 2 1 t 2 1 ,a dt e e xot hpet o h ntd tts rm 01 o 03 n hr ws a tetm,n idcto i tercr ta ti i lkl a, t h ie o niain n h eod ht hs s iey t c a g ,i e ,e e i s b e ti p r sf o t ec m l t ds b e t o hne .. vn f ujc mot rm h uuae ujc c u t i sw r t i c e s ,I Cd dn tf n t a a ys c i c e s onre ee o nrae T i o id ht n uh nrae wud lkl trae mtra ijr t te dmsi idsr ol iey hetn aeil nuy o h oetc nuty gvn ta te sgiiac o te vlm o sbet iprs dd ie ht h infcne f h oue f ujc mot i nt cue mtra ijr t te dmsi idsr oe te PI o as aeil nuy o h oetc nuty vr h O. SeVesa 4-0 e iw t 95. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 0 Te Cmiso rcgie ta Cia (PC) ipsd h omsin eonzd ht hn “R” moe atdmig dte o GE fo Rsi ta bcm efcie i niupn uis n OS rm usa ht eae fetv n 21, bt i epaie ta toe dte wr aray i efc 00 u t mhszd ht hs uis ee led n fet truhu te PI hogot h O. As, wie te Ida Sel Mnsr ws lo hl h nin te iity a r p r e t h v e f c i e yb n e i p r so l w g a ee e t i a eotd o ae fetvl and mot f o-rd lcrcl sel i Jn 21, te rcr dd nt idct ta sc te n ue 01 h eod i o niae ht uh rsrcin rsle i dvrig a vlm o sbet iprs t etito eutd n ietn oue f ujc mot o te Uie Sae ta mtral ijrd te dmsi idsr h ntd tts ht aeily nue h oetc nuty drn te pro, nr ws tee ay idcto ta ti wud uig h eid o a hr n niain ht hs ol cag i te imnn ftr. Se i. a 5. US ipres hne n h miet uue e d t 1 .. motr’ i v n o i sa s f l o e t eP I a da t o g i v n o i so t e netre lo el vr h O, n lhuh netre f h sbet mrhnie hl i te sbet cutis icesd fo ujc ecads ed n h ujc onre nrae rm 21 t 21,te wr as poetdt dciei te ftr. 01 o 03 hy ee lo rjce o eln n h uue Sei. e d Wt rgr t lkl pie efcs IC fud ta, ih ead o iey rc fet, T on ht n t i h t n i g p e a e t u d r e l n , t e s b e t i p r s d dn t owtsadn rvln neslig h ujc mot i o hv asgiiatavreefc o pie frtedmsi lk ae infcn des fet n rcs o h oetc ie p o u ta dt a t ed m s i i d s r w st e e o en tm t r a l rdc n ht h oetc nuty a hrfr o aeily ijrdb rao teef Sei.a 5. ICas fudta, nue y esn hro. e d t 2 T lo on ht w i es m c n i u di c e s i s b e ti p r v l m m g to c r hl oe otne nrae n ujc mot oue ih cu i te imnn ftr, ay sc ices wud lkl nt b n h miet uue n uh nrae ol iey o e sgiiat nr b sfiin t hv ay avre efcs o te infcn o e ufcet o ae n des fet n h Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 1 dmsi idsr bcueiprso tesbetmrhniewr oetc nuty eas mot f h ujc ecads ee ulkl t etr a pie ta wud b lkl t hv a niey o ne t rcs ht ol e iey o ae s g i i a td p e s n o s p r s i ge f c o d m s i p i e o infcn ersig r upesn fet n oetc rcs r t ices dmn fr mr iprs o nrae ead o oe mot. Se i. Mroe, hvn e d oevr aig fud n sgiiat cua rltosi bten te sbet on o infcn asl eainhp ewe h ujc iprs ad te dmsi idsr’ promne drn te PI mot n h oetc nutys efrac uig h O, n t i h t n i gt ed m s i i d s r ’ d c i e i p r o m n ea d owtsadn h oetc nutys elns n efrac n oeaig icm lvl, te Cmiso hd ltl rao t prtn noe ees h omsin a ite esn o blee ta ay frhr dtroain o te cniin o te eiv ht n ute eeirto f h odto f h dmsi idsr wud b “y rao o” te sbet iprs i oetc nuty ol e b esn f h ujc mot n t ei m n n f t r . S ei . I Ca s f u dt a s b e ti p r s h miet uue e d T lo on ht ujc mot h dn th ds g i i a ta t a o p t n i ln g t v e f c so t e a o a infcn cul r oeta eaie fet n h eitn dvlpet ad pouto efrs o te dmsi xsig eeomn n rdcin fot f h oetc idsr, icuig efrs t dvlp a drvtv o mr nuty nldn fot o eeo eiaie r oe avne vrino tedmsi lk pout Sei.a 5. dacd eso f h oetc ie rdc. e d t 3 I I T ec u tn c s a i yh sp r s dp a n i f ’s b i s o s h or eesrl a eue litfs umsin cnetn ICs dtriain a wl a toe fld b te otsig T’ eemntos s el s hs ie y h itreo-eednsi spotteef Tecnetqaiyo nevnrdfnat n upr hro. h otn ult f alteppr i sc a t ovaetebreigo tepris l h aes s uh s o bit h udnn f h ate wt oa agmn,adtemto teeo cnb,adi hrb ih rl ruet n h oin hrfr a e n t eey i, dne. s eid Mroe, te ppr cnan bsns cnieta oevr h aes oti uies ofdnil Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 2 ifrain ta ne ntb rctd o rfre t hri, sv nomto ht ed o e eie r eerd o een ae to “rmtc eet ta ocre drn te pro o w daai” vns ht curd uig h eid f ivsiain SeOpsto o itreo-eednsJESel netgto. e poiin f nevnrdfnat F te Croain ad Npo Sel & Smtm Mtl Croain oprto n ipn te uioo ea oprto (JEN&M)a 34 “F/SS” t -. A Jdca rve eaie wehr a dtriain i uiil eiw xmns hte eemnto s s p o t db s b t n i le i e c o t ea m n s r t v r c r a d upre y usata vdne n h diitaie eod n i i acrac wt lw wih ncsaiy fae te ise. s n codne ih a, hc eesrl rms h sus Se 1 USC §56()1()i. e 9 ... 11ab()B() I te rcr cnan “uh f h eod otis sc r l v n e i e c a ar a o a l m n m g ta c p a a e u t t eeat vdne s esnbe id ih cet s dqae o s p o t a c n l s o ”, t k n i t a c u t t e e t r r c r , upr ocuin3 aig no con h nie eod icuigwaee “arydtat” te tedtriainms nldn htvr fil ercs, hn h eemnto ut b ssand e utie. Eg, Alni Sgr Ld v Uie Sae, 74 .. tatc ua, t. . ntd tts 4 F 2 1 5 ,1 6 ( e . i .1 8 ) I a a e c h s“ x m n [ ]t e .d 56 52 FdCr 94. f n gny a eaied h r l v n d t a da t c l t [ ]as t s a t r e p a a i nf ri s eeat aa n riuaed aifcoy xlnto o t a t o ,i c u i gar t o a c n e t o b t e nt ef c sf u da d cin nldn ainl oncin ewe h at on n t e c o c m d ”, t a i s f i i n , f r “ w i c n i t n h hie ae4 ht s ufcet o to nosset cnlsos fo te eiec de nt peet a amnsrtv ocuin rm h vdne os o rvn n diitaie 3 (98. 13) Cnoiae Eio C. v NR, 35 US 17 29 osldtd dsn o . LB 0 .. 9, 2 MtrVhceMr.Asnv SaeFr Mt At.Is oo eil fs s' . tt am u. uo n. C. 43US 2,4 (93(nenlqoainmrsdltd. o, 6 .. 9 3 18)itra utto ak eee) 4 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 3 aec’ fnig fo big spotd b sbtnil eiec. gnys idn rm en upre y usata vdne” Cnoov Fd Mr Cm',33US 67 60(96. osl . e. a. omn 8 .. 0, 2 16) IC i as peue t hv cniee al o te T s lo rsmd o ae osdrd l f h ifrain i nomto n te amnsrtv h diitaie rcr. eod Eg, Gags .. rne M t l v r e A v U i e S a e ,1 C T4 1 4 9 7 6F S p .1 , ealekn B . ntd tts 3 I 7, 7, 1 .up 7 2 (99. I ohr wrs ee i te rcr cnan sm 4 18) n te od, vn f h eod otis oe eiec t wih a cmliat cn pit ta tns t dtat vdne o hc opann a on ht ed o erc fo a amnsrtv cnlso, ta de nt ncsaiy rm n diitaie ocuin ht os o, eesrl, r n e t ec n l s o u r a o a l . E g ,A l n i S g r 7 4F 2 edr h ocuin nesnbe .. tatc ua, 4 .d a 16. t 53 () i T e p a n i f f r t c n e d I C s p i e e f c sa a y i h litfs is otn T’ rc fet nlss i nt spotd b sbtnil eiec o te rcr. s o upre y usata vdne n h eod Te h rlvn sauerqie cnieaino wehr()“hr hs eeat ttt eurs osdrto f hte 1 tee a be sgiiat pie udreln b te ipre mrhnie en infcn rc neslig y h motd ecads rltv t te pie o pout mnfcue i te Uie eaie o h rc f rdcs auatrd n h ntd Sae” ad () wehr “h efcs o sbet iprs hv tts n 2 hte te fet f ujc mot ae d p e s dp i e ,o p e e t dp i ei c e s st a o h r i ew u d erse rcs r rvne rc nrae ht tews ol h v o c r e ,t as g i i a td g e ” 1 U S C § 6 7 7 ( ) i ) ae curd o infcn ere. 9 ... 17()C(i. T ep a n i f a g et a t ep i ee f c sa a y i i u d r i e h litfs ru ht h rc fet nlss s nemnd b t ef c t a I Cm r l a k o l d e t e“ i e ti p r e ”d t y h at ht T eey cnwegd h drc motr aa btohrieinrdte adrle ol uo te“rdtoa” u tews goe hm n eid ny pn h taiinl Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 4 p i i gd t . C m a eP a n i f ’M m r n u o L wa 2 - 3w t rcn aa opr litfs eoadm f a t 12 ih V e sa 3 - 7 T e c a mi w se r n o sf rt ea e c n tt iw t 53. hy li t a roeu o h gny o o hv cniee te drc ipre dt “n tne” wt te ae osdrd h iet motr aa i adm ih h “ r d t o a ”d t ,a dt e t b l t t o er c r d t o p g 2 taiinl aa n hy auae hs eod aa n ae 3 o t e rb i f r f r n i gS a fR p r ,V 9t V 1 &A p .Da f hi re, eeecn tf eot - o -6 px t D6t D1,Co 24 Seas Panif’Rpy p 7 - o -5 Dc 5. e lo litfs el, . . Te Ves idct ta, wie toe dt d idct h iw niae ht hl hs aa o niae ta sbet iprs wr pie lwr ta te dmsi lk ht ujc mot ee rcd oe hn h oetc ie pouti 1 o 3 cmaiosfriprsfo Jpn 2 o 2 rdc n 7 f 0 oprsn o mot rm aa, 5 f 8 c m a i o sf ri p r sf o P l n ,a ds v no e g tc m a i o s oprsn o mot rm oad n ee f ih oprsn f ri p r sf o R s i ,C n R ca D 3t D 4 P b e a D 3 t e o mot rm usa ofe t - o -, uRc t -, hy arayakolde ta lwrpie aepeaeti tepie led cnwegd ht oe rcs r rvln n h rc cmaios oprsn. Mroe, fr te hget vlm o simns o oevr o h ihs oue f hpet f U S - r d c dp o u t 4 ,t ei c d n eo h g e a dl w rp i e ..poue rdc, b h niec f ihr n oe rcs i m x d S eC / R T b eD 5 T ev l m so i p r si v l e i s ie. e RP, al -. h oue f mot novd n tee cmaios ae qie sal hs oprsn r ut ml. We cmae t te sbet hn oprd o h ujc iprs ta ae nt drcl ipre b ed ues toe fw mot ht r o iety motd y n sr, hs e d r c p r h s sc u dn th v l dt ep i e o t ed m s i l k iet ucae ol o ae e h rcs f h oetc ie poutdwwr. Vesa 4 n 10 rfrnigApni Dt rdc onad iw t 0 . 5, eeecn pedx o teSafRpr. h tf eot T ep a n i f c n e dt a t ep r e to t t ls b e t h litfs otn ht h ecn f oa ujc iprsrpeetdb tedrc ipre dt vlm cnhrl mot ersne y h iet motr aa oue a ady Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 5 b caatrzda “ut sal gvnta ICakolde te e hrceie s qie ml” ie ht T cnwegd h “infcne o te pretgs a cmae wt simns o sgiiac” f h ecnae s oprd ih hpet f s b e tm r h n i ef o t eU S p o u e sa df o J p n P l n ujc ecads rm h .. rdcr n rm aa, oad ad Rsi; ta te drc ipre dt acut fr a szal n usa ht h iet motr aa con o iebe pret o te ttl vlm o piig dt o te sbet ecn f h oa oue f rcn aa n h ujc i p r s; t a I C h s f u d s g i i a t i j r o s e f c s i mot5 ht T a on infcn nuiu fet n svrlrcn ivsiain ivligee lwrUS simns eea eet netgtos novn vn oe .. hpet o i p r s; a d t a “ u t s a l i “ i c l a o d ” w t f mot6 n h t q i e m l ” s d re t y t d s ih I C sf n i g t a t ed r c i p r e d t a c u t df rs z a l T’ idns ht h iet motr aa cone o iebe pretgso ttlrpre sbetiprsfo Jpn Pln, ecnae f oa eotd ujc mot rm aa, oad adRsi drn tePI n usa uig h O. Panif’Mmrnu o Lwa 3, litfs eoadm f a t 1 rfrnig Ves a 3 n 16 eeecn iw t 2 . 1. Frhroe te panif utemr, h litfs cned ter tblto cnim ta te vlm o te drc otn hi auain ofrs ht h oue f h iet Ie, ttl sbet ipr vlm i Apni Dpu .. oa ujc mot oue n pedx ls t t ls b e ti p r v l m r p r e i S c i nV S eP a n i f ’ oa ujc mot oue eotd n eto . e litfs Mmrnu o Lwa 3 &n 3. eoadm f a t 0 . 2 5 S ei .a 3 ,r f r n i gC l i mH p c l r t F o t e e d t 1 eeecn acu yohoie rm h P C I v N s 7 1 T - 1 a d7 1 T - 2 5( i a ) U I CP b 4 1 R, n. o. 0-A50 n 3-A14 Fnl, ST u. 55 ( a .2 1 )p 1 ( [ ] ep i i gd t a c u t df ra p o i a e y Jn 05 . 7 “th rcn aa cone o prxmtl ...2 . p r e to s b e ti p r si 2 1 ,w t l w rc v r g 13 ecn f ujc mot n 03 ih oe oeae f rs b e ti p r si o h ry a so t eP I ) M l i a e e W o o ujc mot n te er f h O”; utlyrd od F o r n F o t eP C I v N s 7 1 T - 7 a d7 1 T - 7 ( i a ) loig rm h R, n. o. 0-A46 n 3-AU9 Fnl, UIC Pb 47 (o. 21) p 2 ([]iig dt rpre b ST u. 28 Nv 01 . 7 “prcn aa eotd y teefrsacutdfrapoiaey...1 pret o US hs im cone o prxmtl 4 ecn f .. s i m n so i p r sf o s b e tp o u e si [ h P C i 2 1 ” ; hpet f mot rm ujc rdcr n te R] n 00) Auiu Etuin Fo te PC Iv Ns 71T-7 ad lmnm xrsos rm h R, n. o. 0-A45 n 7 1 T - 1 7( i a ) U I CP b 4 2 ( a 2 1 ) p 2 ( [ ] i i g 3-A17 Fnl, ST u. 29 My 01, . 2 “prcn dt rpre b tee frs acutd fr apoiaey fu aa eotd y hs im cone o prxmtl or p r e to 2 1 U S s i m n so s b e ti p r sf o [ h P C ” . ecn f 00 .. hpet f ujc mot rm te R]) 6 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 6 i p r e d t e c e st ec m a a l “ r d t o a ”d t f rs xo t motr aa xed h oprbe taiinl aa o i u o t np i i gp o u t a dt a t ev l m o i p r sf o J p n f e rcn rdcs n ht h oue f mot rm aa, Pln ad Rsi cvrd b te drc ipre dt lkws oad n usa oee y h iet motr aa ieie ecestecmaal taiinlpiigdt. xed h oprbe rdtoa rcn aa Te dfnat mitis ta h eedn anan ht te panif h litfs ae r ipoel akn tecutt sbttt jdmn fri o sc mrpry sig h or o usiue uget o t n uh mtes atr. Eg, Dfnat US Itrainl Tae Cmiso’ .. eedn .. nentoa rd omsins O p s t o t P a n i f ’M t o f rJ d m n o t eA e c R c r poiin o litfs oin o uget n h gny eod ( D f n a t sR s o s ” a 2 ,r f r n i gC - t e R r t n I c “eedn’ epne) t 1 eeecn oSel aia, n. v Itl Tae Cm’, 37 F3 19, 10 (e.i. 20) (h . n’ rd omn 5 .d 24 39 FdCr 04 te “ o r i n te p w r dt s b t t t i sj d m n f rt a o t e cut s o moee o usiue t uget o ht f h aec”, ad Npo Sel Cr. v Itl Tae Cm’, 35 F3 gny) n ipn te op . n’ rd omn 4 .d 17, 18 (e.i. 20) ([]dr te saue ol [T] my 39 31 FdCr 03 “une h ttt, ny IC a fn te fcs ad dtrie cuain ad utmtl mtra id h at n eemn asto n liaey aeil ijr”. Ide, te aplae cut hs rcgie ta i i nuy) ned h pelt or a eonzd ht t s n i h r“ u p i i gn rp r u s v ”t a p r i sp a n i fa ea l ete srrsn o esaie ht ate litf r be t pit t “vdne o rcr wih dtat fo te eiec o on o eiec f eod hc ercs rm h vdne wihspot [T]sdcso”o cn“yohsz araoal hc uprs IC’ eiin r a hpteie esnbe b s sf rac n r r d t r i a i n ,M t u h t E e .I d s C .v ai o otay eemnto” assia lc nu. o . Uie Sae, 70 F2 97 96 (e.i. 18) ad te ntd tts 5 .d 2, 3 FdCr 94, n h Cmiso hr mitis ta i “rpry rle o pie omsin ee anan ht t poel eid n rc c m a i o st a r f e t de u v l n s a e o t a e a t e“ e t oprsn ht elce qiaet tgs f rd” s h bs Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 7 i f r a i no r c r ” t a t et a i i n ld t i c u e e d u e nomto f eod, ht h rdtoa aa nldd n-sr oeae ad ta “nlso” o te ipre dt i acrac vrg, n ht icuin f h motr aa n codne wt panif’agmnsmrl icessteaon o sbet ih litfs ruet eey nrae h mut f ujc ipr piig dt i pretg trs bt de nt rne mot rcn aa n ecnae em u os o edr uraoal nesnbe ICs “eine o T’ rlac n dt aa soig ha-oha hwn edt-ed cmeiinbtendmsi adipre pout. Dfnats optto ewe oetc n motd rdcs” eedn’ Rsos a 4 2. epne t , 5 I h sl n b e t er l t a I C sd t r i a i n m s t a og en h ue ht T’ eemntos ut tk “no acut te etr rcr, icuig waee fil ae it con h nie eod nldn htvr ary d t a t f o t e s b t n i l t o t e e i e c ”, a d p a n i f ’ ercs rm h usataiy f h vdne7 n litfs agmnsd nt t ti pit peieyso wa i i aot ruet o o, o hs on, rcsl hw ht t s bu t ed r c i p r e d t t a “ a r yd t a t ”f o I C sr l a c h iet motr aa ht fil ercs rm T’ eine uo te taiinl ipre dt i mkn is dtriain pn h rdtoa motr aa n aig t eemnto. Tepanif hv rcs tercr t terlkn,bti cn h litfs ae eat h eod o hi iig u t a nt b cnldd teerm ta te aec hs nt tkn it o e ocue hrfo ht h gny a o ae no acutteetr rcr o ta isaprn asgmn o ls con h nie eod r ht t paet sinet f es wih t te drc ipre dt ws uraoal. egt o h iet motr aa a nesnbe A te s h Alni Sgr spa 74 F2 a 16 (otoe tatc ua, ur, 4 .d t 52 font oitd. mte) Fr eape te drc ipre dt, cvrn o xml, h iet motr aa oeig apoiaey[ prxmtl [ ] pret o US poues simns wud ] ecn f .. rdcr’ hpet, ol as se t hv rsle fo a fr o “edt-ed lo em o ae eutd rm om f ha-oha” c m e i i n N n t e e s I C s“ r s m t v a a e e s i o A B optto. oehls, T’ peupie wrns” s f B Ic’ psto o pyn “rmu” pie fr dmsi sucs n.s oiin f aig peim rcs o oetc ore, wih apas t b idcto o wliges t egg i ls hc per o e niain f ilnns o nae n es “ioos cmeiin vgru” optto. 7 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 8 dfnat pit ot te taiinl piig dt ecmas te eedn ons u, h rdtoa rcn aa nops h mjrt o piigdt fo fu sbetcutisada lat aoiy f rcn aa rm or ujc onre n t es sm o te dt fo al cutis ad panif’ on oe f h aa rm l onre, n litfs w cluain so ta te sbet ipr vlms fr piig acltos hw ht h ujc mot oue o rcn pout 1, 1, ad 2 rmi “eaiey lw ee we te rdcs a b n b ean rltvl” o vn hn h drc ipr piigdt aeicue. I pit otteeae iet mot rcn aa r nldd t ons u hr r n p o u t 1 d r c i p r s p o u t1 w u d s o r l t v l f w o rdc a iet mot, rdc b ol hw eaiey e sot tn aog te ageae drc ipr ad taiinl hr os mn h grgtd iet mot n rdtoa p i i gd t a c m a e t t es o tt n o d m s i a l p o u e rcn aa s oprd o h hr os f oetcly rdcd pout ad smlry fr piig pout 2, ie, ipre rdc, n iial o rcn rdc b .. motd vru dmsial poue sot tn, rsetvl. ess oetcly rdcd hr os epciey Cmae opr P a n i f ’M m r n u o L wa 2 w t S a fR p r ,T b e V 2 litfs eoadm f a t 3 ih tf eot als -, V3 V5 -, -. Hvn akolde “oe pie ae peaet i te aig cnwegd lwr rcs r rvln n h piecmaios,ICcnlddta te“e”drc prhss rc oprsn” T ocue ht h fw iet ucae b ed ues a cmae wt ter taiinl piig dt y n sr s oprd ih hi rdtoa rcn aa cutrat cud nt hv ld te pie o te dmsi lk oneprs ol o ae e h rcs f h oetc ie pout dwwr. rdc onad Ti cut i nt pstoe, b lw t hs or s o oiind y a, o oetr vld Cmiso fcul fnig o is raoal vrun ai omsin ata idns r t esnbe c n l s o sb s dt e e n S e1 U S C § 5 6 ( ) 1 ( ) I . F r ocuin ae hro. e 9 ... 11ab()B() o ta mte, cnrr t panif’ agmn, te sgiiat ht atr otay o litfs ruet h infcn udreln ta te drc ipre dt frhr rva (n neslig ht h iet motr aa ute eel i Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 1 ae 9 a d t o t t a a r a yi d c t db t et a i i n lp i i gd t ) diin o ht led niae y h rdtoa rcn aa de nt “edl epan te piig dcie eprecd b os o raiy xli h rcn elns xeine y dmsi pouesfrtoepout.8 oetc rdcr o hs rdcs” (i i) T e p a n i f s r s t a I C d d n t d s u s p o u t3 h litfs tes ht T i o ics rdc a rdc ht cone o h eod ihs oue f a a l, a p o u t t a a c u t d f r t e s c n h g e t v l m o t l9 t et np i i gp o u t a dag e t rv l m t a a yo t et r e h e rcn rdcs n rae oue hn n f h he pout ietfe i te Ves a rfetn “ sgiiat rdcs dniid n h iw s elcig a infcn aon o cmeiin bten te dmsi lk pout ad te mut f optto ewe h oetc ie rdc n h sbet iprs bt wih pie dcie IC fud t hv be ujc mot” u hc rc elns T on o ae en “oprbet tedces i rwmtra css” Vesa 3. cmaal o h erae n a aeil ot. iw t 7 Te panif pit ot ta te dcie i dmsi idsr h litfs on u ht h eln n oetc nuty pie frpout3 wsnal [ rcs o rdc a a ery [ ] tmslre ta toe ] ie agr hn hs dcie frpout 2,4,ad5 adta teaslt vlm elns o rdcs a b n b n ht h boue oue o sbetiprsudrpout3 wsnal [ f ujc mot ne rdc a a ery [ ] a get ] s ra Panif’ Mmrnu o Lw a 2. T spotter litfs eoadm f a t 6 o upr hi a g m n ,t ep a n i f a s t b l t t ed g e so u d r e l n ruet h litfs lo auae h ere f neslig r f e t di t ed r c i p r e d t . S ei .a 2 ,r f r n i g elce n h iet motr aa e d t 7 eeecn Saf Rpr, Ap. D tf eot px . IC i peue, hwvr t hv tkn T s rsmd oee, o ae ae sc ifrainit acut uh nomto no con. 8 Tepanif as cmli o alc o dsuso o h litfs lo opan f ak f icsin f piig pout 3, bt te fcs ter dsuso o piig rcn rdc b u hy ou hi icsin n rcn pout3. rdc a Te dfnat das atnin t te fc ta te h eedn rw teto o h at ht h vlmsfr3 ae“ut sal,ad“h mriso oeslig oue o b r qie ml” n te agn f vreln s g i i a t y o t e g e t em r i s o u d r e l n . D f n a t s infcnl uwihd h agn f neslig” eedn’ Rsos a 3 n 3,rfrnigSafRpr,TbeV7 epne t 6 . 0 eeecn tf eot al -. 9 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 0 a tevlm fr2 adapoiaeytretmsa hg a te s h oue o a n prxmtl he ie s ih s h v l m s o p o u t 4 a d5 r f e t d i t e t a i i n l i p r e oue f rdcs b n b elce n h rdtoa motr piigdt. rcn aa T ed f n a tr s o d t a i d dn ti n r d t a t n h eedn epns ht t i o goe ercig e i e c ;t eC m i s o ’ d s u s o ,v r a i ,o p i ed c i e vdne h omsins icsin ebtm f rc elns i a flos s s olw: Sm o te piig cmaios sc a fr piig oe f h rcn oprsn, uh s o rcn pout 2, 4, ad 5, ivle vlms o sbet rdcs a b n b nov oue f ujc iprs ta cmee drcl wt te ms cmaal mot ht opt iety ih h ot oprbe dmsi lk pout Ohrpiigcmaios sc oetc ie rdc. te rcn oprsn, uh a fr piig pout 1, 1, ad 2, ivle fr s o rcn rdcs a b n b nov a salrvlmso sbetiprs mle oue f ujc mot. I.a 3-6(mhssadd. I ohrwrs i d t 53 epai de) n te od, t d dn ts a et a t e ep r i u a c r e a i n a p i d i o tt ht hs atclr orltos ple t a l1 p i i gp o u t . W a i e i e tf o w a i o l 0 rcn rdcs ht s vdn rm ht t dd sae i ta i eaie al te piig pout i tt s ht t xmnd l h rcn rdcs a df u dc r a nc r e a i n a dt e d w t r g r t n on eti orltos n rns ih ead o seii pout ta idctd ta sbet iprs pcfc rdcs ht niae ht ujc mot wr nttecueo tedmsi idsr’ dciig ee o h as f h oetc nutys elnn pie. Gvn ta te eiec prann t ms o rcs ie ht h vdne etiig o ot f te piig pout dmntae tee ted ad h rcn rdcs eosrtd hs rns n creain, [t ws nt olgtd t epan aa a orltos i] a o biae o xli wy creain wt rset t oe piig pout ot o orlto ih epc o n rcn rdc u f 1. 0 DfnatsRsos a 3-6 eedn’ epne t 53. Te panif rpy ta pout 3 i peiey te h litfs el ht rdc a s rcsl h “n piig pout ot o 1” ta cnrdcs te mjrt’ oe rcn rdc u f 0 ht otait h aoiys cnlso ta te piig pout wt te hget vlms o ocuin ht h rcn rdcs ih h ihs oue f Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 1 s b e t i p r s h d t e s a l s p i e d c i e .0 T e a e t a ujc mot a h mlet rc elns1 hy vr ht te pie dcie te sfee o pout 3 wr hgl h rc elns hy ufrd n rdc a ee ihy s g i i a tb t e nt ef r tq a t ro 2 1 a dt ef r tq a t r infcn ewe h is ure f 01 n h is ure o 2 1 ,1 a d t a t e p i i g i f r a i n t e e o “ i e t y f 041 n ht h rcn nomto hrfr drcl c n r d c s I C s a a y i o p o u t 2 , 4 a d5 , o w i h i otait” T’ nlss f rdcs a b n b n hc t as fud“hr wsasgiiataon o cmeiinbten lo on tee a infcn mut f optto ewe tedmsi lk poutadsbetiprs aduo wihIC h oetc ie rdc n ujc mot” n pn hc T rle “ohaiy i cnldn teewsn cneto bten eid s evl” n ocuig hr a o oncin ewe te pie dcie sfee b te dmsi idsr ad te h rc elns ufrd y h oetc nuty n h sbetiprs 1 ujc mot. 2 Te panif age te asne o ay h litfs ru h bec f n Tepanif cnedpout3 rfetdtehget h litfs otn rdc a elce h ihs v l m o s b e ti p r si d r c c m e i i nw t t ec m a a l oue f ujc mot n iet optto ih h oprbe d m s i i d s r p o u to a yo t ep o u t i t et a i i n l oetc nuty rdc f n f h rdcs n h rdtoa ipre piig dtbs o wih te IC mjrt bsd is motr rcn aaae n hc h T aoiy ae t piig aayi. Sbet iprs o ti pout acutd fr rcn nlss ujc mot f hs rdc cone o fly [ ] preto tettlvlm o alcmltdsbet ul [ ] ecn f h oa oue f l uuae ujc iprs mot. Se Panif’ Mmrnu o Lw a 2. I ter e litfs eoadm f a t 3 n hi oiin sbetipr vlmso pout3 wr sgiiati pno, ujc mot oue f rdc a ee infcn n aslt vlm ad i rlto t dmsi cnupin teef boue oue n n eain o oetc osmto hro, w t at t ls b e ti p r v l m o [ ] s o tt n a c m a e ih oa ujc mot oue f [ ] hr os s oprd t ttl dmsi poue simns o [ ] sot tn, ie, o oa oetc rdcr hpet f [ ] hr os .. [ ] pret o dmsi cnupin o te pout Se Saf [ ] ecn f oetc osmto f h rdc. e tf Rpr a V1. Frhr te age udreln b te sbet eot t -0 ute, hy ru neslig y h ujc iprs o piig pout 3 ws peoiat ocrig i a mot f rcn rdc a a rdmnn, curn n mjrt o psil cmaios Sei.a V1. aoiy f osbe oprsn. e d t -3 1 0 1 1 SeSafRpr a V1 adV2. e tf eot t -3 n -7 Ie,bcuepiedcie frpout 2,4 ad5 .. eas rc elns o rdcs a b n b w r “ o p r b et t ed c e s i r wm t r a c s s ” V e sa ee cmaal o h erae n a aeil ot. iw t 3 .S eP a n i f ’R p ya 1 .T e e p a i et a t ed c i ei 7 e litfs el t 1 hy mhsz ht h eln n t ed m s i i d s r ’ p i e f rp o u t3 w sn a l t ot m s h oetc nutys rcs o rdc a a ery w ie b n b n h boue lre ta toe fr pout 2, 4 ad 5, ad te aslt agr hn hs o rdcs a (otne.. cniud.) 1 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 2 dsuso o ipr vlmsadpiigted frpout3 i icsin f mot oue n rcn rns o rdc a n te Ves mjrt oiin aons t “ givu oesgt h iw aoiy pno mut o a reos vrih i d c t v o a u w l i g e st c n i e e i e c d t a t n f o niaie f n nilnns o osdr vdne ercig rm i sf n i gt a t es b e ti p r sw r n tac u eo t ep i e t idn ht h ujc mot ee o as f h rc dpeso sfee b tedmsi idsr. Panif’Rpy ersin ufrd y h oetc nuty” litfs el a 1-2 t 11. T ep a n i f f r h rc n e dt a ,f rt ed f n a tt h litfs ute otn ht o h eedn o rsodta i “i ntsaeta teepriua creain epn ht t dd o tt ht hs atclr orltos apid t al 1 piig pout” bt ta i nvrhls ple o l 0 rcn rdcs u ht t eetees “xmndaltepiigpout adfudcrancreain eaie l h rcn rdcs n on eti orltos ad ted wt rgr t seii pout ta idctd ta n rns ih ead o pcfc rdcs ht niae ht sbet iprs wr nt te cue o te dmsi idsr’” ujc mot ee o h as f h oetc nutys dciigpie aonst ps hcrtoaiain SeUio elnn rcs mut o ot o ainlzto. e snr I d s e lS A v U i e S a e ,2 C T4 7 4 8( 0 2 ( ‘ w h r nute .. . ntd tts 6 I 6, 7 20) “[]ee a epaaini lcigo tercr,ps hcrtoaiain n xlnto s akn n h eod ot o ainlzto fr[h Cmiso’]atosi isfiin’adrmn myb o te omsins cin s nufcet n ead a e aporae fr frhr epaain) (utn Te Tme C. v prpit o ute xlnto” qoig h ikn o . Uie Sae, 2 CT 11, 11, 97 FSp. 93 95 (95) ntd tts 0 I 15 18 3 .up 5, 5 19). (.cniud ..otne) vlm o pout 3 iprs ws nal tie a get a te oue f rdc a mot a ery wc s ra s h v l m f rp o u t2 ,a da p o i a e yt r et m sa h g a t e oue o rdc a n prxmtl he ie s ih s h b n b n h rdtoa motr rcn aa vlms fr 4 ad 5 i te taiinl ipre piig dt. oue o Panif’ Mmrnu o Lw a 2, rfrnig Saf Rpr, litfs eoadm f a t 3 eeecn tf eot V2. -7 1 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 3 Te camtedfnatdsussol tepiigpout ta hy li h eedn icse ny h rcn rdcs ht ft wti ICs cnlsos ad fis t ades te piig i ihn T’ ocuin n al o drs h rcn pout ta d nt rdcs ht o o. Ti cutcno cnu ta tedfnatge byn hs or ant ocr ht h eedn os eod caiiain it te ram o nw rtoae ad panif’ lrfcto no h el f e ainl, n litfs o e a lp e e t t o o t i p i td e n td m n t a eo p r u d vrl rsnain n hs on os o eosrt r esae ta te Cmiso’ dtriain i ete uspotd b ht h omsins eemnto s ihr nupre y sbtnil eiec o nt i acrac wt lw usata vdne r o n codne ih a. I dd nt t i o cnld ta al piig pout wt te hget vlms o ocue ht l rcn rdcs ih h ihs oue f s b e ti p r sh dt es a l s p i ed c i e a dv c v r a i ujc mot a h mlet rc elns n ie es, t i e t f e t r ep o u t w t t em s s b t n i lp i ed c i e dniid he rdcs ih h ot usata rc elns a dt r ep o u t i w i ht e eh db e as g i i a ta o n o n he rdcs n hc hr a en infcn mut f c m e i i n w t p i ed c i e t a I Cf r h rf u dc m a a l optto, ih rc elns ht T ute on oprbe t t ep r e t g d c e s ( )i r wm t r a sc s s I t e e o e o h ecnae eraes n a aeil ot. t hrfr cnldd tee ws a lc o creain aog al sc dt ocue hr a ak f orlto mn l uh aa btenpiedcie adiprs ewe rc elns n mot. ICs cnlso i nt uraoal, ad panif’ T’ ocuin s o nesnbe n litfs agmns o ti ise d nt prud ta te Cmiso hs ruet n hs su o o esae ht h omsin a “niey fie t cnie a iprat apc o te polm etrl ald o osdr n motn set f h rbe” w t i t em a i go M t rV h c eM r .A s nv S a eF r M t ihn h enn f oo eil fs s' . tt am u. A t .I s C . 4 3U S 2 ,4 ( 9 3 . T a i ,I C sp e u p i e uo n. o, 6 .. 9 3 18) ht s T’ rsmtv i t r r t t o o t er c r a aw o ed e n ta p a i a c r t nepeain f h eod s hl os o per ncuae Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 4 o uspotd b te sbtnil eiec o rcr ee i te r nupre y h usata vdne f eod vn n h asneo epiaino tesbeto pout3 i ioain bec f xlcto n h ujc f rdc a n slto. Hr aan panif’ agmn i esnily fr te cut t ee gi, litfs ruet s setal o h or o s b t t t i sj d m n f rt a o t ea e c o t em t e ,w i h usiue t uget o ht f h gny n h atr hc cno ocr i acrac wt te sadr o is jdca ant cu n codne ih h tnad f t uiil rve. eiw Se Uiesl Cmr Cr. v NR, 30 US 44 48 e nvra aea op . LB 4 .. 7, 8 ( 9 1 ( a t m t e s...r q i i ge p r i eac u tm y[ o ] 15) “s o atr eurn xets or a nt dslc te [gny’ coc bten to fil cnlcig ipae h aec]s hie ewe w ary ofitn ves ee tog te cut wud jsiiby hv md a iw, vn huh h or ol utfal ae ae dfeetcoc hdtemte be bfr i d nv”. ifrn hie a h atr en eoe t e oo) BcueteCmiso “i peue t hv cniee eas h omsin ‘s rsmd o ae osdrd al o te eiec o te rcr,” i i “nt rqie t l f h vdne n h eod’ t s ‘o eurd o epiil ades eey pee o eiec peetd b te xlcty drs vr ic f vdne rsne y h p r i s ”d r n a i v s i a i n N c rC r .v U i e S a e ,2 ate’ uig n netgto. uo op . ntd tts 8 CT18 24 38FSp.2 10,14 (04 (utn UE Ic I 8, 3, 1 .up d 27 27 20) qoig SC n. v Uie Sae, 3 FdAp. 75 703 (e.i. 20). . ntd tts 4 e.px 2, 3-1 FdCr 02) Ised i ne ol ades te “sus mtra t [t] nta, t ed ny drs h ise aeil o is dtriain s ta te “ah o te aec my raoal b eemnto” o ht h pt f h gny a esnby e dsend” Saeet o Amnsrtv Ato fr te Uuuy icre. ttmn f diitaie cin o h rga R u dA r e e t A t H R R p N .1 3 3 6 v l I a 8 2( 9 4 . on gemns c, .. e. o 0-1, o. , t 9 19) O t ep r i u a p i tr i e h r ,t ep a n i f d n tp r u d n h atclr on asd ee h litfs o o esae Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 5 ta epne dsuso adesn te dt fr pout 3 i ht xadd icsin drsig h aa o rdc a s “aeil t ICsoealpieefcsaayi. mtra” o T’ vrl rc fet nlss (i) ii Te h panif litfs nx et cnet ots ICs T’ psto oiin o n u d r e l n ,n m l t a i “ e s n b yf u dt es g i i a c o neslig aey ht t raoal on h infcne f [h] udreln t b mtgtd b te lc o sgiiat te neslig o e iiae y h ak f infcn ipc o te dmsi idsr’ mre sae a te dmsi mat n h oetc nutys akt hr, s h oetc idsr ls ol [ ] pretg pit o mre saedrn nuty ot ny [ ] ecnae ons f akt hr uig t e[ O ] . D f n a t sR s o s a 2 T e a g et a n w e ei h PI” eedn’ epne t . hy ru ht ohr n isaayi de ICcnie tedmsi idsr’ saeet t nlss os T osdr h oetc nutys ttmns cnenn is srtg o hlig mre sae ad lwrn is ocrig t taey f odn akt hr n oeig t pie t me lwrpie cmeiinfo sbetiprs ad rcs o et oe-rcd optto rm ujc mot, n t a w a r a o i gI Cd e o f ri c r u a ,e s n i l yw i i g ht ht esnn T os fe s iclr setal rtn tepieefcsaayi rqieetoto tesaue h rc fet nlss eurmn u f h ttt: I C n r s h dw n e I Cn v rt r a ha a f r a i e f oges a atd T ee o ec n fimtv ijr nuy dtriain uls eemnto nes te sbet iprs h ujc mot d m n t a e as g i i a tm r e s a ei p c ,i w u d eosrtd infcn akt hr mat t ol hv witn te lwt mk te mre sae ipc a ae rte h a o ae h akt hr mat ncsay peeust t poed t a pie efcs eesr rrqiie o rce o rc fet aayi. Te saue hwvr i nt witn i ti nlss h ttt, oee, s o rte n hs m n e .R t e ,t ev l m a dp i ei p c a a y e a e anr ahr h oue n rc mat nlss r eul ad cetnie eeet o te lw ad rqie qa n oxesv lmns f h a, n eur IC t tk it acut sc crusacs a T o ae no con uh icmtne, s dmntae b te rcr, wee dmsi poues eosrtd y h eod hr oetc rdcr lwrdpie rte ta cd mre sae oee rcs ahr hn ee akt hr. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 6 Panif’ Rpy a 1-3 (mhss i oiia) rfrnig litfs el t 21 epai n rgnl, eeecn Sox Hny Asn v Hrfr Is C. 62 F3 14, 15 iu oe s’ . atod n. o, 7 .d 01 02 (e.i. 21) (“it i a ln-ed tnt o sauoy FdCr 02 ‘[] s oghl ee f tttr i t r r t t o t a o es c i no al ws o l n tb i t r r t d nepeain ht n eto f a hud o e nepee s a t rne aohr scin maiges” (utn Pics o s o edr nte eto ennls’) qoig rnes Cuss Ic v Uie Sae, 21 F3 15, 16 (e.i. rie, n. . ntd tts 0 .d 32 32 FdCr 20). Smlry te panif cned dfnats asrin 00) iial, h litfs otn eedn’ seto ta ICs “nlss o ls sls ad rvne rsoss ws ht T’ aayi f ot ae n eeus epne a lkws raoal,priual gvnta teewr n sit ieie esnbe atclry ie ht hr ee o hfs i mre sae1 ipis ta a dcie i dmsi idsr n a k t h r ”3 m l e ht eln n oetc nuty mre sae i a ncsay peusr t ay assmn o te akt hr s eesr rcro o n seset f h pie efcs o te sbet iprs Ti raoig te rc fet f h ujc mot. hs esnn, h panif age oc aan efciey wie ot te pie litfs ru, ne gi fetvl rts u h rc efc scin o te saue a i rfet a asmto ta fet eto f h ttt, s t elcs n supin ht mre sae ipc i a trsod ise Ad ioial, te akt hr mat s hehl su. n, rncly h panif frhr pit ot IC dd fn te vlm o sbet litfs ute on u, T i id h oue f ujc i p r s“ i n f c n i a s l t t r sa dr l t v t c n u p i n mot sgiiat n boue em n eaie o osmto i t e U i e S a e ”4 b t f u d t a t e l c o a s i t i n h n t d t t s 1, u on ht h ak f hf n mre sae aa fo te dmsi idsr idctd ta n akt hr wy rm h oetc nuty niae ht o pie ipc ws eiet rc mat a vdn. Te panif age IC ms epan h litfs ru T ut xli 1 3 DfnatsRsos a 5 eedn’ epne t . 1 4 I.a 1. d t 5 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 7 wyalc o mre saesiti eiec o n ngtv pie h ak f akt hr hf s vdne f o eaie rc efcsweedmsi poueslwrdpie t poetmre fet hr oetc rdcr oee rcs o rtc akt sae hr. F o t i c u t sp r p c i e t em i p o l mw t s c rm hs or’ esetv, h an rbe ih uh agmn i ta,ntihtnigteVes rgr o rltvl ruet s ht owtsadn h iw’ ead f eaiey sal mre sae a idctn “iiain, te Ves d nt tbe akt hr s niaig mtgto” h iw o o u e u v c l yi d c t t e t e to m r e s a ea ap e e u s t nqioal niae ramn f akt hr s rrqiie o peusrt dtriigmtra ijr. Mre saei,o r rcro o eemnn aeil nuy akt hr s f cus,btoeo mn fcosteCmiso eautsi odr ore u n f ay atr h omsin vlae n re t dtrie “mat, 1 USC §677()ii, ad i i, o o eemn ipc” 9 ... 17()C(i) n t s f cus, as frhr drce t cnie i is eauto o ore lo ute ietd o osdr n t vlain f “rc” wehr “h efc o iprs o sc mrhnie pie hte te fet f mot f uh ecads ohrie dpess pie t a sgiiat dge o peet tews erse rcs o infcn ere r rvns pie icess wih ohrie wud hv ocre, t a rc nrae, hc tews ol ae curd o s g i i a t d g e ”5 b t f n i g t e e i t n e o d m s i infcn e r e 1, u idn h xsec f oetc i d s r p i er d c i n s ,i o d rt m i t i m r e s a e i nuty rc euto() n re o anan akt hr, s nt is fco ncsaiyidctv o mtra ijr “am o, po at, eesrl niaie f aeil nuy hr” wti te maig o te saue a tee my b “uh ohr ihn h enn f h ttt, s hr a e sc te eooi fcos a ae rlvn t te dtriain rgrig cnmc atr s r eeat o h eemnto eadn w e h rt e ei m t r a i j r b r a o o i p r s t a b a o hte hr s aeil nuy y esn f mot” ht er n 1 5 1 USC §677()i)I) 9 ... 17()C(i(I. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 8 t ea a y i o ag v ns t a i n 1 U S C § 6 7 7 ( ) i ) T e h nlss f ie iuto. 9 ... 17()B(i. h Ves rfrnet “iiain adalc o mre saesit iw’ eeec o mtgto” n ak f akt hr hf ms b rgre i tecneto teohreooi fcosIC ut e eadd n h otx f h te cnmc atr T cniee a peet i te ivsiain i priua te osdrd s rsn n h netgto, n atclr h dcessi cpct uiiainfo te“ytmc sok ta erae n aaiy tlzto rm h ssei” hcs ht bt panif eprecd drn te PI ad nt sll wt oh litfs xeine uig h O, n o oey ih rgr t sbetiprs SeVesa 3-0 ead o ujc mot. e iw t 74. (v i) Te panif dvt mc o ter bif agig h litfs eoe uh f hi res run aant ICs raoig o te pout’ pie dcie. gis T’ esnn n h rdcs rc elns Se e, e g ,i .a 4 ( [ ] ep i ed c i e ...w r ar s l o l w r .. d t 4 “th rc elns ee eut f oe rw a mtras aeil pie, rcs uue nsd cpct aaiy ad n itaidsr nr-nuty cmeiin) optto”. Te prs “nr-nuty cmeiin i fud h hae itaidsr optto” s on o l o c ,b t a am t e o t er c r a dI C sc n l s o s i ny ne u, s atr f h eod n T’ ocuin, t dmntsteVes oiae h iw. T ep a n i f a v n en m r u l n so a t c t e e n h litfs dac ueos ie f tak hro, nn o wih poe aaln. oe f hc rv viig Te akolde ta, i hy cnweg ht f hg-emaiiy GE i pie lw eog, i my b ue i ihpreblt OS s rcd o nuh t a e sd n pae o cnetoa pout i cran apiain. Hwvr lc f ovninl rdc n eti plctos oee, te age te rvre i nt tu, a lat fr cran hy ru, h ees s o re t es o eti a p i a i n 1, a d g v n t a d m n f r h g - e m a i i y G E p l c t o s6 n ie ht ead o ihpreblt OS 1 6 SeVesa 2 n l5 e iw t 9 . 0. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 2 ae 9 icesd sgiiaty drn te PI lrey de t hge nrae infcnl uig h O, agl u o ihr efcece fiinis mnae adtd b y te h US .. gvrmn oenet fr o pwr oe t a s o m r ,t e c n e dt a “ n w u d[ a e e p c [ d t s e rnfres hy otn ht oe ol hv] xete] o e pie otie b te sl dmsi poue t b ic esn” rcs band y h oe oetc rdcr o e n raig, wihwsnttecs. hc a o h ae C n i e i gt er c r a aw o e I Cc n l d dw yt a osdrn h eod s hl, T ocue h ht wsnttu. SeVesa 3 ([]ecag i teepie ws a o re e iw t 7 “th hne n hs rcs a c m a a l t t ed c e s i r wm t r a c s s a d“ d e r a i g oprbe o h erae n a aeil ot” n []cesn cpct uiiain ]cnrbtdt tedcie i pie fr aaiy tlzto[ otiue o h elns n rcs o dmsial poue pout” (otoe oitd. Cnetn oetcly rdcd rdcs) font mte) otsig ta cnlso,tepanif hr cnedta teVesgie ht ocuin h litfs ee otn ht h iw ld oe te fc ta ol A Sel poue te hg-emaiiy vr h at ht ny K te rdcd h ihpreblt pout 4 ad rdcs b n 5 ad ta itaidsr cmeiin ws b n ht nr-nuty optto a teeoe nt a fco i te dcie i te pie fr toe hrfr o atr n h elns n h rcs o hs p o u t 1,a dt a p i i gi f r a i n t e e n d m n t a e t a r d c s7 n ht rcn nomto hro eosrts ht sbetiprshdsgiiatpieefcs ujc mot a infcn rc fet. C i i a o d f n a t sr s o s ,p 3 ,t a “ r e t n rtcl f eedn’ epne . 6 ht []sig t ep i i ga a y i o ap o u tm n f c u e b o l h l o t e h rcn nlss n rdc auatrd y ny af f h Drn uig te PI h O, Algey Ldu lehn ulm hdol md a ny ae sbtnil ivsmns i usata netet n rsac eerh ad dvlpet o n eeomn f hg-emaiiy GE bt nt i cmeca-uniy pouto ihpreblt OS u o n omrilqatt rdcin teef Se Tasrp o IC Haig o Jl 2, 21 hro. e rncit f T ern n uy 4 04 (eenfe “r”,Po 14 a 2. hriatr T.) Dc 8, t 8 1 7 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 0 d m s i i d s r w e t er c r c n a n p i i gd t p r a n n oetc nuty hn h eod otis rcn aa etiig t t ei d s r a aw o ew u dr nc u t rt t i m n a e ,t e o h nuty s hl ol u one o hs adt” h panif age sc raoig i “ofudn” bcue IC hs litfs ru uh esnn s cnonig eas T a n v rl m t di sp i i ga a y i t t o ep o u t t a a em d ee iie t rcn nlss o hs rdcs ht r ae b al mmes o te dmsi idsr, ad i i toe eat y l ebr f h oetc nuty n t s hs xc pout (bad 5) o wih i rss “o mc” o is piig rdcs 4 n b n hc t et s uh f t rcn aayi ad is cnlso ta te piig pout wt nlss n t ocuin ht h rcn rdcs ih r l t v l h g i p r l v l s o e r l t v l l wp i ed c i e . eaiey ih mot ees hwd eaiey o rc elns I C sd f n e( sp r p r s db t ep a n i f )i t a , T’ ees a aahae y h litfs s ht dsie icesd dmn fr pout 4 ad 5, ad dsie ept nrae ead o rdcs b n b n ept flig pie aln rcs teeo, ad as hrfr n lo asn bet “nr-nuty itaidsr” cmeiin teeo, IC rcgie ta pie dcie drn optto hrfr T eonzd ht rcs elnd uig t e P I “ o a l d m s i a l p o u e p i i g p o u t ”8 ( h c h O fr l oetcly rdcd rcn rdcs1 wih o v o s y i c u e p o u t 4 a d5 ) a d t a s c d c i e w r biul nldd rdcs b n b, n ht uh elns ee det ()tedmsi idsr’ dciigeprso GE;() u o 1 h oetc nutys elnn xot f OS 2 k o l d eb U S p r h s r o e c s U S i d s r c p c t ;( ) nweg y .. ucaes f xes .. nuty aaiy 3 AlgeyLdu’ ls o acnrc wt alreprhsr ad lehn ulms os f otat ih ag ucae; n ( )d c e s dr wm t r a sc s s S eD f n a t sR s o s a 3 , 4 erae a aeil ot. e eedn’ epne t 7 qoigVesa 3. utn iw t 5 P a n i f ’R p ya 1 ,q o i gD f n a t s R s o s a litfs el t 5 utn eedn’ epne t 3 (or’ lmtto o qoe psae. 1 cuts iiain f utd asg) 1 8 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 1 Te panif age “ah1 o te aoe epaain h l i t f s r u e c ”9 f h b v x l n t o s i nt spotd b sbtnileiec. Se eg Panif’ s o upre y usata vdne e, .. litfs Mmrnu o Lw a 4-9 eoadm f a t 24. Te bgn b cnedn IC hy ei y otnig T “ e e m n d t a c m e i i nb t e nA l g e yL d u a dA S e l dtrie” ht optto ewe lehn ulm n K te f rt eb s n s o H w r I d s r e “ e u t d i t es g i i a t o h uies f oad nutis rsle” n h infcn d c i e i p i e a w i ht ed m s i i d s r w sa l t s l elns n rcs t hc h oetc nuty a be o el G E i t eU S m r e d r n t eP I T e c a m“ n r - n u t y OS n h .. akt uig h O. hy li itaidsr cmeiin cudnthv be tesl o ee apiaycue optto” ol o ae en h oe r vn rmr as o US piedpeso bcueAlgeyLdu ddntpoue f .. rc ersin eas lehn ulm i o rdc hg-emaiiy GE drn te PI ad bcue A Sel te ihpreblt OS uig h O, n eas K te, h ol dmsi poue o sc GE, wud hv hd eey ny oetc rdcr f uh OS ol ae a vr mtvto t ngtae fr te hget pie psil fr ta oiain o eoit o h ihs rc osbe o ht pout sc ta te ol pie cmeiin ta wud hv rdc, uh ht h ny rc optto ht ol ae m t v t dA S e lt r d c i sp i e f rh g - e m a i i yG E oiae K te o eue t rcs o ihpreblt OS ms hv rsle fo te ohr sucs ta poue tee ut ae eutd rm h te ore ht rdcd hs pout, nml, iprs o hg-emaiiy GE fo Jpn rdcs aey mot f ihpreblt OS rm aa, Kra adtePC Te cag teVeswt gosn oe te oe, n h R. hy hre h iw ih lsig vr h i f r a i no t er c r o t ep i e a w i hH w r I d s r e nomto n h eod f h rcs t hc oad nutis prhsdGE drn tePIa wl a tecrusacso te ucae OS uig h O s el s h icmtne f h e p r t o o i sc n r c u la r n e e tw t A l g e yL d u a xiain f t otata ragmn ih lehn ulm t Ntwrh hr i ta panif’ bifn de nt oeoty ee s ht litfs reig os o ades te dmsi idsr’ dciig eprs o GE drn drs h oetc nutys elnn xot f OS uig tePI h O. 1 9 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 2 te ed o 21, wih ivle Hwr Idsre cutrn a h n f 02 hc novd oad nutis oneig pieofrfo A Selfrprhssi 21 wt lwrpie rc fe rm K te o ucae n 03 ih oe rcd s b e ti p r s a lo w i hd m n t a e t a t ep i e a w i h ujc mot, l f hc eosrts ht h rcs t hc Hwr Idsre prhsd GE ws nt ad cud nt hv be oad nutis ucae OS a o n ol o ae en afce b cmeiinbtenAlgeyLdu adA Sel fetd y optto ewe lehn ulm n K te. Tepanif as cneddfnatsrsos rie h litfs lo otn eedn’ epne ass a nme o pit ta ae icret ubr f ons ht r norc. Frt i rpy t is is, n el o t rsos ta te se t “usin te nto ta tee ws epne ht hy em o qeto h oin ht hr a i t a i d s r c m e i i nb t e n t e t o d m s i p o u e s , t e nr-nuty optto ewe h w oetc rdcr” h panif cned ter agmn i nt ta tee ws n litfs otn hi ruet s o ht hr a o i t a i d s r c m e i i ni g n r l b tt a t ef c so r c r nr-nuty optto n eea, u ht h at f eod d nt etbih ta tee ws ay sgiiat itaidsr o o sals ht hr a n infcn nr-nuty c m e i i n b t e n t e f r H w r I d s r e ’ b s n s .0 optto ewe hm o oad nutis uies2 Te hy I afont,tepanif frhrcmli o ICs n otoe h litfs ute opan f T’ r s o s q o i gt et s i o yo a A l g e yL d u o f c a f r epne utn h etmn f n lehn ulm fiil o t ep o o i i nt a h sc m a ya dA S e l“ o p t v g r u l ” h rpsto ht i opn n K te cmee ioosy, bt wtot qoig tsioy b ti sm ofca ad b hs u ihu utn etmn y hs ae fiil n y i cutrat a A Sel ta ietfe ufil tae sbet onepr t K te ht dniid nary rdd ujc iprs a te cue o sgiiat pie dcie i te US mot s h as f infcn rc elns n h .. mre. Se eg, T. a 3, Po 14 (ttn ta Algey akt e, .. r t 0 Dc 8 saig ht lehn Ldu ws “ofotd wt vr lw pie iprs a ery a ulm a cnrne ih ey o rcd mot s al s 2 1 ,w l b f r o rl s o H w r I d s r e ’b s n s i 2 1 ” 01 el eoe u os f oad nutis uies n 03 adta te cmayws“bet er araoal rtr ... n ht h opn a al o an esnbe eun utl te lwpie iprs etrd te mre ad cue ni h o-rcd mot nee h akt n asd d v s a i gd c i e i p i i g )( e t m n o M .P l n k ) i . eattn elns n rcn” tsioy f r oisi; d a 2 - 5( [ ] i eo rc m a yc m e e a g e s v l w t A l g e y t 42 “whl u opn opts grsiey ih lehn L d u ,o rs l ss a fh sb e t l r p a e l b c s o e st a ulm u ae tf a en od eetdy y utmr ht w m s l w ro rp i e i o d rt r t i t e rb s n s ,o t e e ut oe u rcs n re o ean hi uies r hy (otne.. cniud.) 2 0 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 3 f r h rc n e dd f n a t sr s o s i i o i ,g v nt a t eo l ute otn eedn’ epne s rnc ie ht h ny eape i te Ves o itaidsr cmeiin ctd i oe xml n h iw f nr-nuty optto ie s vr teHwr Idsre acut h oad nutis con. S c n ,t ep a n i f c n e dt a d f n a t sr s o s , eod h litfs otn ht eedn’ epne a wt IC aayi i is amnsrtv poedns er i s ih T nlss n t diitaie rceig, rs n a t i u i ga yo t ed c i i gp i e a w i hH w r I d s r e trbtn n f h elnn rcs t hc oad nutis prhsd GE t cmeiin bten Algey Ldu ad A ucae OS o optto ewe lehn ulm n K Sel te. Se Dfnats Rsos a 3 (utn Ves a 3-9. e eedn’ epne t 9 qoig iw t 83) Se as Rsos Bif o itreo-eedn AB Ic (ABs e lo epne re f nevnrdfnat B n. “B’ Rsos” a 1; JEN&M Opsto a 3-4 ad Rsos epne) t 3 F/SS poiin t 13; n epne Mmrnu o itreo-eedn Tysnrp Eetia Sel eoadm f nevnrdfnat hseKup lcrcl te G b a 6 D f n a t sr s o s a t i u e d c i e i p i e p i mH t . eedn’ epne trbts elns n rcs ad b Hwr Idsre fr GE prhsd fo Algey Ldu y oad nutis o OS ucae rm lehn ulm bten 21 ad 21 t itaidsr cmeiin2 ewe 01 n 0 2 o n r - n u t y o p t t o .1 Te h (.cniud ..otne) wl prhs lwrpie ipre GE fo te sbet il ucae oe-rcd motd OS rm h ujc cutis)(etmn o M.Ptre o A Sel. onre” tsioy f r eesn f K te) 2 0 Te panif as cmli o ICsatiuino h litfs lo opan f T’ trbto f piedcie t “iepedkolde aogUS prhsr o rc elns o wdsra nweg” mn .. ucaes f t ed m s i i d s r ’ e c s c p c t ,w i hi c n l d da l w d h oetc nutys xes aaiy hc t ocue loe te prhsr t ngtae lwr pie. Se Ves a 3. Te h ucaes o eoit oe rcs e iw t 9 h panif cnedteol ceil rcr eiec ctdb IC litfs otn h ny rdbe eod vdne ie y T i spoto “ieped koldei tetsioyo asnl n upr f wdsra” nweg s h etmn f ige idsr wtes Tu,te ageta,wieICas ctste nuty ins. hs hy ru ht hl T lo ie h t s i o yo ac n u t n r t i e b aJ p n s p o u e f rI C s etmn f oslat eand y aaee rdcr o T’ ivsiain hs tsioy “ae cer i i bsd o netgto, i etmn mks la” t s ae n s e u a i na dn tp r o a k o l d e S eP a n i f ’M m r n u pclto n o esnl nweg. e litfs eoadm o Lwa 5-4 f a t 35. 2 1 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 4 p a n i f s a et a A l g e yL d u ’ p i i gd r n t a p r o litfs tt ht lehn ulms rcn uig ht eid w ss tb al n - e mc n r c a d t u ,A l g e yL d u h dn a e y ogtr otat n, hs lehn ulm a o rao t (n dd nt ngtae lwr pie wt Hwr esn o ad i o) eoit oe rcs ih oad I d s r e i r s o s t p r o t dc m e i i nf o A S e l S e nutis n epne o upre optto rm K te. e Panif’ Mmrnu litfs eoadm o f Lw a a t 4-5 (mhss add. 34 epai de) Acrigy te cned rcr eiec de nt spot ICs codnl, hy otn eod vdne os o upr T’ dtriain ta te dcie i pie a wih Hwr eemnto ht h elns n rcs t hc oad Idsre prhsd GE bten 21 ad 21 wr de t nutis ucae OS ewe 01 n 03 ee u o c m e i i nb t e nA l g e yL d u a dA S e lf rt a a c u t optto ewe lehn ulm n K te o ht con. Frhr te panif pit ot ICs Ves d nt ietf a ute, h litfs on u, T’ iw o o dniy snl ige ohr te isac ntne o f itaidsr nr-nuty cmeiin optto ta ht protdydoedw pie i teUS mre. uprel rv on rcs n h .. akt Smaiig te panif miti ta wie Hwr umrzn, h litfs anan ht hl oad Idsre i asgiiatprhsro cnetoa GE,ICs nutis s infcn ucae f ovninl OS T’ “ a l r ”t i e t f “ n o h re i e c i s p o to t ei t n e fiue o dniy ay te vdne n upr f h nes itaidsr cmeiin ta protdy doe dw mre nr-nuty optto ht uprel rv on akt pie dmntae is fnig i nt spotd b sbtnil rcs eosrts t idn s o upre y usata eiec. Panif’Rpya 1-9&n 2. vdne” litfs el t 81 . 7 T i d i r g r t d f n a t sr s o s t a “ h t e o hr, n ead o eedn’ epne ht wehr r n tt et oc m a i sb l e e t e w r c m e i gw t o ea o h r o h w opne eivd hy ee optn ih n nte frHwr Idsre’bsns i bsd tepit”bcueIC o oad nutis uies s eie h on, eas T Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 5 “a fcsd o wa tasie wt rset t pie” te ws oue n ht rnprd ih epc o rcs, h p a n i f r p yt a t i s a e e ts g i i a t yd p r sf o t e litfs el ht hs ttmn infcnl eat rm h a a y i i I C sV e s w i ha t i u e t ed c i i gp i e f r nlss n T’ iw, hc trbts h elnn rcs o GE oe te pro o te cmeiin bten te to dmsi OS vr h eid f h optto ewe h w oetc p o u e s S eV e sa 3 ( t r b t n t ed c i ei p i e t a rdcr. e iw t 9 atiuig h eln n rcs ht Hwr Idsre pi fr GE oe te PI t “nrae oad nutis ad o OS vr h O o icesd c m e i i nb t e nd m s i p o u e s ) T e a g et i a o n s optto ewe oetc rdcr”. hy ru hs mut t a “era” fo ICs fnig drn te udryn o rtet rm T’ idns uig h nelig amnsrtv poedns ad rfet te lc o sbtnil diitaie rceig n elcs h ak f usata eiec spotn ta fnig vdne uprig ht idn. Fut, te panif cned ta, i seig t orh h litfs otn ht n ekn o ietf sm rcr eiec t spot ICs cnlso ta dniy oe eod vdne o upr T’ ocuin ht i t a i d s r c m e i i nw st ec u eo t ed c i i gp i e a nr-nuty optto a h as f h elnn rcs t wih Hwr Idsre prhsd GE drn te pro, te hc oad nutis ucae OS uig h eid h dfnatsae ta tepanif d ntcnedta A Sel eedn tts ht h litfs o o otn ht K te h dn r a o t l w ri sp i e . D f n a t sR s o s a 4 . T a o esn o oe t rcs eedn’ epne t 0 o t ec n r r ,t ep a n i f c n e d t e e p a n dt I Ct a A h otay h litfs otn, hy xlie o T ht K S e ll w r dt ep i e i o f r dt H w r I d s r e i 2 1 i te oee h rcs t fee o oad nutis n 03 n rsos t lwr pie iprs epne o oe rcd mot. Se Panif’ Mmrnu o e litfs eoadm f L wa 4 ,d s u s n t ed c a a i no o e[ a t 6 icsig h elrto f n [ ] o A ] f K S e l w ow sp r o a l r s o s b ef rn g t a i gt ec n r c te, h a esnly epnil o eoitn h otat udrwihA Selsl GE t Hwr Idsre i 21,ad ne hc K te od OS o oad nutis n 03 n Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 6 c t n t ep t t o e s J l 3 ,2 1 P s - e r n B i f E .7a iig h eiinr’ uy 1 04 otHaig re, x t 1,Co 28 Po 20 Tedfnatasrsteifraini 6 Dc 1, Dc 0. h eedn set h nomto n ta dcaain i icneunil ht elrto s nosqeta. Te panif dsge, h litfs iare c a m n i i t eo l i f r a i no t er c r t a s e i i a l liig t s h ny nomto n h eod ht pcfcly a d e s sw yA S e ll w r dt ep i e a w i hi s l G E t drse h K te oee h rcs t hc t od OS o Hwr Idsre i 21. oad nutis n 03 Se Pttoes Jl 3, 21 e eiinr’ uy 1 04 P s - e r n B i f E .7a ¶ ,C o 2 8 P o 2 0 A s c ,t e otHaig re, x t 6 Dc 1, Dc 0. s uh hy cned “hr i n rcr ifrain t spot a cnlso otn, tee s o eod nomto o upr ocuin ta tedciei pie i 21 a wihA Selsl GE t ht h eln n rcs n 03 t hc K te od OS o H w r I d s r e w sd et a y h n o h rt a s b e ti p r s , oad nutis a u o ntig te hn ujc mot” laig uspotd b sbtnil eiec te Cmiso evn nupre y usata vdne h omsin mjrt’ cnlso ta te dcie ws de t itaidsr aoiys ocuin ht h eln a u o nr-nuty cmeiin optto. Ffh te panif age ta te epaain i it, h litfs ru ht h xlnto n dfnats rsos fr wy IC acre ltl wih t te eedn’ epne o h T codd ite egt o h [ [ ] dcaain mshrceie is aayi. I ] elrto icaatrzs t nlss n priua, dfnats rsos asrs ta i “xlie ta atclr eedn’ epne set ht t epand ht t e ew sc n r d c o ye i e c i t er c r ”a dt a i “ o n hr a otaitr vdne n h eod n ht t fud ohr eiec . . . t oteg te dcaain wih ws te vdne o uwih h elrto, hc a r a o a l ,a di s p o t db s b t n i le i e c . D f n a t s esnbe n s upre y usata vdne” eedn’ Rsos a 4 n 3. Tepanif ageteesaeet ae epne t 1 . 6 h litfs ru hs ttmns r Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 7 i c n i t n w t t eV e s I i se t r t ,t ep a n i f p i t nosset ih h iw. n t niey h litfs on ottedsuso teeno te[ u h icsin hri f h [ ] dcaainsae: ] elrto tts []eas Pttoes PshaigBif Eh 1a 4 Se lo eiinr’ otern re, x. t 8 (eiinr camHwr Idsre ue iskolde pttoes li oad nutis sd t nweg o lw ipr piig t lvrg dw A Sels f o mot rcn o eeae on K te’ cnrcul pie) otata rcs. Ti hs cam ws bsd o li a ae n a c n i e t a d c a a i n A s c ,i c n o b v r f e ofdnil elrto. s uh t ant e eiid a Cmiso saf atmt t d wt “ot rvne s omsin tf teps o o ih ls eeu” algtos leain. Vesa 4 n 18 iw t 0 . 4. Tu,tepanif age cnrr t te hs h litfs ru, otay o h rpeettos i dfnats rsos, te Ves d nt sae ersnain n eedn’ epne h iw o o tt ta ohrrcr eiec otegste[ ht te eod vdne uwih h [ ] dcaain ] elrto, m c l s c t t o e e r f r n ea ys c r c r e i e c .T e uh es ie o r vn eeec n uh eod vdne hy cned a age aoe ta ICcudnthv ctdaysc otn, s rud bv, ht T ol o ae ie n uh rcr ifrain bcue tee i nn ta cnrdcs ta eod nomto eas hr s oe ht otait ht d c a a i n se p a a i no t ec r u s a c st a r s l e i A elrto’ xlnto f h icmtne ht eutd n K Sels dcso t lwr te pie a wih i sl GE t te’ eiin o oe h rcs t hc t od OS o Hwr Idsre i 21. oad nutis n 03 Sxh te panif cned ta te dfnat as it, h litfs otn ht h eedn lo mshrceie icaatrzs ICs T’ fnig idn rgrig eadn US .. prhsr ucaes i e t f i gA S e la dA l g e yL d u a “ r c l a e s . T e dniyn K te n lehn ulm s pie edr” hy age ta IC msnepee te prhsr’ rsoss i ru ht T iitrrtd h ucaes epne n c n l d n t a t ed m s i i d s r w s“ e p n i l ”f rl a i g ocuig ht h oetc nuty a rsosbe o edn pie dw fr GE i te US mre. rcs on o OS n h .. akt Se Panif’ e litfs Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 8 Mmrnu o Lwa 4-2 Tedfnatcutr ta “T dd eoadm f a t 95. h eedn ones ht IC i nt peue ta pie mvd i ay priua drcin - u, o rsm ht rcs oe n n atclr ieto - p dw, o rmie sal we i smaie te qetonie on r eand tbe hn t umrzd h usinar rsoss a idctn te dmsi poues wr te pie epne s niaig h oetc rdcr ee h rc l a e s .D f n a t sR s o s a 4 .S ea s J E N & MO p s t o edr” eedn’ epne t 3 e lo F/SS poiin a 2 - 9 T ep a n i f c a mt a t eC m i s o V e sc n r d c t 82. h litfs li ht h omsin iw otait ti saeet “e fn sc wdsra kolde o eitn hs ttmn: W id uh ieped nweg f xsig d m s i u u e c p c t e a l dp r h s r t o t i l w rp i e . oetc nsd aaiy nbe ucaes o ban oe rcs T e eo s r a i n a ec n i t n w t e i e c i t er c r t a hs bevtos r osset ih vdne n h eod ht te dmsi poues ae te pie laes i te idsr. h oetc rdcr r h rc edr n h nuty” Panif’ Rpy a 2, qoig Ves a 3-0 (litfs litfs el t 1 utn iw t 94 panif’ epai) mhss. Tu, te cam cnrr t te sgeto i hs hy li, otay o h ugsin n d f n a t sr s o s ,t eV e sm k c e rt ea e c ’ c n l s o eedn’ epne h iw ae la h gnys ocuin ta te dmsi idsr - a protd pie laes - ws ht h oetc nuty - s upre rc edr - a rsosbe fr laig pie fr GE i te US mre epnil o edn rcs o OS n h .. akt dwwr. onad T te cnrr, te panif cniu, ICs o h otay h litfs otne T’ q e t o n i em k sc e rt a a“ r c l a e ”i n tn c s a i y usinar ae la ht pie edr s o eesrl t el w r p i e s p l e ,a do h rs a e e t m d b p r h s r h oe-rcd upir n te ttmns ae y ucaes dmntaeta te ietfe tedmsi pouesa “rc eosrt ht hy dniid h oetc rdcr s pie laes bsd o ter efrs t ices te pie a wih edr” ae n hi fot o nrae h rcs t hc GE wssl i teUS mre. OS a od n h .. akt Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 3 ae 9 S v n h t ep a n i f e p a i et a t ep i ed c i e eet, h litfs mhsz ht h rc elns o pout 4 ad5 drn tePIfrecee tedcie i n rdcs b n b uig h O a xedd h elns n r wm t r a sc s st e e o . I d e ,t e s r s t a I Cs a e a aeil ot hrfr ned hy tes ht T ttd ta toe pout soe “ sgiiat aon o cmeiin ht hs rdcs hwd a infcn mut f optto btentedmsi lk poutadtesbetiprs,Ves ewe h oetc ie rdc n h ujc mot” iw a 3 ,a dt e o j c t I C sc n l s o t a t ed c i e i t e t 7 n hy bet o T’ ocuin ht h elns n h p i i gp o u t ( tl a tf r2 ,4 ,a d5 )w r a t i u a l t rcn rdcs a es o a b n b ee trbtbe o dcie i rwmtra pie rte ta sbetiprs Se elns n a aeil rcs ahr hn ujc mot. e Panif’Mmrnu o Lwa 3-7 litfs eoadm f a t 63. H r ,a s m n t a d l i gf r h ri t t i p i tm g t ee suig ht evn ute no hs on ih ass terae’ udrtnig i sol b rcle ta IC sit h edrs nesadn, t hud e eald ht T osre ta pie fr pout 2, 4, ad5 dcie, wie bevd ht rcs o rdcs a b n b elnd hl t ec s o r wm t r a su e t p o u eo et no G E d c e s d h ot f a aeil sd o rdc n o f OS erae o aeae b a cmaal pretg. n vrg y oprbe ecnae Se Ves a 3. Te e iw t 7 h panif age ta, wie te pretg dcie i pout litfs ru ht hl h ecnae elns n rdc piig my hv be smlr t te dcie i rw mtras rcn a ae en iia o h eln n a aeil css eaiain o te rcr sos ta te aslt pie ot, xmnto f h eod hw ht h boue rc dcie fr ece te dcie i rw mtras css elns a xed h eln n a aeil ot. Rw a mtra css dcie b [ ] pr tn bten 21 ad 21, aeil ot elnd y [ ] e o ewe 01 n 03 w i eU S p i e f rt et r ep i i gp o u t f l b t e n[ ] hl .. rcs o h he rcn rdcs el ewe [ ] prtnad[ ] prtndrn tesm pro,adteaeae e o n [ ] e o uig h ae eid n h vrg ui vleo US simnsdcie b [ ] prsottn Se nt au f .. hpet elnd y [ ] e hr o. e Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 0 Panif’ Mmrnu o Lw a 3; Saf Rpr a C4 V1, litfs eoadm f a t 7 tf eot t -, -5 V1, ad V2. Te panif pit ot ta te dcie i -6 n -7 h litfs on u ht h eln n dmsi poue pie fr pout 4 ad 5 ws getr ta oetc rdcr rcs o rdcs b n b a rae hn w sj s i i db t ed c i ei r wm t r a sc s s a dt e c a m a utfe y h eln n a aeil ot, n hy li te“aslcneto”t sbetiprsi dmntae b te h cua oncin o ujc mot s eosrtd y h udreln dt isl, wih so udreln i cmaios neslig aa tef hc hw neslig n oprsn f r p o u t 4 a d f r p o u t5 i t e t a i i n l p i i g d t , o rdc b n o rdc b n h rdtoa rcn aa a wl a i 6 o 1 cmaios fr pout 4 ad 1 o 1 s el s n f 3 oprsn o rdc b n 1 f 5 c m a i o sf rp o u t5 i t ed r c i p r e d t . S eS a f oprsn o rdc b n h iet motr aa e tf Rpr, V1, V1, ad Ap. D D1 ad D1. eot -5 -6 n px , -3 n -5 Ad ntn n, oig dfnats rsos ta te panif cno “hoe wih eedn’ epne ht h litfs ant cos” hc mtoooy (.. aslt bss IC ue i is aayi ad ehdlg eg, boue ai) T ss n t nlss n ta i i fe t cos is on mtoooy s ln a i i ht t s re o hoe t w ehdlg o og s t s r a o a l 2, t e p a n i f c u t r i t e r r p y t a t e[ ] e s n b e2 h litfs one n hi el ht h [ ] d c i ei r wm t r a c s sa c u t f rj s 1 t 1 p r e to eln n a aeil ot cons o ut 3 o 7 ecn f tepiedcie frtepout udrrve. h rc elns o h rdcs ne eiw Egt,tepanif ageta,atog dfnats ihh h litfs ru ht lhuh eedn’ rsos rle o ABsasrin ta i “eoitsissls epne eis n B’ setos ht t ngtae t ae wt US poues wl bfr i ngtae sls wt is ih .. rdcr el eoe t eoits ae ih t Dfnats Rsos eedn’ epne a t 3 4 (anann ta te mitiig ht h p a n i f “ i p ya s r t a [ T ]s o l c o s c l u a i n f r litfs sml set ht IC hud hoe acltos o is aayi ta ae mr fvrbe t te otoe te wud t nlss ht r oe aoal o h ucm hy ol lk”. ie) 2 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 1 frin sples i spot o ICs cnlso ta “ujc oeg upir” n upr f T’ ocuin ht sbet i p r s o p i i g p o u t 4 a d5 d d n t l a d m s i p i e mot f rcn rdcs b n b i o ed oetc rcs dwwr, i i cerfo tercr ta ABprhsdsbet onad” t s la rm h eod ht B ucae ujc i p r s o p o u t 4 a d5 t a u d r o d t e p i e i p i t mot f rdcs b n b ht nesl h rcs t ad o tedmsi idsr i 1 o 2 cmaios Te cnedta, h oetc nuty n 6 f 6 oprsn. hy otn ht ee tog te Jpns rsodns asre ta ter ha vn huh h aaee epnet setd ht hi et a r ueir o h pof hg-emaiiy pout 4 ad 5 ae spro t te ro, ihpreblt rdcs a n hg-emaiiy pout ofrd b A Sel (n sol tu ihpreblt rdcs fee y K te ad hud hs hv cmadd a peim, te pie pi b AB fr toe ae omne rmu) h rcs ad y B o hs pout wr ls ta te pie AB pi fr dmsi rdcs ee es hn h rcs B ad o oetc nnha-ro GE pout 4 ad5 i eeysnl cmaio o-etpof OS rdcs b n b n vr ige oprsn drn tePI SeSafRpr,D1 t D1. uig h O. e tf eot -2 o -5 C n i e i gt ef r g i g i i p a nf o t eV e sa d osdrn h oeon, t s li rm h iw n Saf Rpr ta IC fud vros fcos aat fo ipr tf eot ht T on aiu atr pr rm mot udreln ta wr bhn te dmsi idsr’ pout neslig ht ee eid h oetc nutys rdc piig I fil rcgie ta “prcsdcie drn te rcn. t ary eonzd ht []ie elnd uig h [ O ]f ra ld m s i a l p o u e p i i gp o u t ” V e sa 3 , PI o l oetcly rdcd rcn rdcs, iw t 5 a dd t r i e t a t ef c o sb h n t ed c i e s w r ( )t e n eemnd ht h atr eid h eln() ee 1 h lre dcie i te dmsi idsr’ eprs () te ag eln n h oetc nutys xot, 2 h wdsra kolde o te rslig uue cpct, () ieped nweg f h eutn nsd aaiy 3 AlgeyLdu’ ls o acnrc wt alreprhsr ad lehn ulms os f otat ih ag ucae, n ()dcesdrwmtra css i.a 3-0 I as eaie 4 erae a aeil ot, d t 54. t lo xmnd Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 2 te taiinl piig dt t osre ta pie fr Jpns h rdtoa rcn aa o bev ht rcs o aaee pout 4 ae hge ta dmsi pie fr pout 4, Saf rdc a r ihr hn oetc rcs o rdc b tf Rpr, Tbe V8 i osre ta AB ngtae is prhss eot al -; t bevd ht B eoits t ucae wt US poues wl bfr i ngtae wt frin ih .. rdcr el eoe t eoits ih oeg sples ad i ntd ta te vs mjrt o drc iprs upir; n t oe ht h at aoiy f iet mot frpout 4 ad 5,sei. Tbe D2t D7 idctdt o rdcs b n b e d, als - o -, niae o IC ta sbet iprso toe pout dd nt la dmsi T ht ujc mot f hs rdcs i o ed oetc p i e d w w r . I Cp i t dt p r h s rr s o s t e p a ni s rcs onad T one o ucae epne o xli t cnlsos o pie laesi, Ves a 4 n 19 ad te ocuin n rc edrhp iw t 0 . 4, n h bedh o kolde i iptd t prhsr rgrig te rat f nweg t mue o ucaes eadn h d m s i i d s r ’ u u e c p c t ,i .a 3 ( e a s T a s r p oetc nutys nsd aaiy d t 9 se lo rncit o ICPeiiayHaig o Ot 2,21,Po 6,a 102: f T rlmnr ern n c. 5 03 Dc 7 t 2-1 “ v r o ei t ei d s r k o st et or a o sw yd m s i p i e eeyn n h nuty nw h w esn h oetc rcs ae flig e ctr) ad IC i, a i sae, “eurd t r aln” t eea, n T s s t tts rqie o ass tedmsi idsr a awoe,DfnatsRsos a ses h oetc nuty s hl” eedn’ epne t 3 ,r f r n i gC m i t ef rF i C k T a ev U i e S a e ,2 6 eeecn omte o ar oe rd . ntd tts 8 CT 14, 16 (04. I 10 17 20) Panif’ agmns rie o te litfs ruet asd n h a p r n i s e s h r d n tp r u d t a I Ch sn td n s ,o paet su() ee o o esae ht T a o oe o r ta is aayi teef cn b hl uraoal, o ta te ht t nlss hro a e ed nesnbe r ht h rcr de nt sbtnit is fu cnlsos aoe eod os o usatae t or ocuin bv. Tu, hs ntihtnig panif’ atmt t fcs “nr-nuty owtsadn litfs tep o ou itaidsr c m e i i n o H w r I d s r ’ p r h s so e t eP Ia d o t e optto” n oad nutys ucae vr h O n/r h Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 3 piig o pout 4 ad 5, i cno b cnldd ta te rcn f rdcs b n b t ant e ocue ht h V e s o e a la s s m n o d m s i c m e i i nd r n t eP Ii iw’ vrl seset f oetc optto uig h O s u r a o a l o u s p o t db s b t n i le i e c o t er c r . nesnbe r nupre y usata vdne n h eod () v L s l ,w t r s e tt t e rc n e t o t a I C sp i e aty ih epc o hi otnin ht T’ rc efcs aayi i uspotd b sbtnil eiec, te fet nlss s nupre y usata vdne h panif age ta te rcr de nt spot is fnig litfs ru ht h eod os o upr t idns r g r i gl s s l sa dr v n e a dt a t eC m i s o f i e t eadn ot ae n eeus n ht h omsin ald o adessbtnilise te rie. drs usata sus hy asd I mkn is pie efcs fnig IC sae ta, n aig t rc fet idn, T ttd ht “whl teeaecnimdls slsadrvne,te aeo []ie hr r ofre ot ae n eeus hy r f mnr mgiue ad d nt oteg ohr dt i te rcr io antd n o o uwih te aa n h eod soig te lc o sgiiat pie efcs” hwn h ak f infcn rc fet. Ves a 4 iw t 1 ( o t o eo i t d . I Cc u t da c n i m do l t o el s s l s font mte) T one s ofre ny hs ot ae a dr v n e a l g t o st a p r h s r e p i i l a m t e . S e n eeus leain ht ucaes xlcty ditd e S a fR p r ,T b eV 1 . “ h c n i m dl s s l sd n td t a t tf eot al -2 Te ofre ot ae o o erc fo or aayi, a tee wr n sit i mre sae a rm u nlss s hr ee o hfs n akt hr s dsusd aoe” icse bv. I. a 4 n 1 (idn to cnimd ls d t 1 . 5 fnig w ofre ot slsalgtosttln [$ ae leain oaig [ ls rvnealgtosttln [$ ot eeu leain oaig [ ] adtrecnimd ] n he ofre ]) ]. Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 4 T ep a n i f a g eI Cf i e t a a y er a o a l t e h litfs ru T ald o nlz esnby h rsoss t te dmsi idsr’ ls sls ad rvne epne o h oetc nutys ot ae n eeu algtos Panif’Mmrnu o Lwa 5-7 Te cned leain. litfs eoadm f a t 56. hy otn i c u dn ts m l e a i ew e h rr s o d n p r h s r “ g e d t ol o ipy xmn hte epnig ucaes are” o “ i a r e ”w t t ea l g t o ,b c u ec r a np r h s r o l r dsged ih h leain eas eti ucaes ny “eid ls sls ad ls rvne algtos o “ehia” dne” ot ae n ot eeu leain n tcncl gons bsd fr eape o a mnr fcul dsue bt te rud, ae o xml n io ata ipt, u h rcr cnan nmru isacs o prhsr ohrie eod otis ueos ntne f ucaes tews c n e i gh v n p r h s dal w r p i e i p r e p o u to u i g ocdn aig ucae oe-rcd motd rdc r sn al w rp i eo f rf rs b e ti p r st f r ed m s i p o u e s oe rc fe o ujc mot o oc oetc rdcr t lwr ter pie t scr a sl. o oe hi rc o eue ae Se i. a 5, ctn e d t 6 iig P t t o e s P e H a i gB i fa 3 - 5 C o 2 3 P o 1 5 T .a eiinr’ r-ern re t 94, Dc 0, Dc 7; r t 4, 133, Po 7 3-4 Dc 14 Pttoes Ps-ern Bif E. 1 a 8; eiinr’ otHaig re, x t 91,4-9 Co 28 Po 20 -4 44, Dc 1, Dc 0. A e e p a ,t ep a n i f p i tt A B sr s o s b i f s xmlr h litfs on o B’ epne re w e ei “ n q i o a l d n e P a n i f ’l s s l sa l g t o s ” hr t ueuvcly eid litfs ot ae leain. A B sR s o s a 9 T e r p yt a ,a t o g A Bc a m t h v B’ epne t . hy el ht lhuh B lis o ae “iare”wt tels slsalgtos [ dsged ih h ot ae leain, [ Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 5 ]. SePanif’Mmrnu o Lwa 5-0 ] e litfs eoadm f a t 86. Al tl, te panif age te rcr eiec l od h litfs ru h eod vdne dmntae ta [ ] pret (y vle o te dmsi eosrts ht [ ] ecn b au) f h oetc idsr’ ls slsalgtosta rcie arsos sol nutys ot ae leain ht eevd epne hud b cniee cnimd adta [ ] pret(yvle o is e osdrd ofre, n ht [ ] ecn b au) f t ls rvne algtos ta rcie a rsos sol b ot eeu leain ht eevd epne hud e cniee cnimd o te asmto (r peupin ta a osdrd ofre, n h supin o rsmto) ht prhsr wud mk te srtgc dcso nt t spot te ucae ol ae h taei eiin o o upr h d m s i i d s r ’ c s b c n i m n s c a l g t o s S ei .a oetc nutys ae y ofrig uh leain. e d t 6. Bsdo ti aayi,tepanif cnedtecnimd 5 ae n hs nlss h litfs otn h ofre ls sls algtos sol ttl [$ ot ae leain hud oa [ ] ad te ] n h cnimdls rvnealgtossol ttl[$ ofre ot eeu leain hud oa [ I. d ]. ] Te ad ta tee fgrs d nt icue a sgiiat hy d ht hs iue o o nld infcn n m e o a l g t o sw e et ep r h s r d dn tr s o dt I C s ubr f leain hr h ucaes i o epn o T’ rqet fr ifrain wih i icue, wud ices te eus o nomto, hc, f nldd ol nrae h ttlls slsfgr t [$ oa ot ae iue o [ ] ad te ttlls ] n h oa ot Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 rvne fgr t [$ eeus iue o [ Pg 4 ae 6 ] -o attlo [$ ] r oa f [ ]. I.a 6-6 ] d t 56. T ep a n i f f r h ra dt a ac r a nf o n t t t e h litfs ute d ht eti otoe o h l s s l sa dr v n es m a yt b ei I C sS a fR p r c n i m ot ae n eeu umr al n T’ tf eot ofrs a amnsrtv fiue t maigul eaut te rsoss n diitaie alr o ennfly vlae h epne rcie t ICs ls sls ad ls rvne qetonie eevd o T’ ot ae n ot eeu usinars bcue i sae: “ths clm i nt a saf assmn o eas t tts []i oun s o tf seset f wehr te prhsr cmet are o dsge; rte, i i hte h ucae omns ge r iare ahr t s ol rprig wehr te prhsr woe are o dsge ad ny eotn hte h ucae rt ge r iare n cmet o tealgtos” SafRpr a V3. omns n h leain. tf eot t -8 Dfnats rsos, te panif frhr cned eedn’ epne h litfs ute otn, d e n ti a ym n e a d e st es b t n eo t e ra g m n sb t os o n n anr drs h usac f hi ruet u asrs te ae mrl seig t hv te cut “eeg” te set hy r eey ekn o ae h or rwih h e i e c o l s s l s a d r v n e 2. vdne n ot ae n e e u s3 T te cnrr, te o h otay h Tepanif camdfnatsrsos mnmzste h litfs li eedn’ epne iiie h s g i i a c o t ed m s i i d s r ’ l s s l sa dl s r v n e infcne f h oetc nutys ot ae n ot eeu algtos saig ta ee i al o te algtos wr leain, ttn ht vn f l f h leain ee a c p e a t u ,t e w u da o n t j s [ cetd s re hy ol mut o ut [ ] p r e to t e ] ecn f h d m s i i d s r ’ t t ls i m n so G E d r n t ep r o ,a d oetc nutys oa hpet f OS uig h eid n ta “ths ttl hrl oteg te ohr eiec i te ht []ee oas ady uwih h te vdne n h rcr ta ICcniee adepand DfnatsRsos a eod ht T osdrd n xlie. eedn’ epne t 4. Se as i. a 4 ([]u, ee i al ls sls ad 8 e lo d t 9 “ths vn f l ot ae n rvnealgtoswr cnimd sbtnileiec spot eeu leain ee ofre, usata vdne uprs ICs fnig bsd o te eiec t wih IC gv te ms T’ idns ae n h vdne o hc T ae h ot wih”. Hr aan te panif cag te dfnat wt egt) ee gi, h litfs hre h eedn ih ps hc rtoaiain a te cam te Cmiso dd nt ot o ainlzto, s hy li h omsin i o cmlt sc a aayi i teudryn ivsiain opee uh n nlss n h nelig netgto. 2 3 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 7 panif cam te se te cuts rqiig IC “o te litfs li, hy ek h or’ eurn T fr h frt tm” t cnie etnie agmnain md b te is ie o osdr xesv ruetto ae y h d m s i i d s r o t r es p r t o c s o si I C sf n lp a e oetc nuty n he eaae cain n T’ ia hs ivsiain bt ta rmie cmltl uadesd i is netgto u ht eand opeey ndrse n t Ves Atog tepanif itrrtdfnatsrsos a iw. lhuh h litfs nepe eedn’ epne s “eit[n] te sgiiac o te dmsi idsr’ bltlig” h infcne f h oetc nutys algtos te pit ot ta te [$ leain, hy on u ht h [ ] i ls ] n ot r v n e o e t ep r o w u dh v m r t a o f e t eo e a i g eeus vr h eid ol ae oe hn fst h prtn ls o [$ os f [ ] sfee b te dmsi idsr i ] ufrd y h oetc nuty n 2 1 . T ep a n i f i s s t a t er d c dp i e t a r s l e 03 h litfs nit ht h eue rcs ht eutd f o t o el s s l sa dr v n e f r e U S p o u e st a c p rm hs ot ae n eeus ocd .. rdcr o cet ee lwr bnhak fr pie ngtain o ftr sls vn oe ecmrs o rc eoitos n uue ae, rslig i a adtoa ngtv ipc o te dmsi eutn n n diinl eaie mat n h oetc idsr’ fnnilcniin nutys iaca odto. Te cu o te polm wt rgr t panif’ h rx f h rbe ih ead o litfs agmns hwvr i ta te ak te cut t itree i ruet, oee, s ht hy s h or o nefr n ICs dcso t cut ol “ofre” ls sls ad rvne T’ eiin o on ny cnimd ot ae n eeus algtos leain. I tres wa wih te aec asgs t te t agt ht egt h gny sin o h e i e c ,am t e w t i i sd s r t o . W i ei m g th v b e vdne atr ihn t icein hl t ih ae en e u l yr a o a l f rI Ct p e u et ea l g t o sc n i m di qal esnbe o T o rsm h leain ofre n teasneo epii dna a wl,tecutcno cnld h bec f xlct eil s el h or ant ocue ta ICsrqieeto epii areeti odrt cuta ht T’ eurmn f xlct gemn n re o on n Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 8 a l g t o “ o f r e ” w su r a o a l i a c r a c w t C n o o leain cnimd a nesnbe n codne ih osl, spa 33 US a 60 (to icnitn cnlsos fo te ur, 8 .. t 2 “w nosset ocuin rm h eiec de ntpeeta amnsrtv aec' fnigfo vdne os o rvn n diitaie gnys idn rm big spotd b sbtnil eiec”. en upre y usata vdne) Te rmidr o h eane f panif’agmnso ti ise teeoe aeuaaln. litfs ruet n hs su, hrfr, r nviig B Te panif calne ICs ipc aayi, wih h litfs hleg T’ mat nlss hc fud ta, bcue te sbet iprs dd nt tk sgi iat on ht eas h ujc mot i o ae in fcn mre sae aa fo te dmsi idsr ad dd nt hv akt hr wy rm h oetc nuty n i o ae s g i i a tp i ee f c s t ed m s i i d s r w sn tm t r a l infcn rc fet, h oetc nuty a o aeily ijrdb rao o tesbetiprs nue y esn f h ujc mot: Tedmsi idsr’ ufvrbeted i oeaig h oetc nutys naoal rns n prtn p r o m n ew r ac m i a i no a v r eo t u - e a e efrac ee obnto f des uptrltd e f c sa da v r er v n ee f c s T e e i t r ,w r fet n des eeu fet. hs, n un ee c u e b t el s o e p r s i m n s h g e u i c s s asd y h os f xot hpet, ihr nt ot rslig fo ls pouto, ad rdcd pie. eutn rm es rdcin n eue rcs Hwvr nn o tee fcos wr a fnto o te oee, oe f hs atr ee ucin f h sbetiprs ujc mot. Vesa 4. iw t 4 T ep a n i f c n e dt eC m i s o m j r t i p o e l h litfs otn h omsin aoiy mrpry apid te saues cuain sadr i nt fnig sbet ple h ttt’ asto tnad n o idn ujc i p r s a c u e o m t r a i j r 2, a d t e a g e i e r d i mot a s f a e i l n u y4 n hy ru t re n T e l t ho t I C ss a e e tt a t el w r q i e i hy ac no T’ ttmn ht h a eurs t t dtrie wehr sbet iprs ae “h” cue o mtra o eemn hte ujc mot r te as f aeil i j r t t ed m s i i d s r ,a dt e a g et e“ yr a o o ” nuy o h oetc nuty n hy ru h b esn f (otne.. cniud.) 2 4 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 4 ae 9 atiuig te dmsi trbtn h oetc idsr’ nutys dtroaig cniin eeirtn odto etrl t fcos ohr ta sbet iprs niey o atr te hn ujc mot. I adto t n diin o t e ra g m n so e a l g de r r i I C sp i ee f c a a y i , hi ruet vr lee ros n T’ rc fet nlss te cned i ipoel atiue te dmsi idsr’ hy otn t mrpry trbtd h oetc nutys dciig promne t “ihr ui css rslig fo ls elnn efrac o hge nt ot eutn rm es p o u t o ”a dn t- a l a ti p r - t s b e ti p r s S e rdcin n o - t es n at - o ujc mot. e Panif’Mmrnu o Lwa 7-1 qoigVesa 4. litfs eoadm f a t 07, utn iw t 4 (.cniud ..otne) s a d r ( )i 1 U S C § 1 7 d b ( )a d1 7 d b ( )d ( s n t tnads n 9 ... § 61()l n 63()l oe) o rqie ufil tae iprs t b te “oe o “rnia” eur nary rdd mot o e h sl” r picpl c u eo i j r . P a n i f ’R p ya 2 ,r f r n i gN p o S e l as f nuy litfs el t 6 eeecn ipn te C .v U I C 3 5F 3 1 7 ,1 8 ( e . i .2 0 )( a a f r a i e o . ST, 4 .d 39 31 FdCr 03 “n fimtv mtra-nuy dtriain udr te saue rqie n mr aeilijr eemnto ne h ttt eurs o oe ta a sbtnilfco soig; tht i, te ‘upn’ ne hn usata-atr hwn[ ]a s h dmig ed ntb tesl o picplcueo ijr”adte“yrao o e h oe r rnia as f nuy n h b esn o ”s a d r i s t s i ds l n a s b e ti p r sa em r t a f tnad s aife o og s ujc mot r oe hn amnmlo tneta cueo ijr;teeitneo fcos iia r agnil as f nuy h xsec f atr ohrta sbetiprsta my hv be agetrcueo te hn ujc mot ht a ae en rae as f ijr de nt peet a afraie ijr dtriain. nuy os o rvn n fimtv nuy eemnto) S ea s M t a S e lP i tL s s L d v U i e S a e ,5 2F 3 e lo itl te on ia, t. . ntd tts 4 .d 87 83(e.i.20) 6, 7 FdCr 08. Ti cut de nt rgr dfnats ue o “h” we hs or os o ead eedn’ s f te hn d s r b n “ a s o m t r a i j r ”( m h s si o i i a )i i s eciig cue f aeil nuy epai n rgnl n t r s o s b i fa a o n i gt am s t t m n o t el w s n et e epne re s mutn o isaeet f h a, ic h s b e d n u d rw i ht a s a e e td r c l a p a sa s s a e uhaig ne hc ht ttmn iety per lo tts t a s b e ti p r sw r n t“ ”c u eo m t r a i j r . I a y ht ujc mot ee o a as f aeil nuy n n e e t i i t eV e s s a e e to t es b e tt a c n r l ,a d vn, t s h iw’ ttmn n h ujc ht otos n t e e ni s e i i a l s a e t a “ h ‘ yr a o o ’s a d r i hri s pcfcly ttd ht te b esn f tnad s s t s i di s b e ti p r sa em r t a am n m lo t n e t a aife f ujc mot r oe hn iia r agnil c u eo i j r . V e sa 2 n 7 .S ea s J E N & MO p s t o as f nuy” iw t 0 . 1 e lo F/SS poiin a 56 t -. 2 4 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 5 ae 0 Mr peiey cnrr t dfnatsaditreooe rcsl, otay o eedn’ n nevnr d f n a t ’ a g m n s5 t e p a n i f c n e d t a “ i h r u i e e d n s r u e t 2, h l i t f s o t n h t h g e n t c s sr s l i gf o l s p o u t o ”w r n tas g i i a tf c o ot eutn rm es rdcin ee o infcn atr i tedmsi idsr’ dciigfnnilpromne Te n h oetc nutys elnn iaca efrac. hy ageta,atog tedmsi idsr’ ui cssicesd ru ht lhuh h oetc nutys nt ot nrae bten21 ad21,tercr dt so n drc creain ewe 01 n 03 h eod aa hw o iet orlto bten dciig pouto ad icesn ui css ewe elnn rdcin n nraig nt ot. I n priua, te panif atclr h litfs epaie ta, wie dmsi mhsz ht hl oetc pouto dcie fo 21 t 21 adfo 21 t 21,US rdcin elnd rm 01 o 02 n rm 02 o 03 .. p o u e s u i c s si c e s df o 2 1 t 2 1 b td c i e f o rdcr’ nt ot nrae rm 01 o 02 u elnd rm 2 1 t 2 1 .S eS a fR p r ,C 4 T u ,t e a g e t er c r 02 o 03 e tf eot -. hs hy ru, h eod de nt spot ICs fnig ta te dcie i te dmsi os o upr T’ idn ht h elns n h oetc idsr’ epr simns ad dmsi pouto rsle i nutys xot hpet n oetc rdcin eutd n sgiiat cs icess ta cue te idsr’ dciig infcn ot nrae ht asd h nutys elnn promne efrac. Jdca rve o tee tps o mtes hwvr i uiil eiw f hs ye f atr, oee, s i l p s t o e t c n i e t e“ i n f c n e o t ed t t w i h l-oiind o osdr h sgiiac” f h aa o hc te panif wud hr pit al ta my b rvee i h litfs ol ee on; l ht a e eiwd s wehrsbtnileiec o rcr spot tedtriain hte usata vdne f eod uprs h eemnto SeDfnatsRsos a 5-3 JEN&MOpsto e eedn’ epne t 25; F/SS poiin a 4 - 2 O p s t o o i t r e o - e e d n sB o h nI o &S e l t 14; poiin f nevnrdfnat asa rn te C. Ld adBote Aeia Ic a 3. o, t. n asel mrc, n. t 9 2 5 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 rahd ece. Pg 5 ae 1 Nntees te age i i sgiiat ta ICs oehls, hy ru t s infcn ht T’ Saf Rpr tf eot atiue trbts te dmsi h oetc idsr’ nutys dciig elnn p r o m n et t er d c dp i e a w i hi w sa l t s l G E efrac o h eue rcs t hc t a be o el OS i te Uie Sae. I priua, te pit t is vrac n h ntd tts n atclr hy on o t aine aayi, wih sos ta o te [$] dcie i te dmsi nlss hc hw ht f h [] eln n h oetc i d s r ’ o e a i gi c m b t e n2 1 a d2 1 ,[ $ ]-o [ ] nutys prtn noe ewe 01 n 03 [] r [ ] pret - ws drcl atiual t te ngtv efc o ecn a iety trbtbe o h eaie fet f dcesdpie.SafRpr,V-3 Tepanif ageta erae rcs tf eot I1. h litfs ru ht b c u eI C sV e sd n ta d e st ev r a c a a y i c n a n d eas T’ iw o o drs h aine nlss otie i t eS a fR p r 2,d f n a t sr s o s n w a s r i gt a t e n h t f e o t6 e e d n ’ e p n e o , s e t n h t h aec “ae ls wih t te vrac aayi ta t te gny gv es egt o h aine nlss hn o h eiec rgrig te dcie i epr sls ad Algey vdne eadn h eln n xot ae n lehn L d u ’ l s o t e H w r I d s r e c n r c ”7 i n t i g m r u l m s o s f h o a d n u t i s o t a t 2, s o h n o e ta ps hcrtoaiainuspotdb tercr. Euly hn ot o ainlzto nupre y h eod qal uspotd te panif cniu, i dfnats asrin nupre, h litfs otne s eedn’ seto, ps hc ta tevrac aayi wsntcmeln2 bcue o t o , h t h a i n e n l s s a o o p l i g8 e a s pie ws a mr dmnn fco bten 21 t 21. rc a oe oiat atr ewe 02 o 03 Te h p a n i f c n e dt a t er c r s o st a p i ev r a c h da litfs otn ht h eod hw ht rc aine a g e t rn g t v i p c o t ed m s i i d s r ’ o e a i gi c m rae eaie mat n h oetc nutys prtn noe 2 6 2 7 a 4-4 t 34. 2 8 SeVesa 3-4 e iw t 34. D f n a t sR s o s a 5 .S ea s J E N & M O p s t o eedn’ epne t 3 e lo F/SS poiin SeDfnatsRsos a 5. e eedn’ epne t 2 Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 5 ae 2 i ec ya o tePIta ete tecs o vlm vracs n ah er f h O hn ihr h ot r oue aine. C .S a fR p r ,V - 3a dV - 4 T ep a n i f t u c a mt a f tf eot I1 n I1. h litfs hs li ht ICs fiue t ades te Saf Rpr’ vrac aayi, T’ alr o drs h tf eots aine nlss wih etbihs ta te dcie i piig - nt icesn hc salse ht h eln n rcn - o nraig css- wstepiayrao frteUS poues fnnil ot - a h rmr esn o h .. rdcr’ iaca d t r o a i nd r n t eP I r p e e t a o h ri s a c i w i h eeirto uig h O, ersns nte ntne n hc te Cmiso fie t ades rcr ifrain ta i h omsin ald o drs eod nomto ht s cnrr t isfnig adta rqie armn t teaec otay o t idns n ht eurs ead o h gny frfrhrdlbrto. o ute eieain Ti cut cno cnu wt sc raoig hs or ant ocr ih uh esnn. IC T akolde te pie dcie, ad i fud ta te raos cnwegd h rc elns n t on ht h esn teeo wr a rsl o lwr rw mtras css uue hrfr ee eut f oe a aeil ot, nsd c p c t ,a di t a i d s r c m e i i n R g r l s o w yi d d aaiy n nr-nuty optto. eades f h t i n tr l o t ev r a c a a y i i i sV e s t eu eo n n u e o ey n h aine nlss n t iw, h s r o-s ws mte wti is dsrto. a atr ihn t icein Se AP Idsre v Uie e W nutis . ntd Sae, 3 CT __ __ 73 FSp.d 16, 18 n 3 (01 tts 5 I _, _, 8 .up2 26 20 . 5 21) ( [ ] r a c a a y i i at o t a t eC m i s o m yu ed r n “vaine nlss s ol ht h omsin a s uig a ivsiain)(mhssadd;At,Ic v Uie Sae, n netgto” epai de) lx n. . ntd tts 2 C T1 2 ,1 3 ( 0 2 ( T n e n tr l o t e r t c lm d li 6 I 45 43 20) IC ed o ey n hoeia oe f “ e sh l f l t a o h rd t i t er c r ) a f d 3 0F 3 1 0 ls epu” hn te aa n h eod, f’, 7 .d 18 (e.i.20) Adpanif’agmnsd ntprud ta, FdCr 04. n litfs ruet o o esae ht Cno.CutN.1-02 osl or o 4020 Pg 5 ae 3 o epan wy rlac uo te vrac aayi wud hv r xli h, eine pn h aine nlss ol ae atrdICsVeso tepiedcie i ayeet lee T’ iw n h rc elns n n vn. II I I cnlso, ad i ve o te frgig te cut n ocuin n n iw f h oeon, h or cn ol osre ta tee i n bih ln bten fi ad a ny bev ht hr s o rgt ie ewe ar n ufi cmeiin- ec stainms b,adncsaiyi, nar optto - ah iuto ut e n eesrl s eautd o is on mrt, a hc2 vlae n t w eis d o .9 Hr, te sadr o ee h tnad f jdca rve pelds d nv rve. Ad te panif d uiil eiw rcue e oo eiw n h litfs o n tp r u d t a I C sV e sa ee t e u s p o t db s b t n i l o esae ht T’ iw r ihr nupre y usata e i e c o t er c r o n ti a c r a c w t l w A c r i g y vdne n h eod r o n codne ih a. codnl, ter mto fr jdmn o ta rcr ms b dne, wt hi oin o uget n ht eod ut e eid ih jdmn etrddsisn tercmlit uget nee imsig hi opan. S odrd o ree. Dcdd NwYr,NwYr eie: e ok e ok Nvme 2,21 oebr 3 06 //Toa J Auln,J. s hms . qiio r Sno Jde eir ug S e e g ,F d T a eC m ' ,A t d m i g L g s a i n a d e, .. e. rd omn niupn eilto n Ohr Ipr Rgltos i te Uie Sae ad Frin te mot euain n h ntd tts n oeg Cutis S Dc N. 7-1 (94 ([]mig hs be onre, . o. o 312 13) “dupn a en r p a e l r c g i e a u f i c m e i i ni n t o a l g s a i n eetdy eonzd s nar optto n ainl eilto ad i itrainl cneecs ad areet, atog i i n n nentoa ofrne n gemns lhuh t s s m t m sv r d f i u tt d a t el n b t e nw a i f i a d oeie ey ifcl o rw h ie ewe ht s ar n w a i u f i i f r i n t a ed v l p e t ) S s nB e m n F i ht s nar n oeg-rd eeomn”; ua ira, ar adUfi Taei a ItretoitEa 7 A.ScyItlL n nar rd n n nevnins r, 7 m o' n' . Po. 14 141 (93 (eak o Syor J Rbn Cara) rc 1, 1-5 18) Rmrs f emu . ui, himn ( [ ] m yw l b t a t er a i i so r l e a a n ti j r f o “it a el e ht h elte f eif gis nuy rm f r i nc m e i i nb u t eo t ni d s i c l n b t e nf i a d oeg optto lr h fe nitnt ie ewe ar n ufi tae) nar rd”. 2 9 ERRATA A Sel Cr. v Uie Sae Itrainl Tae Cmiso, K te op . ntd tts nentoa rd omsin Cnoiae Cut N. 1-02, Si O. 1-0 (ofdnil osldtd or o 4020 lp p 618 cnieta vrin,dtdNvme 2,21: eso) ae oebr 3 06 A dt t el s o i t r e o - e e d n si t ec p i n “ n d o h it f nevnrdfnat n h ato: ad BOHN IO & SEL C. LD, BOTE AEIA IC, ad ASA RN TE O, T. ASEL MRC, N. n NVLPTKSEL” OOIES TE, Adt tels o cuslo pg 2 d o h it f one n ae : “ h l p eM B u oa dR s S J o g G e n e gT a r g L P Piip . rn n oa . en, rebr rui, L, Wsigo, DC, fr itreo-eedns Bohn Io & Sel ahntn .. o nevnrdfnat asa rn te C. Ld adBote Aeia Ic” o, t. n asel mrc, n.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.