Thomas West, et al v. Janice Brewer, et al, No. 11-16707 (9th Cir. 2011)

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¯Ã¨ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã²Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ±Ã² Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã Ã²Ã Ã² Ã ±Ã² Ã®Ã¦Ã¯Ã¯Ã³½ªÃ³Ã°Ã¯Ã¬Ã°Ã§Ã³Ã Ã Ã Ã ·-¬®·½¬ ±º Ã ®·¦±²¿Ã´ Ã ¸±»²·¨ Ã ´¿·²¬·ºº- Ã³ Ã °°»´´¿²¬-Ã´ ªÃ² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ±ª»®²±® ±º Ã ®·¦±²¿Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ·®»½¬±®Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã »°¿®¬³»²¬ ±º Ã ±®®»½¬·±²-Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ¿®¼»²Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã »°¿®¬³»²¬ ±º Ã ±®®»½¬·±²-Ã³ Ã ´±®»²½»Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ²¿³»¼ ¿- Ã ±»- Ã¯Ã³ Ã«Ã°Ã´ Ã »º»²¼¿²¬- Ã³ Ã °°»´´»»-Ã² Ã »º±®»Ã¦ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ¿²¼ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ·®½«·¬ Ã «¼¹»-Ã² Ã ¸±³¿- Ã ¿«´ Ã »-¬ ·- -½¸»¼«´»¼ ¬± ¾» »¨»½«¬»¼ ¾§ ¬¸» Ã ¬¿¬» ±º Ã ®·¦±²¿ ¬±³±®®±©Ã´ Ã «´§ Ã¯Ã§Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯Ã² Ã ¿-¬ ²·¹¸¬Ã´ ¬¸» ¼·-¬®·½¬ ½±«®¬ ¼»²·»¼ Ã »-¬Å½- Ã ³»®¹»²½§ Ã ±¬·±² º±® Ã »³°±®¿®§ Ã »-¬®¿·²·²¹ Ã ®¼»® ±® Ã ®»´·³·²¿®§ Ã ²¶«²½¬·±² ·² ©¸·½¸ Ã »-¬ -±«¹¸¬ ¬± ¬»³°±®¿®·´§ -¬¿§ ¸·- »¨»½«¬·±²Ã² Ã »-¬ º·´»¼ ¿ ²±¬·½» ±º ¿°°»¿´Ã´ ¿²¼ ¬¸·- ³±®²·²¹ º·´»¼ ¿² Ã ³»®¹»²½§ Ã ±¬·±² Ã ²¼»® Ã ·®½«·¬ Ã «´» Ã®Ã©Ã³Ã º±® ¿² Ã ²¶«²½¬·±²Ã² Ã » ¼»²§ ¸·- »³»®¹»²½§ ³±¬·±²Ã² Ã ² ±®¼»® ¬± ±¾¬¿·² °®»´·³·²¿®§ ·²¶«²½¬·ª» ®»´·»ºÃ´ Ã »-¬ ³«-¬ -¸±© ¢Ã¸Ã¯Ã· ¬¸¿¬ ¸» ·- ´·µ»´§ ¬± -«½½»»¼ ±² ¬¸» ³»®·¬- ±º -«½¸ ¿ ½´¿·³Ã´ Ã¸Ã®Ã· ¬¸¿¬ ¸» ·- ´·µ»´§ ¬± -«ºº»® ·®®»°¿®¿¾´» ¸¿®³ ·² ¬¸» ¿¾-»²½» ±º °®»´·³·²¿®§ ®»´·»ºÃ´ Ã¸ÃÃ· ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸» ¾¿´¿²½» ±º »¯«·¬·»- ¬·°- ·² ¸·- º¿ª±®Ã´ ¿²¼ Ã¸Ã¬Ã· ¬¸¿¬ ¿² ·²¶«²½¬·±² ·- ·² ¬¸» °«¾´·½ ·²¬»®»-¬Ã²Å Ã »¿¬§ ªÃ² Ã ®»©»®Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã²Ã¼ Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã Ã Ã®Ã°Ã¬Ã°Ã§Ã¯ÃªÃ´ Ã¶ Ãª Ã¸Ã§¬¸ Ã ·®Ã² Ã ¿§ Ã®Ã«Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯Ã· Ã¸½·¬·²¹ Ã ·²¬»® ªÃ² Ã ¿¬«®¿´ Ã »-Ã² Ã »ºÃ² Ã ±«²½·´Ã´ Ã ²½Ã²Ã´ Ã«Ã«Ã« Ã Ã²Ã Ã² Ã©Ã´ Ã¯Ã®Ã§ Ã Ã² Ã ¬ ÃÃªÃ«Ã´ ÃÃ©Ã¬ Ã¸Ã®Ã°Ã°Ã¨Ã·Ã² Ã - ©» ¼·¼ ·² Ã »¿¬§Ã´ ¢Ã ©Ã » ¿½µ²±©´»¼¹» ¬¸¿¬ Ã Ã »-¬Ã ¸¿- ¿ -¬®±²¹ ·²¬»®»-¬ ·² ¾»·²¹ »¨»½«¬»¼ ·² ¿ ½±²-¬·¬«¬·±²¿´ ³¿²²»®Ã´ ¾«¬ ¸» ¸¿- ²±¬ -¸±©² ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸·- ·²¬»®»-¬ ·¬¸®»¿¬»²»¼ ·² ¬¸·- ½¿-»Ã²Å Ã ¼Ã² Ã »-¬ ¸¿- ²±¬ -¸±©² ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸» ³¿²²»® ·² ©¸·½¸ Ã ®·¦±²¿ ·²¬»²¼- ¬± »¨»½«¬» ¸·³ ¢½®»¿¬»- ¿ ¼»³±²-¬®¿¬»¼ ®·-µ ±º -»ª»®» °¿·²Ã² Ã » ³«-¬ -¸±© ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸» ®·-µ ·- -«¾-¬¿²¬·¿´ ©¸»² ½±³°¿®»¼ ¬± ¬¸» µ²±©² ¿²¼ ¿ª¿·´¿¾´» ¿´¬»®²¿¬·ª»-Ã²Å Ã ¿¦» ªÃ² Ã »»-Ã´ Ã«Ã«Ã Ã Ã²Ã Ã² ÃÃ«Ã´ ÃªÃ¯ Ã¸Ã®Ã°Ã°Ã¨Ã·Ã² Ã ¸» ½±«®¬ ¸»¿®¼ ¬»´»°¸±²·½ ±®¿´ ¿®¹«³»²¬ ±² ¬¸·- ³¿¬¬»® ¬±¼¿§Ã² Ã ¬ ¿®¹«³»²¬Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿Å½- ½±«²-»´ ³¿¼» -»ª»®¿´ ®»°®»-»²¬¿¬·±²-Ã² Ã ·®-¬Ã´ ¸» ®»°®»-»²¬»¼ ¬¸¿¬ Ã ®·¦±²¿Å½- °®±¬±½±´ º±® ½¿®®§·²¹ ±«¬ »¨»½«¬·±²-Ã´ ¿ ®»´»ª¿²¬ °±®¬·±² ±º ©¸·½¸ ·¿¬¬¿½¸»¼ ¿- Ã ¨¸·¾·¬ Ã ¬± ¬¸·- ±®¼»®Ã´ ¸¿¼ ¾»»² º±´´±©»¼ ·² ¬¸» °¿-¬ ¿²¼Ã´ ³±®» ·³°±®¬¿²¬´§Ã´ ©·´´ ¾» º±´´±©»¼ ·² Ã »-¬Å½- »¨»½«¬·±²Ã² Ã °»½·º·½¿´´§Ã´ ¸» ®»°®»-»²¬»¼ Ã® ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸» ¼®«¹- ½¿´´»¼ º±® ·² ¬¸» °®±¬±½±´ ¿®» ¿ª¿·´¿¾´» ·² ¬¸» Ã ¬¿¬»Å½- °±--»--·±²Ã´ ¿²¼ ©·´´ ¾» «-»¼ ·² Ã »-¬Å½- »¨»½«¬·±²Ã² Ã ±®»±ª»®Ã´ ¸» ®»°®»-»²¬»¼ ¬¸¿¬ ¬¸» °®±¬±½±´ ©·´´ ¾» º±´´±©»¼ ®»¹¿®¼·²¹ ¬¸» ´±½¿¬·±²- ¿²¼ ±®¼»® ±º °®»º»®»²½» º±® ·²-»®¬·±² -·¬»- ¿¼»¬¿·´»¼ ·² Ã ¿®¿¹®¿°¸ Ã ±º ¬¸» °®±¬±½±´Ã² Ã ±® ¬¸» ®»¿-±²- »¨°®»--»¼ ¾§ ¬¸» ¼·-¬®·½¬ ½±«®¬Ã´ ®»·²º±®½»¼ ¾§ ¬¸» ®»°®»-»²¬¿¬·±²- ³¿¼» ¾§ Ã ®·¦±²¿Å½- ½±«²-»´ ¿¬ ±®¿´ ¿®¹«³»²¬Ã´ ©» ½±²½´«¼» Ã »-¬ ¸¿º¿·´»¼ ¬± -¿¬·-º§ ¸·- ¾«®¼»² ¬± ¼»³±²-¬®¿¬» ¿ -«¾-¬¿²¬·¿´ ®·-µ ±º -»ª»®» °¿·² ¾§ ¬¸» ³»¬¸±¼ Ã ®·¦±²¿ ·²¬»²¼- ¬± «-» ¬± »¨»½«¬» ¸·³Ã² Ã ¿¦»Ã´ Ã«Ã«Ã Ã Ã²Ã Ã² ¿¬ ÃªÃ¯Ã² Ã ½½±®¼·²¹´§Ã´ Ã »-¬Å½- ³±¬·±² ·- Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã ±«²-»´Ã¦ Ã ±® Ã »¬·¬·±²»®Ã³Ã °°»´´¿²¬ Ã »-¬Ã¦ Ã ±² Ã Ã² Ã ¿²¼-Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã »¼»®¿´ Ã «¾´·½ Ã »º»²¼»®Ã´ Ã ¿´» Ã ¿·½¸ Ã¸¿®¹«»¼Ã·Ã´ Ã ±¾·² Ã Ã² Ã ±²®¿¼Ã´ Ã --·-¬¿²¬ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã »¼»®¿´ Ã «¾´·½ Ã »º»²¼»®-Ã´ Ã ¸±»²·¨Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã ±® Ã »-°±²¼»²¬Ã³Ã °°»´´¿²¬ Ã §¿²Ã¦ Ã ¸±³¿- Ã Ã² Ã ±®²»Ã´ Ã ¬¬±®²»§ Ã »²»®¿´Ã´ Ã ±²¿¬¸¿² Ã ¿-- Ã¸¿®¹«»¼Ã·Ã´ Ã --·-¬¿²¬ Ã ¬¬±®²»§ Ã »²»®¿´Ã´ Ã «½-±²Ã´ Ã ®·¦±²¿ Ã¬ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã« Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ Ã®Ã§ ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ° ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ¯ ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ® ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ¬ ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ« ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃª ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬ Ã ¿-»Ã¦ Ã¯Ã¯Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃ©Ã°Ã© Ã°Ã©Ã±Ã¯Ã¨Ã±Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯ Ã ¿¹»Ã¦ ÃÃ© ±º Ã¬Ã© Ã Ã Ã¦ Ã©Ã¨Ã®Ã®ÃªÃÃ° Ã µ¬Ã ²¬®§Ã¦ ÃÃ³Ã¬

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.