Mills v. United States - 164 U.S. 644 (1897)
U.S. Supreme Court
Mills v. United States, 164 U.S. 644 (1897)
Mills v. United States
Submitted December 15, 1896
Decided January 4, 1897
164 U.S. 644
On the trial of a person accused of rape, the court, in charging the jury, said:
"The fact is that all the force that need be exercised, if there is no consent, is the force incident to the commission of the act. If there is nonconsent of the woman, the force, I say, incident to the commission
of the crime is all the force that is required to make out this element of the crime."
Held, that this charge covered the case where no threats were made, where no active resistance was overcome, where the woman was not unconscious, where there was simply nonconsent on her part and no real resistance, and that such nonconsent was not enough to constitute the crime of rape.
The case is stated in the opinion.