Pierce v. United States - 160 U.S. 355 (1896)
U.S. Supreme Court
Pierce v. United States, 160 U.S. 355 (1896)
Pierce v. United States
Submitted November 19, 1995
Decided January 6, 1896
160 U.S. 355
When two counts in an indictment for murder differ from each other only in stating the manner in which the murder was committed, the question whether the prosecution shall be compelled to elect under which it will proceed is a matter within the discretion of the trial court.
Certain testimony held not to prejudice the defendants, but rather tending to bear in their favor, if at all material.
Confessions are not rendered inadmissible by the fact that the parties are in custody, provided that they are not extorted by inducements or threats.
The plaintiffs in error were indicted for the murder on January 15, 1895, in the Cherokee Nation, in the Indian country, of one William Vandeveer, a white man, and not an Indian. There were two counts in the indictment. The first charged the murder to have been committed with a gun, and the second charged it to have been committed "with a certain blunt instrument." The jury found both defendants guilty of murder as charged in the first count, and they were accordingly both sentenced to death.