Black Diamond Coal Mining Co. v. Excelsior Coal Co.
156 U.S. 611 (1895)

Annotate this Case

U.S. Supreme Court

Black Diamond Coal Mining Co. v. Excelsior Coal Co., 156 U.S. 611 (1895)

Black Diamond Coal Mining Company v. Excelsior Coal Company

No. 200

Argued January 30, 1895

Decided March 4, 1895

156 U.S. 611

Syllabus

If there be any invention in the machine patented to Martin R. Roberts by reissued letters patent No. 7341 for an improvement in coal screens and chutes, dated October 10, 1876 (upon which the court expresses no opinion), it is clear that it was not infringed by the defendant's machine. The Court takes judicial notice of the fact that hoppers with chutes beneath them are used for many different purposes.

Page 156 U. S. 612

This was an action at law by the Excelsior Coal Company to recover damages for the infringement of reissued letters patent No. 7,341, granted October 10, 1876, to Martin R. Roberts, for an "improvement in coal screens and chutes."

It seems by the statement of the patentee that, previous to this invention, in unloading vessels of coal the coal had, for the most part, been hoisted from the hold, over the bulwarks, and dumped upon the wharf or upon the coal previously dumped, or, if chutes were used, such chutes were fixed; nor, so far as the patentee was aware, had a movable chute ever been known or used by which the coal could be received from the vessel at any point on the wharf, and be screened and delivered to the cart. The patentee further states in his specification:

"My invention consists of a portable apparatus for receiving coal from the bucket by which it is hoisted from the ship, and for screening and delivering it to carts on the wharf, said apparatus being adapted for ready removal from place to place when required."

"By this apparatus, I am able to save repeated handlings and consequent expense and the breakage of the coal, and the apparatus can be changed from one point to another where the vessel may be placed."

The invention is shown in the following drawing:

Page 156 U. S. 613

image:a

The invention in question consisted substantially of a strong frame (A) surmounted by a hopper (BB') in the form of a trough, into which the coal is dumped from the hoisting buckets. The coal falls through the hopper upon an inclined screen (D) whose meshes, constructed of horizontal wires, are coarse enough to detain only the larger lumps, which accumulate in a reservoir (O) formed by the screen on one side, and three inclined surfaces on the other. This reservoir is in fact a secondary hopper at the bottom of which is located a chute (F) and gate (h) through which the large coal is drawn off as required into the cart or other vehicle. The smaller coal, which passes through the meshes of the screen (D) falls upon a second inclined screen (I) standing transversely to the upper one, whose meshes are finer than the other. The coal is again shifted by this screen into two grades, the coarser of which is discharged down the incline at one side of the machine, while the finer falls through the meshes upon the floor or wharf beneath the frame.

The patentee further added in his specification:

"The frame

Page 156 U. S. 614

(AA) will be mounted upon small wheels, so that it can be moved from one place to another upon a wharf in order to be placed in position to receive the discharging cargo of different ships; but when moving it from one wharf to another, I employ axles across each end of the frame, upon which strong wheels are placed, so that the entire machine can be drawn along similar to any vehicle. . . . When it is not desired to screen the article or substance to be unloaded, a false bottom or metal blank (K) is placed upon the granting or inclined side (D) of the reservoir, so that the substance will be carried directly through the chute into the cart or wagon intended to convey it away."

Plaintiff relied upon an infringement of all the claims of the patent, which read as follows:

"1. A portable combined coal receiving, screening, and delivering apparatus, arranged to receive the coal or other cargo from a swinging suspended tub or bucket, by which it is hoisted from the hold of a ship or other watercraft, and to screen it automatically, and deliver it into carts; said apparatus being constructed and arranged substantially as described."

"2. The receiving hopper (BB') in combination with the reservoir (O) with its screen or granting side (D), chute (F), with its toothed gate (h) and one or more independent screens (I), all combined and arranged substantially as and for the purpose above described."

"3. The metal blank or false bottom (K), in combination with the receiving hopper (BB'), reservoir (O), chute (F), and gate (h), substantially as and for the purpose above described."

"4. The combination of the hopper (BB') for receiving the coal from a swinging bucket, the reservoir (O), arranged to receive the coal as it passes from the hopper, with the chute (F) and gate (h), all constructed to operate substantially as and for the purpose set forth."

"5. In combination with the elongated hopper, the screen (D), reservoir (O), and chute (F), with its gate (h), the combination being substantially as is herein set forth."

The case was tried before a jury, and resulted in a verdict of $8,830.90 for the plaintiff, upon which a judgment was subsequently

Page 156 U. S. 615

entered. To review this judgment. the Black Diamond Coal Mining Company, defendant therein, sued out this writ of error.

Official Supreme Court caselaw is only found in the print version of the United States Reports. Justia caselaw is provided for general informational purposes only, and may not reflect current legal developments, verdicts or settlements. We make no warranties or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained on this site or information linked to from this site. Please check official sources.