Louisville & Nashville R. Co. v. Palmes - 109 U.S. 244 (1883)
U.S. Supreme Court
Louisville & Nashville R. Co. v. Palmes, 109 U.S. 244 (1883)
Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company v. Palmes
Argued November 8-9, 1883
Decided November 19, 1883
109 U.S. 244
The Legislature of Florida, acting under the constitution of the state, passed an improvement act exempting from taxation the capital stock of railroad companies accepting its provisions. The Alabama and Florida Railroad Company was organized, and constructed a railroad within the state limits, and became entitled to enjoy the exemption. In 1868, the State of Florida adopted a constitution which provided for a uniform and equal rate of taxation, and that the property of corporations theretofore or thereafter to be incorporated should be subject to taxation. The road and property, rights, privileges, and franchises of the A. & F. Co., being sold under decree of foreclosure, became by mesne conveyances vested in the Pensacola & Louisville Railroad Co. In 1872, the legislature enacted that the P. & L. Co., as assignees of the A. & F. Co., should be exempted from taxation during the remainder of the period for which the A. & F. Co. would have been exempted. In 1877, the title of the P. & L. Co. to its road and other property, and its franchises, rights, privileges, easements, and immunities were conveyed to the Pensacola Railroad Company, and the legislature authorized the P. R. Co. to acquire and enjoy them. The P. & L. Co. possessed, among other things, the power to lease to a railroad company out of the state. It was claimed that this right passed to the P. R. Co., and the latter leased its railroad and property, rights, privileges, easements and immunities to the plaintiff in error.
1. That the right of exemption from taxation did not pass from the A. & F. Co. to the P. & L. Co. by the sale under the mortgage.
2. That the language of the act of 1877 was broad enough to create that right anew, if the legislative grant was valid, but that
3. The Legislature of Florida, after the adoption of the Constitution of 1868, could not make an original grant to a railroad, exempting its railroad property from taxation.
4. That any right of this kind that could have been created by the act of 1877 was personal, and not assignable.
5. That a demurrer to the bill does not admit the contrary of these facts in law which appear upon the face of the bill, and of which the court must take judicial notice.
8. That the federal question before the Court is whether the state court gave effect to a state law which impairs the obligation of a contract, in deciding which and in determining whether there was a contract, the
Court is not necessarily governed by previous decisions of state courts except where they have been so firmly established as to constitute a rule of property.
This was a writ of error bringing into review a decree of the Supreme Court of Florida dismissing a bill in equity filed by the plaintiff in error which sought to enjoin the defendant, a collector of revenue under the laws of Florida for the County of Escambia, from collecting, by a sale of property levied on for that purpose, certain taxes claimed by him to be due from the complainant
The ground of our jurisdiction is, as stated and shown in the record, that in the cause wherein the decree complained of was rendered there was drawn in question the validity of a statute of the State of Florida, to-wit, "An act entitled an act for the assessment and collection of revenue," approved March 5, 1881, wherein and whereby certain taxes for state and county purposes were imposed upon the line of railroad extending from the City of Pensacola, in the State of Florida, to the northern boundary of the State of Florida, in the direction of Montgomery, Alabama, of which railroad the plaintiff in error is in possession and is owner, the validity of this statute being questioned on the ground that it was repugnant to the Constitution of the United States, in that it impaired the obligation of a contract, and the decision of the Supreme Court of Florida being in favor of its validity.
The contract the obligation of which it is alleged has been thus impaired and of which the plaintiff in error claims the benefit is asserted to arise as follows:
The General Assembly of the State of Florida passed an act, which took effect January 6, 1855, entitled "An act to provide for and encourage a liberal system of internal improvements in this state," the preamble to which recites that:
"The constitution of the state declares"
" That a liberal system of internal improvements, being essential to the development of the resources of the country, shall be encouraged by the government of this state, and it shall be the duty of the General Assembly, as soon as practicable, to ascertain by law proper objects of
improvements in relation to roads, canals, and navigable streams. and to provide for a suitable application of such funds as may be appropriated for such improvements."
The act then proceeds to create an internal improvement fund to aid in the construction of certain described railroads and other works of internal improvement by means of corporations organized or to be chartered for that purpose, and the 18th section provides as follows:
"That the capital stock of any railroad company accepting the provisions of this act shall be forever exempt from taxation, and the roads, their fixtures and appurtenances, including workshops, warehouses, vehicles, and property of every description, needed for the purpose of transportation of freight and passengers, or for the repair and maintenance of the roads, shall be exempt from taxation while the roads are under construction, and for the period of thirty-five years from their completion, and that all the officers of the companies, and servants and persons in the actual employment of the companies, be and are hereby exempt from performing ordinary patrol or militia duty, working on public roads, and serving as jurors."
By an Act of the General Assembly of Florida approved December 14, 1855, it was enacted:
"That a line of railroad to be constructed from the City of Pensacola or any other point or points on the waters of Pensacola Bay or the waters of St Andrew's Bay to the north line of the state, leading in the direction of Montgomery, Alabama, shall be considered proper improvements to be aided from the internal improvement fund in the manner provided for, or may hereafter be provided for, in 'An act to provide for and encourage a liberal system of internal improvements in the state,' approved January 6, 1855."
The Alabama and Florida Railroad Company, by an Act approved January 8, 1853, had been incorporated to build a railroad falling within that description, to extend from some point on the Bay of Pensacola to some point on the boundary line between the States of Florida and Alabama, to meet
and connect with a railroad leading thence to the City of Montgomery. This company, it is alleged in the bill, built and for a time operated the line of railroad contemplated by its charter, and became entitled to the benefits and privileges of the Internal Improvement Act of 1855, by accepting its provisions and complying with its conditions. Its line of railroad was completed about January 1, 1860.
By virtue of a decree of foreclosure and sale at the suit of trustees of a first mortgage, to satisfy the bonds secured thereby, the railroad of the Alabama and Florida Railroad Company, and all the rights, privileges, and franchises of the said company, were sold and conveyed on August 7, 1872, to one A. E. Maxwell, his heirs and assigns, in trust, and by him were sold and conveyed on December 10, 1872, to the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, a corporation created by the laws of Florida.
The original act incorporating the last-named company was passed July 16, 1868, but it appears to have been reorganized by an amendatory act which took effect February 4, 1872, the 18th section of which is as follows:
"That the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, having become the assignee of the Alabama and Florida Railroad, of Florida, and the franchises of the said corporation, and being in possession of and operating the said line of road, which corporation was exempt from taxation for a limited period, the said Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company and its property, now owned or hereafter to be acquired, shall also be exempt from taxation during the remainder of said period."
On May 6, 1878, in pursuance of a decree of the circuit court of the State of Florida, sitting in Leon county, a sale and conveyance was made transferring the title of the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company in and to its road and other property, "together with all the franchises, rights, privileges, easements, and immunities" of that company, to the Pensacola Railroad Company. This company was a corporation of the State of Florida, created by an Act of the General Assembly which took effect February 27, 1877. The second section of that act is as follows:
"SEC. 2. Be it further enacted, that the said Pensacola Railroad Company be, and it is hereby, authorized and empowered to acquire by purchase and assignment all the property, rights, franchises, privileges, and immunities of the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, a corporation created by an act of the General Assembly of the state, approved July 16, A.D. 1868, whether the same were acquired under the laws of the states of Florida or Alabama, or the laws of the United States, or as the assignee and successor of the Alabama and Florida Railroad Company, and upon completion of the said purchase and assignment, the said Pensacola Railroad Company shall be deemed in law and equity to be fully invested with and entitled to all the said property, rights, franchises, privileges, and immunities of said Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, as though the same were originally granted to or acquired by the said Pensacola Railroad Company."
By the 13th section of the act of 1872, amending the charter of the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, it was provided that
"It shall be lawful for said company to purchase, lease, acquire an interest in, to unite or consolidate with, lease or sell to, any other railroad company in or out of the state, and to make the same one company, with a consolidated stock and property, and with one board of directors,"
The right under this section to sell and transfer its property and franchises to a corporation of another state, it is claimed, passed from the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company to the Pensacola Railroad Company, and accordingly, on October 20, 1880, the Pensacola Railroad Company conveyed to the Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company, the plaintiff in error, its railroad from its junction with the Mobile and Montgomery Railway, to its terminus in Pensacola bay, its property, real and personal with certain exceptions, all its franchises, except the franchise to be and exist as a corporation, rights, privileges, easements, and immunities, by virtue of which conveyance the plaintiff in error claims in the bill that it became entitled to all the rights, property, privileges, franchises, and
immunities of the Alabama and Florida Railroad Company, the Pensacola and Louisville Railroad Company, and the Pensacola Railroad Company, under the various acts incorporating these companies, and acts amendatory of the same.
The plaintiff in error, the Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company, is a corporation of Kentucky, and by an amendment to its charter, which took effect March 6, 1878, reciting that its stockholders had become largely interested in the commerce and railroad business between the states of Kentucky and Tennessee and the southeast, and the several railroad connections in that part of the country, by an extension of its system, was enabled
"to operate, lease, or purchase, upon such terms or in such manner as they deem best, any railroad in any other state or states deemed necessary for the protection of the interest of the stockholders. "